[op-ed of the day] A welcome debate on electoral reforms

Mains Paper 2 : Representation Of People's Act |

Note4Students

From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :

Prelims level : Nothing Much

Mains level : Electoral Reforms


Note- Op-ed of the day is the most important editorial of the day. Aspirants should try to cover at least this editorial on a daily basis to have command over most important issues in news. It will help in enhancing and enriching the content in mains answers. Please do not miss at any cost.

CONTEXT

 A short-duration discussion in the Rajya Sabha on electoral reforms occured. It was initiated by Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Derek O’Brien, with the backing of as many as 14 Opposition parties.

Dimensions of reforms

  • The TMC MP touched on six major themes —
  • Appointment system for Election Commissioners and Chief Election Commissioner (CEC);
  • Money power;
  • Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs);
  • The idea of simultaneous elections;
  • The role social media;
  • And lastly, the use of government data and surrogate advertisements to target certain sections of voters.

1.Appointment process

  • On the issue of appointments of Election Commissioners, Mr. O’Brien quoted B.R. Ambedkar’s statement to the Constituent Assembly that “the tenure can’t be made a fixed and secure tenure if there is no provision in the Constitution to prevent a fool or a naive or a person who is likely to be under the thumb of the executive.”

Collegium system- All parties demanded the introduction of a collegium system.

2.Money power  –

As regards the chronic problem of the crippling influence of money power, Mr. O’Brien spoke about various reports and documents — a 1962 private member’s Bill by Atal Bihari Vajpayee; the Goswami committee report on electoral reforms (1990); and the Indrajit Gupta committee report on state funding of elections (1998).

Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA) – Congress MP Kapil Sibal, citing an independent think tank report on poll expenditure released in June, discussed at length the regressive impact of amending the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA) and removing the 7.5% cap on corporate donations.

3.Funding of elections –

  • Congress MP termed electoral bonds “a farce” and gave a proposal for state funding (of political parties) based on either a National Electoral Fund or the number of votes obtained by the respective parties.
  • He also proposed crowdfunding in the form of small donations.
  • He said that the current expenditure cap on candidates is unrealistic and should either be raised or removed to encourage transparency.

4.EVM –

  • The old issue of returning to ballot papers was raised by several parties.
  • The TMC said that “when technology doesn’t guarantee perfection, you have to question technology.”
  • The BJD said that to strengthen public faith in Voter-Verified Paper Audit Trails, five machines should be counted right in the beginning. The BSP added that postal ballots should be scanned before counting so as to increase transparency.

5.On simultaneous elections

  • Many BJP MPs highlighted issues linked to electoral fatigue, expenditure and governance and also reports of the Law Commission and NITI Aayog to push for simultaneous elections.
  • But the TMC said that the solution lies in consulting constitutional experts and publishing a white paper for more deliberation.

6.Internal democracy

  • Internal democracy within political parties was also mentioned by a couple of speakers.
  • The BJD suggested that an independent regulator should be mandated to supervise and ensure inner-party democracy.

7.Wider representations

  • For improving the representativeness of elections, the demand for proportional representation system was put forth by the DMK, the CPI and the CPI (M).
  • The DMK cited the example of the BSP’s performance in 2014 Lok Sabha elections, when the party got a vote share of nearly 20% in Uttar Pradesh but zero seats.
  • A number of MPs argued for a mixed system, where there was a provision for both First Past the Post and Proportional Representation systems.

8.Common electoral roll

  • The important issue of the “fidelity of electoral rolls” was raised by the YSR Congress Party (YSRCP).
  • The idea of a common electoral roll for all the three tiers of democracy was supported by the BJP and the SP.

Reforms in a streamlined manner

  •  Reducing the number of phases in elections by raising more security forces.
  • Depoliticisation of constitutional appointments by appointing Commissioners through a broad-based collegium;
  • State funding of political parties by means of a National Electoral Fund or on the basis of the number of votes obtained;
  • Capping the expenditure of political parties;
  • Giving the Election Commission of India (ECI) powers to de-register recalcitrant political parties;
  • Inclusion of proportional representation system;
  • Revisiting the Information Technology Act, to strengthen social media regulations.

Conclusion

  • The governments should also rise above their obsession with immediate electoral gains and think of long-term national interests.
  • The TMC MP was right in saying that Parliament must not only urgently “debate and deliberate but also legislate” on electoral reforms.
  • The time has come to find and enact concrete solutions in the national interest.
  • Having heard a number of practical and constructive proposals raised in the Rajya Sabha last week, I remain hopeful that Parliament will take it upon itself to enable the world’s largest democracy to become the world’s greatest.
Electoral Reforms In India
  • Subscribe

    Do not miss important study material

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
  Subscribe  
Notify of