Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Why in the News

Pakistan’s climate minister is to attend the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi. Since the Pahalgam attack, India’s position has been that terrorism and bilateral talks cannot coexist. The visit raises a choice: keep the hard line on terrorism while using multilateral platforms to restart cooperation where India’s own interests, especially water, demand it.

What is India’s current stance on Pakistan?

  1. No talks amid terror: India refuses bilateral talks while cross-border terrorism continues, a stance adopted after the Pahalgam attack and the border confrontations that followed.
  2. Wider conditionality: A month later, the Prime Minister extended the condition to trade and water, making relations subordinate to India’s demands on cross-border terrorism.
  3. Limits of suspension: Suspending ties communicates political resolve but does not diminish terrorists’ capabilities or improve India’s security.
  4. The takeaway: Suspension alone also shuts the channels India needs on shared issues such as water, so the policy needs a second track of selective engagement.

How has SCO diplomacy opened a door?

  1. Convening power: By inviting all SCO members to New Delhi and joining meetings ahead of the Islamabad SCO Summit in August 2027, India has shown maturity as a convening power, a country able to bring rivals to one table.
  2. Pakistan’s pragmatism: Pakistan, as SCO chair, keeps channels open by joining an initiative championed by the Indian Prime Minister.

Why is water the hardest test?

  1. Two-way exposure: India is upstream of Pakistan and Bangladesh and downstream of China, a position its water policy does not account for.
  2. Indus measures: India stopped sharing routine hydrological data on the Indus and approved the Chenab-Beas link tunnel project. Pakistan’s climate minister responded that Pakistan would “cut off those hands” restricting its water share.
  3. China’s mirror move: China has restricted hydrological data on the Brahmaputra while building the Medog mega-dam in Tibet.
  4. Padma and Farakka: India has protested Bangladesh’s proposed Padma Barrage. India itself built the Farakka Barrage over East Pakistan’s objections in 1961, so the protest mirrors its own past conduct.
  5. Climate pressure: Climate change makes cooperation more necessary, because neighbours must jointly manage disputed areas, keep border communities engaged and develop hydroelectric power.

What does isolation cost India in South Asia?

  1. Least integrated region: South Asia is among the least economically integrated regions, with intra-regional trade at around 5%.
  2. China fills the gap: Chatham House, a London-based think tank, inferred that strained ties between India and its neighbours created vacuums Beijing has used through trilateral and regional groupings.
  3. Bangladesh’s drift: Bangladesh has been increasing its alignment with China even as India objects to its barrage plans.
  4. Leadership deficit: Suspension has compromised India’s ambition for regional leadership, which requires the ability to keep engaging even difficult neighbours.

Challenges

  1. Domestic cost of outreach: After a terror attack, any engagement with Pakistan carries a high political cost at home.
  2. Recurring terrorism: A fresh attack by Pakistan-based groups can end any cooperative track overnight.
  3. Treaty in abeyance: With the Indus Waters Treaty kept on hold by India, no agreed mechanism remains for sharing river data.
  4. Upstream leverage of China: China can use against India on the Brahmaputra the same tools India uses on the Indus.

Way Forward

  1. Issue-based engagement: Identify areas where bilateral cooperation serves India’s interests, including with Pakistan, starting with climate and disaster data.
  2. SCO as a channel: Use SCO meetings for low-stakes technical contacts that do not dilute the terrorism condition.
  3. Consistent water principles: Apply to downstream neighbours the same data-sharing standard India seeks from China.
  4. Regional trade facilitation: Revive South Asian trade and transit links to shrink the space others fill.

Conclusion

India can keep its terrorism condition and still choose issue-specific engagement where its own interests, above all shared rivers, are at stake. Whether SCO-linked meetings in the coming months produce any issue-specific contact with Pakistan is the marker to watch.

Back2Basics: Shanghai Cooperation Organisation

  1. Formation: Founded in 2001; India became a full member in 2017.
  2. Headquarters: Beijing, China.
  3. Mandate: Security, political and economic cooperation in Eurasia.
  4. Members include: China, Russia, India, Pakistan, Iran, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan.

Matching Previous Year Question

“[2015, GS2, 12 marks] Terrorist activities and mutual distrust have clouded India-Pakistan relations. To what extent the use of soft power like sports and cultural exchanges could help generate goodwill between the two countries? Discuss with suitable examples.”

Click here to Download X-Factor Notes for FREE. Cover the entire Microthemes with PYQs.

Download free X-Factor Notes
Revised and updated X-Factor Notes for UPSC Mains 2026: nine subject booklets