💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Archives: Mains

  • Discuss the role of the National Commission for Backward Classes in the wake of its transformation from a statutory body to a constitutional body.

    The 102nd Constitution Amendment Act, 2018 inserted Article 338B, elevating the commission to par with the NCSC and NCST.

    Role of the National Commission for Backward Classes

    Investigating Constitutional Safeguards provided to backward classes under the Constitution.

    Exercising Civil Court Powers to summon officials, demand public records, and examine witnesses during active inquiries.

    Inquiry into Rights Violations: investigates specific citizen grievances regarding the outright denial or subversion of rights belonging to SEBCs.

    Advising on Socio-Economic Development: Formulates policy guidelines and advises both Union and State governments on targeted welfare planning for backward communities.

    Evaluating Departmental Progress: Reviews and audits the grassroots performance and execution speed of central and state-level affirmative action schemes.

    Presents comprehensive structural review reports to the President of India regarding the operational health of welfare frameworks.

    The Union and State governments consult the NCBC on all major policy matters affecting SEBCs.

    Enforcing Reservation Compliance: Monitors and checks public sector recruitment pipelines to guarantee strict adherence to the mandated 27% OBC quotas.

    Aids the institutional procedure of identifying and reviewing communities for the Central OBC list under Article 342A.

    Case Studies

    Enforcing Creamy Layer Compliance in Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs)

    The commission played a central key role in implementation of the 27% OBC reservation within the All India Quota for undergraduate and postgraduate medical and dental courses (NEET).

    Major issues

    Recommendations are not binding on executive

    Overlapping jurisdiction with other bodies like NHRX, NCW etc

    Lack of administrative and financial autonomy

    Strengthening the NCBC is essential to achieve constitutional objective of Social Justice

  • Discuss the role of the Vice-President of India as the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha.

    The Vice-President of India, under Article 64 of the Constitution, is the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha (Council of States).

    Role of the Vice-President

    Presiding Authority – The Vice-President, as ex-officio Chairman, conducts proceedings, maintains order and decorum, and ensures smooth legislative functioning.

    Regulator of Debates – Allocates time, permits discussions, and ensures equal opportunity to both treasury and opposition benches.

    Interpreter of Rules – Decides points of order and interprets parliamentary rules to maintain procedural consistency.

    Casting Vote – Does not ordinarily vote but exercises a casting vote in case of a tie, ensuring impartial decision-making.

    Promotes Deliberation – Facilitates meaningful debates and consensus-building, enabling Rajya Sabha to act as a House of Review.

    Upholds Federal Balance – Protects state interests and ensures fair representation of diverse regional perspectives.

    Encourages Transparency – Ensures proceedings are open and accessible (e.g., live telecast of sessions) to enhance accountability.

    Maintains Impartiality – Expected to act above party lines, setting high ethical standards in conduct.

    Limitations of the Vice-President Compared to the Speaker of Lok Sabha

    Does not preside over joint sittings of Parliament (Article 118).

    The Vice-President cannot suspend or expel MPs for disorderly conduct, unlike the Speaker who can act under Rules 373 and 374A.

    No Role in Money Bills under Article 110.

    No Power Over Confidence Motions

    The Vice-President as Chairman ensures that the Rajya Sabha functions as the House of sober second thought, balancing federal interests and national priorities.

  • To what extent, in your opinion, has the decentralisation of power in India changed the governance landscape at the grassroots ?

    73rd and 74th CAA are the embodiment of grass-root democracy and democratic decentralization in India. They are inspired by Gandhiji’s concept of “Oceanic Circles of Power” and “Swaraj”.

    Positive Transformations in Governance Landscape

    Rajni Kothari described local bodies as “schools of democracy” where political awareness and participation are cultivated at the grassroots level.

    Democratic Deepening with over 32 lakh elected representatives across 2.6 lakh Panchayats and 4,000+ urban bodies.

    Social Inclusion and Equity – Reservation for SCs, STs, and women enhanced representation of marginalised groups in decision-making. Eg- Women’s Representation at 46.44%

    Panchayats manage programmes like MGNREGA, PMAY-G, Jal Jeevan Mission, bringing last-mile efficiency.

    Participatory Planning – Gram Sabhas and Ward Committees have improved local accountability and need-based development. Eg- Social Audits of MGNREGA

    Strengthened Disaster Response – Eg- during COVID-19 and Kerala floods.

    Efficient Resource Management- Eg- Hiware Bazar in Maharashtra effectively managed water resources through watershed development.

    Conflict Resolution- Reports indicate a 30% reduction in petty disputes reaching district courts due to effective Panchayat mediation.

    Challenges

    “PRIs exist as over-structured but underpowered organisations.” (2nd ARC)

    No decentralisation of power, rather decentralisation of corruption – Mani Shankar Iyer Committee

    Dependence on higher tiers- Around 95% of Panchayat funds come from Central/State transfers, limiting fiscal autonomy.

    Limited own-source revenue- Poor tax collection efficiency (>1% own tax).

    Barriers to Local Taxation- Freebie culture and fear of losing popularity discourage local taxation.

    Incomplete devolution- less than 20% of States have transferred all 29 subjects under 11th Schedule (MoPR, 2022). (​​overall Panchayat Devolution Index is only 43.89% (2021-22))

    Centralised Welfare via Cash Transfers – The welfare state now relies on DBT through JAM, bypassing panchayats and reducing local accountability and participatory governance

    Shortage of staff- Average 0.67 Panchayat Secretaries per Gram Panchayat, as low as 0.33 in Uttar Pradesh.

    Weak Gram Sabhas- Low participation, elite domination, and token meetings.

    Gender and social barriers leading to proxy control. (Sarpanch Pati)

    Manishankar Aiyar Committee recommendations.

    Establish National Commission for Panchayati Raj.

    Create Panchayat Ombudsman for grievance redressal.

    Set up a separate cadre of Panchayat bureaucracy with a code of conduct.

    Adopt activity mapping for clear delineation of 3Fs – Funds, Functions, Functionaries.

    To realise the vision of “Gram Uday se Bharat Uday”, India needs second-generation Panchayati Raj reforms

  • Right of movement and residence throughout the territory of India are freely available to the Indian citizens, but these rights are not absolute. Comment

    “Liberty means freedom to do everything which injures no one else.” (French Declaration of the Rights of Man, 1789). The Right to Movement and Residence under the Indian Constitution embodies this idea of liberty.

    Constitutional Provision

    Article 19(1)(d) – Right to move freely throughout the territory of India.

    Article 19(1)(e) – Right to reside and settle in any part of India.

    However, it is not absolute as

    Reasonable Restrictions under Article 19(5) – interests of the general public or for the protection of Scheduled Tribes.

    Protection of Scheduled Tribes – Restrictions in 5th and 6th Schedules safeguard traditional culture, property rights, and protect tribes from exploitation by outsiders.

    Security of State – Eg – Restrictions under AFSPA in disturbed regions.

    Public Order – Curfews, preventive detention, or restrictions during riots.

    Judicial Endorsement – Eg – State of UP v. Kaushailiya (1964) upheld restrictions on movement of prostitutes to protect public health and morality.

    Pandemic Situations – During COVID-19 lockdowns, freedom of movement was restricted to control spread of the virus.

    Inner Line Permit (ILP) – Required in certain north-eastern states; prior approval of state government needed to protect local interests.

    Foreigners – Can be deported for violating rules, even though citizens enjoy freedom of residence.

    “Liberty is not a license, but is regulated freedom.” Ensuring individual liberty while safeguarding collective interests reflects balanced constitutionalism.

  • The most significant achievement of modern law in India in the constitutionalization of environmental problems by the Supreme Court. Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws.

    “The Constitution is not a mere lawyers’ document, it is a vehicle of Life, and its spirit is always the spirit of Age.”- B.R. Ambedkar

    Constitutionalization of environmental problems under Article 21 is the embodiment of this spirit.

    Constitutionalization is done through

    Expansion of Article 21

    Use of Directive Principles (Art. 48A, 51A(g))

    Development of Doctrines (Polluter Pays, Precautionary Principle, Public Trust, Absolute Liability, Intergenerational Equity)

    Expansion of Judicial Review & PILs

    Use of Continuous Mandamus

    Relevant case laws

    Industrial Pollution

    MC Mehta v. Union of India (Oleum Gas Leak, 1986) – Established Absolute Liability for hazardous industries.

    Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action v. UOI (1996) – Applied Polluter Pays Principle.

    Water Pollution

    MC Mehta v. UOI (Ganga Pollution, 1988) – Ordered closure of polluting tanneries.

    Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti v. UOI (2017) – Directed installation of Sewage Treatment Plants (STPs).

    Air Pollution

    MC Mehta v. UOI (Delhi Pollution, 1998) – Mandated conversion of public transport to CNG.

    MC Mehta v. UOI (Firecrackers, 2024) – Imposed ban to ensure clean air.

    Deforestation & Forest Rights

    T.N. Godavarman v. UOI (1997-ongoing) – Continuous mandamus for forest conservation.

    Niyamgiri Case (2013) – Empowered Gram Sabha to protect tribal rights.

    Climate Change

    M.K. Ranjitsinh v. UOI (2024) – Recognised Right against adverse climate impacts under Articles 14 and 21.

    Natural Resources

    MC Mehta v. Kamal Nath (1997) – Applied Public Trust Doctrine to rivers.

    Reliance Natural Resources v. RIL (2010) – Declared natural resources as public property.

    Development Projects

    Narmada Bachao Andolan v. UOI (2000) – Integrated sustainable development into constitutional law.

    Vanashakti v. UOI (2024) – Stressed need for prior environmental clearance.

    As Justice P.N. Bhagwati observed, “Right to life includes the right to live with human dignity” – and dignity today is inseparable from a clean and healthy environment.

  • Examine the potential of wind energy in India and explain the reasons for their limited spatial spread. (भारत में पवन ऊर्जा की संभावना का परीक्षण कीजिए एवं उनके सीमित क्षेत्रीय विस्तार के कारणों को समझाइए|)

  • Discuss the significance of the lion and bull figures in Indian mythology, art and architecture.(भारतीय मिथक कला और वास्तुकला में सिंह एवं वृषभ की आकृतियों के महत्व पर विचार करें।)

    Animal symbolism occupies a central place in Indian civilisational thought. Among these, the lion and bull find continuous expression from Vedic times to modern India in religion, art and architecture.

    Significance of the Lion

    Mythological Significance

    Divine power and protection – Lion is the vahana of Goddess Durga, symbolising victory of dharma over adharma. Eg- Mahishasuramardini imagery.

    Incarnation of Vishnu – Narasimha avatar (half-man, half-lion) represents divine intervention against tyranny.

    Royal authority – Lion associated with kingship and sovereignty in Puranic literature.

    Buddha is also called as Shakya-Simha. His first sermon is described as the “Lion’s Roar” (Simhanada), signifying the power and authority of Truth.

    Throne Symbolism- The Indian word for throne is Simhasana (Lion-seat), indicating that the occupant possesses the qualities of a lion.

    Artistic Significance

    Symbol of fearlessness and majesty – Eg- Lions shown overpowering elephants or enemies

    Ashokan Lion Capital – Four lions back-to-back at Sarnath symbolise power, vigilance and moral governance.

    Narasimha is an important form in Indian sculpture and paintings. Eg – Narasimha’s relief at the temple of Belur.

    Architectural Significance

    Guardian figures – Lions placed at temple entrances and gopurams as protectors of sacred space.

    State symbolism – Adopted as National Emblem of India, reflecting continuity of ancient political ideals.

    Significance of the Bull

    Mythological Significance

    Vehicle of Lord Shiva – Nandi, the bull, symbolises devotion, strength and fertility

    Cosmic order – Bull associated with Dharma standing on four legs in Satya Yuga.

    Agrarian symbolism – Bull revered as sustainer of life, linked with prosperity and agriculture.

    The first Jain Tirthankara is symbolized by the Bull (Rishabha), representing the beginning of the spiritual path

    Artistic Significance

    Icon of devotion – Sculpted Nandi figures placed facing the sanctum in Shiva temples. Eg- Brihadeeswara Temple, Thanjavur.

    The bronze bull of Kalibangan represents Harappan skill in lost-wax casting

    Bull sculptures on the capital of Mauryan pillars depicting the zodiac sign of Taurus.

    Rampurva Bull Capital represents the calm, stable aspect of the Emperor’s rule.

    Architectural Significance

    Integral temple element – Separate Nandi mandapas in Dravidian temples. Eg- Largest monolithic statue of Nandi in Lepakshi Temple.

    Alignment of Nandi with garbhagriha symbolises direct spiritual connection.

    The Lion and the Bull act as the dual pillars of Indian iconography, reflecting the “spirit of India.”

  • How will you explain that medieval Indian temple sculptures represent the social life of those days? (स्पष्ट करें कि मध्यकालीन भारतीय मंदिरों की मूर्तिकला उस दौर के सामाजिक जीवन का प्रतिनिधित्व करती है।)

  • Explore and evaluate the impact of ‘Work From Home’ on family relationships.

    The Work From Home (WFH) model, accelerated during the COVID-19 pandemic, has reconfigured the interface between work and family.

    Positive Impacts of WFH on Family Relationships

    Increased Family Time and financial stability due to reduced commuting time and cost

    Strengthening of Emotional Bonds – Eg- Shared meals and daily conversations improving marital and parent-child relationships.

    Improved value transmission and greater “parent watch” over children.

    Opportunity for renegotiation of gender roles. Eg- Increased involvement of men in childcare and household responsibilities.

    Support for Elderly Care – Easier supervision and emotional support for ageing parents.

    Improved Work-Life Balance – Flexibility in scheduling family and work commitments.

    Greater flexibility in work led to an increased number of women entering the workforce.

    Negative Impacts of WFH on Family Relationships

    Blurring of Work-Family Boundaries – Eg- Extended work hours causing stress and irritability.

    Constant proximity–

    Reduction in personal space and time leading to conflicts as reflected in increasing divorce rates

    Rise in cases of domestic violence during COVID

    Dual Burden on Women – paid work + disproportionate housework and care duties.

    Mental Health Strain – Isolation from colleagues leading to isolation and loneliness.

    Sedentary Family Habits- Parents and children transitioning directly from work/school screens to leisure screens without leaving the house.

    Lower-income households face stress due to cramped living conditions and unstable jobs.

    Way Forward

    Clear work-hour norms to protect family time

    Gender-sensitive workplace policies

    Mental health support for employees

    Hybrid work models offering flexibility

    The right to disconnect Bill needs to be passed to ensure work life balance in the WFH context.

  • Discuss the meaning of colour-coded weather warnings for cyclone prone areas given by India Meteorological Department. (भारतीय मौसम विज्ञान विभाग द्वारा चक्रवात प्रवण क्षेत्रों के लिए मौसम सम्बन्धी चेतावनियों के लिए निर्धारित रंग-संकेत के अर्थ की चर्चा करें।)