Judicial Appointments Conundrum Pre-NJAC Verdict

Justice Dave recuses himself from NJAC Bench

  1. Senior advocate Fali Nariman pointed out there is a clear conflict of interest as Justice Dave is also a member of the NJAC.
  2. Justice Dave, who heads the five-judge bench, is the third senior-most Supreme Court judge.
  3. He is also a member of the NJAC as per the statute which prescribes that the six-member Commission will have the CJI and the next 2 senior most judges as its members.
  1. Senior advocate Fali Nariman pointed out there is a clear conflict of interest as Justice Dave is also a member of the NJAC.
  2. Justice Dave, who heads the five-judge bench, is the third senior-most Supreme Court judge.
  3. He is also a member of the NJAC as per the statute which prescribes that the six-member Commission will have the CJI and the next 2 senior most judges as its members.