Why in the News
India’s cyber reporting rules make companies report attacks within six hours, but an outage caused by a technical fault falls outside them. A Microsoft infrastructure fault has disrupted Microsoft 365, including Outlook, worldwide, hitting the email of IndiGo, Akasa Air and Air India. No Indian rule clearly says who must report such a failure, and to whom.
What is a service outage, and why is it an accountability question?
- Cloud service outage: A cloud service runs many firms’ systems on one provider’s remote servers. An outage is like a power cut in a building where they all rent offices.
- Microsoft’s explanation: Microsoft apologised for the 12 to 13 November disruption and blamed a fault in an upgrade of its network capacity.
- Customer recourse: A customer’s only remedy is its contract: a missed service level earns a service credit, a discount on a future bill.
- The takeaway: Services lakhs of Indians depend on can fail with no rule making anyone explain why.
Which Indian rules apply, and where does each fall short?
- CERT-In directions: The Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-In), the national cyber incident agency, issued directions under the Information Technology Act, 2000. Firms must report cyber incidents to it within six hours.
- Attacks, not faults: The directions cover attacks and intrusions, not outages caused by technical faults. CERT-In can still seek Microsoft’s explanation under Section 70B(6) of the IT Act.
- RBI outsourcing directions: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) requires a bank using cloud services to assess its dependence on the supplier and keep an exit strategy. The RBI holds the bank responsible.
- Data protection law: The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 treats an accidental “loss of access to personal data” as a breach. From May 2027, each breach must be reported to the Data Protection Board and affected persons.
- Unclear on outages: Failing to report a breach can cost up to Rs 200 crore. The law does not say whether a temporary outage counts as a “loss of access”.
How do other countries hold cloud providers accountable?
- European Union, DORA: EU financial supervisors named 19 companies, including Microsoft and Tata Consultancy Services, under the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA).
- United Kingdom: Microsoft and three others were placed under the Bank of England. Both the EU and UK schemes cover only services sold to financial firms.
- European Union, NIS2: This broader law covers cloud firms in all sectors. Total unavailability for over 30 minutes is a “significant incident”, so the Microsoft outage would have counted.
- Singapore: A new law requires large data centres and cloud firms to hold a licence and report service interruptions to the regulator.
- South Korea: After a data centre fire knocked out KakaoTalk in 2022, large platforms and data centres must file disaster management plans.
Challenges
- Attack-based trigger: India’s reporting duty depends on whether an attack occurred; its peers look at outage duration and users affected.
- Duty on the customer: The organisation that collected the data must report, even though the data sits on Microsoft’s servers.
- Indian vendors uncovered: A technical fault at an Indian email supplier carries no Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-In) reporting duty either.
Way Forward
- Wider CERT-In reporting: CERT-In should add major service disruptions, whatever their cause, to the incidents reported to it.
- Direct regulator: The Union government should put the largest digital service providers under a direct regulator, as the EU and UK have.
- Data Protection Board clarification: Before the Rules take effect, the Board should clarify whether outages are breaches and who reports them. Eg. Europe demands reports only where people are at risk.
- Indian vendors: Authorities can shift services to Indian vendors to cut foreign reliance. Eg. 12.68 lakh official email accounts moved to Chennai-based Zoho.
Conclusion
India regulates cyber attacks but not the failure of the services those attacks target, so a global outage can hit Indian users with no one obliged to explain it. A clear rule on who must report a major outage, and to whom, is what to watch before the data protection Rules take effect.
Key numbers
- CERT-In directions: 28 April 2022.
- RBI outsourcing directions: 28 November 2025, carrying forward rules in force from 1 October 2023.
- DORA designation: 18 November 2025.
- UK designation: as of 13 July 2026.
- NIS2 partial failure: over an hour and over 5% or 1 million EU users, whichever is smaller; notice in 24 hours, full report in 72.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2022, GS3, 10 marks] What are the different elements of cyber security? Keeping in view the challenges in cyber security, examine the extent to which India has successfully developed a comprehensive National Cyber Security Strategy.”