💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (August Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

GS Paper: GS3

  • Launch of Bima Sugam Portal

    Why in the News?

    Bima Sugam, envisioned as the world’s largest online marketplace for insurance, was officially launched by the Bima Sugam India Federation (BSIF) at the IRDAI headquarters in Hyderabad.

    What is Bima Sugam?

    • Overview: World’s largest unified digital marketplace for insurance products and services, initiated by the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI).
    • Coverage: Includes life, health, motor, travel, property, agricultural, and commercial insurance.
    • Function: Works like Unified Payments Interface (UPI) for insurance, providing common infrastructure for purchase, renewal, management, and claims.
    • Stakeholders: Brings together insurers, intermediaries, agents, brokers, banks, and customers on a single platform.
    • Governance: Operated by the Bima Sugam India Federation (BSIF) with equity participation from insurance companies.
    • Policy Goal: Forms part of India’s Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI), aligned with the vision of Insurance for All by 2047.
    • Working:  The simplified way for a user on the platform would be as follows:
      • Registration: A person can register using Aadhaar-based KYC or other valid ID.
      • e-Bima Account Creation: A secure, integrated insurance repository has been created.
      • Policy search and comparison: Products from all registered insurance companies are listed with standardized information for easy comparison.
      • Purchase: Policies can be purchased digitally with instant e-documentation and secure payments.
      • Service: Policyholders can renew, update, port, or cancel policies and receive real-time assistance.
      • Claims: Users can submit claims and track the process; insurance companies and TPAs will use backend access for faster verification and settlement.

    Key Features:

    • Phased Rollout: Begins as an information and guidance hub; full transactions enabled gradually.
    • Low-Cost Model: Minimal user charges, unlike private aggregators that rely on high commissions.
    • Centralised Database: Enables policy comparison, customer query resolution, and faster product adoption.
    • Secure Digital Storage: Provides safe policy storage with robust security and compliance standards.
    • Inclusive Ecosystem: All insurers mandated as members, ensuring transparency and fair access.
    [UPSC 2014] With reference to “Aam Admi Bima Yojana”. Consider the following statements:

    1. The member insured under the scheme must be the head of the family or earning member of the family in a rural landless household.

    2. The member insured must be in the age group of 30 to 65 years.

    3. There is a provision for free scholarship for up to two children of the insured who are studying between classes 9 and 12.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    Options: (a) 1 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only* (d) 1, 2 and 3

     

  • In news: Almatti Dam

    1. Why in the News?

    Karnataka govt. has approved Upper Krishna Project Phase-III to raise Almatti dam height, while Maharashtra warned of moving the Supreme Court against it.

    Why is Maharashtra opposing it?

    • Fears submergence of villages and agricultural land in its territory if water levels rise further.
    • Worries about reduced water availability downstream, affecting its irrigation and drinking water projects.

    About Almatti Dam:

    • Overview: It is a hydroelectric and irrigation project built on the Krishna River in North Karnataka.
    • Completion: July 2005, as part of the Upper Krishna Irrigation Project (UKP).
    • Dimensions: Height 52.5 m, length 3.5 km.
    • Power Generation: A 290 MW station using vertical Kaplan turbines (five of 55 MW and one of 15 MW).
    • Two separate powerhouses: Almatti I and II generate power before releasing water into the Narayanpur Reservoir.
    • Functions: Provides irrigation, potable water, hydroelectric power, and helps in flood management.

    Back2Basics: Krishna River

    In news: Almatti Dam

    • Origin: Near Mahabaleshwar (Satara, Maharashtra), in the Western Ghats.
    • Length: ~1,300 km, second-longest river in peninsular India after Godavari.
    • Course: Flows through Maharashtra (303 km), Karnataka (480 km), Telangana, and Andhra Pradesh, before emptying into the Bay of Bengal.
    • Major Tributaries:
      • Right-bank: Ghatprabha, Malprabha, Tungabhadra.
      • Left-bank: Bhima, Musi, Munneru.
    • Hydropower & Irrigation Projects: Includes Koyna, Tungabhadra, Srisailam, Nagarjuna Sagar, Almatti, Narayanpur, Bhadra.

     

    [UPSC 2005] The Almatti Dam is on the river:

    Options: (a) Godavari (b) Cauvery (c) Krishna* (d) Mahanadi

     

  • Ant Queens giving birth to different species

    Why in the News?

    A groundbreaking study published in Nature (2025) has revealed that Messor ibericus, a Mediterranean harvester ant species, can produce male offspring of a completely different species, Messor structor.

    Ant Queens giving birth to different species

    About the Specie Messor ibericus:

    • Overview: A Mediterranean harvester ant, widely distributed across Southern Europe, known for its grain-harvesting behaviour and large colonies.
    • Hybrid Workers: All workers are hybrids, carrying DNA from both Messor ibericus and Messor structor.
    • Cross-Species Male Production: About 10% of queen’s eggs develop into pure Messor structor males, even without nearby structor colonies.
    • Genetic Signature: These males retain Messor ibericus mitochondrial DNA, proving maternal origin.
    • Reproductive Strategy: As per the Nature study:
      • Ibericus sperm produces new queens.
      • Structor sperm produces hybrid workers and additional structor males.
    • Evolutionary Significance: First documented case of a species naturally producing offspring of another species, challenging classical species concepts.
    • Colony Advantage: By producing both hybrid workers and pure structor males, queens secure compatible mates for future generations, sustaining both lineages.
    [UPSC 2024] Which one of the following shows a unique relationship with an insect that has coevolved with it and that is the only insect that can pollinate this tree?

    Options:

    (a) Fig* (b) Mahua (c) Sandalwood (d) Silk cotton

     

  • Upgradation of Army Radars

    Why in the News?

    After Operation Sindoor and Pakistani drone incursions, the Army is upgrading air defence with advanced radars to counter low-RCS (radar cross-section) drones and other aerial threats along northern and western borders.

    What are Radars?

    • About: Radar stands for Radio Detection and Ranging; it uses radio waves to locate, track, and measure speed of objects.
    • Components: Transmitter emits radio signals, receiver captures reflections.
    • Functions: Measures direction, distance (via time delay), and velocity (via Doppler shift).
    • Types in air defence:
      • Surveillance radars: Monitor airspace and detect aerial objects, not directly linked to weapons.
      • Fire control radars: Provide targeting data to guide anti-aircraft guns or missiles.

    Current Indian Capabilities:

    • Indian Air Force: Operates High-Power Radars and Medium-Power Radars for long-range, high-altitude threats such as jets, AWACS, and large transport aircraft.
      • For fire control, the Air Force employs systems like the 3D Central Acquisition Radar and Rajendra radar.
    • Indian Army: Uses Low-Level Light-Weight Radars, designed to pick up low-flying, small radar cross-section objects like drones.
      • Upgraded Flycatcher and Air Defence Tactical Control Radar systems to aim weapons and manage local defence.

    India’s Air Defence Infrastructure:

    • Missile systems: Includes Russian S-400 and the indigenous Akash missile system.
    • Army’s Akashteer system: Integrates radars, sensors, air defence guns, and communications into a real-time operational air picture.
    • IAF’s IACCS (Integrated Air Command and Control System): Unifies data from multiple assets for coordinated detection and interception.
    • Mission Sudarshan Chakra: Ongoing modernisation programme; DRDO recently tested the Integrated Air Defence Weapon System.
    [UPSC 2024] Consider the following activities:

    1. Identification of narcotics on passengers at airports or in aircraft

    2. Monitoring of precipitation

    3. Tracking the migration of animals

    In how many of the above activities can the radars be used?

    (a) Only one (b) Only two* (c) All three (d) None

     

  • Unseen labour, exploitation: the hidden human cost of Artificial Intelligence

    Introduction

    The promise of AI as an automated, error-free technology often masks the unseen human labour that makes it possible. From labelling raw data to moderating harmful content, “ghost workers” form the backbone of AI ecosystems. Yet, their contributions remain invisible, underpaid, and unprotected. The debate on AI is incomplete without recognising the human cost of automation, a matter of global ethics, labour rights, and governance.

    The Hidden Human Cost of AI

    Why is AI’s invisible labour in the news?

    AI companies, especially in Silicon Valley, outsource essential annotation and moderation work to low-paid workers in developing countries. Recent revelations of exploitative conditions, such as Kenyan workers earning less than $2 an hour for traumatic tasks like filtering violent content, have exposed the dark underbelly of AI. This has amplified global concerns about modern-day slavery, violation of labour rights, and the absence of legal safeguards in AI supply chains.

    Areas of Human Involvement in AI

    1. Data Annotation: Machines cannot interpret meaning; humans label text, audio, video, and images to train AI models.
    2. Training LLMs: Models like ChatGPT and Gemini depend on supervised learning and reinforcement learning, requiring annotators to correct errors, jailbreaks, and refine responses.
    3. Subject Expertise Gap: Workers without domain knowledge label complex data, e.g., Kenyan annotators labelling medical scans, leading to inaccurate AI outputs.

    Are Automated Features Truly Automated?

    1. Content Moderation: Social media “filters” rely on humans reviewing sensitive content (pornography, beheadings, bestiality). This causes severe mental health risks like PTSD, anxiety, and depression.
    2. AI-Generated Media: Voice actors, children, and performers record human sounds and actions for training datasets.
    3. Case Study (2024): Kenyan workers wrote to U.S. President Biden describing their labour as “modern-day slavery.”

    What Challenges Do Workers Face?

    1. Poor Wages: Less than $2/hour compared to global standards.
    2. Harsh Conditions: Tight deadlines of a few seconds/minutes per task; strict surveillance; risk of instant termination.
    3. Union Busting: Workers raising concerns are dismissed, with collective bargaining actively suppressed.
    4. Fragmented Supply Chains: Work outsourced via intermediary digital platforms; lack of transparency about the actual employer.

    Why Is This a Global Governance Issue:

    1. Exploitation in Developing Countries: Kenya, India, Pakistan, Philippines, and China host the bulk of annotators, highlighting global North-South labour inequities.
    2. Digital Labour Standards: Current international labour frameworks inadequately cover digital gig work.
    3. Ethical Responsibility: Big Tech profits from AI breakthroughs while invisibilising the labour behind them.
    4. Need for Regulation: Stricter global and national laws must ensure fair pay, transparency, and dignity at work.

    Way Forward

    1. Transparency Mandates: Disclosure of supply chains by tech companies.
    2. Fair Labour Standards: Minimum wages, occupational safety norms, and psychological health safeguards.
    3. Recognition of Workers: From “ghost workers” to “digital labour force.”
    4. Global Collaboration: Similar to climate treaties, AI labour governance requires multilateral regulation.

    Conclusion

    Artificial Intelligence is not fully autonomous—it rests on millions of invisible workers whose exploitation challenges the ethics of the digital age. For India and the world, the future of AI must balance innovation with human dignity, equity, and justice. Without recognising and regulating this labour, the AI revolution risks deepening global inequalities.

    Value Addition

    Global Frameworks and Conventions

    1. ILO Convention 190 (2019): Addresses workplace violence and harassment — highly relevant to content moderators exposed to graphic/traumatic data.
    2. ILO Recommendation 204: Transition from informal to formal economy — ghost workers are currently informal, with no rights.
    3. UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (2011): Corporate duty to respect human rights across supply chains, including digital gig platforms.
    4. EU Artificial Intelligence Act (2025): First comprehensive law regulating AI systems; includes risk categories and human oversight.
    5. Santa Clara Principles (2018): Framework for transparency, accountability, and due process in online content moderation.

    Conceptual Tools and Keywords

    1. Digital Colonialism: Global North exploits cheap digital labour in Global South for AI systems.
    2. Surveillance Capitalism (Shoshana Zuboff): Big Tech monetises personal data and labour while eroding privacy and dignity.
    3. Platform Precarity: Gig workers face algorithmic control, constant surveillance, and lack of social protection.
    4. Ghost Work (Mary Gray & Siddharth Suri, 2019): Term for invisible human labour powering AI systems.
    5. Cognitive Labour: Work that relies on human judgment, emotional resilience, and meaning-making (beyond physical labour).
    6. Algorithmic Management: Use of algorithms to allocate, monitor, and discipline workers—stripping them of agency.
    7. Ethics of Invisibility: Recognition gap when workers’ contributions are hidden, making justice claims difficult.

    Reports and Studies

    1. Oxford Internet Institute (2019, “Ghost Work”): Estimated millions of hidden workers behind AI, mainly in developing countries.
    2. WEF Future of Jobs Report (2023): Warned of AI-induced job displacements alongside new digital gig work.
    3. ILO Report on Digital Labour Platforms (2021): Documented widespread exploitation, lack of contracts, and cross-border regulatory challenges.

    Indian Context

    1. Code on Social Security, 2020: Recognises gig and platform workers, but still weak on implementation.
    2. NITI Aayog Report on “India’s Booming Gig and Platform Economy” (2022): Predicts 23.5 million gig workers by 2030.
    3. Personal Data Protection Act, 2023: Regulates data, but silent on labour rights of those who process AI data.
    4. India’s AI Mission (National Strategy for AI, NITI Aayog): Envisions “AI for All” but doesn’t sufficiently cover labour dimensions.

    PYQ Relevance

    [UPSC 2023] Introduce the concept of Artificial Intelligence (AI). How does Al help clinical diagnosis? Do you perceive any threat to privacy of the individual in the use of Al in healthcare?

    Linkage: AI aids clinical diagnosis by analysing medical scans and predicting outcomes with high accuracy, but it relies on human annotators to label sensitive data. The article shows how even untrained workers in Kenya were tasked with labelling medical scans, raising concerns of reliability. Such outsourcing also heightens the risk of privacy violations in handling patient data across insecure global supply chains.

  • Topography, climate change: Behind heavy rains in Himalayas

    Introduction

    Extreme rainfall in Uttarakhand over the past week has triggered multiple landslides, swelling rivers and leading to the loss of at least 15 lives. While such events have always occurred in the Himalayan belt during the monsoon, the frequency, intensity, and unpredictability of these disasters have sharply increased in recent years. This phenomenon is closely linked to climate change, altered monsoon dynamics, and the fragile geology of the region.

    Why in the News?

    Uttarakhand and parts of Himachal Pradesh have witnessed back-to-back extreme rainfall events over the last month, leading to landslides, mudslides, flash floods, and large-scale disruption. The striking fact is not just the death toll, but the scale of surplus rainfall, 34% above normal in August and 67% above normal in early September. Such heavy rainfall, while common in coastal states like Kerala or Meghalaya, is catastrophic in the Himalayas where steep slopes, loose soil, and fragile ecosystems amplify the risks.

    Why is rainfall unusually high in Uttarakhand this season?

    1. Active monsoon systems: Consecutive low-pressure systems from the Bay of Bengal have travelled farther north than usual, dumping large amounts of rain in the Himalayan belt.
    2. Surplus rainfall data: Northwestern India received 34% surplus rainfall in August and over 67% surplus rainfall in early September.
    3. Record-breaking events: Udhampur (J&K) recorded 630 mm in 24 hours, equivalent to a year’s rainfall in Rajkot, Gujarat; Leh recorded 59 mm in 48 hours, highest since 1973.

    Why are hilly regions more vulnerable to disasters?

    1. Fragile geology: Extreme rainfall triggers landslides, mudslides, and flash floods as rainwater drags soil, rocks, and debris downhill.
    2. River choke-points: When streams are blocked, water gushes into settlements, destroying roads and bridges.
    3. Comparative impact: While 300 mm of rain in Goa or Kerala drains into the sea, the same amount in Uttarakhand leads to catastrophic slope failure.
    4. Recent examples: Landslides across Mandi, Kullu, Dharali, Tharali, and Jammu in the past two weeks illustrate cascading effects.

    How is climate change altering monsoon dynamics?

    1. Southward shift of western disturbances: Once dominant in winters, these systems are increasingly interacting with the summer monsoon, intensifying rainfall events in the Himalayas.
    2. Global warming: Rising temperatures are linked to changing wind patterns and higher atmospheric moisture.
    3. Arctic connection: Melting Arctic sea ice may be influencing jet streams, further complicating rainfall behaviour.
    4. Future risks: Longer dry spells interspersed with intense rainfall events are likely to define Himalayan monsoons.

    What does this mean for Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh?

    1. Human cost: Frequent deaths, loss of livelihoods, and displacement.
    2. Economic disruption: Road blockages, tourism losses, and damage to hydro projects.
    3. Policy challenge: Need for climate-resilient infrastructure, stricter land-use regulations, and predictive weather modelling.

    Conclusion

    The Uttarakhand landslides are a grim reminder that the Himalayas, often called the “third pole”, are at the frontline of climate change. Extreme rainfall patterns, when coupled with unregulated urbanization and fragile geology, amplify disaster risks. Building climate-resilient infrastructure, enhancing early warning systems, and ensuring ecological sensitivity in planning are essential for safeguarding lives and livelihoods in these vulnerable mountain states.

    PYQ Relevance:

    [UPSC 2017] ‘Climate Change’ is a global problem. How India will be affected by climate change? How Himalayan and coastal states of India will be affected by climate change?

    Linkage: The Uttarakhand landslides highlight how Himalayan states are increasingly vulnerable to climate change–induced extreme rainfall, cloudbursts, and landslides due to fragile geology. Similarly, coastal states face rising sea levels, cyclones, and saline intrusion, threatening lives and livelihoods. Thus, climate change amplifies both mountain hazards and coastal vulnerabilities, making India’s geography uniquely exposed.

  • What are Stablecoins?

    Why in the News?

    Globally, stablecoins face regulatory scrutiny; the Bank of England has proposed ownership limits (£10k–£20k for individuals, £10m for businesses) to reduce banking system risks.

    About Stablecoins:

    • Definition: Cryptocurrencies designed to maintain stable value, usually pegged to fiat currency, commodities, or other crypto.
    • Role: Provide price stability, often used to park profits or enable fast, low-cost cross-border transactions without intermediaries.
    • Use: Rarely for retail payments; mainly act as a bridge asset within crypto markets.
    • Types:
      • Fiat-backed (e.g., Tether/USDT).
      • Commodity-backed (gold, silver, oil).
      • Crypto-backed (collateralised by other cryptos).
      • Algorithmic (peg maintained via programmed supply-demand adjustments).
    • Example: Tether (USDT) backed in theory by cash and US Treasuries.
    • Market Growth: Could rise tenfold to $2 trillion by 2028 (Standard Chartered, Apr 2025).

    Risks Associated with Stablecoins:

    • Financial Stability Risk: Vulnerable to bank-run scenarios. Example: TerraUSD collapse (2022) lost 60% peg value.
    • Banking System Impact: Can drain deposits from banks, reducing lending capacity.
    • BIS Concerns:
      • Singleness: Deviations from fiat peg in secondary markets.
      • Elasticity: Limited expansion due to reserve requirements.
      • Integrity: Weak KYC, enabling money laundering, terror financing.
    • Cybersecurity: DeFi-linked stablecoins prone to hacking and theft.
    • Regulatory Gaps: Lack of uniform global standards leads to fraud and accountability issues.

    Global Regulatory Approaches:

    • United States, GENIUS Act (2025): Only insured financial institutions may issue; must hold 1:1 low-risk reserves; AML/CFT compliance required.
    • European Union, MiCA (2024): Regulates E-money Tokens (EMTs) and Asset-Referenced Tokens (ARTs); issuers restricted to authorised EU firms; strict reserve and consumer protection.
    • Hong Kong, Stablecoin Ordinance (2025): Licensing by HK Monetary Authority; full high-quality liquid reserves; strict audits and AML/CFT rules.
    • United Kingdom, Bank of England: Proposed ownership limits to prevent rapid deposit outflows and maintain financial stability.
    [UPSC 2016] With reference to ‘Bitcoins’, sometimes seen in the news, which of the following statements is/are correct?

    1. Bitcoins are tracked by the Central Banks of the countries.

    2. Anyone with a Bitcoin address can send and receive Bitcoins from anyone else with a Bitcoin address.

    3. Online payments can be sent without either side knowing the identity of the other.

    Select the correct answer using the code given below.

    Options: (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only* (c) 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3

     

  • What is Portable Ion Chromatography?

    Why in the News?

    Australian scientists have developed a simpler, portable version of ion chromatography called Aquamonitrix, enabling field-based analysis of nitrate and nitrite ions.

    About Ion Chromatography:

    • Overview: A laboratory technique used to separate and measure ions (charged particles) in a sample.
    • Process: A liquid sample is passed through a long column that separates ions based on their properties.
    • Equipment: Requires large, complex, and costly lab machines.
    • Use in Environment: Detects harmful ions like nitrate and nitrite that pollute soil and water.

    What is Aquamonitrix?

    • Overview: A portable ion chromatograph designed by the University of Tasmania (Australia).
    • Features: Small, battery-operated, and nearly 10 times cheaper than lab equipment.
    • Testing: Students tested it on soil pore water, measuring nitrate and nitrite levels accurately when compared with lab results.
    • How it Works?
      • Soil water collected with a vacuum pump and filtered.
      • Water injected into the Aquamonitrix unit.
      • Uses a sodium chloride solution to carry the sample.
      • Equipped with a UV light detector, showing nitrate and nitrite as clear peaks.
      • Simpler design avoids messy interference from multiple ions.

    Applications:

    • Environment: Monitoring nitrate and nitrite pollution in soil and water.
    • Agriculture: Helps optimise fertiliser use and reduce overuse.
    • Water Safety: Tests drinking water quality on site.
    • Education: Serves as a teaching tool linking classroom to real-world chemistry.
    [UPSC 2024] “Membrane Bioreactors” are often discussed in the context of:

    Options: (a) Assisted reproductive technologies

    (b) Drug delivery nanotechnologies

    (c) Vaccine production technologies

    (d) Wastewater treatment technologies*

     

  • Unified Pension Scheme (UPS)

    Why in the News?

    The Centre has approved the Unified Pension Scheme, starting Apr 2025, with NPS employees allowed to switch till Sept 30, 2025.

    About Unified Pension Scheme (UPS):

    • Launch & Applicability: Announced in August 2024; implemented from 1 April 2025. Applicable to central govt employees who joined service after 1 January 2004 (those under NPS).
    • Nature: Hybrid pension system combining features of the assured benefit of OPS and the contributory model of NPS.
    • Assured Pension: 50% of the average basic pay drawn in the last 12 months before retirement, with minimum 25 years of service.
    • Minimum Pension: ₹10,000/month assured after 10 years of service.
    • Family Pension: 60% of pension last drawn, payable to spouse on retiree’s death.
    • Contributions: Employee contributes 10% of basic pay + Dearness Allowances (DA); govt contributes 10% + an additional 8.5% towards a pooled corpus.
    • Lump Sum at Retirement: 1/10th of last pay + DA for every completed six months of service, in addition to gratuity.
    • Inflation Indexation: DA-linked relief on pensions, tied to CPI-IW.
    • Flexibility: Employees may choose between NPS and UPS, but once shifted, re-entry into UPS is not allowed.

    Difference between OPS, NPS and UPS:

    Old Pension Scheme (OPS) National Pension System (NPS) Unified Pension Scheme (UPS)
    Type Defined Benefit Defined Contribution (market-linked) Hybrid (Defined + Contribution)
    Employee Contribution None 10% of Basic + DA 10% of Basic + DA
    Govt Contribution Entire burden on govt 14% of Basic + DA 10% + 8.5% pooled corpus
    Assured Pension 50% of last drawn pay + DA None; depends on market returns 50% of avg. basic pay (last 12 months)
    Minimum Pension Not fixed, but effectively higher None ₹10,000 after 10 years’ service
    Family Pension 50% of pension last drawn Depends on accumulated corpus 60% of pension last drawn
    Lump Sum Commutation of up to 40% pension (reduces monthly pension) 60% withdrawal of accumulated corpus at retirement Lump sum = 1/10th of last pay + DA for every 6 months of service; pension unaffected
    Indexation (DA link) Full DA linked Market-driven returns; no DA link DA-linked inflation relief
    Fiscal Burden High, unfunded Lower, market-based Moderate (partially funded + assured)

     

    [UPSC 2021] With reference to casual workers employed in India, consider the following statements:

    1. All casual workers are entitled to Employees Provident Fund coverage.

    2. All casual workers are entitled to regular working hours and overtime payment.

    3. The government can, by notification, specify that an establishment or industry shall pay wages only through its bank account.

    Which of the above statements are correct?

    Options: (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only* (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2, and 3

     

  • The conduct of social media companies amid political unrest

    Introduction

    The insurrection in Nepal, which led to the fall of the K.P. Sharma Oli government after just two days, brought with it an immediate digital clampdown: a ban on 26 social media platforms. While such state actions are not unprecedented, what deserves scrutiny is the consistent passivity of social media companies in moments of political crisis. Despite marketing themselves as champions of free expression, Big Social firms often prioritise profit motives and regulatory compliance over defending user rights. The Nepal episode is not an isolated case but part of a global pattern spanning Russia, Myanmar, Nigeria, and Iran.

    Why is this issue in the news?

    The Nepal unrest marks the latest instance of governments weaponising internet shutdowns, but the bigger story is the role of social media platforms. Instead of resisting, they largely issued boilerplate statements, leaving millions of users disconnected. This sharp contrast between their claims of empowering citizens and their reluctance to act exposes the gap between rhetoric and responsibility. The scale of the problem is massive, bans disrupt civic life, cost economies billions, and exacerbate inequality in times of crisis.

    The Conduct of Social Media Companies Amid Political Unrest

    Why do social media companies stay passive?

    1. Profit Motives: Companies fear losing access to lucrative markets more than reputational harm.
    2. Government Pressure: Host states can fine, jail, or exclude companies, discouraging open resistance.
    3. Commercial Interests vs. Civic Responsibility: Platforms project neutrality but continue profiting while users bear risks.

    How has this pattern unfolded globally?

    1. Russia (2018): Telegram fought bans technically but gave little political solidarity to users facing arrests.
    2. Myanmar (2021): Facebook ban cut off protestors from news and organising tools.
    3. Nigeria (2021): Twitter suspension cost the economy $26 million/day while the company stayed largely silent.
    4. Iran (2022): Instagram and WhatsApp issued generic appeals while small businesses collapsed.

    What technological solutions exist but remain unused?

    1. Decentralised Networks: Tor, I2P, Mastodon, and Signal proxies allow traffic rerouting.
    2. Corporate Tools: Google’s Outline VPN, YouTube’s delivery networks, and WhatsApp piggybacking on HTTPS could bypass bans.
    3. Underdeployment: Companies avoid such measures due to fears of retaliation and loss of ad-driven surveillance models.

    How does Big Social compare with other industries?

    1. Financial Sector: PayPal and Visa cut services in Russia citing ethics.
    2. Wikipedia: Won a legal battle against Turkey’s ban.
    3. Telecom Firms: Unlike them, SM companies market themselves as defenders of expression, making passivity starker.

    What are the wider consequences of passivity?

    1. Digital Divide: Richer users bypass bans with VPNs, poorer citizens are excluded.
    2. Insecurity: Users shift to unsafe alternatives, scams rise, and access to trusted news collapses.
    3. Corporate Power Paradox: Meta’s revenue ($134 bn) and Alphabet’s ($300 bn) exceed GDPs of Nepal and Nigeria, yet they plead helplessness.

    What could be the way forward?

    1. Transparency Mandates: Publish shutdown orders, legal justifications, and company responses.
    2. Technical Contingencies: Industry-wide standards for proxy modes, redundancy, and fallback networks.
    3. Regional Cooperation: Blocs like AU and SAARC can negotiate common demands.
    4. Moral Responsibility: Companies must balance profit motives with defending civic infrastructure.

    Conclusion

    The Nepal episode illustrates a broader global pattern where social media companies retreat into silence during political unrest. While they claim neutrality, their choices are deeply political, amplifying inequalities and weakening democratic resilience. Given their vast resources and influence, neutrality is no longer an option. Transparency, decentralisation, and moral responsibility must become cornerstones of their global operations, especially in the Global South where civic stakes are highest.

    Value Addition
    • Santa Clara Principles (2018): 
      • Framework urging tech companies to publish government takedown requests, explain moderation decisions, and ensure due process in digital rights protection.
      • Highlights the need for transparency and accountability in content moderation.
    • UNHRC Resolution (2016):
      • Declared internet shutdowns as a violation of international law and an infringement on freedom of expression.
      • Recognises access to the internet as a fundamental enabler of human rights.
    • Economic Impact of Shutdowns:
      • Nigeria’s Twitter ban (2021) cost the economy nearly $26 million/day, showing how bans hurt not just civic spaces but also small businesses and livelihoods.
      • Similarly, India has often topped the list of internet shutdowns globally, costing billions annually.
    • Concept of Digital Authoritarianism:
      • Use of internet control, shutdowns, and surveillance by states to curb dissent. Seen in Myanmar (2021 coup), Iran (2022 protests), and Nepal (2025 unrest).
    • Surveillance Capitalism (Shoshana Zuboff):
      • Business model of Big Tech that monetises user data through targeted ads. Centralised control discourages adoption of decentralised, privacy-respecting technologies.
    • Civic Infrastructure at Risk:
      • Platforms are not neutral spaces but essential public utilities during crises. Their passivity undermines democratic resilience and widens the digital divide.
    • Technological Solutions & Precedents:
      • Signal Proxies (Iran, 2022) – volunteers hosted relays to bypass censorship.
      • Wikipedia vs. Turkey – fought a multi-year legal battle and restored access, unlike Big Social’s passivity.
      • Google’s Outline VPN – toolkit for journalists and activists, an example of proactive circumvention tools.
    • International Comparisons:
      • Financial Sector – PayPal & Visa cut ties with Russia citing ethics after Ukraine invasion.
      • Telecoms – forced into compliance immediately with shutdown orders, unlike Big Social which claims neutrality yet markets itself as pro-free expression.

    PYQ Relevance:

    [UPSC 2016] Use of internet and social media by non-state actors for subversive activities is a major security concern. How have these been misused in the recent past? Suggest Effective guidelines to curb the above threat.

    Linkage: The Nepal case and similar crises show how governments misuse shutdowns while non-state actors exploit social media for mobilisation, misinformation, and violence. The passivity of Big Social aggravates risks by denying safe, transparent channels, widening the digital divide. Thus, effective guidelines must balance security imperatives with digital rights, corporate accountability, and technological safeguards.