Why in the News
The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 protects personal data but carries no specific exemption for journalism, and news publishers say this gap threatens press freedom. The Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA), representing 21 publishers, has asked the Supreme Court for an interim stay on the Act’s provisions. The case tests how the law balances the Right to Privacy against the public’s right to know.
Why are publishers challenging the data protection law?
- What it is: The Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act governs how digital personal data is collected and used, and rests largely on the consent of the person concerned. It works like having to ask someone’s permission before using their photograph.
- Publishers’ objections: The DNPA’s petition, filed on October 6, argues that the Act could:
- impede investigative journalism;
- expose confidential sources;
- force the removal of published reports;
- deter whistleblowers.
- “Pre-censorship” warning: The DNPA’s counsel argued that requiring consent from the people reported on would create “a complete regime of pre-censorship”, meaning control over a story before it is published.
- The takeaway: Reporting on a person means handling their data, so without a carve out the people reported on could decide what is published.
How have Indian courts balanced privacy and press freedom?
- Two rights in tension: Article 19(1)(a) protects the press’s freedom to investigate. The Right to Privacy is a Fundamental Right under Article 21, recognised in the K.S. Puttaswamy judgment (2017).
- Official acts are not private: In R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu (1994), the ‘Auto Shankar case’, the Court held that an official cannot claim privacy over official acts.
- No prior restraint: The same ruling barred the State from imposing prior restraint (a ban before publication) on privacy grounds.
- Postponement orders: Sahara India Real Estate Corp. v. SEBI (2012) let courts briefly postpone reporting where publicity poses a real and substantial risk to a fair trial.
- No media trial: Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2010) cautioned against coverage that turns an accused into a convict in public opinion before the verdict.
Can journalists use sting operations to expose misconduct?
- Sting upheld: In R.K. Anand v. Registrar, Delhi High Court (2009), the Supreme Court upheld a sting operation (secret recording to catch wrongdoing) exposing an attempt to suborn (improperly influence) a witness in the BMW trial.
- No blanket immunity: In Rajat Prasad v. CBI (2014), the Court held that a sting’s public interest value gives no immunity for unlawful acts committed during it.
- Liability on evidence: Courts judge each accused person’s intent and role on evidence, so public interest alone does not cancel criminal liability.
How do other countries protect journalism alongside privacy?
- International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: Articles 17 and 19 protect privacy and free expression together.
- European Convention on Human Rights: Articles 8 and 10 likewise protect both rights side by side.
- Axel Springer AG v. Germany (2012): The European Court of Human Rights Grand Chamber ruled, 12-5, that curbs on a newspaper’s report of an actor’s cocaine arrest violated free expression. It treated the press as a public watchdog.
- United States: The First Amendment protects press freedom, and the Privacy Protection Act, 1980 restricts searches of journalists’ unpublished work, subject to exceptions.
- Journalistic exemptions in data laws: Several data laws exempt journalism:
- the U.K.’s Data Protection Act, 2018, where publication is reasonably believed to serve the public interest;
- Brazil’s General Data Protection Law, for journalistic processing;
- Section 52 of Kenya’s Data Protection Act, 2019, conditionally.
Challenges
- Consent as a veto: A consent rule lets the subject of a report decide whether it is written, reversing the watchdog role of the press.
- Uncertain public interest line: Courts weigh public interest case by case, so newsrooms cannot know in advance where private life begins.
- Privacy harm from media excess: An unconditional exemption could let coverage expose private lives or prejudge accused persons.
Way Forward
- Conditional exemption: Parliament should add a journalism exemption tied to a public interest test, on the lines of the U.K. and Kenyan laws.
- Retained safeguards: Courts’ power to postpone reporting and the criminal law on stings should stay intact.
- Source protection: The law should shield confidential sources and unpublished material from compelled disclosure.
Conclusion
The DPDP Act leaves open whether journalism deserves special treatment, and the Supreme Court must now settle it. Whether the Court grants an interim stay at its next hearing will decide how far consent rules reach into newsrooms.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2024] Under which of the following Articles of the Constitution of India, has the Supreme Court of India placed the Right to Privacy? (a) Article 15 (b) Article 16 (c) Article 19 (d) Article 21* ANSWER: (d)”