Why in the News
The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls has moved from a punitive process to a package of concessions. The Election Commission of India (ECI) amended or reversed several rules and forms within 10 days, but the relief applies only in the seven States where the SIR is still under way. Critics argue the reversals admit overreach but do nothing for voters already removed.
What is the SIR, and what has the ECI reversed?
- What it is: The SIR is a time-bound, house-to-house re-enumeration of voters. Every voter fills a fresh form, like rebuilding a register from scratch instead of correcting it.
- Re-entry for excluded voters: The ECI held a punitive line for 16 months and eased it after opposition protests. Excluded voters may now file an enumeration form with a declaration instead of Form 6, the new enrolment form, and keep their Elector Photo Identity Card (EPIC) number.
- Other concessions: The ECI accepts it can correct its own mistakes under Rule 21A of the electoral rules. Relocated voters need only Form 8 to update their address, and the enumeration window stays open.
- Form 6 declaration withdrawn: The ECI had added an extra declaration to Form 6, first in Bihar and West Bengal and later inside the online form. Changing a form prescribed by law is for Parliament and the Union government, so the ECI has reversed it.
- The takeaway: The concessions ease re-entry for voters still in the process, but also concede steps critics had called illegal.
Who decides inclusion and deletion, the officer or the software?
- Statutory role: Under the Representation of the People Act, 1950 (RPA), only the local Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) can add or delete names in a constituency’s roll.
- Centralised control: During the SIR, that power was shifted to Delhi through the ECINET and ERONET software systems, so software decided what an ERO could do.
- The Goa case: On a Supreme Court direction, State election officers reviewed 97 questionable deletions and found 90 wrong. EROs could not restore the names, because the software lacked that option.
- Correction now: The ECI is returning inclusion and deletion powers to EROs. It has set up a committee to audit its IT systems for legal compatibility.
How were decisions on the SIR taken?
- Internal dissent: Two Election Commissioners formally dissented at least 14 times against the SIR’s conduct, and the new reforms track those objections.
- No minutes: The ECI now promises formal agendas and recorded minutes for meetings, which shows key decisions were taken without basic records.
- No signed order: Right to Information (RTI) disclosures show no signed formal order initiating the nationwide SIR. None appeared in the ECI’s 240-page affidavit before the Supreme Court.
Do the reversals deliver relief, or only admit the error?
- No relief where closed: The SIR has already closed for roughly 75% of India, including Bihar, West Bengal and Karnataka. Eg. Bengaluru voters deleted after residence shifts and slum demolitions lack remedies now offered in Delhi.
- Shrinking rolls: The shortfall of registered voters against India’s adult population widened from 2 crore to 15 crore after the SIR.
- Persisting errors: Hundreds of duplicate voter IDs survive. Critics also allege unaddressed targeted exclusion, especially of Muslim voters in West Bengal.
- Remedies sought: Critics want EPIC restoration in completed States, an audit of deletions made on Form 7 objections, and disposal of West Bengal appeals, 91% of which show wrongful deletion.
- Accountability sought: They also seek a public apology and the Chief Election Commissioner‘s resignation.
Challenges
- Software over statute: Rolls run through centrally set software can override the legal role of the ERO.
- Speed gap: Deletions follow the election calendar, but appeals have no deadline, so a late win may not restore a vote in time.
- Bulk objections: Objections to inclusion can be filed in bulk with little deterrent, so names can be removed on others’ complaints.
Way Forward
- Notice before deletion: Give every voter an individual notice stating the ground, a hearing and a reasoned order before any deletion.
- Software by rule: Align ECINET options with the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, including rollback of wrongful deletions.
- Appeal deadlines: Set statutory deadlines for appeals, and finalise no roll until its appeals are decided.
Conclusion
Concessions made after protests correct some of the SIR’s procedures, but they leave voters already removed in most States without a remedy. Whether the ECI extends restoration to completed States before the next elections will show if the reversals amount to accountability.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2026, GS2, 10 marks] Is the right to vote a fundamental right? Discuss the position of the Election Commission of India while undertaking the revision of electoral rolls. Can it also examine the question of citizenship of voters?”