💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (August Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

GS Paper: GS3-18.Conservation, Environmental Pollution and Degradation, Environmental Impact Assessment.

  • [2nd November 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The Nilgiris as a shared wilderness

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q) How does biodiversity vary in India? How is the Biological Diversity Act,2002 helpful in conservation of flora and fauna? (UPSC CSE 2018)

    Q) How can the mountain ecosystem be restored from the negative impact of development initiatives and tourism? (UPSC CSE 2019)

    Q) Examine the status of forest resources of India and its resultant impact on climate change. (UPSC CSE 2020)

    Mentor’s Comment:  The Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve, a region in southern India, is celebrated for its rich biodiversity and unique ecosystems. However, it faces significant environmental challenges that threaten its ecological balance and the livelihoods of local communities. 

    Today’s editorial explores the pressing issues surrounding the Nilgiris as a shared wilderness, emphasizing the need for sustainable practices and community involvement in conservation efforts.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    Experts at a recent conference emphasized the urgent need for community involvement in restoration efforts within the Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve (NBR).

    • They highlighted threats such as invasive species, unregulated tourism, and land use changes that have disrupted the ecological balance.
    About the Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve (NBR):

    • Located in the Western Ghats of southern India, it is a critical ecological zone renowned for its rich biodiversity and unique ecosystems.
    • Established in 1986, it was the first biosphere reserve in India and is recognized under UNESCO’s Man and the Biosphere Programme.
    • The NBR spans parts of Tamil Nadu, Kerala, and Karnataka, making it a significant area for conservation efforts.

    Significance:
    • The diverse vegetation types, ranging from tropical evergreen forests to montane sholas and grasslands, contribute to the region’s ecological richness.
    • It supports many endangered species like the Nilgiri Tahr and Lion-tailed Macaque.
    • The region’s forests are crucial for watershed management, helping to regulate water flow and maintain water quality for millions of people living downstream.
    • The forests within the NBR act as carbon sinks, absorbing CO2 from the atmosphere and helping mitigate climate change effects.

    What are the ecological challenges facing the Nilgiris?

    • Habitat Loss: Non-native plants like Lantana and Eucalyptus are taking over, outcompeting local flora and harming wildlife habitats.
      • Urbanization and agricultural expansion (like tea and coffee plantations) are destroying natural landscapes, leading to fragmentation of wildlife habitats.
    • Climate Change: Altered weather patterns are affecting plant and animal distributions, causing shifts in biodiversity and increasing soil erosion.
    • Unregulated Tourism: Increased tourist activity is causing littering and habitat disturbance, putting pressure on sensitive ecosystems.
      • As humans expand into wildlife areas, Human-animal conflicts arise, especially with elephants raiding crops, leading to retaliatory actions.
    • Illegal Activities: Poaching and illegal logging threaten the region’s biodiversity, particularly valuable species like sandalwood.

    How do indigenous communities interact with and contribute to the conservation of the Nilgiris?

    • Traditional Knowledge: Indigenous peoples have deep knowledge about local plants and animals, helping them manage resources sustainably.
      • For example, Their traditional farming methods, such as rotational agriculture, promote ecological balance and help maintain wildlife habitats.
    • Sustainable Practices: Many rely on non-timber forest products (like honey and medicinal plants) and practice eco-friendly agriculture, which supports both their livelihoods and biodiversity.
      • Indigenous groups actively participate in conservation projects, such as restoring degraded areas and managing invasive species.
    • Advocacy: Indigenous leaders advocate for their rights to land and resources, emphasizing their role as protectors of the environment.
      • They pass down traditional knowledge to younger generations through workshops, ensuring that conservation practices continue.

    What policies or initiatives are necessary to balance development and conservation in the Nilgiris?

    • Carbon Neutral Initiatives: Need to encourage eco-friendly tourism practices, such as cycling tours and car-free pathways, to reduce vehicular traffic and pollution.
    • Community Involvement: Facilitate the development of sustainable livelihoods that align with conservation goals, such as harvesting non-timber forest products. Their traditional knowledge can guide sustainable practices and restoration activities.
    • Regulation of Development Activities: State governments needs to enforce stringent regulations on construction activities to prevent encroachments and protect wetlands and other sensitive areas.
    • Restoration Projects: Need to develop programs that focus on restoring degraded habitats, such as montane grasslands and shola forests, which are critical for biodiversity.
    • Water Resource Protection: Need to implement measures to safeguard water bodies from pollution and encroachment, recognizing that the Nilgiris are vital water sources for surrounding regions.
      •  For example, restoring wetland areas that have been converted for agriculture or development, enhancing their capacity to retain water and support biodiversity.

    Way Forward: By recognizing the interconnectedness of culture and ecology, there is potential to develop sustainable practices that honor both the natural environment and the rich heritage of its inhabitants. The path forward lies in fostering collaboration and promoting awareness about the importance of conserving this unique biosphere for future generations.

    https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/the-nilgiris-as-a-shared-wilderness/article68820359.ece

  • Why the goal to arrest global temperature rise to 1.5°C is unrealistic?

    Why in the News?

    Over nine years ago, the world promised to cut emissions significantly, but it hasn’t succeeded. As a result, the goal of keeping global warming below 1.5 degrees is now out of reach.

    Is the 1.5°C Target Still Achievable?

    • Rising Emissions: Global emissions are still increasing, with 2023 seeing record levels. Despite clean energy advancements, emissions reductions have been insufficient to meet the pace required for the 1.5°C target.
    • Potential for Emission Peaking: The UNEP Emissions Gap Report suggests that emissions could peak by 2023 or 2024 if significant additional measures are taken, but global actions remain inconsistent and often insufficient.
    • Need for Accelerated Action: For the 1.5°C goal, global emissions need to drop by at least 43% by 2030 from 2019 levels.
      • Current projections indicate only a 2.6% reduction by 2030, far short of the required cuts.
    • Technological and Financial Challenges: Achieving the 1.5°C target hinges on rapid technological deployment, energy transition, and substantial financing for climate action. However, these remain constrained by a lack of coordination and resources.

    Implications of Exceeding the 1.5°C Limit

    • Increased Frequency of Extreme Events: Exceeding 1.5°C would lead to more frequent and severe extreme weather events, such as heatwaves, droughts, wildfires, and intense storms.
    • Impacts on Ecosystems and Biodiversity: Many species and ecosystems are sensitive to small temperature changes; coral reefs, for instance, face near-total collapse beyond 1.5°C warming.
    • Threats to Human Health and Livelihoods: Exceeding 1.5°C could lead to more heat-related illnesses, loss of productivity, water scarcity, and risks to food security, disproportionately affecting vulnerable populations.
    • Feedback Loops: Warming beyond 1.5°C may activate feedback loops (e.g., Arctic ice melt, permafrost thawing), which could lead to irreversible changes and make further warming difficult to control.

    Should We Reconsider the Focus on the 1.5°C Target?

    • Adaptation vs. Mitigation: Given the increasing difficulty of limiting warming to 1.5°C, some argue for a shift in focus towards adaptation strategies to manage the unavoidable impacts of higher temperatures.
    • Realigning Expectations: While the 1.5°C target was critical to rally global climate action, a shift towards realistic, achievable goals may better support gradual but sustained progress, especially if mitigation pathways fall short.
    • Moving Towards a ‘Just Transition’: With a likely overshoot of the 1.5°C target, there is a greater need to ensure that climate adaptation and resilience measures do not disproportionately burden low-income countries and communities.
    • Science-Based Overshoot Scenarios: The IPCC and other scientific bodies continue to assess overshoot scenarios (e.g., temporarily exceeding 1.5°C and then returning below it later) to guide global climate strategies. However, returning to a lower temperature after an overshoot requires substantial and sustained negative emissions, which are currently unfeasible at scale.

    Way forward: 

    • Prioritize Scalable Emissions Reductions and Resilient Adaptation: Accelerate global transition to renewable energy, improve energy efficiency, and reduce methane and other non-CO₂ emissions. Simultaneously, invest in adaptation measures to help vulnerable communities manage the impacts of warming beyond 1.5°C.
    • Strengthen Climate Finance and International Cooperation: Mobilize substantial climate funding for developing nations to support both mitigation and adaptation efforts. Enhance cross-border technology sharing and policy alignment to enable collective, equitable climate action.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q ‘Climate change’ is a global problem. How India will be affected by climate change? How Himalayan and coastal states of India will be affected by climate change? (UPSC IAS/2017)

  • Misuse of EPR legislation worsening India’s plastic problem, shows CSE report

    Why in the News?

    The Indian government’s 2022 “Extended Producer Responsibility” guidelines mark progress, but a recent report states that stronger measures are needed to fully enforce the “polluter pays” principle in plastic waste management, per a recent CSE report.

    What is the CSE report? 

    • A CSE report is a publication by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), a prominent Delhi-based think tank focused on environmental research and advocacy.
    • CSE reports analyze pressing environmental issues, often providing data-driven insights and policy recommendations.

    What is Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR)? 

    • Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) is a policy approach where producers are given significant financial and sometimes operational responsibility for the treatment or disposal of post-consumer products.
    • The primary goal of EPR is to make manufacturers accountable for the entire lifecycle of their products, especially in terms of environmental impact, by ensuring that they take part in the collection, recycling, and disposal processes.

    Extent of the misuse of EPR certificates in India’s plastic recycling industry

    • Fake Certificates: An assessment by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) and findings from the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) revealed the generation of over 700,000 fake recycling certificates, indicating widespread fraud among plastic recyclers.
    • Certificate Inflation: Some processors and recyclers reported volumes vastly exceeding their registered capacities.
      • For example, cement plants engaged in end-of-life co-processing claimed to process 335.4 million tonnes annually, despite an actual capacity of only 11.4 million tonnes.
    • Undermined Trust: Fraudulent activities result in artificially low certificate prices, undermining the credibility of the EPR system and making it difficult to accurately track plastic waste management.

    How does this impact environmental compliance and plastic waste management?

    • Underreported Waste Generation: PIBOs introduced 23.9 million tonnes of plastic packaging in April 2022, translating to an annual waste generation of approximately 8 million tonnes. However, CPCB’s estimate of 4.1 million tonnes of plastic waste generation annually indicates significant underreporting.
    • Limited Stakeholder Participation: The absence of key contributors, such as urban local bodies and informal waste collectors from the EPR system, reduces traceability and leaves much of the waste management burden on local governments.
    • Compromised Recycling Integrity: Due to low-cost fraudulent certificates, genuine recycling efforts suffer from underfunding and inadequate regulation, jeopardizing sustainable plastic waste management efforts and hindering the implementation of the “polluter pays” principle.

    What measures can be implemented to improve oversight and accountability within the EPR framework?

    • Inclusion of Informal Sector: Recognizing and formalizing the role of informal waste collectors and urban local bodies within the EPR framework could enhance waste collection, segregation, and recycling rates, creating a more transparent value chain.
    • Combatting Fraud: Strengthening the auditing and certification process to identify and remove fraudulent recyclers and processors, supported by stricter legal and financial penalties, would help deter misuse.
    • Transparent Reporting: Enhancing the EPR portal to ensure accurate data collection on plastic waste generation and disposal, and setting fair prices for recycling certificates to prevent undervaluation.
    • Standardizing Products: By mandating uniform standards for plastic packaging materials and designs, recyclability could be improved, reducing contamination and making recycling more effective.
    • Enhanced Monitoring and Accountability: Strengthening CPCB and State Pollution Control Boards’ (SPCBs) monitoring capacity and ensuring consistent enforcement of guidelines at both the state and central levels.

  • Mount Fuji

    Mount Fuji

    Why in the News?

    Japan’s iconic Mount Fuji has set a new record for the longest delay in snowfall since records began in 1894.

    Why delay in snowfall at Mount Fuji? 

    • Higher Temperatures: Japan’s hottest summer on record and above-average October temperatures have delayed the cooling needed for snow.
    • Heatwave: Japan experienced numerous “extremely hot” days with temperatures exceeding 35°C, even into September.
    • Jet Stream Shift: A northerly shift in the sub-tropical jet stream brought warmer air over Japan, further hindering snow formation.

    About Mount Fuji:

    Details
    Location Honshu Island, Japan, about 100 kilometers (62 miles) southwest of Tokyo.
    Height 3,776 meters (12,389 feet), making it the tallest mountain in Japan.
    Type of Volcano Stratovolcano, characterized by a conical shape formed from alternating layers of lava flow, ash, and tephra.
    Eruptions Last major eruption occurred in 1707 (Hoei eruption), causing ash to fall on Edo (now Tokyo).
    Geological Formation Formed through volcanic eruptions over thousands of years; current shape solidified around 300,000 years ago.
    Climate Varied climate with decreasing temperatures at higher altitudes; snow caps the summit from November to May.
    Surrounding Area Part of Fuji-Hakone-Izu National Park; surrounded by five lakes: Lake Kawaguchi, Lake Yamanaka, Lake Sai, Lake Shoji, and Lake Motosu.
    Cultural Significance • National symbol of Japan
    • Sacred in Shintoism, associated with the deity Konohanasakuya-hime
    • Known as one of Japan’s Three Holy Mountains
    Art and Literature A popular subject in traditional Japanese art (e.g., Hokusai’s Thirty-Six Views of Mount Fuji), referenced in poetry and literature.
    UNESCO World Heritage Site Designated as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2013 for its cultural significance and beauty.
    Cultural Festivals Hosts various festivals, such as the Fuji Shiba-sakura Festival, celebrating local flora.

     

    PYQ:

    [2021] Mention the global occurrence of volcanic eruptions in 2021 and their impact on regional environment.

  • Similipal Tiger Reserve

    Why in the News?

    The Odisha government has translocated a female tiger from Maharashtra’s Tadoba-Andhari Tiger Reserve to Similipal Tiger Reserve, the State’s largest, to enhance the genetic diversity of its tiger population.

    Similipal Tiger Reserve

    Why discuss this?

    • The All Odisha Tiger Estimation (AOTE-2023-24) says a total of 30 tigers were found in Odisha. Similipal has 27 of them.
    • A total of 13 adult tigers (seven females and six males) were found to be pseudo-melanistic in Similipal, and no other wild habitat in the world has pseudo-melanistic tigers.
      • Research indicates that a single mutation in the Transmembrane Aminopeptidase Q (Taqpep) gene causes Similipal’s black tigers to develop distinctive striped patterns.

    About Simlipal Tiger Reserve (STR):

    Details
    Location Located in the Mayurbhanj District, Northernmost part of Odisha, surrounded by high plateaus and hills.
    Highest Peak Twin peaks of Khairiburu and Meghashini, at 1515 meters above mean sea level.
    Designation Declared a Tiger Reserve in 1956; included in the Project Tiger national conservation program in 1973.
    UNESCO Recognition Included as part of the World Network of Biosphere Reserves by UNESCO in 2009.
    Terrain Mostly undulating and hilly, interspersed with open grasslands and wooded areas.
    Vegetation A mix of different forest types, predominantly Northern tropical moist deciduous and semi-evergreen patches.
    Tribal Communities Inhabited by various tribes including Kolha, Santhala, Bhumija, Bhatudi, Gondas, Khadia, Mankadia, and Sahara.
    Flora Home to 1078 species of plants, including 94 species of orchids, with Sal being the dominant tree species.
    Fauna Diverse wildlife including Leopard, Gaur, Elephant, Langur, Barking and Spotted Deer, Sloth Bear, Mongoose, Flying Squirrel, Porcupine, Turtle, Monitor Lizard, Python, Sambar, Pangolin, etc.

     

    PYQ:

    [2020] Among the following Tiger Reserves, which one has the largest area under “Critical Tiger Habitat”?

    (a) Corbett

    (b) Ranthambore

    (c) Nagarjunsagar-Srisailam

    (d) Sunderbans

  • 2024 Global Nature Conservation Index

    Why in the News?

    India has been ranked 176th in the Global Nature Conservation Index (NCI) 2024 with a score of 45.5 out of 100, placing it among the five worst performers alongside Kiribati (180), Turkey (179), Iraq (178), and Micronesia (177).

    Reasons for India’s Low Ranking:

    • High Rate of Land Conversion: 53% of India’s land is converted for urban, industrial, and agricultural purposes, contributing to deforestation and habitat fragmentation that severely impact biodiversity.
    • Soil Pollution: India’s sustainable nitrogen index is 0.77, indicating high levels of soil pollution primarily due to extensive pesticide use, threatening soil health and agricultural sustainability.
    • Minimal Marine Conservation: Only 0.2% of India’s national waterways are protected, with no protected areas in its Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), highlighting limited efforts in marine biodiversity conservation.
    • Illegal Wildlife Trade: India ranks as the fourth-largest illegal wildlife trader globally, with an estimated annual trade value of £15 billion, putting added pressure on vulnerable wildlife species.

    About the Nature Conservation Index (NCI):

    Details
    Developed By Goldman Sonnenfeldt School of Sustainability and Climate Change at Ben-Gurion University of the Negev.
    Purpose To assess each country’s progress in balancing conservation and development through data-driven analysis.
    Aim To help governments, researchers, and organizations identify concerns and enhance conservation policies for long-term biodiversity protection.
    Launch Date Launched on October 24, 2024.
    Scope Ranks 180 countries based on their conservation efforts.
    Pillars of the Index • Managing Protected Areas
    • Addressing Threats Against Biodiversity
    • Nature and Conservation Governance
    • Future Trends in Natural Resource Management
    Significance Provides insights into conservation policies and practices, aiding in the global effort to protect biodiversity and promote sustainable development.

    Key highlights of the reports:

    • Finland, Norway, Switzerland, Costa Rica, and New Zealand ranked highest, showing strong conservation practices and governance.
    • Nations with advanced climate adaptation policies (e.g., Sweden and Denmark) are better positioned to mitigate biodiversity risks from climate change.
    • Despite Protected Areas, 46.9% of terrestrial and 67.5% of marine species are in decline worldwide.
    • High-density nations such as Bangladesh and the Netherlands face intense biodiversity pressures, driving them to implement urban greening and sustainable practices.

    PYQ:

    [2018] “Momentum for Change: Climate Neutral Now” is an initiative launched by:

    (a) The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change

    (b) The UNEP Secretariat

    (c) The UNFCCC Secretariat

    (d) The World Meteorological Organisation

  • What is the Hasdeo Arand Forest?

    Why in the News?

    In Chhattisgarh’s Hasdeo Arand forest, tribals ambushed the police after tree-felling resumed for coal mining in the area.

    What is the Hasdeo Arand Forest?

    • Hasdeo Arand Forest is known as the “lungs of Chhattisgarh” due to its rich biodiversity.
    • It is the largest unfragmented forest in Central India with pristine Sal and teak forests.
    • It spans 1,879.6 sq km across the Sarguja, Korba, and Surajpur districts in Chhattisgarh.
      • The Hasdeo River runs through the forest.
    • It is home to nine protected species under Schedule I of the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972, including:
      • Elephants, leopards, sloth bears, Indian grey wolves, and Indian pangolins.
    • It supports 92 bird species, 25 mammals, 16 types of snakes, and serves as a corridor for elephants and tigers.
    • It hosts 640 plant species, including 128 medicinal plants and 40 timber-yielding species.

    Why are the People Protesting for its ‘Protection’?

    • Environmental Impact: Mining threatens to destroy the forest cover, impacting biodiversity and wildlife corridors.
    • Livelihood Concerns: Local communities depend on the forest for farming and forest produce.
    • Displacement Issues: Villagers report inadequate compensation and resettlement offers, which do not match the size of their current homes.
    • Alleged Forgery: Villagers allege that fake gram sabha resolutions were used to secure clearances for mining projects.
    • Demand for Cancellations: Activists want the Parsa coal block cancelled and assurances that the 1,995 sq km Lemru Reserve Forest will be protected from future mining.

    PYQ:

    [2012] A particular State in India has the following characteristics:

    1. It is located on the same latitude which passes through northern Rajasthan.

    2. It has over 70% of its area under forest cover.

    3. Over 12% of forest cover constitutes Protected Area Network in this State.

    Which one among the following States has all the above characteristics?

    (a) Arunachal Pradesh

    (b) Assam

    (c) Himachal Pradesh

    (d) Uttarakhand

  • Why ‘protected’ areas are seeing faster biodiversity decline?

    Why in the News?

    According to a recent study conducted by the Natural History Museum (NHM) in London, biodiversity is decreasing more rapidly within key protected areas than outside of them.

    What did the Biodiversity Intactness Index (BII) say?

    • The Biodiversity Intactness Index (BII) is a quantitative measure designed to assess the state of terrestrial biodiversity with its natural baseline, before significant human impact.
    • It decreased by 1.88% points globally between 2000 and 2020, indicating a loss in the average natural biodiversity of regions worldwide.
    • Within the 22% of ‘Critical Biodiversity Areas’ that are protected, biodiversity has declined by 2.1 percentage points, while non-protected areas saw a decline of 1.9 percentage points during the same period.

    Why is the decline happening?

    • Inadequate Ecosystem Protection: Many protected areas focus only on specific species rather than the entire ecosystem, failing to prioritize overall biodiversity intactness.
    • Pre-existing Degradation: Some protected areas may have been already degraded before being designated as protected, limiting their effectiveness in conserving biodiversity.
    • External Threats: Activities such as oil, gas, and mining concessions encroach on protected areas, leading to habitat destruction and further biodiversity loss.
    • Climate Crisis Impact: Increased frequency of extreme weather events, such as droughts and wildfires, has severely affected protected areas, undermining their conservation efforts.

    Steps taken by the Indian Government to conserve biodiversity:

    • Legislative Framework

        • Biological Diversity Act, 2002: Established to conserve biological resources and regulate access to these resources, ensuring equitable sharing of benefits derived from their use.
        • Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972: Facilitates the creation of Protected Areas for wildlife conservation and imposes penalties for illegal hunting.

    • Conservation Policies:

        • Project Tiger: Launched in 1973, this initiative aims to protect tiger populations across designated reserves.
        • Project Elephant: Initiated in 1992, it focuses on the management and protection of wild elephant populations and their habitats.
        • National Biodiversity Mission: A mission mode initiative aimed at documenting and conserving India’s biodiversity.

    • Protected Areas

      • Establishment of a Protected Area Network: This includes National Parks, Wildlife Sanctuaries, Conservation Reserves, and Community Reserves to provide better protection for wildlife and their habitats.
      • Designation of Biosphere Reserves: These reserves are aimed at conserving representative ecosystems.

    What should be done? (Way forward)

    • Ecosystem-Centric Management: Shift focus from individual species to the overall health of ecosystems to ensuring comprehensive protection of habitats and their interdependent species.
    • Strengthened Protection and Regulation: Implement stricter regulations to limit industrial activities (e.g., oil and gas exploration) within and around protected areas, alongside enforcing more robust land-use policies.
    • Community Engagement and Education: Involve local communities in conservation efforts and enhance public awareness about biodiversity’s importance, fostering a collective responsibility for sustainable practices.

  • US court to decide whether elephants get human rights

    Why in the News?

    Colorado’s highest court recently reviewed whether older African female elephants can legally contest their captivity, as the NonHuman Rights Project claims they are unlawfully confined.

    What is nonhuman?

    • Nonhuman animals are living beings other than humans, including mammals, birds, reptiles, fish, and insects, recognized for their capacity to feel, behave, and interact.

    What is Legal personhood? 

    • Legal personhood is the status granted to an entity, allowing it to hold legal rights and obligations, traditionally applied to humans and some organizations.
    • Example: All human individuals are recognized as legal persons. This allows them to enter into contracts, sue, and be sued in court.

    What Constitutes Legal Personhood for Nonhuman Animals?

    • Legal Personhood Definition: Legal personhood refers to the capacity of an entity to have legal rights and duties. In law, a “person” is not strictly limited to human beings; corporations, for example, are considered legal persons.
    • Application to Nonhuman Animals: Extending legal personhood to nonhuman animals involves granting them certain legal rights, such as the right to not be unlawfully confined or exploited. This would require redefining animals’ status from property to beings with inherent rights.
    • Arguments in Favor: Proponents argue that certain highly intelligent and socially complex animals, such as elephants, dolphins, and great apes, should be granted legal rights because they can experience suffering and possess a degree of autonomy akin to that of humans.
    • Arguments Against: Opponents of legal personhood for animals argue that the legal system is designed for human society and extending personhood to animals could lead to complex legal issues.
      • They contend that animal welfare can be ensured through legislative protections rather than redefining personhood.

    How can societies balance animal welfare with cultural practices that might clash with today’s views on animal rights?

    • Engagement and Dialogue: Encourage conversations between cultural leaders, communities, and animal rights advocates to understand different perspectives and find common ground on how to improve animal welfare while respecting traditions.
    • Education and Awareness: Promote education about animal welfare and the capacity of animals to feel pain and suffering, helping communities to reconsider practices and adopt alternatives that align with both cultural values and humane treatment.
    • Legal Frameworks: Implement laws that protect animal welfare while allowing for cultural practices to continue in a regulated manner, ensuring that such practices do not involve cruelty or inhumane treatment of animals.

    What are the Rights of Animals in the Indian Context?

    • Traditional and Cultural Practices: In India, animals play a significant role in various cultural and religious practices. For instance, cows are considered sacred in Hinduism, while elephants are used in festivals and ceremonies.
    • Legal Framework for Animal Rights: India has several laws aimed at protecting animal rights, such as the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960, and the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972. These laws establish standards for animal welfare and criminalize cruelty.
      • However, they stop short of granting legal personhood to animals.
    • Judicial Intervention: The Indian judiciary has taken progressive stances on animal rights in some cases.
      • For example, the Uttarakhand High Court in 2018 declared all animals in the state to be legal entities, with citizens acting as guardians. This ruling emphasized the need to protect animals’ dignity and well-being, though it did not grant full legal personhood.

    Conclusion: India can look toward a framework that balances animal welfare with cultural practices by adopting context-specific policies. This could include creating more robust welfare standards, engaging with communities to find humane alternatives, and fostering a cultural shift toward greater empathy for animals.

  • [pib] Environmental Ship Index (ESI)

    Why in the News?

    • Mormugao Port Authority has gained global recognition as an incentive provider on the Environmental Ship Index (ESI) platform.
      • It is the first port in India to implement Green Ship Incentives under the ESI, promoting eco-friendly practices in shipping.
      • The port launched the “Harit Shrey” scheme in October 2023, offering port fee discounts based on ESI ratings of commercial vessels.

    About the Environmental Ship Index (ESI):

    Details
    What is it? A scoring system that measures the environmental performance of ships, specifically their air pollution emissions.
    Establishment Launched in 2011 by the World Ports Sustainability Program (WPSP) under the International Association of Ports and Harbours (IAPH).
    Scope ESI evaluates emissions of:
    • Sulfur oxides (SOx)
    • Nitrogen oxides (NOx)
    • Carbon dioxide (CO₂)
    • Particulate matter from seagoing vessels.
    Purpose To encourage ships to adopt technologies and practices that minimize emissions, contributing to air quality improvement and climate change mitigation.

    How effective is ESI to reduce emissions, and what metrics are used to evaluate this effectiveness?

    • The ESI provides a framework for incentivizing ships based on their environmental performance, specifically targeting reductions in air emissions such as CO2, SOx, and NOx.  
    • The effectiveness of the ESI is evaluated using specific metrics, including a ship’s ESI score, which is derived from factors such as engine efficiency, fuel quality, and the implementation of emission reduction technologies.
    • The ESI enables ports to analyze the overall impact of green shipping initiatives through aggregated data on participating vessels.

    What are the future developments planned for the ESI?

    • Future plans include expanding metrics to cover additional pollutants and carbon intensity for a more comprehensive environmental assessment.
    • Enhancements in digital reporting for easier tracking of emissions data and performance analytics.
    • Planned updates will aim to support the International Maritime Organization’s (IMO) 2050 decarbonization targets, including zero-emission technology.

    How will they align with global maritime regulations aimed at decarbonization?

    • ESI updates will align with IMO’s MARPOL Annex VI regulations on pollutant emissions and greenhouse gases (GHG).
    • ESI’s future adaptations will address carbon intensity targets and promote alternative fuels like ammonia and hydrogen, in line with IMO’s goal of net-zero GHG emissions by 2050.
    • The ESI is part of the broader World Ports Sustainability Program (WPSP), promoting sustainability in port operations and low-carbon maritime trade.
    • ESI aims to further incentivize the adoption of energy-efficient engines, battery systems, and hybrid propulsion to support long-term emission reduction.

    PYQ:

    [2015] With reference to ‘Indian Ocean Rim Association for Regional Cooperation (IOR-ARC)’, consider the following statements:

    1. It was established very recently in response to incidents of piracy and accidents of oil spills.
    2. It is an alliance meant for maritime security only.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    (a) 1 only
    (b) 2 only
    (c) Both 1 and 2
    (d) Neither 1 nor 2