Why in the News
India has, for the first time at a climate conference, argued that sharing transboundary waters cannot rest on “archaic mechanisms” or be divorced from the wider relationship between countries. The Union Environment Minister said this in India’s national statement at the 31st Conference of the Parties (COP31) in Antalya, Turkiye, answering Pakistan’s Prime Minister without naming the Indus Waters Treaty, 1960.
What did India say, and what was it answering?
- Changed conditions: India said cooperation on transboundary flows can bring shared prosperity, but climatic and demographic changes and technological advancements cannot be ignored.
- Cooperation tied to relations: Such cooperation cannot be delinked from the overall relationship of the countries involved, echoing the Prime Minister’s line that “blood and water cannot flow together”.
- Pakistan’s charge: Pakistan’s Prime Minister told COP31 that “water must never be weaponised”. He said water sharing agreements must be honoured in letter and spirit.
Where does the Indus Waters Treaty stand now?
- Abeyance: The Pahalgam terror attack last year killed 26 tourists. India then put the Treaty “in abeyance”, meaning suspended, until Pakistan abjures cross-border terrorism.
- Practical effect: India no longer considers itself bound by the Treaty. It has pushed ahead with Indus basin projects without addressing Pakistan’s objections.
- Pakistan’s protest: Pakistan depends heavily on these rivers and protests at every forum. Flows from India remain largely unchanged.
- Court of Arbitration: Pakistan won a verdict in its favour from the Court of Arbitration. India did not take part, since it does not recognise how the Court was constituted.
- The takeaway: By suspending the Treaty, India has made water sharing depend on Pakistan’s conduct on terrorism, and has now carried that position to a climate forum.
Can the Treaty be renegotiated?
- India’s offer: India has offered to renegotiate, citing demographic and developmental pressure on water demand, new technology and climate change. Pakistan has not responded.
- Upcoming visit: Pakistan’s Minister for Climate Change and Environmental Coordination is due in New Delhi for the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue Forum.
- Mixed signals: The minister earlier threatened to “cut off the hands” that tried to control Pakistan’s waters, but says his visit has no bilateral agenda.
What climate equity positions did India set out?
- Paris obligations: Developed countries’ failure to meet Paris Agreement obligations must not shift unjustified burdens onto developing countries.
- Historical responsibility: Some countries grew on two centuries of unbridled greenhouse gas emissions, so making the Global South bear the cost is unjustified.
- Right to development: Developing countries cannot be made to choose between climate action and decent living standards, health and education.
- Carbon budget: Equitable access to the remaining carbon budget, the carbon dioxide the world can still emit within a warming limit, is “non-negotiable”. Developed countries must also meet their climate finance obligations.
- Developed India by 2047: India becoming developed by 2047 will also benefit other developing countries.
Challenges
- No exit clause: Article XII of the Treaty permits termination only through a ratified treaty between both governments, and the text has no suspension provision.
- Unbuilt storage: India’s permitted storage on the Western Rivers is largely unbuilt, so it cannot physically hold back water.
- One-sided record: Boycotting the Court of Arbitration leaves it deciding on Pakistan’s evidence alone.
- Lower riparian exposure: An upstream State setting aside a water treaty sets a precedent usable against India on rivers rising in Tibet.
Way Forward
- Formal renegotiation track: Pursue modification through notices under Article XII(3), with a defined agenda on demand, technology and climate.
- Build permitted capacity: Complete storage and run-of-the-river projects on the Western Rivers so India’s position has physical backing.
- Climate evidence base: Commission basin studies of glacier-fed flows to show how climate change altered the Treaty’s assumptions.
Conclusion
India now argues that water sharing must follow the state of the relationship, while Pakistan holds that a signed treaty binds regardless. With the renegotiation offer unanswered, the Pakistani minister’s New Delhi visit is the next point to watch.
Back2Basics: Indus Waters Treaty
- Origin: The World Bank brokered the Treaty, which has survived three India-Pakistan wars.
- River division: The Treaty governs six transboundary rivers. The Eastern Rivers (Ravi, Beas, Sutlej) went to India. The Western Rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab) went to Pakistan.
- India’s rights on Western Rivers: India may build run-of-the-river hydropower projects, provided the diverted water returns to the same river system.
- Dispute ladder: Questions go to the Permanent Indus Commission, technical differences to a Neutral Expert, legal disputes to a Court of Arbitration.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2016, GS1, 12 marks] Present an account of the Indus Water Treaty and examine its ecological, economic and political implications in the context of changing bilateral relations.”