Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Search results for: “”

  • Prasar Bharati is not a public service broadcaster

    Why in the News

    The Prasar Bharati (Broadcasting Corporation of India) Act, 1990 promised an autonomous public broadcaster, but the bodies meant to secure that autonomy have never been set up. Twelve years after a 2014 promise to recast Prasar Bharati on the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) model, the 138th “Mann Ki Baat” (the Prime Minister’s monthly radio address) shows the state still treats public airwaves as its own platform.

    What is Prasar Bharati meant to be?

    1. What it is: Prasar Bharati is the statutory corporation running All India Radio (AIR) and Doordarshan. Like the BBC, it was meant to be autonomous, editorially free and accountable to Parliament.
    2. Origins: The Emergency of 1975 made AIR and Doordarshan instruments of the regime. A BBC-style model drawn up by B.G. Verghese became the 1979 Prasar Bharati Bill, which lapsed.
    3. The Act: Introduced as “a charter of freedom” under Article 19(1)(a) (freedom of speech and expression), it received assent but was enforced only in 1997.
    4. Section 12 duties: The corporation must inform, educate and entertain, and safeguard “the citizen’s right to be informed freely, truthfully and objectively”.
    5. The takeaway: The law already promises independence, so the failure is one of implementation.

    Which parts of the Act were never implemented?

    1. Section 13: A 22-member parliamentary committee, elected from both Houses, was to oversee Prasar Bharati for Parliament. No government has constituted it.
    2. Sections 14 and 15: A Broadcasting Council was to receive complaints and guard political impartiality. It has never been set up, so no one can challenge an editorial decision.
    3. Section 10: A recruitment board meant to keep appointments free of government interference saw no action until July 2020, when the head of Bharat Prakashan, publisher of Panchajanya and Organiser, became chairman.
    4. Section 23: The Centre can still issue binding directions on what may or may not be broadcast.

    Does Prasar Bharati pass the public broadcaster test?

    1. UNESCO test: The United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) defined public broadcasting in 2001 as neither commercial nor state-controlled.
    2. Engineering-heavy workforce: A manpower audit found almost half of the 25,000 staff in engineering, against a little over 10% at the BBC.
    3. Thin content staff: Content staff were under 20%, against about 70% at the BBC. So Prasar Bharati is staffed to run transmitters, not to make news and programmes.

    Why has autonomy never been delivered?

    1. Nehru’s formula: In 1948 Jawaharlal Nehru told the Constituent Assembly that broadcasting should be a semi-autonomous corporation, “otherwise not conducted as a government department”. That caveat has not been honoured.
    2. Supreme Court direction: Secretary, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting v. Cricket Association of Bengal (1995) held that airwaves are public property. Its direction for an independent authority to control them is unmet.
    3. Chanda Committee: The Chanda Committee concluded in 1966 that “a psychological transformation is necessary” in the government’s approach to broadcasting, and that change has not come.

    Challenges

    1. Ministerial answerability claim: Ministers insist they alone answer to Parliament, so they keep summoning AIR and Doordarshan officials.
    2. Bureaucratic control: Officers of the Indian Information Service, a government cadre, run daily broadcasting.
    3. No independent money: With no fund of its own, the Prasar Bharati Board depends on the Ministry for money.
    4. No complaints channel: The government told the Lok Sabha it got no formal complaints about autonomy last year, but with no Council, complaints have nowhere to go.

    Way Forward

    1. Parliamentary committee: Constitute the Section 13 committee so that Parliament, not the Ministry, oversees Prasar Bharati.
    2. Broadcasting Council: Create the regulatory council the Act names, to hear complaints and guard impartiality.
    3. Professional Board: Rebuild the Board, now filled with bureaucrats who defer to the Ministry, as a professional body, and transfer to it the assets and staff never handed over.
    4. Funding without strings: Design funding free of government strings and remove Indian Information Service officers from operational control.

    Conclusion

    Prasar Bharati’s autonomy fails for want of political will rather than law. The open question is whether citizens go to court to enforce the Act and the Supreme Court’s direction, or wait for a future Lok Sabha willing to act.

    Key numbers

    1. Public Service Broadcasting Day: 12 November, declared in 2000, marks Gandhiji’s only AIR broadcast, made in 1947 to two lakh refugees at Kurukshetra.
    2. Prasar Bharati Bill: A new version was introduced in 1989.
    3. BBC in India: Accused of a “continuing colonial mindset” after its 2023 documentary, the BBC split its Indian news operation from April 2024 to meet foreign-investment rules.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2014, GS2, 12 marks] What do you understand by the concept “freedom of speech and expression”? Does it cover hate speech also? Why do the films in India stand on a slightly different plane from other forms of expression? Discuss.”

  • SEBI eases rules for early share delivery

    Why in the News

    Shares that a seller hands over early will now count towards margin obligations (money a trader must deposit to cover the risk of a trade), instead of the investor or broker putting up extra funds against a sale already covered. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has amended its Early Pay-In (EPI) rules to this effect, from February 22, 2027.

    What is Early Pay-In?

    1. What it is: Early Pay-In lets an investor selling shares transfer them to the clearing corporation, the body that completes exchange trades, before the scheduled settlement date. It is like paying a bill before it falls due.
    2. Why it helps: The value of shares delivered early can be used to meet the margin requirement for the corresponding sale, which reduces the need to provide additional funds.
    3. The takeaway: Shares already handed over cover the seller’s delivery obligation, so counting them towards margin frees money that would otherwise be locked up.

    What has SEBI changed?

    1. Trade-date valuation: Clearing corporations will calculate the accepted EPI value, the share value that counts towards margin, on the trade date itself.
    2. Lower-of rule: The accepted value will be the lower of the value of securities delivered early or the value of securities sold. So a seller cannot claim margin credit beyond the sale itself.
    3. Same-day positions: For investors who buy and sell in the cash market (where shares change hands outright) on the same day, clearing corporations will calculate margin requirements after deducting the accepted EPI value.
    4. Broker relief: Brokers will not have to collect additional margin for these positions to the extent the accepted EPI value covers them.

    Who gains, and what must happen first?

    1. Stated aim: The amendment eases margin requirements for both stockbrokers and investors.
    2. System upgrade: Brokers and clearing corporations get four months to upgrade their systems before the framework applies.

    Conclusion

    SEBI has amended the Early Pay-In framework so that early-delivered shares reduce margin calls on the same trade. The next milestone is its start date, by which brokers and clearing corporations must have upgraded their systems.

    Back2Basics: Clearing corporation

    1. What it does: A clearing corporation settles trades made on a stock exchange, so that the buyer receives the shares and the seller receives the money.
    2. Central counterparty: It becomes the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer, so one broker’s default does not stop settlement for others.
    3. Margins: It collects margins from its clearing members, mainly brokers, to cover the risk that a party fails to pay or deliver.
    4. Examples: NSE Clearing Limited (of the National Stock Exchange) and Indian Clearing Corporation Limited (of BSE, formerly the Bombay Stock Exchange) are regulated by SEBI.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2021] With reference to India, consider the following statements: 1.Retail investors through a demat account can invest in ‘Treasury Bills’ and ‘Government of India Debt Bonds’ in the primary market. 2.The ‘Negotiated Dealing System-Order Matching’ is a government securities trading platform of the Reserve Bank of India. 3.The ‘Central Depository Services Ltd’ is jointly promoted by the Reserve Bank of India and the Bombay Stock Exchange. Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 1 only (b) 1 and 2 (c) 3 only (d) 2 and 3 ANSWER: (b)”

  • GST reforms to be rolled out in phases, starting November 1

    Why in the News

    GST compliance is shifting from issuing notices over mismatched returns to redesigning the returns so that the mismatches do not arise. The process reforms announced by the Goods and Services Tax (GST) Council earlier this month will be rolled out in phases, starting with administrative changes from November 1.

    What is being changed in GST returns, and why?

    1. GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B: GSTR-1 is a business’s monthly or quarterly statement of outward supplies (sales), and GSTR-3B is the summary return through which it pays tax. The two must agree, like a shop’s sales register and its tax bill.
    2. Mismatch notices: When the sales a business reports in GSTR-1 do not match the tax it declares in GSTR-3B, it gets a notice. Such mismatches account for nearly 80% of GST notices issued at present.
    3. Return redesign: The government is modifying GSTR-1 and improving the Invoice Management System (IMS), where buyers check their suppliers’ invoices, so that GSTR-3B needs no manual editing. Without edits, the two returns agree and no notice arises.
    4. Public draft: The Ministry of Finance will post the draft GST returns, shaped by industry representations, on the myGov.in portal on November 1. The public can comment till November 30.
    5. The takeaway: Getting the returns right at the source is meant to remove most notices, instead of chasing errors after filing.

    What changes in the first phase from November 1?

    1. Administrative changes only: The first phase covers changes that need only administrative processes, not an amendment of the law.
    2. Registration: Small sellers on e-commerce platforms get simplified GST registration, and every applicant follows one unified set of registration documents.
    3. Refunds and notices: Refunds will be faster. A GST notice will issue only once the amount crosses a Rs 10,000 threshold.
    4. Notifications ready: The legal department has approved the notifications and circulars on these process reforms, and they are due to be issued on Friday.

    What comes later, and why does it matter?

    1. Law changes: Changes that need an amendment to the GST law will be implemented from April 1, 2027.
    2. Supply chain integrity: The Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) administers central GST. It expects successful returns reforms to resolve integrity issues in the supply chain, such as sellers and buyers reporting the same sale differently.
    3. Foundation for more reform: The CBIC calls the returns redesign the foundation for further GST reforms.

    Challenges

    1. Two-level amendment: A change in GST law needs the central GST law amended by Parliament and each State’s GST law by its legislature, after the Council recommends it.
    2. Conditional gains: The benefit depends on the redesigned returns being implemented successfully, a condition the CBIC itself sets.
    3. Adjustment for small firms: Small businesses and e-commerce sellers must adapt their accounting software and filing habits to new return formats.

    Way Forward

    1. Use the comment window: Industry bodies and small sellers should test the draft forms and flag mismatch risks before they are finalised.
    2. Synchronised amendments: The Centre and the States should time their GST law amendments so that the law changes take effect together.
    3. Track notices: The CBIC should publish data on mismatch notices after the redesign to show whether they fall.

    Conclusion

    The first phase of GST process reforms begins with administrative changes and a public draft of the new returns. The next milestones are the close of comments on the draft and the law changes due at the start of the next financial year.

    Back2Basics: Invoice Management System (IMS)

    1. What it does: IMS is a facility on the GST portal that lets a buyer accept, reject or keep pending each invoice its suppliers report.
    2. Why it matters: Invoices the buyer rejects or keeps pending stay out of GSTR-2B, its statement of input tax credit (credit for tax already paid on purchases), so disputes are settled before the return is filed.
    3. When it began: The facility was introduced on the GST portal in October 2024.
    4. Run by: The Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN), the company that runs the GST technology system.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2019, GS3, 10 marks] Enumerate the indirect taxes which have been subsumed in the goods and services tax (GST) in India. Also, comment on the revenue implications of the GST introduced in India since July 2017.”

  • Tunnelling through

    Tunnelling through

    Why in the News

    China’s Ministry of Commerce and General Administration of Customs have placed tunnel boring machines (TBMs), walking excavators and high-altitude wet shotcrete machines on an export control list. The move reveals a blind spot in India’s supply chain diversification (buying from several countries instead of one), because India is one of the world’s largest TBM importers.

    What is a TBM, and why does China’s grip matter?

    1. What it is: A TBM is a large machine that cuts a tunnel through rock and soil as it moves forward. It works like a giant drill built for one project’s ground.
    2. Complex build: Each TBM must be configured to the geology of its project site and perform numerous tasks, so it is hard to build.
    3. Dual use: A suitable TBM can serve civilian or military purposes, which makes it a dual-use item.
    4. Market share: China has cornered about 70% of the global TBM market. Western makers also source many components from China to cut costs.
    5. The takeaway: Even a machine bought from a Western firm can rest on Chinese parts, so switching suppliers alone does not remove the exposure.

    How will China’s export controls work?

    1. Sensitive destinations: From November 18, a shipment meant for a country or region China deems sensitive because of ongoing disputes will need an export licence from its commerce authorities.
    2. Other destinations: Exporters to other countries must register, obtain an export certificate and submit end-use declarations that the equipment will not be re-routed to sensitive locations.
    3. India’s experience: India has faced TBM hold-ups with China for at least two years. Eg. The Mumbai-Ahmedabad high-speed rail project.

    Why can India not simply make every TBM at home?

    1. Production economics: A new TBM plant pays off only with a minimum number of orders. It also needs local industry able to design, make and repair specialised components.
    2. Existing base: Germany’s Herrenknecht AG set up an assembling and refurbishing facility in Chennai in 2007-08.
    3. Cost of full self-reliance: Making every sophisticated machine in India would send public infrastructure costs soaring.
    4. Costlier alternatives: If China holds back machines meant for India, India may have to buy from plants in Germany or Japan at a higher capital cost.
    5. BEML lesson: The experience of BEML Limited, the public sector heavy equipment maker, shows that manufacturing partnerships can fail without secure licensing and sustained demand.

    What is Beijing’s wider aim?

    1. Pattern of controls: Beijing is systematically picking sectors where it commands large global capacity and placing export controls on them. It uses these controls to answer Western curbs on technology, such as those on advanced semiconductors.
    2. Compounding risk: Any critical infrastructure sector relying on Chinese supply lines faces geopolitical risk that grows with each new control Beijing adds.

    Challenges

    1. Project delays: Tunnel-heavy metro, rail and hydropower projects slip and cost more when a machine is held up.
    2. Widening controls: China’s list can extend to other inputs India’s projects need. Eg. Chinese curbs on rare earth magnets in 2025.
    3. Testing gap: TBM makers and their suppliers lack common testing and precision manufacturing facilities in India.
    4. Uncertain demand: Tunnel orders come in irregular bursts, so a domestic plant may not secure the minimum order book it needs.

    Way Forward

    1. Make with partners: Make equipment in India under agreements with established foreign firms.
    2. Shared facilities: Build common testing and precision manufacturing infrastructure for TBM makers and suppliers, instead of backing single “national champions”.
    3. Secure terms and orders: Write secure licensing terms into partnerships and give them a steady pipeline of public orders.
    4. Map exposure: Identify every critical infrastructure sector that relies on Chinese supply lines and line up alternative sources.

    Conclusion

    TBM controls show that India’s diversification effort has missed specialised infrastructure equipment where China dominates. The test is whether India can build a domestic base with foreign partners before Beijing’s controls reach other machines its projects need.

    Back2Basics: Export controls on dual-use items

    1. What they are: Licensing rules that let a government restrict exports of goods and technology with both civilian and military uses.
    2. China’s framework: China’s Export Control Law took effect in December 2020. China has since curbed exports of critical minerals such as gallium and germanium.
    3. India’s list: India controls such items through its SCOMET list (Special Chemicals, Organisms, Materials, Equipment and Technologies), set under the Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992. The Directorate General of Foreign Trade administers it.
    4. Export control regimes: India joined the Missile Technology Control Regime, the Wassenaar Arrangement and the Australia Group between 2016 and 2018.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2011] With reference to India, consider the following Central Acts: 1. Import and Export (Control) Act, 1947 2. Mining and Mineral Development (Regulation) Act, 1957 3. Customs Act, 1962 4. Indian Forest Act, 1927 Which of the above Acts have relevance to/bearing on the biodiversity conservation in the country? (a) 1 and 3 only (b) 2, 3 and 4 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 (d) None of the above Acts ANSWER: (c)”

  • Canary in coal mine

    Why in the News

    Growth in the Index of Core Industries (ICI) rose to a series-high of 7.9% in September 2026, the second straight month of faster growth. The editorial reads it as a warning, because the drivers are temporary or import-heavy and the government’s fiscal space (room to spend without unsafe borrowing) is shrinking.

    Is the record core sector reading a real recovery?

    1. What the index shows: The ICI tracks monthly output of the basic industries that supply fuel, power and building material. It works like a pulse reading for industry, since most goods need these inputs.
    2. Coal spike: Coal growth shot up to 10.7% in September. Over the longer April to September period, coal output still shrank by 1.1%.
    3. Cause of the spike: The jump is a temporary blip, aided by a low base (weak output a year earlier) and by power plants pressing for coal as stocks ran down in the heat wave.
    4. The takeaway: A record built on a one-off coal surge says little about whether industry will keep growing.

    Which sectors will not sustain the pickup?

    1. Electricity: Power output grew 11.4% in September, capping a half-year of double-digit growth. Power plants will need less coal ahead, because the El Niño effect (a periodic Pacific warming) behind the heat wave also brings a milder winter.
    2. Steel: Steel mills, the other heavy users of coal, grew faster in September. Their extra demand is still too small to keep coal output at September’s level.
    3. Iron ore: The steel uptick returned iron ore to double-digit growth, which helps the mining component of the wider Index of Industrial Production (IIP).

    Why does refinery growth point to a fiscal problem?

    1. Falling domestic output: Crude oil and natural gas output have contracted continuously since 2024, yet refinery output rose 10.3% in September. So refineries were processing more expensive imported oil.
    2. Import bill: Oil imports in September rose 7% by volume but 47% by value. India paid far more for a little more oil, because prices are high.
    3. Price shock: Attacks on Saudi Arabia’s energy infrastructure have pushed global oil above $112 a barrel, almost a six-month high, so the import bill is set to worsen.
    4. End of discounts: A United States reprieve on potential tariffs linked to Russian oil keeps Russia a reliable supplier, but Russian oil no longer comes at a discount.
    5. Reserve drain: Each imported barrel eats into India’s foreign exchange reserves, which are also being used to defend the rupee.

    Can government spending keep industry growing?

    1. Only steady sectors: Cement and steel are the only core sectors growing sustainably, and both rest on government infrastructure spending.
    2. Shrinking room: Industrial output is only temporarily propped up. The government’s fiscal space is shrinking fast, so public spending cannot carry industry for long.

    Challenges

    1. Import dependence: India imports most of the crude it refines, so faster refinery growth widens the import bill instead of cutting it.
    2. Thin reserve cushion: Reserves spent defending the rupee leave less room to absorb a further oil price rise.
    3. Reliance on public capital spending: Growth led by government construction stalls when fiscal space shrinks, unless private investment takes over.

    Way Forward

    1. Domestic exploration: The Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas should speed up award of blocks under the Open Acreage Licensing Policy (OALP), where companies pick the areas they bid for, to arrest falling crude and gas output.
    2. Supplier spread: Oil companies should spread crude purchases across suppliers so that one supply shock does not set the import bill.
    3. Private investment: The Centre should draw private capital into infrastructure so that growth does not rest on public spending alone.

    Conclusion

    India’s industrial pickup rests on a temporary coal and power surge and on public construction, and costlier oil imports are draining the reserves. Whether private demand and domestic energy output can take over before public spending runs out of room is unresolved.

    Back2Basics: Index of Core Industries (ICI)

    1. What it measures: Monthly output of nine core industries: coal, crude oil, natural gas, refinery products, fertilisers, steel, iron ore, cement and electricity.
    2. Compiled by: The Office of the Economic Adviser in the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), Ministry of Commerce and Industry.
    3. New series: The new series uses 2022-23 as its base year, replacing 2011-12, and added iron ore as the ninth sector.
    4. Link with the IIP: The core industries are also part of the IIP, which the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation compiles.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2012] In India the overall Index of Industrial Production, the Indices of Eight Core Industries have combined weight of 37.90%. Which of the following are among those Eight Core Industries? 1. Cement 2. Fertilizers 3. Natural Gas 4. Refinery products 5. Textiles Select the correct answer using the code given below: (a) 1 and 5 only (b) 2, 3 and 4 only (c) 1, 2, 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 ANSWER: (c)”

  • [UPSC Webinar] Mastering the New UPSC Pattern with Fixed Microthemes Pre+Mains. Smart Notes. Revision. by Shivali Thakur, IRMS, UAP student | 22 October 2026, 7:00 PM IST

    [UPSC Webinar] Mastering the New UPSC Pattern with Fixed Microthemes Pre+Mains. Smart Notes. Revision. by Shivali Thakur, IRMS, UAP student | 22 October 2026, 7:00 PM IST

    Join Shivali Thakur, IRMS, UAP student for a free live session: Mastering the New UPSC Pattern with Fixed Microthemes Pre+Mains. Smart Notes. Revision..

    📅 Thursday, 22 October 2026 at 7:00 PM IST  |  💻 Zoom (Live)  |  ⏱ 45 minutes, followed by open Q&A

    Free for the first 100 registrations. Once those close, attendance is paid. Seats: 200.

    In this session, Shivali will explain how you can stop chasing an unpredictable Prelims and start building fixed Pre+Mains Microthemes, exam-ready notes and a revision cycle that runs from Day 1.

    Leave with a clear plan for UPSC 2028

    One evening. 45 minutes. A Microthemes strategy you can actually follow from Day 1.

    Join live on Zoom: Thursday, 22 October 2026 at 7:00 PM IST

    Free webinar · FREE CIVILSDAILY PRACTICE KIT for all joinees · Limited seats


    What you will learn

    1. Embracing the 2026 pattern shift: decoding Prelims randomness vs predictable Mains themes, and targeting high-yield Microthemes (Pre + Mains)
    2. Live Topper’s Notes walkthrough: showcasing Shivali’s own notes to demonstrate exact content depth, precision, and what finished exam-ready notes look like
    3. Multi-revision & testing timelines: why core subjects demand repeated cycles, and why clearing UPSC is impossible without combining Mocks + Revision
    4. Integrated Current Affairs strategy: why CA is not a last-minute task and how to carry Static, Current Affairs, and Testing together from Day 1

    Who should attend

    • Beginners targeting UPSC 2028
    • 2027 attempt aspirants
    • Candidates struggling with dynamic Prelims patterns, note-making depth, and last-minute Current Affairs overload

    About the speaker

    Shivali Thakur, IRMS, UAP student

    Shivali Thakur, IRMS, UAP student

    After facing 5 consecutive failures in the UPSC Prelims, she completely re-engineered her preparation strategy with Civilsdaily’s UAP to clear the examination on her 6th attempt

    Her Masterclass is not be missed.

    Session details

    • Date: Thursday, 22 October 2026
    • Time: 7:00 PM IST
    • Platform: Zoom (Live)
    • Duration: 45 minutes, followed by open Q&A
    • Fee: Free for the first 100 registrations. Once those close, attendance is paid.
    • Seats: 200
    • Bonus: FREE CIVILSDAILY PRACTICE KIT for all joinees

    FAQs

    Is the webinar free?

    Free for the first 100 registrations. Once those close, attendance is paid. Register early to secure a free seat.

    Will I get a recording?

    Attend live to get the most out of the session and the Q&A.

    Do I need to prepare anything?

    No. Bring a notebook and your biggest doubt.


    Only 200 seats. FREE CIVILSDAILY PRACTICE KIT for all joinees.

    Free live webinar · UPSC 2028

    Fix your Microthemes. Crack UPSC 2028.

    An unpredictable Prelims is not your problem. Unfixed themes and unfinished notes are. In 45 minutes, Shivali Thakur shows you the Microthemes, notes and revision cycle that carried her to IRMS.

    Thu, 22 Oct 2026

    7:00 PM IST

    45 min + open Q&A

    2,400+ aspirants registered · FREE CIVILSDAILY PRACTICE KIT for all joinees

  • The struggle to preserve a fair international law

    The struggle to preserve a fair international law

    Why in the News

    South African jurist Navi Pillay has won the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize, as powerful authoritarian leaders weaken international law. The debate is whether authoritarian states are destroying that law or retooling it. Tom Ginsburg calls the second view “authoritarian international law”, a body of rules that shields regimes from scrutiny.

    What is authoritarian international law?

    1. What it is: It is an attempt by authoritarian states to build a new normative order. It is like a club that keeps its rulebook but rewrites it to protect its members from complaints.
    2. The order it departs from: The liberal order built after the Second World War, shaped by democratic states and deepened after the Cold War, wrote civil, political and human rights into its working.
    3. Courts and organisations: States gave international organisations (IOs) significant powers and created courts and tribunals to settle disputes, a trend called judicialisation.
    4. The takeaway: Authoritarian states are not simply hollowing out international law but rewriting it, so the fight is over whose purposes it serves.

    Is international law being hollowed out or retooled?

    1. Hollowing out: The ban on using force has been broken as multiple wars rage, compliance with human rights law has waned, and war crimes and crimes against humanity have risen.
    2. Vague language: A former US President favoured the ambiguous “rules-based order” over “international law”, a move towards governance with few binding norms. The current US President said his own morality guides him, not international law.
    3. Retooling: The other view is that authoritarians are retooling international law for their own objectives, as rising authoritarianism, even within liberal democracies, alters the liberal order.

    How do authoritarian states retool international law?

    1. Regime survival over rights: Authoritarian states treat international law as a tool for coordinating regime survival, so rights and accountability for war crimes get little place.
    2. Sovereignty claims: Sovereignty now shields regimes from scrutiny. Eg. Israel rejects UN human rights body reports as interference in its sovereign affairs.
    3. Weak organisations: Regimes delegate as little power as possible to IOs, so the members stay in control. Eg. the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO).
    4. Negotiation over courts: Regimes prefer negotiation or quasi-judicial mechanisms to third party adjudication. Eg. the backlash against the International Criminal Court (ICC).

    Why does the Pillay prize matter?

    1. The signal: By honouring Pillay, the Nobel Committee has signalled that international law matters, and the open question is which kind.
    2. Israel’s condemnation: Israel called the prize the “greatest lie” of the 21st century.
    3. The inquiry: Pillay chaired the UN’s Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory. That commission concluded that Israel committed genocide in Gaza.
    4. Individual as a subject of law: The law Pillay represents rests on equality, fairness and accountability. It makes the individual a subject of international law, meaning a person holds rights and duties under it, and most authoritarian regimes despise that.

    Challenges

    1. Vague vocabulary: Phrases like “rules-based order” let states choose which rules bind them.
    2. Weak enforcement: International courts have no police force and depend on states to carry out their orders.
    3. Pressure on courts: Sanctions on court officials weaken a court’s work. Eg. US sanctions on ICC officials in 2025.

    Way Forward

    1. Courts: Courts should keep hearing war crimes and rights cases, and national courts should apply international norms.
    2. Civil society: Civil society should document violations and give evidence to UN inquiry bodies.
    3. Academia: Academics should expose the retooling of law and defend precise legal rules.
    4. Democratic states: Democracies should speak of binding international law, not the vaguer “rules-based order”.

    Conclusion

    International law is contested less by repeal than by redefinition, and what it comes to protect depends on that contest. Whether democratic states and courts hold to binding law instead of looser language is the test to watch.

    Back2Basics: International Criminal Court (ICC)

    1. What it is: A permanent court at The Hague that tries individuals for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression.
    2. Founding: The Rome Statute was adopted in 1998 and entered into force in 2002.
    3. Last resort: It acts only when national courts are unwilling or unable to prosecute, a principle called complementarity.
    4. India: India is not a party to the Rome Statute.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2015] Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action’, often seen in the news, is (a) a strategy to tackle the regional terrorism, an outcome of a meeting of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (b) a plan of action for sustainable economic growth in the Asia-Pacific Region, an outcome of the deliberations of the Asia-Pacific Economic Forum (c) an agenda for women’s empowerment, an outcome of a World Conferene convened by the United Nations (d) a strategy to combat wildlife trafficking, a declaration of the East Asia Summit ANSWER: (c)”

  • How to break the ration shop monopoly

    How to break the ration shop monopoly

    Why in the News

    One Nation One Ration Card (ONORC), introduced in 2019 so migrant workers could draw subsidised grain away from home, is used mostly to switch ration shops near home. Its main gain is bargaining power over the shop dealer, not long-distance mobility, according to Bihar’s transaction records.

    What is ONORC, and what was it meant to fix?

    1. What it is: ONORC lets a beneficiary draw subsidised grain at any ration shop in India, much like keeping a mobile number in any city. The shop checks identity through Aadhaar, India’s biometric ID.
    2. PDS scale: About six in ten Indians draw subsidised cereals each month from 5 lakh fair price shops (FPS), the ration shops of the Public Distribution System (PDS).
    3. Old gap: Until 2019 the entitlement was tied to the address on the card, so a worker in a Punjab field or Surat mill could not draw grain there.
    4. Two elements: Portability lets a beneficiary collect the quota at any FPS in India. Divisibility lets the entitlement be split across draws, part at home and part where the migrant stays.
    5. The takeaway: ONORC serves mainly as a way to shop around locally rather than to move across States, which changes the dealer’s power.

    What does Bihar’s data show?

    1. Dataset: The study uses 891 million transactions from Bihar’s online PDS portal since April 2022, together with inter-State data. Bihar is India’s poorest State and its largest source of migrants.
    2. Nearby use: 55% of ONORC use is at another shop in the same block, against 38% at the assigned shop, the one the card is tied to.
    3. Two types: Type 1 portability is use at a nearby shop, which dissatisfaction with price, quantity or quality at the assigned shop would drive. Type 2 is use by long-distance migrants, and it is far smaller: only 1% of use is in other States.
    4. Trend: Portable transactions have risen about six percentage points a year, evenly across Bihar but most in type 1.
    5. Divisibility: Divisibility is used sparingly. Low awareness and dealer incentives are among the suspected reasons.

    Why does the freedom to switch discipline the dealer?

    1. Old monopoly: Before ONORC the dealer was a monopolist. A household tied to one shop had no bargaining power when cheated on price, quantity, quality or service. This mostly hurt households with little social power, such as female-headed and lower-caste ones.
    2. Exit threat: A cardholder can now threaten to leave. That hurts the dealer, because commission depends on the volume of grain disbursed. A cardholder who switches keeps the dealer in check, so beneficiaries can get better outcomes.
    3. Welfare gain: ONORC made the dealer-client relationship negotiable. The authors say this shift in bargaining power may be the largest welfare change the PDS has seen in decades.

    Challenges

    1. Authentication failures: Elderly and manual workers with worn fingerprints, and shops with weak networks, can be denied grain when Aadhaar checks fail.
    2. Thin dealer margin: A fixed commission per quintal gives dealers a thin margin and a reason to short-weigh or divert grain.
    3. Outdated coverage: Coverage is pegged to the 2011 Census, so experts estimate over 100 million eligible people lack ration cards.

    Way Forward

    1. Awareness drive: States should publicise portability and divisibility at every FPS so cardholders use the choice they hold.
    2. Fallback authentication: Offer iris scanners and one time password overrides where fingerprints fail.
    3. Fair margin: The Centre and States should review dealer commission so that income does not rest only on volume.
    4. Updated coverage: Revise coverage with the latest Census so excluded households get cards.

    Conclusion

    ONORC has proved less a migrants’ scheme than a tool that gives every cardholder a choice of dealer. The test ahead is whether other States show the same pattern and whether dealer incentives are reformed to keep that choice meaningful.

    Public Distribution System and the National Food Security Act, 2013

    1. Entitlement: The Act gives a legal entitlement to subsidised foodgrain to up to 75% of the rural and 50% of the urban population.
    2. Categories: Antyodaya Anna Yojana households (the poorest) get 35 kg a family a month, and Priority Households get 5 kg a person a month.
    3. Division of work: The Centre procures, stores and allocates grain in bulk, and States identify beneficiaries, issue cards and run the shops.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2021, GS3, 15 marks] What are the salient features of the National Food Security Act, 2013? How has the Food Security Bill helped in eliminating hunger and malnutrition in India?”

  • Drug prices: overcharging claims of Rs 8,447 crore remain unpaid

    Drug prices: overcharging claims of Rs 8,447 crore remain unpaid

    Why in the News

    Medicine makers that overcharge must repay the excess, yet about 84% of the Rs 10,029.8 crore the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority (NPPA) has demanded for overcharging remains unpaid. The Rs 8,447.4 crore outstanding surfaces as the Supreme Court presses the government to extend price limits to more medicines.

    How does price control work, and how is overcharging recovered?

    1. What it is: The Drugs (Prices Control) Order, 2013 (DPCO) is the government order that sets the highest price for listed medicines. It works like a fare cap: charging above it is overcharging.
    2. Who enforces it: The NPPA, the government’s drug-price regulator set up in 1997, raises a demand with interest on companies that overcharged. Its records go back to 1979.
    3. Trade margin: A seller adds a markup between the price it pays for a medicine and the price the patient pays. That markup is the trade margin.
    4. Patients get nothing back: Recovering money from companies is separate from compensating patients. A 2019 Lok Sabha reply said no mechanism exists to compensate consumers, though the NPPA takes consumer complaints.
    5. The takeaway: Medicines make up nearly one fifth of a rural hospital bill, yet recovery runs between the regulator and companies, so patients see no refund even when a demand is met.

    How much has been recovered, and where is the rest stuck?

    1. Recovered: By March 2026 only Rs 1,582.4 crore had been realised, so the unpaid sum is more than five times the amount recovered.
    2. Litigation: More than Rs 5,800 crore of the unpaid sum is tied up in court cases.
    3. Recovery process: Rs 200 crore relates to cases referred to district collectors for recovery, and Rs 2,369.3 crore is still being processed.
    4. Old backlog: Almost half of the unpaid sum dates from cases before 2009.

    Why is the Supreme Court pressing for wider price limits?

    1. Margin cap: The Centre told the Court it had capped trade margins at 30% for non-scheduled anti-cancer medicines, those outside the ceiling price list.
    2. Court’s question: A two judge Bench asked why similar limits cannot cover other medicines and medical products.
    3. Price gaps: Citing steep gaps between supply prices and prices charged to patients, the Court asked the government to work out broader measures to regulate medicine prices.
    4. Overcharging versus margins: Overcharging beyond regulated prices breaks the DPCO, but a high margin need not be illegal. Both raise costs for patients.
    5. Next hearing: The matter will be heard again on October 27.

    Challenges

    1. Undercounted overcharging: The dues cover only cases the NPPA detected and pursued, so actual overcharging is larger.
    2. Uneven enforcement: The number of cases taken up each year peaked in 2015-16 and fell sharply by 2020-21, so pressure on companies is uneven.
    3. Narrow price control: Ceiling prices apply only to scheduled medicines on the National List of Essential Medicines, and other medicines face only a cap on yearly price rises.
    4. Weak deterrent: When most demanded money stays unpaid for years, overcharging carries little penalty.

    Way Forward

    1. Priority hearings: The Department of Pharmaceuticals should seek early hearings in the NPPA recovery cases pending in court.
    2. Time-bound recovery: Set deadlines for district collectors on cases referred to them for recovery.
    3. Patient redress: Build a compensation route for consumers, funded from recovered overcharges.
    4. Wider margin cap: Extend a uniform trade margin cap beyond anti-cancer medicines, as the Court has asked the government to examine.
    5. Public reporting: The NPPA should publish yearly data on overcharging detected and money recovered.

    Conclusion

    Price rules bind makers on paper, but the money owed for breaking them has largely not been collected, and none of it reaches patients. The next hearing will show whether the government widens margin control or first strengthens recovery.

    Key numbers

    1. Before 2009: 731 cases, with Rs 4,764.75 crore demanded and Rs 3,987.5 crore outstanding.
    2. Since 2009: About Rs 5,265 crore demanded, of which about Rs 4,460 crore is outstanding.
    3. Annual cases: 268 (2015-16), 224 (2017-18), 38 (2020-21), 148 (2022-23) and 133 (2025-26).
    4. Medicine spend per hospital stay (2025): Rural Rs 6,368 of Rs 32,884; urban Rs 6,948 of Rs 46,774.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “No direct PYQ traced in the provided files. Thematic PYQ: [2015, GS2, 12 marks] For achieving the desired objectives, it is necessary to ensure that the regulatory institutions remain independent and autonomous. Discuss in the light of the experiences in recent past.”

  • Unlocking agri-potential of FRA lands

    Unlocking agri-potential of FRA lands

    Why in the News

    The Forest Rights Act, 2006 (FRA) has given millions of tribal and forest-dwelling families legal rights over land. Two authors now propose growing pulses and oilseeds on these plots to turn titles into livelihoods, because these crops suit rain fed marginal land and could cut India’s import dependence.

    Why do land titles need crops to become livelihoods?

    1. FRA lands: The Act recognises land rights of Scheduled Tribes and other forest dwellers who long occupied forest land. A title without seed, water and a market is like a shop licence without stock.
    2. Next step: A parcel of land is the base of a livelihood only if conditions make it productive and sustainable. The authors want titles paired with sustainable farming, soil and water management, institutional support and market access.
    3. Why these crops: Pulses and oilseeds adapt to rain fed (watered only by rainfall) and marginal (poor quality) land, raise productivity and support climate-resilient farming. They also strengthen domestic supplies.
    4. The takeaway: A title secures the land, but crops and support decide whether it becomes a livelihood.

    Which tribal districts suit pulses and oilseeds?

    1. Soil suitability: An analysis using the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) soil map finds many tribal regions suited to soybean, groundnut, sunflower, mustard, chickpea and other pulses.
    2. Oilseeds: Of the 244 tribal districts, 60 have major oilseed production potential.
    3. Pulses: 31 districts have strong pulse potential, and 23 have favourable conditions for both crops.
    4. Cropping pattern: Paddy and maize dominate the Kharif (monsoon) season, and wheat, gram, mustard and lentil the Rabi (winter) season. Millets, cotton, sesame and spices offer scope for sustainable diversification.
    5. Local variety: The districts span 33 States and Union Territories with different settlement patterns and resources, so plans must follow local conditions.

    How do the proposals fit existing schemes?

    1. Scheme convergence: The authors would link the plan to the PM Krishi Sinchayee Yojana (irrigation), National Food Security and Nutrition Mission, National Mission on Edible Oils (edible oil output), PM-AASHA (price support) and Van Dhan Yojana (tribal produce).
    2. Aspirational districts: Many tribal districts overlap with aspirational districts, the districts flagged as lagging on development indicators, so the effort reaches places with the greatest need.

    Challenges

    1. Recognition gap: Only 47% of individual claims under the FRA have been approved, so many families hold no title to farm.
    2. Wheat-rice bias: Procurement favours wheat and rice, so oilseeds and pulses lack assured markets that would reward farmers.
    3. Low, rain fed yields: Over 70% of oilseed cultivation depends on the monsoon, and yields are about half those of the US and Brazil.
    4. Cheap imports: Imported palm oil causes price swings that deter domestic growers. Eg. Indonesia and Malaysia are the main sources.

    Way Forward

    1. Production clusters: Develop region-specific oilseed and pulse clusters on FRA lands in high-potential tribal districts.
    2. Inputs and water: Supply certified seeds, irrigation, watershed management and stronger agri-extension.
    3. After harvest: Build local drying, storage, grading and primary processing to cut post-harvest losses.
    4. Farmer institutions: Strengthen farmer producer organisations (FPOs), cooperatives and self-help groups to aggregate produce and reach markets.
    5. Planning and finance: Plan crops with Geographic Information System (GIS) maps and back them with credit, crop insurance and assured procurement.

    Conclusion

    FRA titles settle who holds the land, and the proposed crop plan tries to settle what the land earns. The test ahead is whether States convert district-level potential into funded clusters.

    Government Initiatives for Pulses and Oilseeds

    1. Mission for Aatmanirbharta in Pulses (2025-31): A six-year mission of about Rs 11,440 crore targets self-reliance in tur (pigeon pea), urad (black gram) and masoor (red lentil).
    2. High-yielding varieties: The Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) approved 343 high-yielding pulse varieties and hybrids between 2014 and 2023.
    3. Assured procurement: The National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India (NAFED) and the National Cooperative Consumers’ Federation of India (NCCF) buy pulses from registered farmers to stabilise prices.
    4. PM Dhan-Dhaanya: The 2025 scheme targets crop diversification across 100 low-productivity districts.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2010] An objective of the Nations Food Security Mission is to increase the production of certain crops through area expansion and productivity enhancement in a sustainable manner in the identified districts of the country. What are the those crops? (a) Rice and Wheat only (b) Rice, Wheat and Pulses only (c) Rice, Wheat, Pulses and Oilseeds only (d) Rice, Wheat, Pulses, Oilseeds and Vegetables only ANSWER: (b)”