Akhilesh Ranjan Committee on Taxation of E-Commerce
A Committee on Taxation of e-commerce constituted by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) to examine the business models for e-commerce submitted its report on 21 March 2016
The Report of the Committee was received by the Government of India and taken into consideration in the preparation of Finance Bill, 2016
The Report provides the view of the Committee on issues related to taxation of e-commerce and recent international developments in this area
The Committee included officers of the CBDT, representatives from the industry, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India and tax experts
The 8 member committee was headed by Akhilesh Ranjan, Joint Secretary (FT&TR-I), C8DT, Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance
Recommendations:
Equalization Levy may be imposed on payments to non-residents for specified services by a separate chapter in the Finance Act, 2016
The Equalization Levy should be chargeable on any sum that is received by a non resident from a resident in India or a permanent establishment in India as a consideration for the specified digital services
The rate of Equalization Levy may be between 6 to 8 % of the gross sum received
Equalization Levy should not be charged unless the consideration received for specified services in a year from a person in India is more than one lakh rupees
Equalization Levy should also not be charged on payments received by a permanent establishment of a non-resident in India, which are attributable to that permanent establishment and taxable under Income-tax Act, 1961
Every person that has received any sum chargeable to Equalization levy, would be required to pay the Equalization Levy chargeable on that sum to the union government
Every person that has received any sum chargeable to Equalization levy, would be required to file a return of Sum chargeable to Equalization Levy as prescribed, if such total sum received by that person in a year exceeds ten crore rupees
Any income arising from a transaction on which Equalization Levy has been paid should be exempted from income-tax, by necessary amendment in Section 10 of the Income-tax Act, 1961
The definition of business connection in section 9 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 may be expanded to include the concept of significant economic presence
Work on exploring the possibility of deduction of Equalization Levy by the payment gateways should be initiated immediately
The implementation and impact of Equalization Levy may be monitored on a regular basis
What is Equalisation Levy?
To avoid some of the difficulties arising from creating new profit attribution rules for purposes of a nexus based on significant economic presence, an equalisation levy could be considered as an alternative way to address the broader direct tax challenges of the digital economy
This approach has been used by some countries in order to ensure equal treatment of foreign and domestic suppliers
An equalisation levy could be structured in a variety of ways depending on its ultimate policy objective
In general, an equalisation levy would be intended to serve as a way to tax a non-resident enterprise’s significant economic presence in a country
In order to provide clarity, certainty and equity to all stakeholders, and to avoid undue burden on small and medium-sized businesses, the equalisation levy would be applied only in cases where it is determined that a non-resident enterprise has a significant economic presence