Why in the News
The Green India Mission was to bring 2.8 million hectares under green cover by 2018, but only 5.3% of the approved area has been covered seven years after that deadline. Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has faulted the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) over this “failure”, citing an audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG).
What is the Green India Mission?
- What it is: The Green India Mission (GIM) is one of the eight national missions under the National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC), run by MoEFCC and launched in February 2014. It aims to restore and enhance forest cover and respond to climate change.
- Why it was introduced: Trees absorb carbon dioxide, so forests act like a carbon sink, a store that pulls carbon out of the air. More forest cover helps India both cut net emissions and adapt to climate change.
- Revision without rules: The mission was revised in 2021, but the government has still not issued the guidelines needed to put the revision into effect.
- The takeaway: A flagship climate mission has delivered a small fraction of its target, so its contribution to India’s climate goals remains largely on paper.
What did the House panel find?
- Ministry without answers: The PAC, chaired by Opposition (Congress) member K.C. Venugopal, said the Ministry could not answer many of its members’ questions. The chair called the mission a complete failure.
- Aravalli green wall: The mission did no work on a green wall, a belt of planting along the Aravallis, though it was a listed priority. The panel linked this failure to its concern over pollution, especially in Delhi.
- Timeframe sought: The PAC asked the government to fix a timeframe for implementing the mission.
Why did planting not produce green cover?
- No visible change: A study by the Indian Institute of Science (IISc) for the CAG found no change in green cover at 70% of the sites checked.
- Sparse canopy: Only about 10% of the mapped area showed tree cover.
- Wrong sites chosen: Saplings were planted inside existing forests and even in a standing paddy field.
- Degraded land skipped: Scrublands, ravines and old mines, the land that most needed cover, were left out.
Where did the mission’s management break down?
- Funding shortfall: Only ₹1,149 crore of the mission’s approved ₹2,400 crore budget was received.
- Slow release: The budget was meant for four years, but even this smaller sum arrived over 10 years.
- Dormant Governing Council: The Governing Council, chaired by the Minister, met only twice in 10 years instead of once a year as stipulated.
- No reporting: No annual report has been prepared, and the carbon the mission captured was never measured.
- No social audit: No social audit, a check of a programme by the community it serves, was held in 14 of the 16 States.
Challenges
- Counting saplings, not trees: Progress is recorded as area planted, not as trees that survive and form canopy.
- Underfunding: Less than half the approved budget reached the mission, so planned areas could not be treated.
- Weak oversight: Without Council meetings, annual reports or social audits, failures surfaced only through an external audit.
- Poor site selection: Planting in existing forests and farmland adds little new cover.
Way Forward
- Revised guidelines: MoEFCC should issue the revised guidelines with a fixed implementation timeframe, as the PAC asked.
- Outcome monitoring: Measure survival, canopy and carbon captured through satellite mapping, not saplings planted.
- Degraded-land focus: Direct new planting to scrublands, ravines and old mines.
- Mandatory accountability: Make an annual report and social audits compulsory in every participating State.
Conclusion
The mission failed less for want of a goal than for want of money, meetings and measurement to pursue it. The next marker is whether the Ministry responds to the PAC with revised guidelines and a deadline it can be held to.
Back2Basics: Public Accounts Committee
- What it is: A financial committee of Parliament that checks whether money Parliament granted was spent legally and for the purpose intended.
- Composition: 15 Lok Sabha members, elected by proportional representation through the single transferable vote, and 7 Rajya Sabha members; members serve one year.
- Chair: By convention the chair comes from the Opposition in the Lok Sabha.
- Basis of work: It examines the CAG’s audit reports; it was first set up in 1921 under the Government of India Act, 1919.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2016] Which of the following best describes/ describe the aim of ‘Green India Mission’ of the Government of India? 1. Incorporating environmental benefits and costs into the Union and State Budgets thereby implementing the ‘green accounting’ 2. Launching the second green revolution to enhance agricultural output so as to ensure food security to one and all in the future 3. Restoring and enhancing forest cover and responding to climate change by a combination of adaptation and mitigation measures Select the correct answer using the code given below. (a) 1 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3 ANSWER: (c)”