Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Governance › Civil Services

Missing in reform charters: India’s Great Stagnation in state capacity

·

Why in the News

India’s “Great Stagnation” of the last two decades lies not in the economy, which has grown, but in the capacity of the Indian state to deliver. The state is too small, wrongly spread across tiers of government and chronically understaffed, yet no reform charter addresses it.

What is state capacity, and how small is the Indian state?

  1. State capacity: The ability of government to staff, run and enforce what it decides. Like a hospital, a state needs enough trained staff, not just buildings and budgets.
  2. Peak public employment: Total public employment peaked at 3.84% in 1981 (Arvind Subramanian and Devesh Kapur, *A Sixth of Humanity*).
  3. Lowest in Asia: It is now just above 2%, the lowest in Asia, even as the economy and the state’s mandate grew. Eg. India has only 1.1 judges per lakh people.
  4. Weak local tier: In China and the US, two-thirds of government employees work for local government, five times India’s share.
  5. The takeaway: The economy has grown but the machinery that delivers policy has not, so the state loses credibility and can lose legitimacy.

Where are the staffing gaps?

  1. Thin local cadres: Andhra Pradesh pays just 26,000 municipal employees, and all its Gram Sachivalayas (village secretariats) together hold only 82,000 staff. Contract staff do not make up the shortfall.
  2. Unfilled sanctioned posts: Recruitment lags even against vacant posts, and the shortage worsens at lower tiers. Eg. Gurugram’s district commissioner’s office is 27% short, and shortfalls of 40% are routine in many States.
  3. No HR policy: The state has no human resources (HR) policy, and beyond hiring contract staff it has not rethought whom to recruit or how.

What does a thin state cost citizens?

  1. Discretion and rents: When few officials control a service, they decide who gets it, so they can demand rents, meaning payments extracted for access.
  2. Selective enforcement: Too few inspectors means selective action, which looks unjust even without rents. Eg. Maharashtra needs at least triple its food safety staff to check all eateries consistently.
  3. Bureaucratic overload: Officials with fewer resources implement programmes worse (Aditya Dasgupta and Devesh Kapur, “The Political Economy of Bureaucratic Overload”).
  4. Underspending: The PRS Legislative Research *State of State Finances* report shows States underspend for lack of capacity to spend.
  5. Cash transfer bias: Scarce staff skew development choices, so the rush to cash transfers reflects the state’s incapacity as much as electoral largesse.

Why has reform kept the state small?

  1. Liberalisation’s blind spot: Reform sought fewer government functions, but markets only change the risks and externalities (costs one party imposes on others) the state must manage.
  2. Fear of discretion: Because so much state power is discretionary, citizens and politicians fear that more personnel means more harassment.
  3. Centralisation: Local government, where most development happens, continues to be neglected.
  4. High public wages: Public pay far exceeds private pay, so government accepts fewer staff on high wages and the public competes for a small elite of jobs.
  5. Fiscal control through vacancies: Governments leave posts empty to cut spending quietly and to limit the power of organised employees, so serious HR planning becomes impossible.

Challenges

  1. Wage bill pressure: High public pay makes each new post costly, so headcount competes directly with scheme spending.
  2. Capacity to reform: Past attempts at administrative assessment of schemes and an HR strategy were aborted because the state lacks the staff to design them.
  3. Investment seen as cost: Spending on the state’s own personnel is treated as expenditure, not investment.

Way Forward

  1. Administrative assessment: Assess the staff needed for every new scheme, regulation and function before approval.
  2. State HR strategy: Frame a long-term HR strategy, including redesigned exams and recruitment.
  3. Recruitment calendar: Fill sanctioned vacancies on a fixed annual calendar instead of using vacancies to control spending.

Conclusion

India’s reform debate has focused on markets and schemes, not on the thinning machinery that delivers them. Until spending on personnel is treated as an investment and recruitment is planned, every new scheme will compete for the same scarce officials.

Government Initiatives for Civil Services Capacity

  1. Mission Karmayogi (2020): The National Programme for Civil Services Capacity Building shifts training from “rule-based” to “role-based” learning through the Integrated Government Online Training (iGOT) Karmayogi platform.
  2. Capacity Building Commission: Approves each department’s Annual Capacity Building Plan, under a Public Human Resources Council chaired by the Prime Minister.
  3. Lateral entry: Recruits domain experts at Joint Secretary and Director levels; first notified in June 2018, and a 2024 notification was withdrawn.

Matching Previous Year Question

“[2016, GS4, 10 marks] Discuss the Public Services Code as recommended by the 2nd Administrative Reforms Commission.”

Click here to Download X-Factor Notes for FREE. Cover the entire Microthemes with PYQs.

Download free X-Factor Notes
Revised and updated X-Factor Notes for UPSC Mains 2026: nine subject booklets