💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (June Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF

Q4 (a)“For any kind of social re-engineering by successfully implementing welfare schemes, a civil servant must use reason and critical thinking in an ethical framework.” Justify this statement with suitable examples.

Social re-engineering refers to the deliberate attempt to transform social structures, behaviors, and cultural norms to achieve a more equitable society. Civil servants act as a “facilitator” of this change.

Need for reason and critical thinking in an ethical framework for successful social engineering

Diagnose real problems, not symptoms – Eg- Nutrition deficits need diet diversity, not only calories.

Build public trust and legitimacy. Eg- Transparent DBT reduced leakage and improved targeting.

Uphold constitutional morality over social morality. Eg- conditional cash transfer under “Kanyashree” scheme improved efficiency.

Design context-specific solutions. Eg- Jal Jeevan Mission adapted to local water sources.

Avoid one-size-fits-all policies. Eg- location specific housing designs under PM Awas.

Prevent unintended harm. Eg- advising against loan waivers to avoid moral hazard.

Balancing competing values. Eg- balancing efficiency and privacy in Aadhaar.

Ensure bottoms up planning. Eg- fair, prior and informed consent of Gram Sabha under PESA.

Prevent elite capture of policy. Eg- Social audits in MGNREGA.

Promote behavioural change, not just compliance. Eg- Gandhigiri in SBM – giving flowers for open defecation.

Ensure sustainability (intergenerational justice). Eg- PM-PRANAM to promote organic farming

Protect rights while delivering welfare. Eg- Consent-based data use in health IDs.

Social transformation requires critical reasoning to design effective interventions and ethical grounding to ensure justice, dignity and inclusion.