Why in the News
India’s tiger translocation protocol demands careful selection, a quick and safe transfer, a secure enclosure and release only when fit, but West Bengal’s first tiger reintroduction at Buxa Tiger Reserve broke all four. Tigress T-138, rushed from Bihar’s Valmiki Tiger Reserve for a date set by the State Forest Minister, strayed into Assam, miscarried and escaped. The stake is whether VIP deadlines are overriding conservation science.
What is tiger reintroduction, and why Buxa?
- What it is: Tiger reintroduction moves tigers from a healthy population into a forest that has lost its own, like restocking an emptied reserve so newcomers can breed.
- Why Buxa needed it: Buxa, on West Bengal’s border with Bhutan, became India’s 15th tiger reserve. It lost its resident tigers by 2005-06, but an inflated official count hid the loss for years.
- Groundwork since 2018: Buxa restored grassland, released chital (spotted deer, the tiger’s prey) and resettled families.
- The takeaway: A resident tiger in the Bengal Dooars (sub-Himalayan floodplains split between West Bengal and Assam) would link tiger populations to the east and west, so the failure matters beyond one animal.
How did Buxa break each of the four translocation rules?
- Selection without checks: The protocol requires choosing by age, health, breeding status and behaviour, yet nobody suspected the three-year-old tigress was pregnant.
- Stressful transfer: She was caged for about 18 hours on a late-night road and air journey, chipping a canine and wearing down her foreclaws.
- Unfit release: The ceremony went ahead on October 2, the start of National Wildlife Week. She was released before veterinarians certified her fit, which they did the next day on the management’s instruction.
- Weak enclosure: After her recapture in Assam with trained elephants and excavators, she aborted her eight-week-old foetuses. She then slipped out of a repurposed chital pen too weak to hold her.
Was the miscarriage avoidable?
- Detectable pregnancy: An ultrasound detects foetal sacs from about Day 20 of gestation, and a relaxin (pregnancy hormone) test turns positive around Day 25. Her status could have been checked while she was sedated.
- Official view: The Director of the Wildlife Institute of India (WII) blamed anaesthesia, transport and stress together, and said a first pregnancy ending early is not unusual.
- Counter view: A conservationist with the non-profit TigerWatch said hormones and instinct carry a tigress through her roughly 15-week pregnancy, so the miscarriage was avoidable.
- Panna precedent: At Panna, India’s most successful reintroduction, the team monitored a possibly pregnant tigress round the clock in 2011 rather than sedate her. She delivered safely.
Why did a VIP deadline override protocol?
- Understaffed department: West Bengal had only 94 Indian Forest Service officers against 126 sanctioned posts. The State has also removed forest chiefs’ power to transfer rangers.
- Deflected accountability: The State Forest Minister first denied knowing of the miscarriage, then said it fell under the Centre’s jurisdiction.
- VIP culture: A former Madhya Pradesh forest officer criticised tailoring conservation to VIP convenience. Eg. Madhav Tiger Reserve held a tiger captive to get a VIP date.
- Central probe: Officials of the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA), the body that oversees tiger reserves, reached Buxa on November 12 and confirmed the foetuses and escape; its probe report is awaited.
Challenges
- Deadline-driven releases: Ceremonies fixed before scientific readiness push teams to skip breeding and fitness checks.
- Thin field capacity: Vacant posts and scarce funds rule out Panna-style round-the-clock monitoring.
- Human-tiger conflict: An injured tigress roams a landscape hemmed in by villages.
- Local resistance: Jayanti village, long earmarked for relocation, rejects moving out for the tiger.
Way Forward
- Science-led calendar: Fix release dates after health and breeding checks, never around VIP events.
- Pregnancy screening: Test a candidate tigress for pregnancy whenever she is sedated.
- Purpose-built enclosures: Build tiger-grade pens before any animal arrives.
- Public findings: Publish the NTCA probe and fill vacant forest posts.
Conclusion
Buxa’s setback came less from a gap in science than from a ceremony calendar overriding it. Whether the NTCA probe fixes responsibility and resets the protocol before the programme continues is what to watch.
Key numbers
- Buxa’s designations: Tiger reserve (1983); wildlife sanctuary (1986); Buxa National Park (1997).
- Past tiger count: Pugmark-based peak of 33 tigers, in 1989 and 1999.
- Habitat preparation (since 2018): About 380 hectares of grassland, over 800 chital, about 240 families resettled, 64 village committees.
- Forest cadre (1 January 2026): 22 of 38 promotion posts from the West Bengal Forest Service vacant.
- Panna revival: From zero to more than 30 tigers in under five years.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2017] The term ‘M-STrIPES’ is sometimes seen in the news in the context of (a) Captive breeding of Wild Fauna (b) Maintenance of Tiger Reserves (c) Indigenous Satellite Navigation System (d) Security of National Highways ANSWER: (b)”