Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Search results for: “”

  • NRI as the non-returning Indian: What gets lost in the US visa debate

    Why in the News

    The US Vice President has called Indian H-1B visa holders (skilled foreigners on temporary US work visas) “foreign indentured servants”. The Union Commerce and Industry Minister has said curbs on these visas would help India retain talent. Both leave out that Indian governments, like British India before them, have long promoted labour export, even as skilled emigrants increasingly stay away.

    What was indentured labour, and how does today’s emigration compare?

    1. What it is: Indentured labour was the colonial system that shipped hundreds of thousands of Indians abroad, each bound by contract to one employer for a fixed term, like a bond. On Indian Ocean islands they were called girmitiyas.
    2. State policy then: It was British India’s official policy, part of two centuries of organised labour export, with legal cover from the state.
    3. State policy now: Free India has also encouraged emigration to countries short of workers, or whose own workers will not do the job. In both eras, greedy businesspersons cheated desperate migrants.
    4. Same push, different conditions: Nineteenth century labourers were as desperate for a better life as today’s middle classes. Plantations were harsh, as are labour camps across the Arab world.
    5. The takeaway: The Indian state has sponsored labour export in both eras, so the “indentured” jibe points at a practice India itself promotes.

    How has India promoted the export of labour?

    1. Mode 4: India has sought a multilateral framework for “Mode 4” of the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS), the World Trade Organization’s services rulebook. Mode 4 covers people crossing borders to work.
    2. Theoretical case: Economists argue that labour should move across borders as freely as capital.
    3. Practical case: Emigrants send dollar remittances home, which build India’s foreign exchange reserves.
    4. Bilateral deals: The government has signed memorandums of understanding (MoUs) with countries from Israel to Taiwan to export Indian labour, through public-private partnerships seeking “global access to talented Indians”.
    5. Exporter of talent: Unable to ensure jobs at home, India has become an exporter of talent to earn foreign exchange.

    What does the visa debate leave out?

    1. US interests: US corporations backing the Republican Party have long gained from lower-cost Indian talent.
    2. India’s shift: The Minister’s welcome of visa curbs departs from official policy, which has consistently sought more overseas work for Indians.
    3. Brain drain: The Minister revived the unfashionable term “brain drain”, the loss of skilled people abroad. His government has celebrated overseas Indians’ success.
    4. Government rebuff: The condescending remark forced a normally cautious government to rebuff the US.

    Is exporting human capital a necessity or a virtue?

    1. Demographic fit: Ageing developed economies face a demographic deficit, so countries with a large, young, unemployed population seek jobs abroad. Exporting human capital is thus a necessity, not a virtue.
    2. Host country view: Labour importers treat migration as an “avoidable necessity”: immigrant talent is celebrated in good times and made an electoral issue in bad times.
    3. Never-returning Indians: With non-resident Indians (NRIs) becoming “never-returning Indians” and elite families emigrating, India needs a plan to retain and attract talent.
    4. Barriers to return: Persistent bureaucratism (red tape) and what critics call authoritarian and majoritarian instincts in government deter return. Global talent seeks opportunity and freedom.

    Challenges

    1. Policy contradiction: India seeks more work visas abroad and speaks of retaining talent at home, with no plan linking the two.
    2. Rising curbs: Anti-immigrant sentiment is growing worldwide, so migration routes can close quickly.
    3. Weak worker protection: Low-skilled emigrants face exploitative recruiters and host labour laws. Eg. The kafala sponsorship system in West Asia.
    4. Closed research system: Highly bureaucratised universities and research bodies do not welcome free-minded returnees.

    Way Forward

    1. Jobs at home: Expand domestic employment so emigration becomes a choice, not a necessity.
    2. Research autonomy: Free universities and laboratories to hire and fund diaspora researchers.
    3. Protected mobility pacts: Negotiate migration agreements carrying social security and wage protection for Indian workers.

    Conclusion

    India promotes emigration as an export and mourns it as a loss, with no policy that reconciles the two. Without better jobs and freer institutions at home, visa curbs abroad will not bring talent back.

    Government Initiatives for the Indian Diaspora

    1. VAIBHAV Fellowship: Brings diaspora scientists to Indian laboratories for collaborative research.
    2. e-Migrate: A digital system protecting low-skilled emigrants from fraudulent recruiters.
    3. Pravasi Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PKVY): Skill certification for workers seeking overseas jobs.
    4. Overseas Citizenship of India (OCI) card: Gives persons of Indian origin a lifelong visa to live and work in India.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2018, GS1, 15 marks] Why indentured labour was taken by the British from India to other colonies? Have they been able to preserve their cultural identity over there?”

  • A vote lost in revision

    Why in the News

    A revision meant to correct Telangana’s electoral rolls has put about 73 lakh voters on its deletion list, but fewer than six lakh have applied to re-enrol. The State’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has closed its window for contesting the draft roll with living voters marked dead and notices citing errors that did not apply.

    What is the SIR, and how was it run in Telangana?

    1. What it is: The SIR is a fresh check of every roll entry, like a door to door census of voters. Booth Level Officers (BLOs), local officials who verify voters, collect an enumeration form confirming each elector’s details.
    2. The ASDD list: Electors not found or not returning a form go on the Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate (ASDD) list and are left out of the draft roll.
    3. Planned design: Begun on June 15, the exercise required at least three BLO house visits per elector.
    4. What went wrong: Many BLOs, drawn from departments with little public contact, held camps in community halls instead:
      • data from a pre-SIR mapping exercise, linking current voters to the earlier roll, was never carried over;
      • voters struggled to find themselves in the 2002 rolls, with misspelt names and pages in Hindi.
    5. The takeaway: A door to door exercise became one where voters chased officials, so the burden of enrolment fell on them.

    Whose names were removed?

    1. Declared dead: About 9.22 lakh ASDD voters were marked dead on death certificates or family declarations, some of them alive.
    2. AI flagging: The ERONET app, the roll management software, used artificial intelligence (AI) to flag entries with similar demographic details or photographs. Checking absent and shifted voters was left to BLOs.
    3. Independent count: An analysis of Election Commission of India (ECI) data by the Sabar Institute and the Constitutional Guardians Forum (CGF) found 53.97 lakh ASDD names, roughly one in four electors.
    4. Hyderabad: Only 59% of Hyderabad district’s electors reached the draft rolls; women were 47.8% of deletions.
    5. Religious skew: Electors the analysis classified as Muslim by name were more often deleted on two grounds:
      • ‘Untraceable/Absent’: 19.8% against 16% of non-Muslims;
      • ‘enrolled elsewhere’: 7.6% against 3.4%.

    Why are deleted voters struggling to return?

    1. New voter form for old voters: Deleted electors who had voted before were told to fill Form 6, the application meant for new voters.
    2. Unknown exclusions: Forms went only to those on the 2025 rolls, so eligible voters missing from them were never counted.
    3. Citizenship notices: More than 92 lakh electors marked unmapped or with ‘logical discrepancies’ were asked to prove citizenship with one of 12 documents. Officials blamed automated software.
    4. Faulty notices: Many notices cited errors that did not apply. Eg. An elector was flagged for a grandparent age gap below 40 years, but the real gap was 60.
    5. Bulk deletion requests: The phase saw 24,323 Form 7 objections to names, including pre-filled forms against Muslim voters allegedly circulated by Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) agents.

    How do officials defend the exercise, and what do critics want?

    1. Population match: Officials cite the House-listing Survey for Census 2027. It found Hyderabad’s electors equal to its entire population, so the old roll was inflated.
    2. Time and assurance: The Chief Electoral Officer (CEO)‘s office cites extended deadlines and the option to re-enrol. It says no deletion stands without documents or BLO verification.
    3. Fresh rolls, not edits: An official from the 2008 roll preparation says intensive revisions must build rolls de novo (from scratch), not tweak old ones.

    Challenges

    1. Unchecked automation: Software generated flags and notices went out without a human check.
    2. Notices past the deadline: Notices kept going out after the October 7 claims deadline, leaving little time to respond.
    3. Concentration in the capital: Hyderabad, Ranga Reddy and Medchal-Malkajgiri held close to 60% of ASDD voters statewide.

    Way Forward

    1. Restore on verification: Reinstate wrongly deleted names after checks, without a fresh Form 6.
    2. Logged house visits: Require BLOs to record three geo-tagged visits before marking anyone absent or shifted.
    3. Human check on flags: Require an Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) to verify every AI flag and system notice before it issues.

    Conclusion

    Telangana’s revision removed names far faster than it let wrongly deleted voters return. How many ASDD names return to the final roll is what to watch.

    Key numbers

    1. Sabar-CGF analysis coverage: 104 of 119 Assembly constituencies.
    2. Grandparent age anomaly notices: Muslims 15.5% of cases; electors with six or more siblings 50.5%.
    3. Elector to population ratio, India: normally 67 to 73%.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2026, GS2, 10 marks] Is the right to vote a fundamental right? Discuss the position of the Election Commission of India while undertaking the revision of electoral rolls. Can it also examine the question of citizenship of voters?”

  • An entitled generation and an Opposition that protests too much

    Why in the News

    Opposition protests treat the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls as mass disenfranchisement, but a test against population estimates finds about 7 million eligible voters left out without explanation, under 1% of adults. The test answers two weeks of Delhi protests by the Congress and the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), with over 2,000 detained in one day.

    What is the SIR, and what does the Opposition demand?

    1. What it is: The SIR is the Election Commission of India (ECI)‘s fresh check of every name on the electoral roll, like a full stock taking. It removes the dead, duplicates and those who moved away.
    2. Opposition demands: The Congress seeks the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC)‘s resignation, the SIR’s cancellation and paper ballots. The CJP wants the CEC out within 48 hours, rolls restored to January 2025 and elections suspended.
    3. The takeaway: The protests seek to undo the whole SIR, so the test is how many eligible voters its rolls miss.

    How does a clean roll test measure wrongful exclusion?

    1. Clean roll, defined: A clean roll is the number of names a roll should hold if it listed every adult except those legitimately absent. The gap from the actual roll counts the missing.
    2. Adult count: The test carries the last Census forward for births, deaths, Covid deaths and emigration, giving about 1,008 million adults. UN and Sample Registration System (SRS) estimates fall within 1.5% of it.
    3. Voluntary registration: Enrolment is voluntary, so about 8.5% of adults are legitimately off the rolls, fewer than in Britain or the US. A clean national roll should hold about 922 million names.
    4. State test: In Bihar and the eight large phase II States, a clean roll should hold about 535 million names against 528 million on the final rolls.
    5. Unexplained gap: Some removed names may be non-citizens. Allowing for them, the shortfall counts eligible voters excluded without adequate explanation: 1 to 13 million.

    Is the SIR mass disenfranchisement or a flawed clean-up?

    1. Removals mostly justified: Of 58 million names removed in these States, 51 million were the dead, duplicates or those who moved for good.
    2. Past rolls were inflated: In 2004, after the last nationwide intensive revision, the roll held 4.4% more names than adults, with no allegation of doctoring then.
    3. The ’13 crore’ figure: The Opposition’s 13 crore is the draft stage count, including the known dead, not a count of the disenfranchised.
    4. State outliers: The exclusion is uneven:
      • Bihar still lists about 6 million more names than a clean roll would;
      • West Bengal shows about 5 million citizens removed without adequate explanation, falling disproportionately on Muslims in Murshidabad and Malda and on Matua Hindus.
    5. Claims without numbers: The CJP alleges “stolen” votes but gives no figure. Faulting how the SIR was run differs from claiming it disenfranchised a seventh of voters.

    Challenges

    1. Haste: Tight timelines left little room to verify each name before removal.
    2. Paperwork burden: The SIR demanded documents the poor and migrants rarely keep, so eligible but undocumented voters risked removal.
    3. Form 6 declaration: The ECI added a declaration to Form 6, the enrolment application, without changing the rules; the Supreme Court has yet to rule on it.
    4. Opaque data: The ECI does not publish removals by reason or booth, so no one can test claims of error.

    Way Forward

    1. Removal data: The ECI should publish removals by reason, State and booth.
    2. Fast appeals: Decide the West Bengal appeals quickly and restore wrongly removed names.
    3. Clean roll audit: Test phase III rolls against a clean roll once final.

    Conclusion

    The evidence points to a revision that wrongly excluded a few million voters in particular States and communities, not mass disenfranchisement. Whether evidence or slogans settle the dispute depends on how openly the ECI accounts for each removal.

    What is the right to vote?

    1. Universal adult suffrage: Article 326 bases elections on universal adult suffrage, so every citizen aged 18 or above may be registered.
    2. One general roll: Article 325 bars exclusion from the electoral roll on grounds of religion, race, caste or sex.
    3. Statutory right: Jyoti Basu v. Debi Ghosal (1982) held the right to vote is neither a fundamental nor a common law right. It is a statutory right, created and limited by law.
    4. ECI’s power over rolls: Article 324 vests control of rolls in the ECI. Section 21 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 lets it order a special revision for reasons recorded in writing.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2026, GS2, 10 marks] Is the right to vote a fundamental right? Discuss the position of the Election Commission of India while undertaking the revision of electoral rolls. Can it also examine the question of citizenship of voters?”

  • Necessary corrective

    Why in the News

    Electoral roll revision is moving from the Special Intensive Revision (SIR)‘s mapping and “logical discrepancy” checks back to enrolment on the original Form 6, the voter application form, without the ancestry declaration. The Election Commission of India (ECI) has announced a special summary revision (SSR) in 17 States and Union Territories, with a drive to re-enrol those “left out”, an implicit admission of the SIR’s flaws.

    What is a summary revision, and how does the special drive differ from the SIR?

    1. What it is: A summary revision is the routine annual update of electoral rolls, adding new electors and removing dead or shifted ones. It is like refreshing a club’s membership list rather than rebuilding it.
    2. Legal basis: Section 21 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 provides for the revision of rolls.
    3. Stalled by the SIR: The exercise was halted last year during the SIR, a document based rebuild of the rolls. It resumes with January 1, 2027 as the qualifying date, by which applicants must turn eighteen.
    4. Checks dropped: The drive drops mapping, which linked each voter to an older roll, and the discrepancy checks. The ECI thereby concedes that the SIR did not need them.
    5. The takeaway: By returning to routine methods, the ECI is undoing the very hurdles that removed voters during the SIR.

    What do the new measures concede about the SIR?

    1. Cap on objections: The ECI has capped Form 7 objections, used to seek deletion of a name, after reports of bulk filings in several States.
    2. Searchable rolls: Parties and candidates will get rolls as searchable text PDFs, so wrongful deletions are easier to trace.
    3. Repair before polls: Uttar Pradesh, Punjab and Uttarakhand, voting early next year, can repair truncated rolls, re-enrolling wrongly deleted voters and adding new ones without quasi-citizenship tests that asked voters to prove their eligibility.

    What remains unresolved where States have already voted on SIR rolls?

    1. West Bengal backlog: Appellate tribunals have disposed of barely 3% of 38 lakh appeals against deletion.
    2. High restoration rate: Deleted electors filed 22 lakh of these appeals, and tribunals restored electors in 93% of cases decided.
    3. Unclear route for appellants: The ECI has not said whether they can use the new drive, or what becomes of the tribunals.
    4. Bihar’s missing women: Bihar’s roll gender ratio, women electors per thousand men, fell from 907 in the last Lok Sabha rolls to 892 after the SIR. Young married women struck off must be allowed to re-enrol.
    5. Supreme Court’s role: The Supreme Court upheld the SIR in May and is now hearing petitions on West Bengal, Delhi and the Commission’s conduct. It should ensure genuine voters are reinstated.

    Are correctives enough without accountability?

    1. Burden on the elector: The ECI’s own 2002-03 guidelines did not shift the burden of proving eligibility onto the elector, and future intensive revisions should return to them.
    2. Role of protest: The corrective steps owe much to sustained protests against the SIR.
    3. Dissent within the ECI: The two Election Commissioners objected on record to decisions of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC), and their questions remain unanswered.
    4. Appointment dispute: Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023) set a selection panel for election commissioners that included the Chief Justice of India. Parliament replaced it by law, and a two judge Bench split on that law last month.
    5. Call for resignation: The CEC who presided over the flawed process, Gyanesh Kumar, should resign.

    Challenges

    1. Time before polls: The SSR runs only months before elections in three States, leaving little time to find deleted voters.
    2. Awareness among the deleted: Many struck off voters, especially migrants and married women who moved, do not know they were removed.
    3. Field staff load: Booth level officers (BLOs), who make the house visits, are stretched after back to back revisions.

    Way Forward

    1. Separate reporting: The ECI should report re-enrolments after deletion separately from fresh enrolments.
    2. Visits, not forms: The drive’s house-to-house visits should do the work, so the burden does not fall on electors again.
    3. Clear route for appeals: The ECI should say whether West Bengal’s appellants can use the drive and what happens to the tribunals.

    Conclusion

    The ECI’s correctives can repair the rolls from here on, but they do not account for voters already struck off or for the decisions that struck them off. Whether the Supreme Court restores deleted voters in States that have voted, and how the dispute over appointing election commissioners is settled, is what to watch.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2026, GS2, 10 marks] Is the right to vote a fundamental right? Discuss the position of the Election Commission of India while undertaking the revision of electoral rolls. Can it also examine the question of citizenship of voters?”

  • Export surge paves way for reform push

    Export surge paves way for reform push

    Why in the News

    India’s merchandise exports rose 23% to $44.4 billion in September, extending a run of strong months after several sluggish years. The surge is led by engineering and electronics goods and helped by a weaker rupee, even as the trade deficit with China keeps widening.

    What are merchandise exports, and why does this surge stand out?

    1. What it is: Merchandise exports are physical goods a country sells abroad, as distinct from services such as software. Like a shop’s sales counter, they show how much the world buys from Indian factories and farms.
    2. Why it is tracked: Export earnings pay for imports. When imports exceed exports, the gap is the trade deficit, which India must finance with money from abroad.
    3. Sluggish record: After a jump in the Covid period, exports barely grew, rising less than 5% in the four years to March 2026.
    4. The takeaway: Exports are growing fast for the first time in years, so India earns more of the foreign currency it needs to pay for imports.

    What is driving the surge?

    1. Engineering and electronics: Exports of these two segments have crossed $100 billion in the financial year so far, up 26% on the same period last year.
    2. Share of non-oil exports: The two sectors now make up almost half of all non-oil exports, meaning exports other than petroleum products.
    3. United States market: The US remains India’s largest export market. Exports to it rose 48% in September, though the tariff terms Washington will apply are still unclear.
    4. China market: Exports to China are up 36% in the year so far.
    5. Gulf weakness: Shipments to the Middle East, including the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Saudi Arabia, remain depressed.

    Why does the import side still worry?

    1. China trade deficit: China holds the largest share of India’s imports. India’s trade deficit with China widened to $68.9 billion in April to September, from $54.4 billion a year earlier.
    2. Current account deficit: The current account deficit (CAD) is the amount by which India’s payments abroad for goods, services and income exceed its receipts.
    3. ICRA forecast: Rating agency ICRA expects the CAD to rise to $13 to 15 billion in the July to September quarter.
    4. Causes of the wider CAD: ICRA expects a modest rise in the merchandise trade deficit. It also expects lower invisible earnings, the receipts from services, remittances and investment income.

    Should the RBI let a weaker rupee help exporters?

    1. Rupee and competitiveness: A weaker rupee makes Indian goods cheaper abroad, so the currency’s decline has helped exporters compete.
    2. RBI intervention: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has announced several measures and intervened in the foreign exchange market to slow the rupee’s fall.
    3. Stated policy: The RBI says it intervenes only to contain excess volatility, meaning sharp swings in the exchange rate, not to hold a set rate.
    4. No rupee target: Holding the rupee at a fixed rupee-dollar level would cancel the price advantage exporters now enjoy, so the RBI should avoid targeting one.

    Challenges

    1. Tariff exposure in the US: India’s largest market is also its most uncertain, so a tariff change can quickly reverse gains. Eg. US tariffs of up to 50% on Indian goods (2025).
    2. Import-heavy electronics: Electronics exports rely on imported components, many of them from China, so higher exports also raise imports.
    3. Currency-led gains: Competitiveness that comes from a falling rupee fades once the rupee recovers, and a weak rupee raises the cost of imported oil.

    Way Forward

    1. Contentious trade deals: The Ministry of Commerce and Industry should move ahead on the more contentious free trade agreements (FTAs), beyond the several already signed.
    2. Manufacturing and investment: The government should boost manufacturing and attract more foreign investment to widen the export base.
    3. Component manufacturing: Expand domestic electronics component production under the Electronics Component Manufacturing Scheme to cut reliance on Chinese inputs.
    4. Gulf markets: Use the India-UAE Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (2022) to revive shipments to West Asia.

    Conclusion

    India’s exports are growing again on two strong sectors and a weaker rupee, but the widening deficit with China shows the gains rest partly on imported inputs. Whether exports hold up once the rupee steadies and US tariff terms settle will show if the surge is lasting.

    Key numbers

    1. Exports, April to September: $259 billion in the first half of this financial year.
    2. Annual exports: $422 billion (2021-22) to $441 billion (2025-26).

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2020] With reference to the international trade of India at present, which of the following statements is/are correct? 1. India’s merchandise exports are less than its merchandise imports. 2. India’s imports of iron and steel, chemicals, fertilisers and machinery have decreased in recent years. 3. India’s exports of services are more than its imports of services. 4. India suffers from an overall trade/current account deficit. Select the correct answer using the code given below: (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 4 only (c) 3 only (d) 1, 3 and 4 only ANSWER: (d)”

  • A contested UNSC seat poses a test for India

    A contested UNSC seat poses a test for India

    Why in the News

    India has launched its bid for a non-permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) for 2028-29, with the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) voting in June 2027. Unlike India’s past wins, the seat is contested: Tajikistan, which has never served, was already the Asia-Pacific group’s agreed candidate. India lost both its earlier contests, to Pakistan in 1975 and Japan in 1996.

    How is a non-permanent UNSC seat won?

    1. What it is: Besides its permanent members, the UNSC has ten elected seats, filled by UNGA vote for two year terms. Like a club rotating posts, each region usually agrees its candidate in advance.
    2. Two thirds rule: A winner needs two thirds of the Assembly, so India needs at least 129 votes of 193.
    3. Regional groups: Seats rotate among the Asia-Pacific, African, Latin American and Caribbean (GRULAC), Western European and Others (WEOG) and Eastern European groups.
    4. Consensus or contest: Groups sometimes settle candidates decades in advance. When consensus breaks, the race moves to the full UNGA.
    5. The takeaway: A seat India once won by turn must now be won by votes.

    Why does India want a ninth term now?

    1. Past record: India has served eight terms as the 55 member Asia-Pacific group’s consensus choice. Even Pakistan votes for India in these elections, and India returns the favour.
    2. Unfinished agenda: COVID-19 disrupted India’s last term. The government wants resolutions on terrorism and UN reform before its own term ends in 2029.
    3. Permanent seat elusive: With permanent membership out of reach, frequent elected terms keep India inside the Council’s decision making.

    What works against India in a contest?

    1. First timers favoured: India’s size, economy and Council record do not win seats by themselves. Many members favour small countries that have never served.
    2. Tajikistan’s pitch: Tajikistan presents itself as a small country that will “listen to all voices, large and small”, which appeals to an under represented Global South.
    3. Bloc arithmetic: Tajikistan is endorsed by Central Asia and the 57 member Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC).
    4. The battleground: India expects the Global North, Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), Caribbean Community (CARICOM) and Pacific island votes. The decisive votes lie in Africa, South America and South Asia.

    What do this year’s UN votes signal?

    1. Anti big power mood: Global South votes have run against the US, Russia and Israel, with at least 13 resolutions criticising Israel in the 80th session.
    2. Upsets: First timer Kyrgyzstan beat the western backed Philippines, and Germany lost to Portugal and Austria, a loss attributed to its support for Israel.
    3. UNGA presidency: Bangladesh’s Foreign Minister Khalilur Rahman beat a western backed candidate from Cyprus.
    4. India’s exposure: Strategic autonomy, India’s refusal to join any bloc, may help it, but its Israel ties may draw questions after the Prime Minister’s visit in February 2026.

    What are India’s options?

    1. Persuade Tajikistan to withdraw: Kazakhstan stepped aside in 2010 and Afghanistan in 2013. Leaders met at the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) summit in Bishkek without any withdrawal.
    2. Cost of a Tajik exit: Global South states may see India as putting its second turn in a decade above a small country’s first.
    3. Step aside: India could return a year or two later with full group backing, honouring Tajikistan’s hosting of an Indian Air Force base at Ayni and a medical base at Farkhor.
    4. Split term: Dividing the term has worked only between evenly matched candidates.

    Challenges

    1. Incumbency fatigue: Frequent terms weaken India against a first time candidate.
    2. Israel ties: Close ties with Israel may cost votes in an Assembly that punished western backed candidates this year.
    3. Partner at stake: Defeating a partner that hosted Indian military facilities could strain ties in Central Asia.

    Way Forward

    1. Sequenced terms: Agree with Tajikistan that one candidate yields now for assured group backing next time.
    2. Global South outreach: Court African, Latin American and South Asian votes through development partnerships.
    3. Early decision: Decide whether to contest or step aside well before the vote.

    Conclusion

    In this contest India’s size counts for less than a small country’s claim to a first turn. Whether New Delhi fights, negotiates or steps aside will show whether it ranks Global South leadership above one more elected term.

    Key numbers

    1. India’s UNSC terms: 1950-51, 1967-68, 1972-73, 1977-78, 1984-85, 1991-92, 2011-12, 2021-22.
    2. Record margins: 187 of 191 votes (2010); 184 of 192 (2020).
    3. Japan: 12 UNSC terms; bid announced in 2024 for the 2043 election.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2015, GS2, 12 marks] Discuss the impediments India is facing in its pursuit of a permanent seat in UN Security Council.”

  • India’s problem of overtreatment, overmedication

    India’s problem of overtreatment, overmedication

    Why in the News

    Modern medicine’s growing power to test and treat is increasingly turning into overtreatment and overmedication: tests, medicines and procedures a patient does not need. In India this sits alongside undertreatment, since many still lack essential primary care, affordable medicines and timely treatment.

    What is overtreatment, and how does it begin?

    1. What it is: Overtreatment is a cascade: a test spots a chance abnormality, which leads to more tests, a diagnosis and a possibly permanent prescription. It is like a car service that keeps finding parts to replace.
    2. Prevention turned treatment: A check up meant to prevent illness can end in long term medication or surgery.
    3. The takeaway: The harm comes from a chain no one stops, so patients carry medicines and procedures they never needed.

    What drives overtreatment?

    1. Unnecessary testing: A 2016 review found routine health check packages often include unwarranted tests. These cause false positives, anxiety and overdiagnosis, meaning labelling conditions that would never have caused harm.
    2. Fragmented, specialist led care: Patients with common problems go straight to specialists, and chronic patients see several, each optimising one part of care, so the patient is treated in parts.
    3. Healthcare as a marketplace: Tests, supplements and devices are sold as products, and payment rewards activity:
      • the fee for service model pays per test and procedure, and many patients think a visit incomplete without a prescription;
      • insurance creates moral hazard, behaviour that changes because someone else pays: people skip preventive care (ex ante), and hospitals and patients choose costlier care after illness (ex post).
    4. Patient expectations: Worried patients want something tangible, so reassurance looks like inaction. Busy doctors often comply.
    5. Defensive medicine: Clinicians fearing a missed rare diagnosis order another test as the safer option, yet every test can uncover abnormalities that would never cause harm.

    Why are older adults most at risk?

    1. Polypharmacy: Polypharmacy, taking several medicines at once, affects about 49% of older adults in India, by a 2021 review of Indian studies.
    2. Five or more medicines: A 2025 study found roughly one in three older adults take five or more prescribed medicines.
    3. Inappropriate medicines: The same study found potentially inappropriate medicines in 28.8% of cases.
    4. Medication reviews: Not everyone on several medicines is overtreated, but the figures show why medication reviews and deprescribing, stopping medicines no longer needed, must become routine.

    What does the global Choosing Wisely movement show?

    1. Middle income spread: Overtreatment was first recognised in high income countries and is now visible across many middle income nations.
    2. Choosing Wisely: This global movement asks doctors and patients to choose interventions more carefully, with specialty societies listing tests and treatments to question (2012 to 2023).
    3. Scale of the lists: Nearly 80 specialty societies published close to 700 recommendations on low value care, care that adds cost or risk without benefit.

    Challenges

    1. Weak primary care: About 40% of public health funds reach primary care, against the two thirds target in the National Health Policy, 2017.
    2. Antibiotic overuse: Over prescription of antibiotics has made India a global hotspot for antimicrobial resistance (AMR), where drugs stop working against infections.
    3. Patients pay directly: Households pay about two fifths of all health spending out of pocket (2021-22), so needless tests drain family budgets.

    Way Forward

    1. Primary care first: Restore the family physician as first contact for non emergency needs, referring patients onward and reconciling prescriptions.
    2. Review and stop dates: Give every prescription a review date and, where suitable, a stop date, and hold structured medication reviews for people on five or more medicines.
    3. Indian lists: Professional societies and the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) should list low value tests and treatments, and hospitals should measure unnecessary care avoided.
    4. Four patient questions: Before any test or treatment, patients should ask why it is needed, what happens if they wait, its benefits and risks, and the alternatives.
    5. Pay for outcomes: Payment systems and insurers should reward outcomes and continuity of care, not volume.

    Conclusion

    India must fix too little care and too much care at once, and both trace back to a weak first point of contact. Whether insurers and professional bodies begin to reward restraint will show if Indian medicine can learn when not to act.

    Government Initiatives for Primary Healthcare

    1. Ayushman Arogya Mandirs (AAMs): Over 1.85 lakh centres, formerly Health and Wellness Centres, provide primary care including screening for non communicable diseases.
    2. Pradhan Mantri Bhartiya Janaushadhi Pariyojana (PMBJP): Jan Aushadhi Kendras sell generic medicines at 50% to 90% lower prices.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2014, GS3, 12 marks] Can overuse and the availability of antibiotics without doctor’s prescription, the contributors to the emergence of drug-resistant diseases in India? What are the available mechanisms for monitoring and control? Critically discuss the various issues involved.”

  • India’s water plants are failing to catch elusive ‘forever chemicals’

    India’s water plants are failing to catch elusive ‘forever chemicals’

    Why in the News

    India’s drinking water standard, IS 10500:2012, sets no limit for per and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), and at one Chennai plant treated water carried more of them than raw water. An Indian Institute of Technology Madras (IIT-Madras) study found all eight target PFAS 5% to 103% higher after treatment, and systems that can remove these “forever chemicals” are not yet commercially available.

    What are PFAS, and why are they called forever chemicals?

    1. What it is: PFAS are synthetic chemicals built on several carbon-fluorine bonds, among the strongest in chemistry, so they barely break down. Like plastic litter, they stay in soil and water long after release.
    2. Industrial uses: Industry has used PFAS for about 60 years in coatings, textiles and other industrial products.
    3. Precursors: Some fluorinated compounds are precursors, less stable chemicals that later turn into stable PFAS. A test that looks only for a fixed list of PFAS misses them.
    4. The takeaway: A chemical that does not degrade and slips past standard tests can build up in drinking water unseen, which is why the missing limit matters.

    What have Indian studies found?

    1. IIT-Madras study (2024): The team analysed 14 samples from groundwater, surface water and successive stages of a Chennai treatment plant. Residential wells near garbage dumps carried the highest PFAS levels.
    2. Precursor conversion in treatment: The likely cause of the rise is unidentified precursors turning into stable PFAS inside the plant. The study did not measure them.
    3. Visakhapatnam coast: A GITAM (Deemed to be) University study tested seawater and sewage for 77 PFAS and found 38.
    4. Sewage as a source: A model estimated sewage supplies about 41% of the median coastal PFAS level. Separating household from factory inputs needs systematic sampling where they mix.

    Why is the true scale of contamination unclear?

    1. No common method: A 2025 review of studies from Gujarat, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal called PFAS a real concern of unclear extent. Research groups test PFAS differently, so results cannot be compared.
    2. Fixed lists miss compounds: The eight target PFAS are a fraction of the fluorinated compounds likely present, so testing should go beyond a fixed list.
    3. Better tools, new errors: High resolution mass spectrometry, a lab screening method, can find PFAS beyond a fixed list. Samples can also pick up stray PFAS during collection.

    How harmful are PFAS?

    1. Risk depends on exposure: Detecting PFAS does not by itself show a health risk, which depends on the type, dose, duration and route of exposure.
    2. Cancer classification: The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), a World Health Organization body, issued a 2025 monograph. It classed perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) as “carcinogenic to humans” and perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) as “possibly carcinogenic to humans”.
    3. Animal evidence: A study published this February found a mix of 24 PFAS delayed zebrafish hatching, slowed growth, built up in blood and lowered heart rates.

    How is India regulating PFAS?

    1. No manufacturing ban: The Union Environment Ministry says no specific regulation bans PFAS manufacturing.
    2. Standard under revision: A Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) Working Group on Emerging Contaminants and Forever Chemicals is examining limits. How many PFAS to cover, and how to test them, is not yet final.
    3. Baseline data: The CSIR-Indian Institute of Toxicology Research (CSIR-IITR), Lucknow, is in a United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) funded National Implementation Plan to build baseline exposure data. The institute can detect 50 PFAS molecules.

    Challenges

    1. Treatment cannot remove PFAS: Conventional biological wastewater treatment cannot remove PFAS, and low cost adsorption materials that bind them are still undeveloped.
    2. No penalty pathway: No clear regulatory pathway exists to penalise a source responsible for PFAS contamination.
    3. Named chemical gaps: Regulating only a named list of chemicals leaves precursors and transformation products outside the law.
    4. Data gaps as delay: Waiting for complete exposure data can hold up controls even on PFAS whose hazards are well established.

    Way Forward

    1. Precautionary interim limits: BIS should set interim limits for well studied PFAS in the revised standard now.
    2. Chemical inventory: Establish which PFAS are manufactured, imported and used in India, alongside baseline monitoring and toxicology studies.
    3. Harmonised monitoring: Adopt one national testing method that also screens for precursors and other fluorinated compounds.

    Conclusion

    India has evidence of PFAS in its water but a standard that does not yet measure them. Whether BIS adopts interim limits that also reach precursors, or waits for full exposure data, will decide how soon treated water is safe.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2024] With reference to perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) that are used in making many consumer products, consider the following statements: 1. PFAS are found to be widespread in drinking water, food, and food packaging materials. 2. PFAS are not easily degraded in the environment. 3. Persistent exposure to PFAS can lead to bioaccumulation in animal bodies. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1,2 and 3* ANSWER: (d)”

  • Sound and fiery

    Why in the News

    Green crackers, the Supreme Court’s answer to Deepavali smog since 2018, promise cleaner fireworks but do little in practice to curb air and noise pollution. The Court’s latest order permits specified next generation joined green crackers and declines a total ban on fireworks, invoking public sentiment, as Delhi and the National Capital Region (NCR) head into another winter.

    What are green crackers, and why did the Court turn to them?

    1. What it is: A green cracker is a firework with a modified chemical mix that releases less smoke and dust per cracker. Like a “lite” product, it means less harm per unit, not none.
    2. CSIR-NEERI: The Council of Scientific and Industrial Research-National Environmental Engineering Research Institute (CSIR-NEERI) promoted green crackers. It says the newer generation cuts PM10, the coarser inhalable dust, by 45% to 60%.
    3. Arjun Gopal judgment (2018): In Arjun Gopal and Others vs Union of India, the Supreme Court stopped short of a ban. It allowed only reduced emission and green crackers.
    4. Laris and time window: The same judgment banned joined crackers (laris), strings that burst in a chain, and set a two hour window for bursting.
    5. The takeaway: Green crackers let the Court avoid a total ban and still promise cleaner air, so the whole policy rests on whether they really pollute less.

    How has the Court’s stance on fireworks swung since 2016?

    1. Tighten and loosen cycle: The Court has alternately tightened and loosened its curbs on fireworks in the NCR, so the rules change from winter to winter.
    2. 2016 suspension: After Deepavali pushed fine particle pollution (PM2.5, particles small enough to reach deep into the lungs) to extreme levels, the Court suspended licences for selling fireworks in the NCR.
    3. 2017 relaxation and reversal: In September 2017 the Court relaxed the suspension, partly to protect existing licence holders and livelihoods. It restored the suspension for Deepavali that October.

    How much do crackers add to Delhi’s winter pollution?

    1. Not the main source: Construction dust, vehicles, stubble burning and stagnant, cold air drive Delhi’s winter pollution, not crackers.
    2. Acute spikes: When those sources push the air towards “severe” levels, crackers add a sharp, short spike on top.
    3. Spike under green crackers: In 2025, the first Deepavali after the Court permitted limited green crackers, Delhi recorded its worst post Deepavali fine particle average since 2021.

    Why do green crackers fall short?

    1. Lab claims versus real use: CSIR-NEERI’s promised cut in particulate emissions does not hold under real world conditions.
    2. More crackers, same smoke: When “cleaner” crackers are burst in greater numbers, the savings in particulate pollution disappear, so a lower emission per cracker yields no lower total.
    3. Noise left out: The claimed gains count only particulate matter and do not account for noise pollution at all.
    4. Sentiment versus health: By invoking public sentiment to refuse a total ban, the Court has set cultural demand against a health harm its own earlier orders acknowledged.

    Challenges

    1. Counterfeit certification: The Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM), the NCR’s statutory air quality body, found registered makers selling green cracker QR codes to unregistered ones. Unauthorised crackers then passed as certified.
    2. No local testing: The explosives regulator, the Petroleum and Explosives Safety Organisation (PESO), had no testing facility in Delhi, so crackers sold there could not be checked.
    3. Police cannot tell: In 2018 and 2019 the police could not distinguish green crackers from conventional ones, so curbs could not be enforced on the street.
    4. Informal industry: Much fireworks manufacturing runs outside the formal sector, beyond licensing and inspection. Eg. Small units around Sivakasi, Tamil Nadu.

    Way Forward

    1. Formal manufacturing: Bring fireworks units into the formal sector, with licensing and inspection, so regulations are followed in practice.
    2. Traceable QR codes: Certifying bodies should issue codes only against verified registrations and audit who sells them.
    3. Testing in the NCR: PESO should set up a testing facility in Delhi.
    4. Public health awareness: Spread awareness of the health toll among those who love crackers, so demand falls alongside supply.

    Conclusion

    Green crackers let the Court avoid choosing between festival sentiment and clean air, but they deliver neither a real pollution cut nor enforceable rules. Until manufacturing is formal and certification can be checked on the street, each new order will change which crackers are legal more than how much pollution they cause.

    Key numbers

    1. PM2.5 behind the 2016 suspension: above 700 µg/m3 in the NCR after Deepavali (November 2016).
    2. Delhi post Deepavali PM2.5, 2025: 488 µg/m3 average; hourly peak of 675 µg/m3.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2015, GS1, 12 marks] Mumbai, Delhi and Kolkata are the three mega cities of the country but the air pollution is much more serious problem in Delhi as compared to the other two. Why is this so?”

  • In Manipur, the work of peace is still to be done

    Why in the News

    At least nine people were killed in a single night across Manipur‘s hill districts of Kamjong, Kangpokpi and Ukhrul, in ambushes and gunfights between armed Kuki and Naga groups. After three and a half years of ethnic violence, the State has only a fragile calm. The killings show the State government cannot heal or contain its divides.

    What has the Manipur conflict become?

    1. What it is: Manipur’s conflict is a chain of ethnic clashes over land and identity, begun in May 2023 between the valley’s Meiteis and the hill based Kuki-Zo. Like a fire opening new fronts, it now involves the Nagas.
    2. Kuki-Naga fault line: The old Kuki-Naga rivalry that fuelled bloodshed in the 1990s has reopened. Since February, dozens from both communities have been killed and houses torched.
    3. Overlapping conflicts: Meiteis, Kukis and Nagas are now caught in overlapping conflicts, so a settlement between any two groups no longer ends the violence.
    4. Blockades: Civilians bear the violence and also blockades across the hill districts that cut their access to essential supplies.
    5. The takeaway: A two sided conflict has become three cornered, so restoring order now needs the State to act across every hill district at once.

    Why have President’s Rule and an elected government not restored peace?

    1. President’s Rule: After the N Biren Singh government was dissolved in February 2025, central rule was expected to bring an administration seen as less partisan.
    2. Partial calm: Large scale clashes declined under President’s Rule, but normalcy stayed elusive and the deep divides between communities persisted.
    3. Elected government: As calls for an elected government grew, Yumnam Khemchand Singh, a Meitei like his predecessor, became Chief Minister, with a Kuki and a Naga Deputy Chief Minister.
    4. Representation without settlement: Power sharing raised hope that political representation would lead to a lasting settlement, but Kuki-Naga violence has grown since.
    5. Central support: The Prime Minister met the Chief Minister last Saturday and promised all possible assistance to the State government.

    Why have weapons surrender appeals failed?

    1. Looted armouries: Thousands of firearms have been looted from State armouries since the conflict began, and armed groups still hold them.
    2. Governor’s appeal: Soon after President’s Rule was imposed, the Governor called for the surrender of weapons.
    3. Chief Minister’s ultimatum: In August the Chief Minister set a 15 day ultimatum for the voluntary surrender of illegal firearms.
    4. Continued gun violence: Shootings have gone on after both appeals, which shows that voluntary surrender has not worked.

    Challenges

    1. Physical separation: The communities remain split by security manned buffer zones, which block movement, trade and contact.
    2. Displacement: Thousands cannot return home. Eg. Around 60,000 people displaced since 2023 (government figures).
    3. Rival political demands: Kuki-Zo organisations demand a separate administration, which remains the central unresolved issue.
    4. Porous Myanmar border: Cross border drug and arms trafficking funds armed groups. Eg. The Moreh drug corridor in Manipur.

    Way Forward

    1. Demilitarise society: Recover looted and illegal firearms and re-establish the State’s authority across the hill districts.
    2. Disarm and prosecute: Disarm the armed groups and prosecute those responsible for the killings as an immediate priority.
    3. Freedom of movement: Reopen roads and end blockades so people can move freely and live safely alongside one another.
    4. Sustained dialogue: Create conditions for continuing dialogue among Meitei, Kuki and Naga representatives as the start of a long reconciliation.

    Conclusion

    Manipur has moved from central rule to a power sharing elected government, but neither has disarmed the groups driving the violence. Recovery of looted weapons and safe movement across the hills will show whether the State has begun to restore its authority.

    Back2Basics: President’s Rule (Article 356)

    1. Constitutional basis: Article 356 lets the President take over a State’s government when its constitutional machinery fails, usually on the Governor’s report.
    2. Effect: The State’s Council of Ministers is dismissed and Parliament exercises the State legislature’s powers. The Assembly may be suspended or dissolved.
    3. Judicial review: S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994) made a proclamation under Article 356 open to judicial review.
    4. Manipur’s spell: The Assembly was kept in suspended animation rather than dissolved, and President’s Rule was revoked in February 2026.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2025, GS3, 15 marks] What are the major challenges to internal security and peace process in the North-Eastern States? Map the various peace accords and agreements initiated by the government in the past decade.”