💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (August Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF

Why a flat map fails to accurately depict Earth

Why in the News

  • The UN General Assembly has adopted a resolution encouraging a shift from the Mercator projection towards the Equal Earth projection.
  • 164 countries, including India, supported the resolution.
  • The United States voted against, while six countries abstained.
  • The resolution is non-binding.
  • The debate centres on how world maps represent the relative size of different regions, particularly Africa.

What is a Map Projection?

  • A map projection converts the three-dimensional Earth into a two-dimensional map.
  • Every projection involves some form of distortion.
  • Four major properties are: Area, Shape, Distance, Direction
  • Major types include:
    • Conformal: Preserves local angles and shapes.
    • Equal-area: Preserves relative areas.
    • Equidistant: Preserves selected distances.
    • Compromise: Balances different types of distortion.

Mercator Projection

  • Developed by Gerardus Mercator in 1569.
  • Designed mainly for navigation.
  • Meridians and parallels are represented as straight lines.
  • A constant compass bearing can be represented as a straight line.
  • It is a conformal projection.

Major Limitation

  • Areas become increasingly exaggerated towards the poles.
  • Greenland and Antarctica therefore appear much larger than their actual relative size.
  • This can visually distort perceptions of the geographical size of regions.

Equal Earth Projection

  • Developed in 2018.
  • It is an equal-area projection.
  • Preserves the relative area of landmasses.
  • Particularly useful for:
    • Population distribution
    • Climate data
    • Land-use mapping
    • Resource distribution
  • It sacrifices some accuracy in shape and distance.

Which Projection for Which Purpose?

  • Navigation → Mercator or other conformal projections.
  • Statistical/thematic maps → Equal-area projections such as Equal Earth.
  • General world maps → Robinson or Winkel Tripel.
  • Polar regions → Azimuthal projections.

Challenges

  • UN resolutions are not legally binding.
  • Digital mapping systems continue to rely heavily on Mercator-derived projections.
  • Changing a projection does not eliminate distortion; it only changes which property is prioritised.
  • Therefore, maps should clearly mention the projection and its principal purpose.

Way Forward

  • Use projection according to purpose, rather than adopting one universal map.
  • Provide equal-area options in government statistical and mapping platforms.
  • Clearly mention the projection used on published maps.
  • Improve geographical literacy by teaching the limitations of different projections.

Prelims Pointers

  • Compromise projections → Balance multiple distortions.
  • Mercator → Conformal projection.
  • Mercator → Developed in 1569.
  • Mercator’s major use → Navigation.
  • Equal Earth → Equal-area projection.
  • Equal-area projection → Preserves relative areas.
  • Geostationary ≠ Geosynchronous is a separate orbital concept, not a map projection.
  • No flat map → Can simultaneously preserve area, shape, distance and direction perfectly.

Join the Community

Free Daily News, Daily Prelims and Mains questions.