💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (June Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF

Discuss the merits and demerits of the four ‘Labour Codes’ in the context of labour market reforms in India. What has been the progress so far in this regard?

The Central Government consolidated 29 existing central labour laws into four codes to simplify the legal framework, improve ease of doing business.

4 Labour codes-

Code on Wages

Industrial Relations Code

Code on Social Security

Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code

Merits

Merging and Simplification of laws reduces complexity and overlaps.

Uniform definitions & wage protections: Eg- code on Wages introduces a floor wage

Flexibility in hiring/retention: IR Code raises the threshold for requiring government approval for layoffs/closures from 100 to 300 workers.

Broader social security coverage: SS Code covers gig workers, platform workers, unorganised sector. (presently only 25%)

Improved safety and working conditions: OSHWC mandates working hours, safety standards, migrant worker welfare.

Promoting formalisation through clearer rules and digital compliance systems.

Minimise exploitative practices – Eg: provision for overtime wages twice normal wages

Easier resolution of industrial disputes – Eg: 14 days’ notice period before strikes & lockdowns

Demerits

Transition and Adaptation Challenges as India’s labour market is 90% informal, contributing nearly 50% of GDP

Weakened collective bargaining: IR Code imposes stricter conditions on strikes (60 days’ notice).

Job-security concerns: Increased flexibility may lead to precarious employment. Eg- fixed-term employment, easier layoffs

Increased burden on SMEs: Eg- requirements such as documentation of wages, benefits, safety norms, etc..

Inconsistent Application Across Sectors – agriculture (60% of informal workforce) and construction (~50 million workers) face seasonal work, casual labour, and absence of contracts

Rising Costs for Businesses

Gratuity obligations

PF contributions

Maternity benefits (26 weeks paid leave + crèche facilities)

Progress So Far

All four codes are legally enacted between 2019-20.

34 States and UTs have notified draft rules but full implementation is pending.

The Centre has initiated digital portals (e-Shram, unified labour compliance) to support implementation.

Resistance from trade unions and worker groups continues. Eg- strikes by AITUC and CPI

Labour is a concurrent subject – state-level variation persists.

Enforcing labour codes can bring in transparency, simplification & digitization in compliance. This can help India to become a manufacturing hub as companies adopt the “China+1” strategy.