💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (August Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

GS Paper: GS1

  • Dubai Consensus for ‘transition away’ from Fossil Fuels

    dubai consensus

    Central Idea

    • The Dubai Consensus, a significant resolution towards reducing fossil fuel dependency, was adopted in COP 28, Dubai.

    Dubai Consensus

    • Key Clause: The resolution emphasizes transitioning away from fossil fuels to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, aligning with scientific recommendations to limit global temperature rise.
    • Balance between Countries: The text reflects a compromise between developed and developing nations on climate action and responsibility.
    • Dilution of Language: Earlier drafts with terms like ‘phase-out’ were softened due to opposition from oil-dependent countries.
    • Coal Usage: The final text moderated its stance on coal, crucial for countries like India, calling for a phase-down rather than a rapid phase-out.
    • Methane Emissions: The consensus introduces a focus on reducing methane emissions by 2030, a potent greenhouse gas.
    • Natural Gas as a ‘Transition Fuel’: The text’s reference to natural gas as a transitional fuel could favor gas-producing countries and overlook the need for developed countries to close the finance gap in climate adaptation.

    New Funding Commitments and Future Goals

    • Diverse Opinions: While some nations expressed dissatisfaction with the agreement’s scope, others highlighted the lack of financial support for developing countries.
    • Financial Pledges: COP 28 saw commitments to the Loss and Damage Fund and pledges to decarbonize the global economy.
    • Focus on Renewable Energy: The resolution signals a move towards phasing out fossil fuels and boosting renewable energy and efficiency.

    India’s Historical Position on Climate Change

    • Emission Statistics: India, a major developing country, has historically contributed 3% of greenhouse gases (1850-2019), compared to higher percentages from the US and EU.
    • Per Capita Emissions: India’s per capita emissions are below the global average, but its development needs and population growth have made it the third-largest emitter.
    • Balancing Development and Emissions: India has been navigating the pressure to reduce emissions while addressing its developmental needs, particularly its reliance on coal.

    India’s Commitments and Challenges

    • Net Zero by 2070: India has committed to achieving a net-zero state by 2070, alongside expanding its renewable energy capacity.
    • Glasgow COP 2021 Agreement: Under pressure, India agreed to a ‘phase-down’ of coal use, highlighting the need for equitable treatment of all fossil fuels, including oil and gas.
    • Import Dependency: As a net importer of oil and gas, India has raised concerns about the focus on coal while other fossil fuels remain under-addressed.

  • What does Unabated Fossil Fuels mean?

    Central Idea

    • At the ongoing COP28 climate summit, the term “unabated” fossil fuels has become a focal point in discussions about climate change mitigation.
    • The draft climate agreement mentions phasing down unabated coal, and US climate envoy John Kerry emphasized the need to phase out all unabated fossil fuels.

    Understanding ‘Unabated’ Fossil Fuels

    • Definition: “Unabated” fossil fuels refer to the use of coal, oil, and natural gas without reducing the associated CO2 and greenhouse gas emissions.
    • Contrast with ‘Abated’: “Abated” fossil fuels involve efforts to decrease emissions to an acceptable level, though the specifics of this level are not clearly defined.
    • IPCC’s Definition: The UN IPCC defines unabated fossil fuels as those without substantial reduction interventions for greenhouse gas emissions, suggesting capturing significant percentages of CO2 and methane.

    Role of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) Technologies

    • CCS Technologies: These technologies capture emissions from power stations or industrial facilities and store them underground.
    • Polarized Views: Oil and gas producers view CCS as essential for emission reduction, while climate activists and experts argue its effectiveness is limited.
    • EU and Nations’ Stance: The EU and several nations stated that CCS should not replace significant fossil fuel cuts and must not be overused.

    Effectiveness of Carbon Capture and Storage

    • IEA Report: The International Energy Agency reports that modern CCS technologies can capture about 90% of CO2.
    • IEEFA Study: A study by the IEEFA found that many flagship CCS projects underperformed or failed.
    • Climate Analytics Analysis: This analysis indicated that reliance on CCS could lead to substantial greenhouse gas emissions, potentially doubling CO2 emissions in 2023 if capture rates are lower than expected.

    Cost and Sustainability of CCS

    • High Costs: CCS technologies are expensive, with alternatives like wind, solar, and batteries being more cost-effective than retrofitting coal plants with CCS.
    • Sustainability Concerns: Scenarios achieving the Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C limit show a near-complete phase-out of fossil fuels by 2050, with minimal use of fossil CCS.

    Implications for COP28 and Beyond

    • Potential COP28 Declaration: The summit’s final declaration might include phasing out or down of unabated fossil fuels, raising concerns about continued fossil fuel use with CCS.
    • Risks of ‘Abated’ Fossil Fuels: Experts like Claire Fyson from Climate Analytics warn that promoting ‘abated’ fossil fuels could misdirect climate finance and greenwash emissions from fossil fuel use.

    Conclusion

    • Balancing Act: The COP28 discussions highlight the complexities of balancing fossil fuel use, technological solutions like CCS, and achieving climate targets.
    • Need for Caution: The debate underscores the need for cautious approaches to fossil fuel use and CCS, ensuring they align with broader climate goals and do not undermine efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

  • Pratap Bhanu Mehta writes on abrogation of Article 370 being upheld: Has SC established a dangerous precedent for federalism?

     

    Three days before its fourth anniversary, Supreme Court will commence hearings on abrogation of J&K's special status – The Leaflet

    Central idea 

    The Supreme Court’s validation of the abrogation of Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir signifies a legal triumph for the Modi government’s approach. The judgment navigates historical complexities, raises questions about federalism, and introduces the need for honest political reconciliation in the region. The Court’s nuanced stance prompts reflections on the balance between integration and preserving regional identity.

    Key Highlights:

    • Supreme Court’s Validation: The judgment upholding the abrogation of Article 370 is considered a significant legal victory for the Narendra Modi government, emphasizing its unwavering approach to Jammu and Kashmir.
    • Historical Ambiguities: The decision reflects on historical ambiguities, procedural intricacies, and legal complexities, asserting that no such considerations should impede the government’s vision of Jammu and Kashmir’s relationship with the Indian Union.
    • Political History Evaluation: Public perception of this judgment hinges on the unfolding of political history. Is it viewed as another instance of Jammu and Kashmir’s betrayal now officially endorsed by the Supreme Court? Does it set potentially precarious precedents for federalism and the credibility of the judiciary?
    • Integration or Half Measures?: The judgment prompts questions about whether this marks the final and complete integration of the state into India’s constitutional scheme or an improvement on the previous half measures, given the special status and autonomy that Article 370 was intended to provide.
    • Valley’s Response: The sullen silence in the Valley is being closely observed. Is it indicative of a final acceptance, a subdued victory, or an opportunity, as suggested by Justice Kaul, to set Kashmir on the path of truth and reconciliation?

    Key Challenges:

    • Federalism and Judiciary’s Authority: A critical challenge lies in the Court’s avoidance of addressing the novel degradation of Indian federalism represented by the downgrading of Jammu and Kashmir to a Union Territory. This non-engagement poses questions about the judiciary’s commitment to upholding constitutional principles.
    • Conjuring Tricks and Constitutional Amendments: The judgment’s acceptance of open-ended promises for restoring statehood at an unspecified future date raises concerns about potential constitutional amendments through backdoor methods, challenging the integrity of the process.

    Key Terms and Phrases:

    • Article 370’s Transitory Nature: The Court’s emphasis on Article 370 being transitory, justifying its abrogation without the Jammu and Kashmir Legislative Assembly’s consent.
    • Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019: The Act that led to the downgrading of J&K to a Union Territory, a significant departure from the state’s historical status.
    • J&K Legislative Assembly: The absence of the requirement for the assembly’s consent raises questions about the democratic process and representation.
    • Union Territory: The transformation of J&K into a Union Territory, a move that alters its political and administrative status within the Indian Union.

    Key Quotes:

    • “The whole of the Constitution of India applies to Jammu and Kashmir. But not yet.” – The Court’s statement encapsulating a performative aspect that delays full application.

    Key Statements:

    • The Court’s avoidance of addressing the degradation of Indian federalism could undermine its authority and the principles it stands for.
    • Justice Kaul’s call for a Truth and Reconciliation Commission underscores the need for an honest reckoning with the complex history of Jammu and Kashmir.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • Article 370’s gradual attenuation since the 1960s, leading to the question of whether its abrogation was a logical progression.
    • The reorganisation of J&K, creating a new precedent and introducing complexities in its political identity.

    Critical Analysis:

    • The Court’s focus on procedural aspects and historical context while sidestepping federalism concerns creates a nuanced perspective on its role in interpreting constitutional provisions.
    • The judicial acceptance of open-ended promises raises questions about the accountability of the government’s actions and the potential misuse of constitutional powers.

    Way Forward:

    • Honest political reconciliation is deemed essential in the absence of a political force capable of fostering genuine dialogue and resolution.
    • The evolving landscape of Indian politics and the Court’s role in navigating constitutional challenges, ensuring a delicate balance between integration and preserving regional identity.

  • Syama Prasad Mookerjee and his Contributions

    syama

    Central Idea

    • Following judgment of the Supreme Court upholding the abrogation of Article 370, many invoked Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee (1901-53), an ardent opponent of Kashmir’s ‘special status’ in the Indian Union.

    Who was Syama Prasad Mookerjee?

    • Syama Prasad Mookerjee, an eminent Indian politician, barrister, and academician, played a significant role in shaping India’s political landscape during the mid-20th century.
    • Born on July 6, 1901, in Kolkata (formerly Calcutta), Mookerjee emerged as a prominent leader and a staunch advocate of Indian nationalism and Hindu politics.

    Early Life and Education

    • Bengali Brahmin heritage: Mookerjee hailed from a respected Brahmin family with roots in Jirat, Hooghly District, and West Bengal.
    • Academic brilliance: He exhibited exceptional academic prowess, pursuing his education at prestigious institutions such as Presidency College and the University of Calcutta.
    • Legal career: Mookerjee became a barrister, being called to the English Bar after studying at Lincoln’s Inn in London.

    Political Career

    • Initial association with Congress: Mookerjee began his political journey as a member of the Indian National Congress, representing Calcutta University in the Bengal Legislative Council.
    • Hindu Mahasabha affiliation: He later joined the Hindu Mahasabha, a right-wing Hindu nationalist organization, and became its president.
    • Championing Bengal partition: Mookerjee actively advocated for the partition of Bengal to safeguard Hindu interests, leading to the establishment of a separate West Bengal within the Indian Union.
    • Resignation from Bengal cabinet: As Finance Minister of Bengal Province, Mookerjee resigned in 1942, condemning the British government’s oppressive policies and their attempts to hold on to India.

    Contributions to Independent India

    • Minister for Industry and Supply: Mookerjee served as India’s first Minister for Industry and Supply in Jawaharlal Nehru’s cabinet after independence.
    • Nehru-Liaquat Pact and resignation: He resigned from Nehru’s cabinet in 1950, protesting against the Nehru-Liaquat Pact, which he believed compromised the interests of Hindus in East Bengal (now Bangladesh).
    • Founding Bharatiya Jana Sangh: Mookerjee, with the support of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), established the Bharatiya Jana Sangh in 1951, laying the foundation for the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

    Mookerjee’s Opposition to Article 370

    • Balkanization of India: Mookerjee strongly believed that Article 370 created a sense of separatism and division within the country, leading to the fragmentation of India’s unity.
    • Rejection of dual governance: Mookerjee famously stated, “Ek desh mein do Vidhan, do Pradhan aur Do Nishan nahi chalenge” (One country cannot have two constitutions, two prime ministers, and two flags), emphasizing his opposition to the separate status enjoyed by Jammu and Kashmir.
    • Reservations about special status: Mookerjee expressed concerns that the special status granted to Jammu and Kashmir under Article 370 would impede the state’s full integration into the Indian Union.
    • Inequality and separatism: He believed that granting special privileges to one state based on religion or regional factors would lead to a sense of inequality and separatism.

    Ideological Stance and Legacy

    • Influence on BJP’s policy agenda: His ideology and vision continue to shape the policies and agenda of the Bharatiya Janata Party.
    • Controversial demise: Mookerjee’s untimely death in 1953 while in custody remains a subject of controversy and speculation, with demands for an independent inquiry.

  • 100 years on, remembering Maulana Azad’s words on Hindu-Muslim unity

    Film on Maulana Abul Kalam Azad set to hit theatres on Jan 18 - DailyExcelsior

    Central idea 

    The article reflects on the legacy of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, emphasizing his commitment to Hindu-Muslim unity and his pivotal role during the Partition era. The author expresses concerns about the current state of unity, citing instances of hate and intolerance, and calls for introspection to preserve the values Azad stood for.

    Key Highlights:

    • The author reflects on the life and contributions of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, focusing on Azad’s commitment to Hindu-Muslim unity and his refusal to sign the Partition Resolution.
    • The article highlights pivotal moments in Azad’s life, emphasizing his dedication to unity and the challenges faced during the partition.

    Key Challenges:

    • The author expresses concern about the current state of Hindu-Muslim unity, citing rising hate and intolerance.
    • Instances of vandalizing Azad’s statue and derogatory comments in Parliament are presented as challenges to the values Azad stood for.

    Key Terms:

    • Hindu-Muslim ittehad (unity)
    • Partition Resolution
    • Swaraj
    • Kakinara
    • Kashmir

    Key Phrases:

    • “Over my dead body.”
    • “You are throwing us to the wolves.”
    • “Nehru ki galtiyon ka khamyaza Kashmir ko bhugatna pada.”
    • “Julam dhha le, tu sitam dhha le/ Hamare bhi to din hain aane waale.”

    Key Quotes:

    • “If an angel were to descend from heaven and declare that India would get Swaraj in 24 hours, provided she relinquishes Hindu-Muslim unity, I will answer, ‘Never’.”
    • “Hate is the favored word; expressions like ‘mohabbat ki dukaan’ are sniggered at.”
    • “Our day, too, will come.”

    Anecdotes:

    • The author recalls instances of vandalism against Azad’s statue and derogatory comments in Parliament, reflecting the challenges faced by ideals of unity.

    Key Statements:

    • “The angel has descended and made his declaration, but he has been shown his place.”
    • “Indians are being swept by a tsunami of hate.”
    • “Today, I grope about in the endless darkness in which my country has been enveloped.”

    Key Examples and References:

    • Mention of Kakinara incident and recent expressions in Parliament.
    • Reference to the filmmaker K A Abbas and his film “Rahi.”

    Key Facts:

    • Azad’s refusal to sign the Partition Resolution.
    • Azad’s pivotal role in advocating Hindu-Muslim unity.
    • Instances of vandalism against Azad’s statue and derogatory comments in Parliament.

    Key Data:

    • The time frame: 100 years since Azad’s pivotal speech, approaching 2024.

    Critical Analysis:

    • The author critically examines the current state of Hindu-Muslim unity, expressing concerns about rising hate and intolerance.
    • The article reflects on the impact of political and social changes on the legacy of freedom fighters like Azad.

    Way Forward:

    • The article implies a call for introspection and a renewed commitment to the values of unity, advocating for a more inclusive and tolerant society.

  • Story of Kashmir’s Accession to India

    kashmir

    Central Idea

    • Union Home Minister recently criticized Jawaharlal Nehru’s handling of the Kashmir issue, citing two major blunders.
    • In response, opposition highlighted Nehru’s commitment to integrating Kashmir into India, contrasting with Sardar Patel’s initial willingness to cede Kashmir for Hyderabad.

    Nehru, Patel, and the Accession Conundrum

    • Post-Colonial Challenges: After British departure in 1947, Jammu and Kashmir, and Hyderabad, with their distinct demographic compositions, initially sought independence.
    • Nehru’s Firm Stance on Kashmir: Nehru was resolute about Kashmir’s integration into India, differing from Patel’s initial stance, as noted in V Shankar’s “My Reminiscences of Sardar Patel.”
    • Shift in Patel’s Viewpoint: Patel’s perspective on Kashmir changed after Pakistan accepted Junagadh’s accession on September 13, 1947.

    The Junagadh Accession Episode

    • Nawab’s Decision and India’s Reaction: The Nawab of Junagadh opted for Pakistan in 1947, leading to India’s military intervention and a subsequent plebiscite in November, favouring India with 91% votes.
    • Influence on Kashmir Policy: Junagadh’s accession impacted India’s policy towards princely states, particularly Kashmir.

    Hyderabad’s Complex Scenario

    • Suggested Hyderabad-Kashmir Barter: The idea of trading Hyderabad for Kashmir, citing Victoria Schofield’s “Kashmir in Conflict,” was deemed impractical.
    • Patel’s Approach to Hyderabad: Patel’s initial leniency towards Hyderabad’s Nizam was influenced by his international stature and the complex political landscape.
    • Military Action in Hyderabad: The Indian Army’s Operation Polo in September 1948 ended the Nizam’s rule amid growing internal dissent.

    Accession of Jammu and Kashmir

    • Maharaja Hari Singh’s Reluctance: Hari Singh, the ruler of Jammu and Kashmir, initially preferred independence.
    • Mounting Tensions and Pakistani Actions: Blockades and revolts in 1947, along with suspected Pakistani support for infiltrators, compelled Hari Singh to seek India’s assistance.
    • Conditional Accession to India: Hari Singh’s request for military aid led to Jammu and Kashmir’s accession to India in October 1947.

    Analyzing Nehru’s Alleged “Blunders”

    • UN Involvement Controversy: The minister’s critique centers on Nehru’s decision to involve the UN and agree to a ceasefire.
    • Factors Influencing Nehru’s Decisions: Nehru’s decisions were influenced by international diplomacy, financial constraints, and strategic considerations.
    • Perspectives on the Ceasefire: While some view the ceasefire as a missed chance, others regard it as a necessary measure under the circumstances.

    Conclusion

    • The historical decisions regarding Kashmir’s accession continue to be a topic of debate in Indian politics.
    • The roles of Nehru and Patel in shaping India’s territorial integrity remain subjects of intricate historical scrutiny.
    • Understanding these historical events is essential for informed discussions on contemporary policies and political narratives.

  • Global Cooling Pledge at COP28 

    Global Cooling Pledge

    Central Idea

    • At the COP28 climate summit on November 6, 63 countries, including the US, Canada, and Kenya, signed the world’s first pledge to reduce cooling emissions.

    Global Cooling Pledge

    • Term: This pledge aims to cut cooling emissions by at least 68% by 2050, addressing a significant source of greenhouse gases.
    • Current Contribution to Global Emissions: Cooling emissions, primarily from refrigerants and cooling energy, currently constitute 7% of global greenhouse gases.
    • Projected Increase: These emissions are expected to triple by 2050 due to rising global temperatures and increased demand for cooling appliances like ACs and refrigerators.

    Role of Refrigerants in Global Warming

    • Transition from CFCs to HFCs and HCFCs: Initially, chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) were used in cooling appliances but were phased out by the 1987 Montreal Protocol due to ozone depletion concerns. They were replaced by hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) and hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs).
    • Greenhouse Gas Potency: Although HFCs and HCFCs don’t harm the ozone layer, they are potent greenhouse gases, with some forms like HFC-134a having a global warming potential 3,400 times that of CO2.

    Sources and Effects of HFC and HCFC Emissions

    • Leakage from Appliances: These gases often leak from damaged appliances or car air conditioning systems, especially at the end of their life cycle.
    • Contribution to Warming: The leakage of these gases contributes significantly to global warming, with the Climate and Clean Air Coalition (CCAC) highlighting their potency.

    Challenge of Cooling Energy

    • Electricity for Cooling: A significant portion of cooling emissions comes from the electricity used to power cooling appliances.
    • Fossil Fuel Dependence: Much of this electricity is generated from fossil fuels, particularly in developing countries, contributing to climate change.

    Vicious Cycle of Cooling Demand and Global Warming

    • Feedback Loop: Rising global temperatures increase the demand for cooling, which in turn contributes to more warming.
    • Growing Cooling Device Market: The number of cooling devices is expected to rise from 3.6 billion to 9.5 billion by 2050, with a potential need for 14 billion devices if cooling access is expanded globally.

    Solutions and Strategies

    • Kigali Amendment to the Montreal Protocol: Over 150 countries agreed in 2016 to reduce HFC consumption by 80% by 2047, potentially avoiding over 0.4 degrees Celsius of global warming by 2100.
    • Promoting Climate-Friendly Refrigerants: The use of natural refrigerants with lower or zero global warming potential is being encouraged.
    • Proper Disposal and Management: Effective management and disposal of refrigerants could significantly reduce CO2 emissions.
    • Alternative Cooling Methods: Focusing on building designs that reduce the need for air conditioners, such as improved insulation and ventilation, is crucial.

    Conclusion

    • The Global Cooling Pledge represents a significant step in addressing a key contributor to climate change.
    • This initiative underscores the need for global cooperation in combating the escalating challenges posed by climate change.

  • Problematising periodisation in history

    Class 8- How, When, And Where-Periodisation of dates

    Central idea 

    The article talks about how historians divided history into ancient, medieval, and modern times, mostly influenced by European ideas. It questions these divisions and suggests we rethink history as a continuous story. The key point is that there isn’t just one way to be “modern,” and we should consider different perspectives in understanding history.

    Key Highlights:

    • The article critiques the conventional historical periodization of ancient, medieval, and modern eras, tracing its origins to European concepts.
    • It explores the imposition of this triad on global history through colonialism and challenges the Eurocentric narrative.
    • The author questions the dichotomies inherent in periodization, such as change versus continuity and stages of development.
    • The notion of modernity is central to periodization, with the article highlighting the evolving understanding of “modernities” in contemporary discourse.
    • The transformation from viewing modernity as an objective reality to a subjective, context-specific concept is emphasized.

    Key Challenges:

    • The article confronts the challenge of reevaluating historical narratives deeply entrenched in Eurocentrism.
    • It challenges the dichotomous framework of periodization, urging historians to consider continuity within apparent changes.
    • The author grapples with the resistance to viewing history as a universal entity, urging a shift from fragmented tranches to a continual process.

    Key Terms:

    • Periodization: Dividing history into distinct periods for analysis and understanding.
    • Modernity: The quality or condition of being modern; contemporary social and cultural features.
    • Eurocentrism: The dominance or undue focus on European culture, history, and values.

    Key Phrases:

    • “Theft of History”: Refers to the imposition of European historical concepts on non-European societies through colonial power dynamics.
    • “Dark Age”: The Eurocentric portrayal of the medieval period as a time of irrationality, regression, and superstition.
    • “Modernities”: Acknowledges the diverse and context-specific manifestations of modernity in different regions.

    Key Quotes:

    • “The modern world that we inhabit was thus essentially the West’s creation.”
    • “Modernity that had for long been accepted as an objective reality ‘out there’… has become subjective in each variant context.”
    • “This calls for the treatment of history as a universal entity of which regions form constituents.”

    Key Statements:

    • The triad of ancient, medieval, and modern periods originated in Europe and was imposed globally through colonialism.
    • The article challenges the dichotomies of periodization and urges a reconsideration of history as a continual process.
    • The evolving understanding of modernity reflects a shift from a singular, Eurocentric perspective to recognizing diverse “modernities.”

    Key Examples and References:

    • Reference to James Mill introducing the triad in Indian history to legitimize British rule.
    • Mention of Jack Goody’s concept of “The Theft of History” in the unequal power relationship between Europe and its colonies.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • The triad of ancient, medieval, and modern periodization originated in Europe in the 16th-17th centuries.
    • The article emphasizes the need to reconsider history as a universal entity, acknowledging contributions from all civilizations.

    Critical Analysis:

    • The article critically examines the Eurocentric biases embedded in historical periodization.
    • It challenges the binary thinking of periodization and encourages a nuanced understanding of historical processes.
    • The evolving nature of the concept of modernity is analyzed, highlighting its subjectivity in diverse contexts.

    Way Forward:

    • The article suggests a shift from fragmented tranches to a more holistic and continual approach to history.
    • Encourages historians to explore emerging areas of research such as climate, planetary history, and reevaluation of pre-history and archaeology.
    • Calls for a more inclusive and diverse narrative that recognizes the contributions of all societies to the world’s historical development.

  • Garba makes it to UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage list

    garba

    Central Idea

    • Garba, a traditional dance form from Gujarat, was included in the UNESCO list of Intangible Cultural Heritage.
    • This recognition makes Garba the 15th cultural item from India to be featured on the UNESCO list, following Kolkata’s Durga Puja, which was added two years ago.

    About Garba

    • What is it? Garba is a traditional dance form from Gujarat, India, primarily performed during the Navratri festival to worship the Hindu goddess Durga.
    • Origins and Meaning: The term “Garba” comes from “Garbha” (womb) and “Deep” (lamp). The dance is performed around a central lamp or a representation of the Goddess, symbolizing life, death, and rebirth.
    • Dance Style: Garba is characterized by energetic, circular movements, clapping hands, and intricate footwork, reflecting the cyclical nature of life.
    • Music and Instruments: The dance is accompanied by rhythmic music, traditionally using instruments like the dhol (drum), harmonium, and flute, with modern adaptations including electronic instruments.
    • Traditional Attire: Women wear a chaniya choli (a colorful, embroidered skirt set) and men don a kediyu and dhoti or pajama, often embellished with mirrors and embroidery.
    • Dandiya Raas Association: Garba is often followed by Dandiya Raas, another dance form using sticks (dandiyas), especially after the Aarti (worship ritual).
    • Inclusivity and Community Aspect: The dance is inclusive, attracting people of all ages and backgrounds, and emphasizing community participation.

    About UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH)

    • ICH means the practices, representations, expressions, knowledge, skills – as well as the instruments, objects, artefacts and cultural spaces associated with them that communities, groups and, in some cases, individuals recognize as a part of their cultural heritage.
    • Furthermore, its importance is not in the cultural manifestation itself, but in the wealth of knowledge, know-how and skills that are transmitted from one generation to the next.
    • The adoption of the Convention for the Safeguarding of the ICH by the General Conference of UNESCO in 2003 was a crucial step towards preserving intangible heritage.
    • UNESCO’s list of Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity was established in the year 2008.

    Criteria for the selection

    • There are three criteria for an intangible cultural heritage to be inscribed in the United Nations list.
    • The entity must-
    1. be recognized by communities, groups and, in some cases, individuals as part of their cultural heritage,
    2. be transmitted from generation to generation and be constantly recreated by communities and groups in response to their environment, their interaction with nature and their history and
    3. provide them with a sense of identity and continuity, thus promoting respect for cultural diversity and human creativity

    India’s ICH on the UNESCO list

    • Sangeet Natak Akademi is the nodal organisation which looks after this function, and files nominations of intangible cultural entities from India, for evaluation by the international body.
    • ICG from India include Kolkata’s Durga Puja (2021), Kumbh Mela (2017), Navroz (2016), Yoga (2016), traditional brass and copper craft of utensil-making among coppersmiths of Punjab (2014), Sankirtana, a ritual musical performance of Manipur (2013), and the Buddhist chanting of Ladakh (2012).
    • Before 2011, the list included Chhau dance, Kalbelia folk songs and dance of Rajasthan, and Mudiyettu, a dance drama from Kerala (2010), Ramman, a religious festival and theatre performance of Garhwal in the Himalayas (2009), and Kutiyattam or Sanskrit theatre, and Vedic chanting (2008).
    • Ramlila, a traditional performance of Ramayana, was also included in 2008.

  • Finally, a plus-size beauty at Miss Universe

     

    Miss Universe 2023 contestants who've been crowned so far

    Central idea 

    The article reflects on the author’s childhood fascination with beauty contests and the absence of plus-size representation, celebrating the recent participation of Miss Nepal as a pivotal moment challenging traditional beauty standards. It critically analyzes the persistent norms in the beauty industry, advocates for a transformative shift towards inclusivity, and emphasizes the empowering impact on children’s dreams, urging a redefinition of beauty beyond conventional ideals.

    Key Highlights:

    • Personal Reflection on Beauty Contests: The author reflects on childhood memories of watching beauty contests, idolizing winners like Sushmita Sen and Lara Dutta, and the absence of plus-size representation in such contests.
    • Evolution of Body Positivity: Over the years, there has been a shift in societal acceptance of diverse body sizes, with the fashion industry offering more inclusive options for plus-sized individuals.

    Key Challenges:

    • Traditional Beauty Standards: The beauty and glamour industry continues to uphold traditional standards, requiring women, especially pageant participants, to conform to wafer-thin ideals, perpetuating unrealistic beauty norms.
    • Ongoing Scrutiny: Even after winning prestigious titles, beauty queens like Miss Universe 2021, Harnaaz Kaur Sandhu, face public scrutiny and body-shaming, highlighting the persistent pressure to maintain certain body standards.

    Key Terms and Phrases:

    • Chubby Girl Stigma: The author describes her childhood perception that beauty contests were not for her due to societal perceptions of beauty and body size.
    • Plus-Size Representation: The article celebrates Miss Nepal, Jane Dipika Garrett, as a significant step toward inclusivity, breaking the mold of traditional beauty standards in beauty pageants.

    Key Quotes:

    • “In the beauty and glamour industry, things remained the same.”
    • “And that it came in the form of a South Asian woman makes it even more special.”

    Key Statements:

    • Evolution of Fashion Industry: While life has become easier for plus-sized individuals in terms of clothing options, the beauty and glamour industry has been slow to embrace inclusivity, maintaining stringent beauty standards.
    • Significance of Miss Nepal’s Participation: Miss Nepal’s confident presence at the Miss Universe stage is hailed as a major step towards inclusivity, breaking the norm of conventional body standards in beauty contests.

    Key Examples and References:

    • Childhood Influences: The author reminisces about childhood memories of watching beauty contests and the impact of societal beauty standards on her perception.
    • Miss Universe 2021 Harnaaz Kaur Sandhu: Highlights the trolling faced by the current Miss Universe for her supposed weight gain, emphasizing the challenges faced by beauty queens even after winning titles.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • Miss Nepal’s Participation: Miss Nepal, Jane Dipika Garrett, is acknowledged for confidently participating in the Miss Universe contest, challenging conventional beauty norms.

    Critical Analysis:

    • Evolution of Beauty Standards: The article critically evaluates the persistence of traditional beauty standards within the glamour industry, noting that while progress has been made in the fashion sector, beauty contests remain slow to adapt. It underscores the need for a more dynamic and inclusive definition of beauty, challenging the industry’s resistance to change.
    • Impact of Plus-Size Representation: The inclusion of Miss Nepal, Jane Dipika Garrett, is recognized as a significant breakthrough, challenging the long-standing norms of beauty pageants. The analysis delves into the potential ripple effect of her participation, sparking conversations about body diversity and fostering a more inclusive environment within the beauty industry.
    • Continued Body-Shaming: The critique extends to the ongoing challenges faced by beauty queens like Miss Universe 2021, Harnaaz Kaur Sandhu, who experiences body-shaming despite her achievements. This highlights the paradox wherein even accomplished individuals in the industry are not immune to societal pressure, emphasizing the need for a cultural shift.
    • Empowering Children’s Dreams: The article makes a compelling argument for allowing children, particularly young girls, to dream without restrictive societal norms. It suggests that dismantling conventional beauty ideals is crucial for fostering a generation that embraces diverse forms of beauty and self-expression.

    Way Forward:

    • Industry-Wide Reform: Advocates for a comprehensive reform within the beauty and glamour industry, urging stakeholders to redefine beauty standards and embrace diversity. This involves challenging established norms, fostering inclusivity in casting, and celebrating a range of body sizes and appearances.
    • Educational Initiatives: Proposes educational initiatives that promote body positivity and self-acceptance, targeting both industry professionals and the wider public. By fostering a cultural shift in perceptions of beauty, these initiatives can contribute to dismantling harmful stereotypes and promoting a more accepting society.
    • Advocacy for Inclusivity: Encourages influencers, celebrities, and industry leaders to actively advocate for inclusivity, leveraging their platforms to challenge beauty norms. This advocacy is seen as instrumental in driving change within the industry and influencing societal attitudes toward diverse representations of beauty.
    • Policy Changes: Calls for the formulation and implementation of policies within the beauty industry that mandate diverse representation, ensuring that beauty contests actively include participants of various body sizes. This structural change aims to create a more equitable and welcoming space for individuals irrespective of their physique.
    • Support for Beauty Queens: Stresses the importance of providing ongoing support and protection for beauty queens who face body-shaming and criticism. This includes implementing measures to counter cyberbullying and creating an environment that empowers individuals to embrace their bodies without fear of judgment.