“Mentor’s Comments”
Introduce your answer writing briefly about QIM.
In body first briefly write about the prevailing conditions and why brutal repression was certain,
Than Expand the aspect why launching QIM became necessary citing various reasons for it.
Conclude your answer with impact of QIM.
Ref id 422329
Please review
Vishal ,
Introduction to the question is written fine. Though length is long but Conclusion articulated very well.
You also must point out how brutal suppression was certainly in a brief paragraph due Draconian laws with war time absolute powers as justification for sustaining war efforts.
In core part you can also add points like almost a decade Gap since last Gandhian movement,
Rising popular discontent due to scarcity and inflation, fear of Japanese taking over British rule etc.
Your answer is fine but more points needed also you must always try to address all the possible Aspect of a question.
Keep writing 🙂
3,5/10
Please review
Chand,
Your introduction and conclusion are the only part which are in tune with the question.
You have to write what is asked in the question not what you know.
Question no where asks you to give details of events occurred during QIM.
Read question properly, try to understand the demand, take your time frame your arguments then write. This is just a practice exercise.
Take help of Mentor’s Comments to understand in what direction you had to write.
There is no doubt that you have knowledge but it would be fruitful only if you mold it as per the demand of the question.
Read others’ answer as well and keep writing 🙂
Note: please mention payment id with the answer otherwise answer will not be evaluated in future.
pay_HH1EGxOD3RGEhl
Subhashree
Your introduction and conclusion are fine.
You have knowledge and good idea about the whole movement yet you failed to satisfy the Demand of the question due to following reasons-
1. You didn’t discussed core part that is ‘why launched’. Core part of the question must always be discussed in details. Just one ,second last, paragraph gives passing references to this part.
2. Diagrams can be drawn but they are no replacement for the content. Never draw a diagram for core part.
Rather In diagram you could’ve depicted phases.
Read question properly. Understand the core demand.
You have good knowledge but you’ll have to improve way of presentation.
Keep writing, I’m sure you’ll improve:)
3.5/10
Please review
Payment Id pay_HHWzC2O9xhkaqA
Utkarsha
Your introduction and Conclusion are fine.
There is no doubt that you have good knowledge about the issue. You also addressed all the parts of the questions.
But there is random presentation and logical flow is missing.
For example you after Reasons you talked about British Repression, than brutal condition than again back to movement.
After intro you must write about prevailing conditions, than talk about why still launched, activities than British response.
Try to maintain the flow and arrangement of various Arguments in logical Order.
Overall content wise fine Attempt, Keep writing:)
4.5/10
Refid# 422544
Anupam,
You can write better Introduction. Also your conclusion is also introductory in nature as per the question Rather you must talk about the impacts of QIM in Conclusion.
In main body whatever you have discussed can be summoned up under just one heading that is British indifference towards India’s freedom.
Here you must add points like rise popular discontent due to scarcity and inflation, Bengal famine, gap of a decade since last Gandhian movement etc.
Also before discussing reasons for launch you must talk about certainly of brutal Repression in brief like war time restriction, absolute control of Power, Draconian laws etc.
Try to take broadest possible approach.
Keep writing:)
Plz review. Payment I’d- HJjaTzqssZMHUB
Ibrahim,
You have Written overall a fine answer. Introduction still can be written better and concise.
Conclusion is fine.
Before addressing the ‘reasons to launch’ you had to discuss in brief why brutal repression was certain. Due to war conditions, Draconian laws with absolute powers etc.
In main section you can add points like gap of a decade since last Gandhian moment, fear that Japan will take over British.
Give proper space between two sections of the answer it will help in visibility of each section.
Rest is fine. Keep writing 🙂
0000382105
Jaya ,
Your introduction is fine and Conclusion articulated very well.
You have understood the demand of the question and addressed it very well.
In second section you can add more points like a decade gap since last Gandhian Movement, inhuman British policies leading to Bengal famine etc
Overall a very good Attempt. Keep writing 🙂
Payment Id pay_HHlJ1R1WIIMdGT
Gauri Shankar,
Introduction is fine. Conclusion articulated very well though it be more concise.
You have tried to address all the sections of the question. However
1. You had to write prevailing conditions even before the launch of the movement because of which suppression of the movement was assured, not why British suppressed it.
Write points here like War conditions, Japanese at doorstep, Draconian laws suppressing civil liberties in name of protection of India
2. Also you had to write it before the reasons to launch, so to maintain logical flow in the answer
Read question properly and try to address all the aspects with logical arrangement of various sections.
Read others’ answers as well, keep writing:)
Idpay_HJ2s89guguFYwg@Swatantra
Harshaa,
Your introduction and Conclusion are simple direct and to the point which is good.
You have understood the question and tried to address it. But structure of the answer is an issue.
First try to write answer in a logical flow of the questions, like after introduction you had to write about why ‘brutal repression’ was a uncertainty. Here write points like war time absolute authoritarian powers, draconian laws with no regards to absolute authority, protection of Indian being a priority at any cost.
Than in second section write various reasons why still movements was launched- popular discontent against British,
Economic hardships scarcity, famine, gap of a decade since last Gandhian movement, failure of Cripps mission etc.
Work upon your structure. Use headings for various sections. Use points if you have to list down reasons etc.
Read others’ answers as well Keep writing 🙂
Review
Ref no 0000420120
Rajlaxmi ,
Your introduction and conclusion are fine.
Structure of the question is also fine but there are following Issue:
1. You had to write ‘why there was a fear that the British will try to supress the movement brutally even before the launch. What you have written occured after the launch.
2. You had to write brutal Repression section before the reasons for launch. So to maintain the logical flow in the Question.
Also you need to add more points in the reasons like economic Hardships causing scarcity, famine, gap of a decade since last Gandhian Movement was making people restless etc.
Read question patiently and try to understand and address all the demands of the question.
Keep writing 🙂
Payment id-HJHAZEWKSzM3CX
Ankita,
Your introduction is Well articulated but still can be more concise. Conclusion written very well.
In main body before going write reasons for launch you must expand separately more on ‘why brutal repression feared’. You have written it with the reasons in point 2.
Try to write short paragraphs.
Rest is fine.
Overall Good Attempt. Keep writing:)
4.5/10
REF ID: #0000425733
Please review @Swatantra Sir
You have written a very good answer.
Introduction and conclusion are fine. You have covered all the aspects of the question.
For further improvement- try to write shorter paragraphs, so that you can distinguish various ideas.
Also there are repetition in your answers. Points 3 and 4 can be clubbed under broader point 5.
Rest is good. Keep it up.
Keep writing:)
5.5/10
Payment ID – HIWaoP4yYMjmlq
Deepika,
Your introduction is fine. But Conclusion is missing. Always conclude your answers.
You need to write what is asked in the Question not all that you know about the topic.
There is no doubt that you have enough knowledge of the topic but mold it as per the requirement of the question.
First, You had to write ‘why brutal repression was a certainty’- due to WW-II, British took over absolute control with draconian laws like Defence of India etc.
Then you had to right- why still launched QIM ? Rising discontent against British due to inhumane policies leading to scarcity, inflation, Bengal Famine, almost a decade gap since last big Gandhian movement, fear of Japanese took over of British etc.
Then in conclusion you can write impacts.
Read question properly, mold arguments as per the demand of the question.
Keep writing for further improvement:)
#0000422551
please review @Swatantra sir
Vamsidhar ,
Your introduction is good.
You have understood the demand of the question and justified it to an extent.
In first part of body add points like draconian laws like Defence of India Act with out any due regards to civil liberty.
In second you must avoid repetition point 1 and 4 are essentially same, add here more points like rising discontent among the masses due to inhuman British policies, Fear of Japanese will replace British, a decade gap since last Gandhian movement etc.
Conclusion written fine.
Overall a fine attempt, keep writing for further improvement:)
pay_HHogiMPYpQ87sC
Kartikeya ,
Introduction and conclusion are written good.
There is a natural flow to the answer. So you should write first ‘why fear of brutal repression’ section then Reasons.
In Reasons section you can need add more points like Gap of a decade since CDM, fear of Japanese control etc. Need to avoid repetition points 3 and 4 means the same thing British ignorance to the cause of Indian Freedom.
Presentation can be improved upon give proper space between different sections, use headings.
Over all a fine attempt.
Keep writing for Further improvement:)
4.5/10
Razor payment id- HHOoNABVzCCLcD
Aabha,
Introduction and conclusion are fine.
You have covered well the Reasons sections, still can add more points here like Gap of a decade since CDM, fear of Japanese replacing British in India etc.
But you missed a part of the question that is ‘why brutal Repression was a certainty even before the launch of QIM’. Due to reasons such as World War II times absolute draconian laws like Defence of India Act, Japanese at door step etc. But you have Written how did British suppress the movement.
Read question properly and Attempt all the sections of the question.
Keep writing for Further improvement:)
3.5/10
Order id- #0000420396
@Swatantra
Rohan,
Your introduction is fine.
In body you have covered reasons section well but few more reasons can be added like a decade gap since CDM, in human wartime policies of British leading to scarcity, Bengal Famine etc.
You have missed a whole section ‘why brutal suppression was a certainty’. You should have written it before the reasons section.
Cover all the possible aspects of the Question.
Conclusion is really well articulated.
Read others answers as well and keep writing 🙂
Payment id HHU8LODcXby9Db
Arpit,
You have Written very good introduction and conclusion.
In main body Reasons also covered thoroughly, how ever you missed a section i.e. ‘why Brutal repression was a certainty’ ?
You need to write it before the reasons here you can add points like British responsibility of protecting its empires, absolute concentration of powers due to war time Draconian laws like Defence of India Act etc.
Rest you have written good. You have a potential to get good score in Mains just read questions properly and Attempt all the possible aspects.
Read others’ answers as well. Keep writing:)
ID-HJjQFLvck5DhqQ
@Swatantra
Please review
Sana 4,
Your introduction and conclusion are fine.
You have missed one section of the question i.e. why brutal repression was a certainty’ even before the launch of the movement. It was due to British aim to protect its most valued colonial possession, war time Draconian laws like Defence of India Act etc.
What you have Written is how it actually got suppressed.
Core section i.e. reasons part is written very well.
Overall structure is good, just try to write shorter paragraph.
You have enough knowledge, read question properly and address all the possible aspects.
Read others answer as well Keep writing:)
#416440
Tanushree,
You can write better introduction. Conclusion is very well articulated.
Following are the Issues with answer-
1. In ‘brutal repression certainty’ section you had to write points like WW-II and British aim to protect its most valued possession at any cost, draconian laws like Defence of India Act, disregard to civil liberties etc.
2. There is a lot of repetition in your answer.
There was no need to write prevailing situation separately rather you should have Inculcate them in Reasons section.
Reasons are covered very well.
Read question properly, address all the sections and avoid repetition of Arguments.
Keep writing for further improvement:)
pay_HH4AoVE2qPd386
Shivanshu,
Your introduction is fine but i can’t make sense of what you want to say in Conclusion.
First of all you’ll get only 2 page of 10 marks question so follow UPSC standard.
You’ve failed in understanding the question. You have written whatever came into your mind.
Read question properly. Except points under Brutal repression whatever you have Written are not directly related to the demand of the question.
You had to write two sections in body first, why there was a fear of Brutal repression even before the launch of the movement (which you have written).
Second what were the reasons behind the launch of the movement despite knowing that there will be severe repression, you have totally missed this core part.
Read the question properly, identify various sections, and stick strictly to the demand of the question.
Read others answers for better understanding. Keep writing:)
2.5/10
Payment Id : 115213946268
Vivek,
Your introduction is fine but Conclusion is not fit as per the demand of the question.
There is no clarity at all in your answer, it seems you failed in understanding the Question.
You have Written what happened during QIM but you had to write two sections-
1. Even before launching the movement Why it was certain that British will brutally suppress the movement. (Less priority)
2. Despite of above certainty, because of what Reasons Gandhi ji still launched the Movement.(core section)
Read questions properly, think over it, understand the demand, frame answer in mind than write it.
Read others’ answers for better understanding keep writing:)
Order id: 0000422561
@Swatantra sir please review. Sorry for late uploading.
Please review 0000425185
@Swatantra sorry for the late uploading Sir 🙏🏻