Subject: Tribal Issues

Why in the News

A common krait entered the girls’ dormitory of a private aided Ashram School at Japtalai in Dhanora taluka of Gadchiroli district, Maharashtra, on the night of 9 and 10 August, bit six girls aged 8 to 14 and killed three. The deaths expose how a residential school built to carry tribal children out of poverty had neither the beds and nets to prevent the bite nor the road and ambulance to survive it.

What is an Ashram School?

1. About: An Ashram School is a residential school for Scheduled Tribe children, providing free education, boarding and lodging, run either directly by a State tribal development department or by a private body on government aid.
2. Purpose: They exist because tribal habitations are scattered across remote forest hamlets where a day school is not viable. e.g. most children on the rolls of the Japtalai school come from Etapalli, a village at least five hours away by road.
3. Funding route: Central support flows largely through grants in aid under Article 275(1) of the Constitution and through State tribal sub plan funds.

What is a common krait?

1. About: The common krait is a nocturnal, highly venomous snake of the Elapidae family and one of India’s Big Four venomous species, alongside the Indian spectacled cobra, Russell’s viper and the saw scaled viper.
2. Why the bite goes unnoticed: Its venom is neurotoxic, attacking the nervous system, and its bite feels like a mosquito bite with fang marks often impossible to locate. Treating clinicians place it at at least ten times more venomous than the king cobra.

What is anti snake venom and why does timing decide survival?

1. About: Anti snake venom (ASV) is an antibody preparation that neutralises circulating venom, and India uses a polyvalent formulation raised against the Big Four species.
2. The golden hour: The effective window for administering ASV is about half an hour after the bite. Beyond it neurotoxic paralysis of the respiratory muscles progresses even after the correct dose is given.

What happened at the Japtalai Ashram School?

1. The dormitory: Anu Koreti, aged 8, and 111 other girls from Classes 1 to 10 were sleeping on the floor of a hall measuring about 850 square feet when the krait entered.
2. The bite: The snake bit six girls aged between 8 and 14. Three died and three survived.
3. The alarm: The snake coiled around the leg of a fourth child, who woke screaming, and the children woke the cook. The cook struck the snake with a stick and called the peon, the only school employee on campus, who killed it.
4. The transport: The first two girls reached Dhanora Rural Hospital, 9 km away, at about 2.20 a.m. in a vegetable delivery van. Three more arrived at 2.40 a.m., and over 12 panicked girls were taken directly to Gadchiroli.
5. The deaths: Two girls were declared dead at about 4.10 a.m. after all protocol doses and cardiopulmonary resuscitation. The 8 year old died on the way to Gadchiroli’s main hospital after referral for ventilator support.
6. The survivors: One girl was airlifted to Nagpur and is home recovering, one remains on ventilator support at Gadchiroli but out of danger, and one is recovering.

What do the hostel’s living conditions reveal about residential school standards?

1. Sleeping arrangements: Over 100 girls slept on mattresses on the floor with no beds. The only bed in the hall belonged to the cook, a contractual worker.
2. No mosquito nets until after the deaths: Nets were fitted only afterwards, and the cook states the demand had been raised repeatedly in the past with no response.
3. Snake habitat at the window: Piles of bricks and wooden logs stood next to open windows and were removed only after the incident. Moist, cool wood is the most conducive environment for a krait.
4. Supervision gap: The school’s woman supervisor had allegedly gone on leave without the principal’s approval, which is why the cook was sleeping with the girls that night. She is absconding after a first information report for negligence.
5. Scale against space: The campus is about half a football field, with a two storied classroom block and a separate building of halls, holding 233 enrolled children.

Why did the emergency response fail?

1. The unusable highway: The 9 km stretch on National Highway 930 was so potholed it was unmotorable, forcing a 35 km detour and consuming the ASV golden hour.
2. No ambulance: The first children were moved in a vegetable delivery van, since the school had no ambulance and no accessible emergency medical service.
3. Delayed information to parents: A peon reached one father at 9 a.m., hours after the death, and did not tell him his daughter had died. He learnt it from a policeman outside the post mortem room.
4. Referral without capacity assessment: The 8 year old was referred onward for ventilator support even though the rural hospital had a ventilator, and she died in transit.
5. Seasonal isolation as a standing condition: Residents state the same highway stretch stays shut for three months every monsoon and the State bus service is suspended annually on that stretch.
6. The official position: The district Collector’s position is that responding quickly and bringing children in during an emergency is the school’s responsibility.

Why is Gadchiroli particularly exposed to snakebite?

1. Forest cover: Gadchiroli is Maharashtra’s easternmost district with dense forest cover of over 75 percent and a scattered tribal population across remote hamlets.
2. Reptile diversity: The dry deciduous forests and river basins of Gadchiroli and neighbouring Chandrapur support over 21 species of snakes, including all four of the Big Four venomous species.
3. The mortality record: 99 people have died of snakebite in Gadchiroli in the last five years.
4. Development profile: The district was earlier part of the Red Corridor and remains among the most underdeveloped and remote parts of the State, with the Chief Minister as its guardian minister.

What has the State done in response?

1. Criminal action: Separate first information reports have been registered against five persons, including the former Member of Parliament who ran the school, under several bailable sections.
2. Licence cancellation: The State government has said the school’s licence will be cancelled.
3. Systemwide audit: A third party has been appointed to audit all 513 private aided residential tribal schools in Maharashtra.
4. Physical fixes: Mosquito nets have been fitted and the brick and log piles near the windows have been cleared.
5. Road repair on ministerial visit: Contractors were called overnight to patch the road with gravel once ministers announced visits, after years of complaints produced nothing.

Why does closing the school not solve the problem for these families?

1. All children are now home: All 233 enrolled children have returned to their villages, with the academic year interrupted.
2. No affordable alternative: Parents who work as farm labour say they cannot afford schools that require them to buy books and uniforms, so closure ends schooling rather than relocating it.
3. The parents’ demand: Parents are asking the government to provide facilities in the same school and let it function rather than shut it down.
4. Access was already fragile: One parent reports her daughter has lost three months of school every year for the last two years because the road is unusable in the monsoon.
5. What the school represented: For two generations of Gonds, a Scheduled Tribe, the school was the only route out of poverty, and the 8 year old who died wanted to become an Anganwadi Sevika.

What does the wider ashram school record show?

1. Scale of the system: Maharashtra runs 1,056 ashram schools for tribal children, of which 513 are private and aided.
2. The death toll: Opposition leaders cite reports that 584 students have died in these schools in the past two years, with the education system described as obsolete.
3. Accountability inversion: The project officer whose lapse is alleged to have led to the incident is the complainant in the case, which is the specific objection raised against the State’s response.
4. Supervision of quality: The demand is for action against senior government officials responsible for overseeing the quality of these schools, not only against school staff.

Challenges to the Ashram School system

1. Overcrowded residential infrastructure: Dormitory space is allotted by headcount rather than by norm, so basic safety fails. e.g. over 100 girls from Classes 1 to 10 sleeping on the floor of an 850 square feet hall at Japtalai.
2. Absent or unqualified wardens and supervisors: Residential care depends on a single staff member who may be absent without sanction. e.g. the woman supervisor at Japtalai who left on unapproved leave, leaving a contractual cook in charge overnight.
3. No emergency medical linkage: Schools in remote blocks have no ambulance, no tie up with a rural hospital and no protocol for night emergencies. e.g. children carried to Dhanora Rural Hospital in a vegetable delivery van.
4. Road connectivity failure in the monsoon: Physical access collapses for months every year, breaking both schooling and emergency evacuation. e.g. National Highway 930 between Dhanora and Japtalai, which is motorable in adjoining Chhattisgarh but not on the Maharashtra stretch.
5. Weak inspection and grant conditionality: Aid continues without verified compliance with hostel norms until a death forces an audit. e.g. the third party audit of Maharashtra’s 513 aided residential tribal schools ordered only after three girls died.
6. Political and private control of aided schools: Management by politically connected trusts blunts enforcement. e.g. the Japtalai school was run by a former Member of Parliament, and a first information report followed only after the deaths.
7. Nutrition and health monitoring gaps: Residential schools carry a documented record of student deaths from disease, suicide and accidents. e.g. the reported 584 student deaths across Maharashtra’s 1,056 ashram schools in two years.

Conclusion

The krait was the immediate cause of death, and every other cause was an administrative decision taken long before that night. A hall with no beds and no nets, a supervisor absent without sanction, a highway that turns 9 km into 35 km, and a vegetable van standing in for an ambulance together consumed the half hour in which anti snake venom works. The State’s response so far is a licence cancellation, five first information reports and a third party audit of 513 aided residential schools. The families most affected are asking for the school to be fixed rather than closed, since closure removes the only schooling their children have.

Tribal Education in India

1. About: Tribal education policy relies on residential schooling, since Scheduled Tribe habitations are dispersed across forest and hill terrain where a viable day school catchment does not exist.
2. Population base: Scheduled Tribes number about 10.45 crore, roughly 8.6 percent of India’s population as per Census 2011, spread across more than 700 notified communities.
3. The persistent gap: Scheduled Tribe literacy and school retention remain below the national average, with the steepest dropout at the transition from upper primary to secondary.
4. Institutional structure: Delivery runs through State run and aided Ashram Schools, centrally supported Eklavya Model Residential Schools, and hostels funded under Article 275(1) grants.
5. Administrative frame: Scheduled Areas are governed under the Fifth Schedule, with Tribes Advisory Councils and a Governor’s report to the President on their administration.

Constitutional Framework Governing Tribal Welfare

1. Article 15(4): Enables the State to make special provisions for the advancement of socially and educationally backward classes and Scheduled Tribes.
2. Article 21A: Makes free and compulsory education for children aged 6 to 14 a fundamental right.
3. Article 46: Directs the State to promote the educational and economic interests of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and protect them from social injustice and exploitation.
4. Article 244 and the Fifth Schedule: Provide for the administration and control of Scheduled Areas and Scheduled Tribes outside the North East.
5. Sixth Schedule: Provides for autonomous district and regional councils in the tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram.
6. Article 275(1): Provides grants in aid from the Union to States for tribal welfare schemes and administration of Scheduled Areas, which funds ashram schools and hostels.
7. Article 338A: Establishes the National Commission for Scheduled Tribes to investigate and monitor safeguards for Scheduled Tribes.
8. Article 342: Empowers the President to specify the tribes deemed to be Scheduled Tribes in each State and Union Territory.

Laws and Rules Governing Tribal Welfare and Child Safety

1. Panchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996: Extends Panchayati Raj to Fifth Schedule areas with adaptations.
2. Makes the Gram Sabha competent to safeguard community resources and mandates its consultation before land acquisition.
3. Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006: Recognises individual and community forest rights of forest dwelling Scheduled Tribes.
4. Recognises the right to community forest resources and to convert forest villages into revenue villages.
5. Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009: Guarantees free and compulsory elementary education and prescribes school infrastructure and pupil teacher norms.
6. Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015: Regulates institutions housing children and prescribes standards of care and mandatory reporting.
7. Residential facilities housing children in need of care require registration and inspection under the Act.
8. Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989: Penalises offences against Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and provides for special courts.
9. Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012: Applies to residential institutions and imposes mandatory reporting duties on staff.

Back2Basics: Eklavya Model Residential Schools (EMRS)

1. Ministry: Ministry of Tribal Affairs, implemented through the National Education Society for Tribal Students (NESTS).
2. Launch: Introduced in 1997 to 1998 and restructured in 2018 to expand coverage.
3. Norm: An EMRS in every block with more than 50 percent Scheduled Tribe population and at least 20,000 tribal persons.
4. Design: Fully residential co educational schools from Class 6 to Class 12, with a sanctioned capacity of about 480 students each.
5. Objective: Provide quality education comparable to Navodaya Vidyalayas to Scheduled Tribe children in remote areas, covering boarding, lodging and academic costs.
6. Funding: Central capital and recurring grants, with construction and running costs met from the Ministry of Tribal Affairs budget and Article 275(1) grants.

Government Initiatives for Tribal Welfare and Snakebite Control

1. Eklavya Model Residential Schools: Central residential schools for Scheduled Tribe children in tribal majority blocks.
2. Pre Matric and Post Matric Scholarships for Scheduled Tribe students: Fee and maintenance support to reduce dropout at the secondary and higher education stages.
3. Pradhan Mantri Janjati Adivasi Nyaya Maha Abhiyan (PM JANMAN): Saturation approach for Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups covering housing, roads, electricity, water and mobile connectivity.
4. Dharti Aaba Janjatiya Gram Utkarsh Abhiyan: Saturation of basic amenities and services across tribal majority villages.
5. National Action Plan for Prevention and Control of Snakebite Envenoming (NAPSE), 2024: Aims to halve snakebite deaths and disabilities by 2030 through ASV availability, training and surveillance.
6. Snakebite as a notifiable condition: States have been advised to make snakebite cases and deaths notifiable so that the true burden is captured.
7. Van Dhan Vikas Kendras: Value addition and marketing support for minor forest produce collected by tribal households.
8. Ashram School scheme under Article 275(1) grants: Central assistance to States for construction and upgradation of tribal residential schools and hostels.

Key Facts about Tribal Welfare and Snakebite in India

1. World Tribal Day, the International Day of the World’s Indigenous Peoples, is observed on 9 August.
2. Janjatiya Gaurav Divas is observed on 15 November, the birth anniversary of Birsa Munda.
3. India accounts for roughly half of global snakebite deaths, with about 58,000 deaths a year estimated by large mortality studies.
4. The World Health Organization classifies snakebite envenoming as a neglected tropical disease and targets halving deaths and disabilities by 2030.
5. The Big Four venomous snakes responsible for most Indian envenomations are the Indian spectacled cobra, common krait, Russell’s viper and saw scaled viper.
6. Gadchiroli has over 75 percent forest cover and is Maharashtra’s easternmost district.
7. Scheduled Tribes constitute about 8.6 percent of India’s population as per Census 2011.

Challenges in Tribal Residential Education

1. Distance between habitation and school: Enrolment forces children to live five hours or more from home, which raises both dropout and vulnerability. e.g. most children at the Japtalai school come from Etapalli, at least five hours away by road.
2. Infrastructure norms that exist on paper: Hostel space, bedding, sanitation and boundary walls are prescribed but unverified. e.g. no beds and no mosquito nets for 112 girls at Japtalai despite repeated staff requests.
3. Staffing and warden accountability: Residential care is left to contractual or unqualified staff at night. e.g. a contractual cook and a peon were the only adults handling a mass envenomation emergency.
4. Health and emergency infrastructure deficit in Scheduled Areas: Primary health centres lack ASV stocks, ventilators and trained staff, and referral chains are long. e.g. 99 snakebite deaths in Gadchiroli in five years in a district with over 75 percent forest cover.
5. Road and connectivity failure: Monsoon isolation cuts both schooling and evacuation for months. e.g. the kuccha forest road to Kehakawahi hamlet in Murumgaon, blocked by fallen trees and unusable in the monsoon.
6. Language and curriculum mismatch: Instruction in the State language alienates first generation tribal learners in early grades. e.g. Gond speaking children entering Class 1 in Marathi medium ashram schools.
7. Weak grievance and reporting culture: Parents learn of serious incidents late and through informal channels. e.g. a father informed at 9 a.m. by a peon who did not disclose that his daughter had died.

Way Forward

1. Make grant release conditional on a safety audit: Tie continued aid to each residential school to an annual verified certification of beds, nets, sanitation, boundary walls and fire and snake proofing.
2. Post a qualified resident warden and a nurse in every hostel: Replace overnight cover by contractual staff with trained residential staff and a mandatory night duty roster.
3. Stock anti snake venom and train staff at the nearest facility: Ensure every rural hospital and primary health centre in a high burden block holds polyvalent ASV and can begin treatment within the golden hour.
4. Attach a dedicated ambulance or emergency vehicle to remote residential schools: Provide a defined emergency transport arrangement rather than relying on whatever vehicle is available.
5. Prioritise all weather road connectivity in Scheduled Areas: Complete and maintain the Dhanora to Japtalai type stretches under road connectivity schemes so monsoon isolation ends.
6. Repair rather than close failing schools: Upgrade facilities in place where closure would end schooling for children with no affordable alternative.
7. Fix accountability upward: Ensure inquiries name the supervising project officers and departmental officials, and bar an official whose lapse is under examination from acting as complainant.
8. Notify and monitor snakebite: Make snakebite reporting mandatory across the district and publish block level data so preventive investment follows the burden.

PYQ:

“`

[2025, GS1, 15 marks] Does tribal development in India centre around two axes, those of displacement and of rehabilitation? Give your opinion.

“`