💥UPSC 2026, 2027, 2028 UAP Mentorship (March Batch) + Access XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to mentor

Civilsdaily

Search results for: “”

  • Among Ministries, Home Affairs ‘dropped’ most assurances

    Why in the News?

    Since 2014, the Ministry of Home Affairs made 421 assurances in the Lok Sabha and 338 in the Rajya Sabha. However, it dropped about 15% of the assurances in the Lok Sabha and 12% in the Rajya Sabha, which is the highest among all the ministries in both houses.

    What is an ‘Assurance’ in the parliamentary process, and how is it tracked?

    • An assurance in the parliamentary process is a commitment made by a Ministry or the executive during a parliamentary session, where the government undertakes to take further action or report back on a matter raised by a Member of Parliament (MP). Example: If an MP asks about the status of a government project, and the Minister promises to provide an update or take further action, that promise becomes an assurance.
    • Tracking of Assurances: Assurances are tracked by the Ministry of Parliamentary Affairs using the Online Assurance Monitoring System (OAMS). The system keeps records of whether assurances are fulfilled, pending, or dropped. If an assurance is not fulfilled within three months, the Ministry must apply for an extension or request that it be dropped.Example: A query about the status of the Adani ports, raised by Congress MP B. Manickam Tagore in 2023, resulted in an assurance, but as of 2024, the assurance remains pending.

    Why has the Ministry of Home Affairs dropped the highest number of assurances in Parliament?

    • Lack of Follow-up on Critical Issues: The Ministry often fails to follow through on assurances related to significant national security issues, leading to unfulfilled promises. For example, a question on the state-wise number of terrorist attacks and the number of terrorists arrested and killed, raised by former MP Sirajuddin Ajmal in 2014, was left unanswered, and the assurance was dropped.
    • Delayed Response to Investigative Matters: The Ministry often fails to follow up on assurances related to complex investigations. An example is the question raised by MP Asaduddin Owaisi in 2014 regarding ‘out of turn promotions’ and ‘gallantry awards’ given to policemen involved in fake encounters, which remained unanswered and was eventually dropped.
    • Inability to Fulfill Commitments on Security Incidents: The Ministry has been slow in responding to assurances related to major security incidents. For instance, questions raised by MP Manish Tiwari in 2019 and 2020 regarding the Pulwama terror attack investigation were not fully addressed, resulting in these assurances being dropped.

    Which ministries have the most pending and dropped assurances in the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha?

    • Ministry of Home Affairs: The Ministry of Home Affairs has the highest number of dropped assurances across both the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha. For example, questions regarding terrorist attacks and the status of security-related investigations, like the one raised by former MP Sirajuddin Ajmal about terrorist attacks, have not been answered, leading to the dropping of the assurance.
    • Other Ministries with High Numbers: Besides the Home Ministry, other ministries like Finance, Law and Justice, Road Transport and Highways, and Railways also feature among the top ministries with the most dropped assurances. For example, the assurance related to the investigation of the Adani Group, raised by MP Mahua Moitra in 2021, was dropped by the Finance Ministry despite the promise of further details on foreign investments and SEBI’s inquiry.

    How does the Online Assurance Monitoring System (OAMS) help in tracking government assurances?

    • Tracking and Monitoring: The Online Assurance Monitoring System (OAMS) allows for real-time tracking of assurances made by the government in Parliament. It records and publishes the status of each assurance, ensuring that the government is held accountable for its commitments. For example, the OAMS portal shows that nearly 65% of the assurances made in 2024 in the Lok Sabha were still pending as of March 24, 2024.
    • Transparency and Accountability: OAMS provides transparency by making the status of all assurances accessible to the public. This helps track whether ministries are fulfilling their promises in a timely manner or whether they request extensions. For example, it highlighted the pending status of the assurance regarding the Adani Group’s ports, made in 2023, which has still not been addressed.

    What are some notable examples of assurances that remain pending or were dropped between 2014 and 2024?

    • Adani Group Ports Assurance: In 2023, Congress MP B. Manickam Tagore asked about the status of government-constructed ports and the volume of trade at Adani-owned ports compared to state-owned ventures. The assurance given in response to this question remains pending as of 2024.
    • Investigation into the Adani Group: In 2021, MP Mahua Moitra raised the issue of investigating the Adani Group and foreign portfolio investors owning stakes in the company. The Finance Ministry provided some details but later dropped the assurance, leaving the matter unresolved.
    • Pulwama Terror Attack Assurances: Congress MP Manish Tiwari raised questions about the Pulwama terror attack in 2019 and 2020, but the Ministry of Home Affairs dropped the assurances related to those questions, leaving the issues without a formal follow-up.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthening Follow-Up Mechanisms: To improve accountability, there should be a more robust system for tracking and following up on assurances. Ministries should be mandated to provide periodic updates, and a dedicated parliamentary committee could be formed to ensure timely resolution.
    • Enforcing Deadlines for Assurance Fulfillment: The government should consider setting stricter deadlines for fulfilling assurances, with consequences for non-fulfillment.

    Mains PYQ:

    Question: “Winning of ‘Hearts and Minds’ in terrorism-affected areas is an essential step in restoring the trust of the population. Discuss the measures adopted by the Government in this respect as part of the conflict resolution in Jammu and Kashmir.” [UPSC 2024]

    Linkage: Counter-terrorism efforts and the situation in Jammu and Kashmir, both significant areas of responsibility for the MHA. In response to such a question, the MHA might give assurances about specific measures being taken, data on their impact, or future plans.

  • Delimitation: Thinking beyond Population Count

    Why in the News?

    The discussion on delimitation and financial distribution has caused worries in Parliament and State Assemblies, as it could affect India’s federal system, especially with the upcoming end of the freeze on parliamentary seats.

    What are the key concerns in delimitation and financial devolution?

    • Impact on Federalism: The redistribution of seats may reduce representation for some states, especially those with better demographic management, affecting their political influence. Example: Southern states like Tamil Nadu and Kerala may lose seats relative to northern states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar.
    • Population vs. Representation Imbalance: States with high population growth could gain more seats, while those that controlled their population may be underrepresented. Example: The 2026 delimitation may increase seats in northern states, reducing the share of states like Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh.
    • Financial Allocation Disparity: The shift from the 1971 population base to the 2011 census for financial devolution may disadvantage states that effectively controlled population growth. Example: The 15th Finance Commission’s formula increased the weight of population (from 0.15 to 0.27), benefiting larger states like Uttar Pradesh.
    • Challenges of Caste and Gender-Based Reservations: Any redistribution must ensure that marginalized communities continue to receive fair representation despite demographic changes. Example: The Women’s Reservation Bill and SC/ST reserved seats need careful adjustments post-delimitation to maintain proportional representation.

    Why are peninsular States anxious about delimitation?

    • Reduction in Lok Sabha Seats: States like Tamil Nadu, Kerala, and Karnataka have controlled population growth, whereas states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar have higher birth rates.Example, If seats are redistributed based on 2026 population projections, peninsular states may lose seats while northern states gain more representation.
    • Unfair Distribution of Financial Resources: The 15th Finance Commission shifted to using the 2011 Census for fund allocation, benefiting high-population states. Example: Tamil Nadu and Kerala, despite better governance, receive fewer funds compared to Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, which have weaker social indicators.
    • Penalty for Development Success: Southern states invested in education, healthcare, and family planning, successfully controlling their population. Example: Kerala’s high literacy rate and Tamil Nadu’s low fertility rate may lead to fewer seats, reducing their voice in national decision-making.

    How did the 15th Finance Commission adjust population weightage?

    • Shift from 1971 to 2011 Census Data: The 15th Finance Commission replaced the 1971 Census with the 2011 Census for financial devolution, increasing the weightage of states with larger populations. Example: Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, with high population growth, received a greater share of central funds.
    • Incorporation of Demographic Performance: To balance the impact on states with controlled population growth, the commission introduced a demographic performance criterion. Example: Kerala and Tamil Nadu, which successfully reduced fertility rates, were given some weightage to offset their lower population share.
    • Increased Weightage for Population Component: The weightage for population in financial devolution increased from 15% (in previous commissions) to 27% under the 15th Finance Commission. Example: Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan, with high population growth, benefited more from this adjustment.

    What is the role of demographic performance in allocation and representation?

    • Balancing Population Growth with Development: Demographic performance considers not just population size, but how well a state has managed population growth, improving socio-economic indicators like fertility rates and life expectancy.
      • Example: Kerala, which has a low birth rate due to effective family planning policies, might not see a drastic population increase but still deserves fair representation based on its demographic success.
    • Addressing Disparities in Development: States with high population growth but poor demographic performance (e.g., high fertility rates, poor health outcomes) may receive less weight in allocation to balance out the disparity with better-performing states.
      • Example: Bihar and Uttar Pradesh, which have high population growth but relatively poor health and education indicators, may see their representation balanced with the inclusion of demographic performance factors.
    • Promoting Equity in Resource Allocation: Demographic performance allows for a more equitable distribution of resources by considering how well states manage their population and its needs. This ensures that states with better demographic indicators, like lower infant mortality or higher literacy rates, are not unfairly penalized in devolution and allocation.
      • Example: Tamil Nadu, which has effectively reduced its population growth while improving key development metrics, should be rewarded with adequate representation despite its smaller population size compared to more populous states like Madhya Pradesh.

    Which alternatives to absolute population can guide representation? (Way forward)

    • Population Density-Based Representation: Instead of using absolute population, population density (people per square kilometer) can be a guiding factor to ensure fair representation. Example: The Northeastern states (e.g., Arunachal Pradesh, Nagaland) have smaller populations but are allocated seats based on geographical and density considerations.
    • Demographic Performance as a Criterion: States that have successfully controlled population growth should not be penalized; demographic performance (such as fertility rates and health indicators) can be factored in. Example: Tamil Nadu and Kerala, which have lower fertility rates, could be granted additional weightage to compensate for their lower population growth.

    Mains PYQ:

    Question: What is the basis of regionalism? Is it that unequal distribu- tion of benefits of development on regional basis eventually promotes regionalism? [UPSC 2016]

    Linkage: Focusing solely on national population figures might mask significant regional disparities that need to be addressed through differentiated policies and resource allocation.

  • Mahabodhi Temple, Gaya 

    Why in the News?

    Since February 2025, Buddhists across India have been protesting, demanding the repeal of the Bodh Gaya Temple Act (BTA), 1949.

    Mahabodhi Temple, Gaya 

    Controversy surrounding the Bodh Gaya Temple Act (BTA), 1949:

    • The BTA was enacted after disputes between the Hindu and Buddhist communities regarding control of the temple.
    • Prior to this, the temple was under Hindu control, especially after the Mughal Empire in 1590 and following the Pala decline.
    • The BTA created an 8-member management committee for the temple with equal representation from Hindus and Buddhists.
    • However, the District Magistrate (usually from the Hindu community) was the ex-officio chairperson, giving Hindus a majority.
    • This has been a point of contention for the Buddhist community, leading to calls for reform.
    • The Supreme Court petition filed by monks in 2012 is yet to be heard, further fuelling their cause.

    About the Mahabodhi Temple:

    Details
    About
    • Bodh Gaya, Bihar, 96 km from Patna, 15 km from Gaya
    • The temple marks the spot where Gautama Buddha attained enlightenment under the Bodhi Tree in 531 BCE.
    • Designated in 2002 for its religious, historical, and architectural importance.
    Architectural Features
    • Early example of brick architecture.
    • Features two large shikhara towers, tallest being 55 meters high.
    • Houses Vajrasana (Seat of Enlightenment).
    • Sculptural reliefs depicting scenes from Buddha’s life.
    Sacred Sites within the Temple Complex
    • Bodhi Tree (descendant of original tree planted by Buddha)
    • Animeshlochan Chaitya (Second Week of Buddha’s meditation)
    • Ratnachakrama (Third Week of Buddha’s meditation)
    • Ratnaghar Chaitya (Fourth Week)
    • Ajapala Nigrodh Tree (Fifth Week)
    • Lotus Pond (Sixth Week)
    • Rajyatana Tree (Seventh Week)
    Historical Timeline
    • First temple built by Emperor Ashoka in 3rd century BCE.
    • Current structure from 6th century CE with restorations during Pala period.
    • Hiuen Tsang visited in 629 AD.
    Key Features and Preservation
    • Built with brick and stucco.
    • Large Buddha statue in meditative posture.
    • Stone railings relocated to nearby museum.
    • Actively preserved and restored as a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

     

    [UPSC 2023] In which one of the following regions was Dhanyakataka, which flourished as a prominent Buddhist centre under the Mahasanghikas, located?

    (a) Andhra (b) Gandhara (c) Kalinga (d) Magadha

     

  • Why the Parker Solar Probe is trying to ‘touch’ the Sun?

    Why in the News?

    The Parker Solar Probe made history on December 24, 2024, by coming within 6.1 million kilometers of the Sun’s surface, marking the closest approach ever by a spacecraft.

    Why the Parker Solar Probe is trying to ‘touch’ the Sun?

    About Parker Solar Probe

    • The Parker Solar Probe, launched in August 2018, is a car-sized robotic spacecraft named after Eugene Newman Parker, an American solar astrophysicist.
    • It is the first NASA mission named after a living researcher, and its mission is humanity’s first to explore within 3.8 million miles of the Sun’s corona.
    • The spacecraft is equipped with an advanced carbon-composite heat shield capable of withstanding temperatures up to 1,370°C.
    • This shield, which weighs only 73 kg, is designed to protect the probe from the Sun’s intense heat.
      • The probe’s instruments remain at a manageable 29°C due to the shield’s protection.
    • The primary goals are:
      • Approach the Sun: The probe aims to get as close as 6.5 million kilometers to study the Sun’s energy flow, solar corona heating, and the sources of solar wind.
      • Explore Solar Wind: Investigate the origins and behaviour of solar wind, the high-speed streams of charged particles that impact space weather.
      • Study Solar Corona: Delve into the mystery of why the Sun’s corona is 200 times hotter than its surface.
      • Investigate Plasma and Magnetic Fields: Study the structure and dynamics of plasma and magnetic fields at the sources of solar wind.
    • The Parker Solar Probe is equipped with four primary instruments:
      • FIELDS: Measures the electric and magnetic fields of the Sun’s atmosphere.
      • ISoIS: Observes energetic particles that lead to solar storms.
      • SWEAP: Records the properties of solar wind particles.
      • WISPR: Takes images of the solar corona.
      • Faraday Cup: Measures ion and electron density in the solar wind.

    Impact of the Mission on Solar Science

    • Understanding Solar Wind: The mission provides crucial data on the origins and behavior of solar wind, enhancing predictions of space weather and its impact on Earth.
    • Solving the Solar Corona Mystery: The probe’s findings suggest that Alfvén waves, plasma oscillations, may be the key mechanism responsible for the heating of the Sun’s corona, addressing a long-standing puzzle in solar physics.
    • New Discoveries on Space Dust: The probe’s discovery of dust-free pockets near the Sun challenges previous assumptions about the interaction of space dust with solar energy, offering new insights into solar dynamics.
    • Space Weather and Solar Flares: By monitoring the Sun’s activity, the probe aids in understanding solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs), helping to mitigate the effects of space weather on Earth’s satellites and infrastructure.
    • Advancement in Solar Exploration Technology: The mission’s success in utilizing advanced heat shields and high-speed space travel techniques paves the way for future solar missions and deeper exploration of stellar physics.
    [UPSC 2022] If a major solar storm (solar flare) reaches the Earth, which of the following are the possible effects on the Earth?

    1.        GPS and navigation systems could fail.

    2.        Tsunamis could occur at equatorial regions.

    3.        Power grids could be damaged.

    4.        Intense auroras could occur over much of the Earth.

    5.        Forest fires could take place over much of the planet.

    6.        Orbits of the satellites could be disturbed.

    7.        Shortwave radio communication of the aircraft flying over polar regions could be interrupted.

    Select the correct answer using the code given below:

    (a) 1, 2, 4 and 5 only

    (b) 2, 3, 5, 6 and 7 only

    (c) 1, 3, 4, 6 and 7 only

    (d) 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7

     

  • Sarhul Festival Celebrations in Jharkhand

    Why in the News?

    On April 1, 2025, tribals in Jharkhand and the larger Chhotanagpur region will celebrate Sarhul, marking both the New Year and the arrival of spring.

    About Sarhul Festival

    • Sarhul is a significant Adivasi festival celebrated in Jharkhand and the Chhotanagpur region, covering parts of Chhattisgarh, Odisha, and Bihar.
    • It is celebrated in the Hindu month of Chaitra, typically three days after the appearance of the new moon.
      • It marks the new year and celebrates the arrival of spring.
    • It is celebrated by various tribes, including Oraon, Munda, Santal, Khadia, and Ho, each with its own unique customs.
    • The Sal tree (Shorea robusta) is venerated as the abode of Sarna Maa, the deity who protects the village from natural calamities and misfortunes.
    • The festival symbolizes the union of the Sun and Earth.
      • The pahan (male priest) represents the Sun, while his wife, the pahen, symbolizes the Earth. This union is essential for sustaining life, emphasizing the connection between sunlight and soil.
    • It also marks the renewal of life.
    • After the rituals, Adivasis begin ploughing their fields, sowing crops, or gathering produce from the forest.

    Cultural Significance of Sarhul

    • Sarhul evolved from a hunting festival to one that celebrates agriculture, reflecting the changing lifestyle of the Adivasi communities.
    • Sarhul is a cultural movement to preserve Adivasi heritage amidst urbanization and modernization, helping reinforce tribal identity.
    • Over time, Sarhul has become a platform for Adivasi political assertion, with some groups using the festival to demand the recognition of Sarna religion and its inclusion in India’s caste census.
    • Sarhul has also become a means for advocating tribal rights and social justice, particularly through the leadership of Baba Karthik Oraon.
    [UPSC 2018] Consider the following pairs: Tradition State

    1. Chapchar Kut festival — Mizoram

    2. Khongjom Parba ballad — Manipur

    3. Thong-To dance — Sikkim

    Which of the pairs given above is/are correct?

    (a) 1 only (b) 1 and 2 (c) 3 only (d) 2 and 3

     

  • Over 1,000 species of Fungi threatened with extinction: IUCN

    Why in the News?

    The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Red List now includes 1,300 fungi species, of which 1000 species are at risk of extinction due to various environmental pressures.

    Important Species under Threat:

    • Fibrous Waxcap (Hygrocybe intermedia): A Vulnerable species of fungi found in Europe, facing threats from habitat loss and land-use changes.
    • 279 Species at Risk: Threatened by deforestation, agricultural expansion, and urban development, leading to habitat loss.
    • 91 Species Threatened by Pollution: Nitrogen and ammonia runoff from fertilizers and industrial activities.
    • 50+ Species at Risk Due to Fire Patterns: Changes in fire cycles, especially in USA, making certain fungi species vulnerable in forest ecosystems.

    About Fungi:

    • Fungi belong to the kingdom Fungi, distinct from animals, plants, and bacteria. They are eukaryotic organisms and include moulds, yeasts, mushrooms, and mildews.
    • Key Properties:
      • Fungi have chitin in their cell walls and form hyphae that create a mycelium network.
      • They are heterotrophic, absorbing nutrients from organic material.
      • They reproduce sexually and asexually through spores.
    • Types of Fungi:
      • Molds: Multicellular, fuzzy fungi.
      • Yeasts: Unicellular fungi used in fermentation.
      • Mushrooms: Fruiting bodies of certain fungi, often edible.
    • Ecological Role: Fungi are crucial in decomposition and nutrient cycling. Some form beneficial relationships with plants (mycorrhizae) to aid in nutrient absorption.
    • Uses:
      • Medicines: Fungi like penicillin have revolutionized medicine.
      • Food: Edible fungi include mushrooms and truffles.
      • Beverages: Yeasts are key in bread, beer, and wine production.
    [UPSC 2021] Which of the following have species that can establish symbiotic relationship with other organisms?​

    1. Cnidarians​

    2. Fungi ​

    3. Protozoa​

    Select the correct answer using the code given below:

    (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3

     

  • Summit Diplomacy: India’s Global Spotlight or a Diplomatic Gamble?

    When Donald Trump and Kim Jong-un met in Singapore in 2018, the world watched with bated breath. The historic summit promised a breakthrough in U.S.-North Korea relations, with bold commitments and glowing headlines. But within months, the promises fizzled, tensions resurfaced, and the grand spectacle turned into yet another footnote in diplomatic history.

    India, too, has had its fair share of high-profile summits—Howdy Modi with Trump, informal Wuhan talks with Xi Jinping, and back-to-back G20 and SCO leadership engagements. These meetings have shaped India’s foreign policy, opening doors to trade deals, strategic alliances, and global influence. But the big question remains: Are these summits truly driving India’s global rise, or are they just diplomatic theatre without lasting substance? Is India building a strong institutional framework to sustain its global momentum, or is it overly dependent on the personal rapport of its leaders?

    Summit Diplomacy and India: A Critical Analysis

    Summit diplomacy has played a pivotal role in India’s foreign policy, helping the country forge strategic partnerships, manage conflicts, and enhance global influence. However, it also presents challenges, including over-reliance on high-profile engagements and the risk of superficial agreements.

    Benefits for India

    BenefitImpact on IndiaExamples
    Strengthened Bilateral and Multilateral RelationsIndia has expanded its global reach by engaging directly with world leaders.Example: India’s engagement with the U.S. through the ‘Howdy Modi’ (2019) and State visits has strengthened the Indo-U.S. strategic partnership.
    Economic and Trade AgreementsSummits have helped India secure FDI, technology transfers, and trade deals.Example: India signed the India-UAE Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (2022) during a summit meeting, boosting trade relations.
    Strategic and Security PartnershipsSummit diplomacy has played a role in strengthening defense ties, intelligence sharing, and maritime cooperation.Example: India-France defense summits led to the Rafale jet deal, enhancing India’s air defense capabilities.
    Crisis Management and Conflict ResolutionHigh-level engagements have helped defuse tensions and manage border disputes.Example: The Modi-Xi Jinping informal summits (Wuhan, 2018 & Mamallapuram, 2019) attempted to stabilize India-China relations despite ongoing border tensions.
    Boosting India’s Global LeadershipIndia has used summits to assert leadership on climate change, global health, and multilateral governance.Example: G20 Presidency (2023) allowed India to champion issues of the Global South, including sustainable development and digital transformation.

    Challenges and Limitations of Summit Diplomacy for India

    ChallengeImpact on IndiaExamples
    Risk of Superficial AgreementsMany summit-level agreements lack follow-up mechanisms, leading to limited implementation.Example: The India-China Wuhan and Mamallapuram summits failed to prevent the Galwan Valley clash (2020) despite earlier commitments to peace.
    Over-Reliance on Personal DiplomacyStrong leader-driven diplomacy can lead to policy fluctuations with changes in leadership.Example: India’s relations with Pakistan saw highs and lows under Modi and Nawaz Sharif (2015 Lahore visit) but later deteriorated after Pulwama (2019).
    Geopolitical Constraints and Strategic MistrustSummit diplomacy cannot resolve deep-rooted geopolitical tensions without institutional support.Example: Despite multiple summits with China, border tensions persist, highlighting the limits of informal diplomacy.
    Limited Impact on Multilateral NegotiationsWhile India actively participates in summits, its efforts are sometimes blocked by global power dynamics.Example: Despite summit engagements, India’s bid for a permanent UN Security Council seat remains unresolved.
    Symbolic vs. Substantive GainsSome summits focus more on optics than concrete outcomes, leading to skepticism about their effectiveness.Example: The BRICS Summits produce many declarations, but real economic cooperation remains limited.

    Institutionalization of Diplomatic Process

    Institutionalization of diplomatic processes strengthens foreign policy by making it more structured, accountable, and resilient. By embedding diplomacy within institutions, nations can reduce the risks of impulsive decision-making and ensure that international agreements lead to long-term peace and cooperation rather than just symbolic gestures. India has institutionalized in the following ways:

    AreaInstitutional MechanismImpact
    Foreign Policy FormulationMinistry of External Affairs (MEA) with specialized divisions (e.g., Economic Diplomacy, Multilateral Affairs)Ensures structured policy-making and coordination across global engagements.
    Strategic DiplomacyThink tanks like IDSA, ORF, RIS advising policymakersProvides research-backed inputs for foreign policy decisions.
    Economic & Trade DiplomacyBilateral Investment Treaties (BITs), Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreements (CEPAs), and FTA negotiationsInstitutionalizes trade partnerships beyond summit announcements.
    Multilateral EngagementsPermanent Missions at the UN, WTO, G20 Sherpa MechanismEnhances India’s global presence in decision-making forums.
    Defense & Security DiplomacyStrategic dialogues (e.g., 2+2 Dialogue with U.S., Japan), QUAD, IOR Defense CooperationStrengthens long-term security partnerships beyond leader-led summits.
    Diaspora & Cultural DiplomacyPravasi Bharatiya Divas, ICCR, Indian Council for Cultural RelationsInstitutionalized outreach to the Indian diaspora and cultural promotion.

    Where India Needs to Improve

    ChallengeGaps in InstitutionalizationNeeded Reforms
    Weak Follow-up MechanismsMany summit agreements lack dedicated task forces or review mechanisms for implementation.Establish inter-ministerial monitoring frameworks to track MoUs and agreements.
    Over-Reliance on Political LeadershipSummit diplomacy often depends on personal engagement of leaders rather than institutional processes.Strengthen bureaucratic decision-making and empower diplomats to sustain momentum.
    Bureaucratic Red Tape & Slow ExecutionComplex approvals and delays hinder the timely execution of trade and defense agreements.Streamline procedures through fast-track mechanisms in MEA and related ministries.
    Limited Global Leadership in Multilateral ForumsDespite participation, India’s leadership in UN reforms, climate change, and WTO negotiations remains reactive.Proactively shape global agendas rather than just responding to initiatives.
    Inadequate Public & Economic DiplomacyIndia’s economic diplomacy is less aggressive compared to China’s Belt & Road Initiative (BRI).Expand India’s global economic influence through better infrastructure investments and trade blocs.

    Conclusion

    While India has made significant progress in institutionalizing diplomacy, further improvements are needed in follow-up mechanisms, bureaucratic efficiency, and multilateral leadership. By enhancing institutional processes alongside summit diplomacy, India can ensure sustained global influence and strategic consistency beyond high-profile engagements.

    #BACK2BASICS: About Summit-Level Diplomacy

    Summit-level diplomacy refers to high-level meetings between heads of state or government, often conducted to address pressing global, regional, or bilateral issues. These summits serve as platforms for direct negotiation, policy coordination, and diplomatic engagement at the highest levels.

    Examples:

    • G20 Summit (Global economic coordination)
    • BRICS Summit (Emerging economies’ collaboration)
    • India-China Informal Summits (Bilateral strategic discussions)

    Five Critical Elements of Summit-Level Diplomacy

    1. High-Level Representation: Involves participation of presidents, prime ministers, or monarchs, ensuring authoritative decision-making.
      • Example: Modi-Biden Summit for Indo-US strategic ties.
    2. Agenda-Setting & Issue Prioritization: Focuses on key economic, security, environmental, or diplomatic concerns.
      • Example: COP Climate Summits prioritize global climate action.
    3. Negotiation & Consensus Building: Provides a space for direct, high-stakes negotiations that can lead to policy breakthroughs.
      • Example: Indo-Pakistan Agra Summit (2001) aimed at peace efforts despite eventual failure.
    4. Bilateral & Multilateral Engagements: Can be bilateral (between two nations) or multilateral (involving multiple countries or organizations).
      • Example: QUAD Summit (US, India, Japan, Australia) for Indo-Pacific security.
    5. Symbolism & Public Diplomacy: Signals diplomatic intent, boosts international image, and reassures domestic audiences.
      • Example: India’s participation in G7 Summits showcases its rising global influence.

    Summit diplomacy plays a crucial role in shaping international relations, resolving disputes, and forging strategic alliances.

    Difference Between Summit-Level Diplomacy and Pseudo Summit-Level Diplomacy

    FeatureSummit-Level DiplomacyPseudo Summit-Level Diplomacy
    DefinitionHigh-level meetings involving heads of state/government for direct diplomatic negotiations.Symbolic or staged meetings that lack substantive decision-making or long-term impact.
    Decision-Making AuthorityLeaders have real authority to negotiate and finalize agreements.Often pre-scripted with little room for genuine negotiation or policy shifts.
    Substance vs. SymbolismFocuses on concrete policy discussions, economic ties, or security cooperation.Primarily for media optics, diplomatic signaling, or domestic political gains.
    Impact on International RelationsLeads to binding agreements, treaties, or diplomatic breakthroughs.Rarely results in significant policy changes or legally binding commitments.
    Examples– India-US 2+2 Dialogue (Defense & foreign policy coordination)
    – Indo-Pak Lahore Summit (1999) (Peace-building effort)
    – G20 Summits (Global economic strategies)    		– Trump-Kim Jong-un Hanoi Summit (2019) (Failed negotiations, no agreements)
    – Indo-China Informal Summits (Wuhan, Mamallapuram) (No formal treaties, mostly optics)
    – SAARC Summits Post-2016 (Minimal progress due to regional tensions)

    Key Takeaway:

    While summit-level diplomacy results in substantive outcomes, pseudo summit-level diplomacy is often limited to symbolism, diplomatic signaling, or media spectacle, without tangible policy changes.

  • [31st March 2025] The Hindu Op-ed: The ‘3Cs’ that haunt Indian education today

    PYQ Relevance:

    Question: National Education Policy 2020 is in conformity with the Sustainable Development Goal-4 (2030). It intends to restructure and reorient education system in India. Critically examine the statement. [UPSC 2020]

    Linkage: Critical analysis of a major education policy, where aspects of centralisation, commercialisation, and the underlying ideological orientation (potentially related to communalisation, although not directly stated) could be part of the critique.

     

    Mentor’s Comment:  The National Education Policy (NEP) 2020 may seem important, but it hides the government’s lack of real effort to improve education for children and youth in India. Over the past ten years, the government has mainly focused on three things—taking more control over education, encouraging private schools and colleges while reducing public funding, and changing textbooks and courses to fit its own ideas.

    Today’s editorial discusses education policy and its impact, providing useful insights for GS Paper 2 in the UPSC Mains exam.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    The government’s three-point agenda is causing serious harm to the education system, affecting accessibility, quality, and fairness in learning opportunities.

    What is the three-point agenda of the government?

    • Centralisation of Power: The Union Government has taken control over education policy and decision-making, sidelining State governments.
    • Commercialisation & Outsourcing to the Private Sector: Government policies have led to the closure of public schools and increased dependence on expensive private education.
    • Communalisation of Curriculum & Institutions:  The Opposition has accused the government of modifying textbooks and appointing ideologically aligned individuals in academic institutions to promote a biased narrative.

    What are the key concerns regarding the centralization of education under NEP 2020?

    • Lack of State Consultation & Decision-Making: Despite education being in the Concurrent List, the Union Government has not consulted State governments on policy implementation. Example: The Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE), which includes State Education Ministers, has not been convened since 2019.
    • Financial Coercion to Implement Central Schemes: The Union Government uses financial control to push State governments into adopting centrally designed schemes. Example: Funds under Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA), meant for RTE implementation, were withheld to pressure States into adopting PM-SHRI model schools.
    • Undermining State Control Over Higher Education: The Union Government is reducing the role of State governments in governing their own universities. Example: The 2025 UGC guidelines remove State governments from the process of appointing Vice-Chancellors, giving power to Governors (as Chancellors) instead.
    • Shift from Neighborhood Schools to Centralized School Complexes: NEP 2020 promotes school complexes, which leads to the closure of small public schools, reducing accessibility for marginalized students. Example: Since 2014, 89,441 government schools have been shut down, while 42,944 private schools have been opened.
    • Increased Control Over Curriculum & Textbooks: The Union Government has made unilateral changes to the NCERT curriculum, promoting a selective historical and ideological narrative. Example: Mahatma Gandhi’s assassination details, Mughal history, and the Preamble to the Indian Constitution were removed from textbooks, later reinstated due to public backlash.

    How has the commercialisation of education impacted public schools and higher education institutions in India?

    • Closure of Public Schools & Growth of Private Schools: The shift towards school complexes under NEP 2020 has led to the closure of public schools, forcing students into expensive private education. Example: Since 2014, 89,441 public schools have been closed, while 42,944 private schools have opened, increasing educational inequality.
    • Higher Education Funding Shift to Loans Instead of Grants: The introduction of the Higher Education Financing Agency (HEFA) forces universities to take loans at market interest rates, instead of receiving government grants. Example: Universities now recover loan repayments from student fees, leading to fee hikes, making higher education less affordable.
    • Rise in Corruption & Lack of Accountability: Increased privatisation and outsourcing have led to corruption in regulatory bodies and lower academic standards. Example: The NAAC bribery scandal and failures of the National Testing Agency (NTA) have exposed financial misconduct and inefficiency in public education governance.

    What is the criticism of the Higher Education Financing Agency (HEFA)?

    • Shift from Grants to Loans Increases Financial Burden: HEFA replaces UGC’s block grants with market-rate loans, forcing universities to generate their own funds. Example: Universities struggle to repay loans, leading to higher student fees, making education less accessible to the economically weaker sections.
    • Universities Rely on Student Fees for Loan Repayments: Most universities lack revenue sources, so they increase student fees to repay loans. Example: The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Education found that between 78% to 100% of HEFA loans were repaid using student fees, worsening affordability.
    • Neglect of Public Education & Research: HEFA discourages public investment in higher education, prioritizing financial viability over quality education and research. Example: Many state universities, lacking resources, avoid infrastructure development or research expansion due to loan repayment concerns.

    Which specific changes in NCERT textbooks have been linked to the alleged communalisation of education?

    • Removal of Mughal History & Selective Erasure of Historical Facts: Chapters on Mughal India and references to their contributions in architecture, administration, and culture have been removed or reduced.Example: Class 12 history textbooks no longer include sections on Mughal rule, diminishing a key period of Indian history.
    • Omission of Mahatma Gandhi’s Assassination and Hindutva Ideology’s Role: References to Nathuram Godse and the RSS’s role in Gandhi’s assassination were removed, altering historical narratives. Example: Class 12 Political Science textbooks no longer mention how Hindu nationalist ideologies influenced Godse’s actions.
    • Exclusion of Constitutional Principles & Secularism: The Preamble of the Indian Constitution was initially removed, and sections on secularism and democracy have been diluted. Example: Class 10 political science textbooks saw removal of content discussing secularism as a foundational principle, sparking public backlash.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Federalism in Education Governance: Restore State consultation mechanisms like the Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE) to ensure inclusive decision-making.
    • Ensure Transparency & Academic Integrity in Curriculum Revisions: Establish an independent curriculum review committee with experts from diverse backgrounds to prevent ideological biases in textbooks.

  • An IJS is an idea whose time has come

    Why in the News?

    Social media has been flooded with memes, and one of the most popular ones says, “For the first time, a fire brigade has started more fires than it put out.” The truth is, the fire is still burning. This perfectly reflects the ongoing controversy surrounding the Delhi High Court judge and the half-burnt currency notes case.

    What key issues arise from the Delhi High Court Judge controversy over half-burnt currency notes?

    • Allegations of Corruption in the Judiciary: The discovery of half-burnt currency notes at a judge’s residence raises suspicions of financial misconduct and corruption within the judiciary. Example: The Justice P.D. Dinakaran case, where allegations of land grabbing and corruption led to his resignation before impeachment proceedings.
    • Lack of Immediate Legal Action and Accountability: Unlike other public officials who face direct investigations, the judge in question was merely repatriated to his parent High Court, reflecting a selective approach to judicial accountability. Example: Justice Soumitra Sen of Calcutta High Court was impeached for financial misconduct, but only after prolonged proceedings, highlighting delays in judicial accountability.
    • Opacity in Internal Inquiry Mechanisms: The judiciary relies on internal probes rather than independent investigations, raising concerns about transparency and impartiality in handling misconduct. Example: The former CJI Ranjan Gogoi sexual harassment case, where an internal Supreme Court panel cleared him without an external review, leading to public outcry.

    Why has the Collegium system of judicial appointments in India faced criticism over the years?

    • Lack of Transparency and Accountability: The Collegium functions through closed-door deliberations without publicly disclosing selection criteria or reasons for appointments and rejections. Example: In 2019, Justice Akil Kureshi’s elevation was delayed without a clear explanation, raising concerns over executive influence and opaque decision-making.
    • Nepotism and Judicial Dynasties: The system has been criticized for favoring judges’ relatives and individuals with strong connections rather than selecting candidates purely on merit. Example: The presence of multiple second-generation judges in the Supreme Court, such as Justice D.Y. Chandrachud (son of former CJI Y.V. Chandrachud), has fueled debates over judicial nepotism.
    • Lack of Diversity and Inclusivity: The Collegium system has led to an underrepresentation of marginalized communities, women, and candidates from diverse backgrounds in the higher judiciary. Example: As of 2024, the percentage of women judges in the Supreme Court remains significantly low, with only three out of 34 judges being women.

    How can the establishment of an Indian Judicial Service help address concerns regarding judicial accountability and transparency?

    • Merit-Based and Transparent Selection Process: The IJS would ensure that judges are selected through a competitive examination, reducing nepotism and favoritism in judicial appointments. Example: Similar to the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), where UPSC conducts open and merit-based recruitment, an IJS would create a level playing field for candidates from diverse backgrounds.
    • Greater Diversity and Inclusivity in the Judiciary: A national-level selection system would bring in candidates from different social, economic, and regional backgrounds, making the judiciary more representative. Example: Currently, women and marginalized communities are underrepresented in the higher judiciary, but an IJS could help bridge this gap by ensuring equal opportunities.
    • Stronger Oversight and Accountability Mechanisms: Judges recruited through IJS could be subjected to periodic performance reviews and disciplinary oversight, ensuring accountability and ethical conduct. Example: In Germany, judges are part of a structured civil service system with evaluation and accountability mechanisms, ensuring higher judicial standards.

    Who would be responsible for conducting the recruitment process for the Indian Judicial Service?

    • Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) as the Conducting Authority: The UPSC, which already handles merit-based recruitment for civil services like IAS and IPS, could be entrusted with conducting exams for IJS to ensure transparency and fairness. Example: The Judicial Services Examination at the state level is conducted by State Public Service Commissions; a national-level IJS could follow the same model under UPSC.
    • Supreme Court and High Courts for Selection Criteria and Oversight: The Supreme Court, in consultation with High Courts and legal experts, could frame eligibility criteria, syllabus, and selection methods to maintain judicial independence. Example: The All India Judicial Service (AIJS) proposal, discussed since the 1960s, suggested a recruitment system similar to UPSC but with judicial oversight to ensure fairness.
    • Independent Judicial Commission for Monitoring and Appointments: An autonomous body, comprising retired judges, legal scholars, and judicial officers, could be set up to oversee appointments and address grievances. Example: Judicial Appointments Commissions exist in the UK, where an independent body handles judicial recruitment, preventing executive or political interference.

    Way forward: 

    • Balanced Judicial Appointments with Greater Transparency: Establish a Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) that includes representatives from the judiciary, executive, and civil society to ensure a more transparent and accountable selection process.
    • Strengthening Judicial Accountability Mechanisms: Implement periodic performance reviews and ethical oversight for judges, with an independent body monitoring judicial conduct and financial integrity.

    Mains PYQ:

    Question: Critically examine the Supreme Court’s judgement on ‘National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014’ with reference to appointment of judges of higher judiciary in India. [UPSC 2017]

    Linkage: Existing mechanism for judicial appointments and the debates surrounding it. The discussion on an IJS often arises as an alternative or complementary approach to the current system, aiming for greater transparency and potentially reducing the scope for concerns raised in the NJAC debate.

     

  • Gender gap in household chores persists in urban India

    Why in the News?

    More urban women have paid jobs but still handle most household work. Though more men now help, the gender gap remains wide. Northeastern states see higher male participation in domestic works.

    What are the trends in urban women’s participation in paid jobs and household work?

    • Increase in Paid Employment but Still Low: The share of urban women engaged in paid work rose from 15.5% in 2019 to 18% in 2024. Example: In Tamil Nadu and Telangana, about 25% of urban women participate in paid work, significantly higher than Bihar (9%) and Uttar Pradesh (10%).
    • Unpaid Household Work Burden Remains High: Despite employment growth, the share of women doing unpaid household work increased from 79.3% to 81%. Example: In Karnataka and Himachal Pradesh, over 80% of employed women also do unpaid domestic chores, highlighting the dual burden.
    • More Men Helping, but Gender Gap Persists: The share of urban men doing unpaid domestic work rose from 23% to 28.5%, but women’s share remains disproportionately high. Example: In Kerala and Northeastern states (Sikkim, Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh), over 50% of urban men participate in household chores, while in most states, it remains between 20-40%.

    Why does the gender gap in household chores persist despite more men helping?

    • Deeply Rooted Social Norms and Gender Roles: Household work is still perceived as a woman’s responsibility, while men’s participation is seen as “helping” rather than sharing duties equally.
      Example: Even in urban households where women work full-time, they are expected to manage cooking, cleaning, and childcare, while men engage in minimal domestic tasks.
    • Unequal Time Distribution Between Paid and Unpaid Work: Women balance both employment and domestic responsibilities, whereas men often focus primarily on paid jobs. Example: In Karnataka and Himachal Pradesh, over 80% of employed women still do household chores, while men’s share remains significantly lower.
    • Limited Structural Support for Household Work: Lack of affordable childcare, elderly care services, and domestic help forces women to take on more unpaid work. Example: Countries like Sweden offer state-funded childcare and paternity leave, reducing the burden on women, whereas India lacks similar support systems.
    • Workplace Expectations and Rigid Work Hours: Men often work longer hours outside the home and face social stigma if they take time off for household chores. Example: In corporate India, men who seek flexible work hours for family responsibilities may face negative career perceptions, unlike in Nordic countries, where parental leave is encouraged for both genders.
    • State-Wise Cultural Differences in Gender Roles: Some states, particularly in Northeast India (Sikkim, Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh), have higher male participation in household chores due to more egalitarian traditions. Example: In Kerala, 44% of men contribute to domestic work, but in states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, men’s participation remains under 30% due to traditional patriarchal norms.

    Which Indian states have the most urban men doing unpaid household work?

    • Northeastern States Lead in Male Participation: Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh, and Nagaland have the highest share of urban men engaged in household chores, with over 50% participation. Example: In these states, matrilineal or more egalitarian traditions encourage men to take on domestic responsibilities, unlike in many other parts of India.
    • Kerala Tops Among Major States: Kerala has 44% of urban men involved in household work, the highest among major Indian states. Example: Kerala’s higher literacy rates, progressive gender norms, and a strong service sector contribute to greater male involvement in domestic chores compared to states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, where men’s participation remains below 30%.

    Why is female workforce participation higher in Tamil Nadu, Telangana, and Karnataka?

    • Strong Industrial and Service Sectors: These states have thriving industries like textiles, IT, and manufacturing, which offer more employment opportunities for women. Example: Tamil Nadu’s garment industry, Telangana’s pharmaceutical sector, and Karnataka’s IT and startup ecosystem employ a significant number of women.
    • Progressive Socio-Cultural Norms and Policies: Higher literacy rates, better education access, and state-driven welfare policies encourage female employment. Example: Tamil Nadu’s Cradle Baby Scheme and Telangana’s WE-Hub for women entrepreneurs promote women’s workforce participation.
    • Higher Urbanization and Better Infrastructure: Cities like Chennai, Hyderabad, and Bengaluru provide better public transport, safety measures, and childcare facilities, making it easier for women to work. Example: Karnataka’s free bus travel for women initiative improves women’s mobility, indirectly supporting their workforce participation.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthening Gender-Inclusive Policies: Implement affordable childcare, flexible work hours, and workplace safety measures to support women’s workforce participation.
    • Encouraging Equal Domestic Responsibility: Promote shared household duties through awareness campaigns, parental leave policies, and incentives for men to engage in unpaid domestic work.

    Mains PYQ:

    Question: Distinguish between gender equality, gender equity and women’s empowerment. Why is it important to take gender concerns into account in programme design and implementation? [UPSC 2024]

    Linkage: The gap between men and women in household work shows that equality at home is still missing, making it harder for women to be truly empowered.

  • India’s Coal Dependence rose to 79%

    Why in the News?

    According to MoSPI’s Energy Statistics in India 2025, coal contributed 79% to India’s total energy generation, amounting to 16,906 petajoules (PJ), marking a 2% increase from the previous year.

    Share of Coal in India’s Energy Basket:

    • Dominance: As of 2023-24, coal contributed 79% to India’s total energy generation, amounting to 16,906 petajoules (PJ), marking a 2% increase from the previous year.
    • Production Growth: In 2023-24, India saw a 12% increase in coal production, continuing a strong growth trajectory from the 15% growth in 2022-23, marking one of the fastest growth rates in the past decade.
    • Dependence on Imports: Despite a surge in domestic production, India remains 26% dependent on coal imports, although this has decreased from 31% in 2019-20.

    India’s Total Energy Basket:

    • Coal: Discussed above.
    • Nuclear Energy: Nuclear power contributes approximately 1.7% to the total electricity generation capacity, with an installed capacity of about 8,180 MW as of late 2024.
    • Crude Oil: The share of crude oil has decreased from 11% in 2014-15 to 6% in 2023-24, indicating a long-term decline in its contribution to India’s energy mix.
    • Natural Gas: Similarly, natural gas’s share has decreased from 9% in 2014-15 to 7% in 2023-24, reflecting a shift away from natural gas in the energy mix.
    • Renewable Energy: Despite significant investments and efforts by the government, renewable energy sources (solar, wind, hydro, and nuclear) contribute only 7% to the total energy mix in 2023-24, showing slow but steady growth over the past decade.

    Shift Towards Renewable Energy:

    • Total Contribution: Renewable sources contributed 7% of India’s total energy production in 2023-24, a modest increase from 6% in 2014-15. While this share remains small, the absolute production from renewables has grown at a 6.76% CAGR over the past 10 years.
    • Growth in Solar and Wind Energy:
      • The generation from solar, wind, and other renewable sources (excluding large hydro) has surged by 210% over the last decade, increasing from 6,555 KToE in FY15 to 20,279 KToE in FY24.
    • Key Renewable Energy Potential:
      • Wind energy holds the largest share of India’s renewable potential at 55.17%, with an estimated potential of 11,63,856 MW.
      • Solar energy is the second-largest contributor at 35.50%, with a potential of 7,48,990 MW.
      • Large hydro contributes 6.32% of the renewable energy potential with 1,33,410 MW.
    • Future Targets:
      • India added 3.4 GW of new wind capacity in 2024, with Gujarat (1,250 MW), Karnataka (1,135 MW), and Tamil Nadu (980 MW) leading the way.
      • India is aiming for 500 GW of non-fossil fuel-based energy capacity by 2030, which would significantly boost the share of renewables in the energy mix, reducing the reliance on coal and crude oil over the coming years.
    [UPSC 2020] Consider the following statements:

    1. Coal ash contains arsenic, lead and mercury.

    2. Coal-fired power plants release sulphur dioxide and oxides of nitrogen into the environment.

    3. High ash content is observed in Indian coal.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and

     

  • What are the Norms for Disclosure of Judges’ Assets?

    Why in the News?

    The discovery of large sums of cash at Delhi High Court judges’ residence has raised concerns about corruption in India’s judiciary and reignited the debate over the public disclosure of judges’ assets and liabilities.

    Current Stance on Judges’ Asset Disclosure

    • Supreme Court’s Historical Approach:
      • 1997 Resolution: The Supreme Court, under Chief Justice J.S. Verma, resolved that judges should disclose their assets to the Chief Justice of India (CJI), but this did not involve public disclosure.
      • 2009 Resolution: The full Bench of the Supreme Court agreed to publish judges’ asset declarations on the court’s website, though this was done voluntarily. However, the website has not been updated since 2018, and the assets of current judges are not publicly available.
      • 2019 Ruling: The Supreme Court ruled that judges’ personal assets and liabilities are not private information, making them subject to the Right to Information (RTI) Act.
    • High Court’s Position:
      • As of March 2024, only 13% of High Court judges have publicly disclosed their assets and liabilities. Many High Courts, including Uttarakhand and Allahabad, have opposed public disclosure and argued that such information is outside the scope of the RTI Act.
    • Resistance to Full Disclosure:
      • The Uttarakhand High Court (2012) passed a resolution opposing the disclosure of judges’ assets under the RTI Act. Similarly, many High Courts have rejected RTI applications seeking information about judges’ assets.

    Parliament’s Role – Proposed Reforms

    • Committee Recommendation (2023):
      • The Parliamentary Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, and Law and Justice recommended that legislation be introduced to make the disclosure of judges’ assets and liabilities mandatory for Supreme Court and High Court judges.
      • However, there has been no progress on implementing this recommendation as of now.
    • Need for Legislation:
      • Despite the RTI Act requiring public servants to disclose their assets, judges have largely remained exempt from such transparency.
      • Legislative action is seen as essential to ensure accountability and transparency within the judiciary, with several advocating for mandatory public disclosure similar to other public officials.
    [UPSC 2017] With reference to the appointment of the High Court Judges, consider the following statements:

    1. Chief Justice of India is consulted by the President in the appointment.

    2. Governor of the State is consulted by the Chief Justice of India in the appointment.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    (a) 1 only (b) 2 only (c) Both 1 and 2 (d) Neither 1 nor 2

    [UPSC 2021] An independent and empowered social audit mechanism is an absolute must in every sphere of public service, including judiciary, to ensure performance, accountability and ethical conduct. Elaborate.

     

  • Tribhuvandas Patel: the Father of Cooperative Movement

    Why in the News?

    The Lok Sabha recently passed a Bill to establish Tribhuvan Sahkari University in Anand, Gujarat, in honour of Tribhuvandas Kishibhai Patel, a visionary leader known as the “father of the cooperative movement” in India, particularly in dairy farming.

    Tribhuvandas Patel the Father of Cooperative Movement

    Who was Tribhuvandas Patel?

    • Patel was born in 1903 to Kishibhai Patel and Lakhiba in Anand, Gujarat. He was an alumnus of Gujarat Vidyapith and was deeply influenced by Mahatma Gandhi.
    • A dedicated freedom fighter, Patel participated in the civil disobedience movement, campaigns against untouchability, and the salt satyagraha.
    • He was jailed in 1930 for his participation in the Salt Movement.
    • He is widely recognized as the “father of the cooperative movement” in India, particularly for his transformative work in the dairy industry.

    Patel’s Contribution to the Cooperative Movement

    • In 1946, Patel founded the Kaira District Cooperative Milk Producers’ Union Limited (KDCMPUL), known later as Amul, to empower farmers and challenge the monopoly of the Polson Dairy in Anand, Gujarat.
    • Patel collaborated with Verghese Kurien, a mechanical engineer, to modernize the dairy plant and increase milk production. This collaboration eventually led to the White Revolution in India.
    • Patel was also instrumental in setting up the Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation (GCMMF), the National Dairy Development Board (NDDB), and the Institute of Rural Management Anand (IRMA), which played a pivotal role in cooperative dairy farming and rural development.
    • After his retirement, Patel used funds from the cooperative community to establish the Tribhuvandas Foundation, focused on community health and welfare.

    Cooperative Movement in India:

    • Pre-Independence Era:
      • The cooperative movement originated from informal local initiatives like Chit Funds and Mutual-Loan Associations in places like Madras Presidency and Punjab.
      • The 1904 Cooperative Credit Societies Act formally recognized cooperatives.
      • The Government of India Act, 1919 empowered provinces to legislate on cooperatives, leading to the Bombay Cooperative Society Act of 1925.
    • Post-Independence Developments:
      • Cooperatives became central to India’s economic strategies, particularly for rural development and social justice.
      • The National Cooperative Development Corporation (NCDC) (1963) and NABARD (1982) supported rural cooperatives and provided credit to farmers.
      • The 97th Constitutional Amendment (2011) granted the right to form cooperatives under Article 19.
      • The Ministry of Cooperation was formed in 2021 to strengthen the cooperative framework.
      • The MSCS Amendment Act 2023 aims to improve governance and operational efficiency of cooperatives.

    Key Types of Cooperatives in India:

    1. Consumers’ Cooperatives: Provide affordable goods by removing intermediaries (e.g., Kendriya Bhandar).
    2. Producers’ Cooperatives: Support small producers by supplying essential materials.
    3. Cooperative Marketing Societies: Help producers market products collectively (e.g., Amul).

     

    [UPSC 2011] In India, which of the following have the highest share in the disbursement of credit to agriculture and allied activities?

    (a) Commercial Banks (b) Cooperative Banks (c) Regional Rural Banks (d) Microfinance Institutions

     

  • Australia’s Economic Engagement with India: Key Insights

    Australia’s Confidence in India’s Economic Future

    Australia anticipates that India will become the world’s third-largest economy by 2030 and has identified key sectors as the “Superhighways of Growth” in its new roadmap for economic engagement.

    Key Sectors Driving Growth

    1. Clean Energy

    • Focus: Renewable energy and critical minerals to support India’s green transition.
    • Example: Australia, as the largest producer of lithium, supplies essential materials for India’s electric vehicle (EV) manufacturing.

    2. Education and Skills

    • Focus: Collaboration on skill development and higher education to equip India’s workforce.
    • Example: Australian universities have opened campuses in Gujarat’s GIFT City and are expanding to Noida, offering advanced training programs.

    3. Agribusiness and Tourism

    • Focus: Enhancing agricultural trade, food security, and fostering tourism.
    • Example: Australia’s advanced agritech supports India’s agricultural modernization, while increased tourism strengthens cultural ties.

    Why does Australia Consider Itself a Natural Partner for India’s Economic Growth?

    1. Complementary Economies

    • Australia provides critical resources India needs, while India supplies services that Australia requires.
    • Example: Australia supplies critical minerals (lithium, cobalt) essential for India’s EV manufacturing.

    2. Strategic Alignment

    • Both nations share regional and global strategic interests, including maritime security in the Indo-Pacific.
    • Example: Regular participation in Quad (with the U.S. and Japan) strengthens defense and economic cooperation.

    3. Geographic Proximity

    • Close ties across the Indian Ocean facilitate trade and collaboration.
    • Example: The Economic Cooperation and Trade Agreement (ECTA) has significantly boosted bilateral trade.

    4. Shared Democratic Values

    • Both countries uphold democracy, rule of law, and a rules-based international order, fostering trust.
    • Example: Australia supports India’s bid for a United Nations Security Council (UNSC) permanent seat.

    5. Strong People-to-People Ties

    • A growing Indian diaspora in Australia enhances cultural and economic collaboration.
    • Example: The Maitri grants program supports Indian diaspora-led initiatives for bilateral engagement.

    Impact of the Economic Cooperation and Trade Agreement (ECTA)

    1. Increased Bilateral Trade Volume

    • ECTA has accelerated trade growth by reducing tariffs and improving market access.
    • Example: India’s exports to Australia have grown by 66% in the past five years, nearly twice as fast as exports to other countries.

    2. Tariff Reductions and Market Access

    • ECTA eliminates/reduces custom duties on key products, making Indian and Australian goods more competitive.
    • Example: Australia removed tariffs on 96.4% of Indian exports, including textiles, jewelry, and pharmaceuticals.

    3. Boost to Key Sectors

    • Strengthens trade in minerals, energy, and education—areas where both countries have complementary strengths.
    • Example: Australia’s exports of lithium support India’s EV manufacturing.

    4. Enhanced Services Trade and Mobility

    • ECTA facilitates cooperation in education, IT, and professional services, enabling easier movement of skilled workers.
    • Example: Indian IT and engineering professionals benefit from streamlined visa processes in Australia.

    5. Foundation for a Comprehensive Agreement

    • ECTA lays the groundwork for a broader Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA).
    • Example: CECA negotiations aim to expand trade in technology, healthcare, and defense.

    Australia’s Support for India’s EV and Skill Development Ambitions

    1. Supplying Critical Minerals for EV Manufacturing

    • Australia is a key supplier of lithium, nickel, and cobalt for India’s EV transition.
    • Example: These resources support India’s goal of increasing EV adoption eightfold by 2030.

    2. Collaborating on Skill Development and Education

    • Australian universities provide technical education for India’s workforce.
    • Example: Campuses in GIFT City (Gujarat) and Noida (Uttar Pradesh) offer training in EV and clean energy sectors.

    3. Investing in Training and Workforce Mobility

    • Australia invests in vocational training and enhances workforce mobility.
    • Example: The Maitri grants program supports technical training to help skill 2 crore Indian workers annually.

    Way Forward

    1. Strengthening Critical Supply Chains

    • Establish long-term supply agreements and joint ventures to boost India’s EV and renewable energy ambitions.

    2. Expanding Education and Workforce Partnerships

    • Enhance mutual recognition of qualifications and dual-degree programs to bridge skill gaps in advanced manufacturing, clean energy, and digital sectors.
    AspectDetailsExample/Initiatives
    Strategic PartnershipComprehensive Strategic Partnership (2020) to counter China’s assertiveness in the Indo-Pacific.Australia-India Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative Partnership (AIIPOIP) for maritime cooperation.
    Economic and Trade RelationsBilateral trade crossed $30 billion in 2023, with growth potential under ECTA.India imports coal, LNG, while Australia imports textiles, pharmaceuticals, IT services.
    Supply Chain ResilienceIndia, Australia, and Japan’s Supply Chain Resilience Initiative (SCRI) ensures diversification.Promotes fair and sustainable trade practices.
    Critical MineralsCritical Minerals Investment Partnership supports Indian investment in Australian mining projects.Australia is a major producer of lithium, cobalt, and rare earths, vital for India’s energy needs.
    Green Energy CooperationCollaboration on hydrogen and solar energy to promote clean energy.Green Hydrogen Taskforce and India-Australia Solar Taskforce enhance renewable energy deployment.
    Defence CooperationAgreements and joint exercises enhance military interoperability.AUSTRAHIND, AUSINDEX, Pitch Black, Air-to-Air Refuelling, Mutual Logistics Support Agreement.
    Regional & Multilateral TiesCollaboration in UN, G20, and IORA for regional security and governance reforms.Australia supports India’s UN Security Council candidature.
    People-to-People TiesIndia is Australia’s largest source of skilled migrants and second-largest source of international students.India-Australia Migration and Mobility Partnership for student, professional, and researcher exchange.
    Science & TechnologyCooperation on space technology and human spaceflight programs.Agreement for transportable telemetry terminals in Cocos Island for India’s Human Space Mission.

    Issues in India-Australia Relations

    IssueDetailsExample/Challenges
    Trade & Market AccessProlonged Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA) negotiations.Non-Tariff Barriers like sanitary & phytosanitary standards hinder India’s exports.
    Pharmaceutical PricingPrice control in Australia on generics restricts market access for Indian pharmaceutical products.Indian pharma companies face difficulty in expanding their footprint.
    Extremism & Anti-India ActsRise of Khalistani extremism in Australia affecting diplomatic ties.Vandalism of Hare Krishna Temple, Shri Shiva Vishnu Temple in Melbourne.
    Nuclear Energy CooperationNo commercial sale of Uranium to India, despite a 2014 agreement on peaceful nuclear energy use.India rejected uranium supply due to lack of commercial viability.
    Visa IssuesAustralia recently increased visa fees by 125%, affecting Indian students and professionals.Financial burden on Indian students pursuing education in Australia.

  • [pib] Exercise INIOCHOS 25

    Why in the News?

    The Indian Air Force will participate in Exercise INIOCHOS-25 hosted by the Hellenic Air Force at Andravida Air Base, Greece.

    About Exercise INIOCHOS

    • INIOCHOS is a biennial multinational air exercise that provides air forces with a platform to enhance their operational readiness.
    • It is hosted by the Hellenic (Greek) Air Force and brings together military aviation units from various countries, promoting international cooperation.
    • It was first conducted in the late 1980s, as a small-scale tactical level exercise.
    • Objective: To allow air forces to practice Combined Air Operations and share tactical knowledge through realistic combat scenarios.

    Key Features of Exercise INIOCHOS:

    • It integrates air and surface assets from fifteen countries, promoting multinational cooperation in air warfare.
    • It will simulate modern-day air warfare challenges, providing a real-world training environment for participating air forces.
    • It will be placed on planning and executing Combined Air operations, refining tactics in complex air warfare scenarios.

    Strategic Importance for India:

    • India’s participation in INIOCHOS-25 underlines its commitment to global defence cooperation and showcases its ability to work seamlessly in joint operations.
    • The exercise will reinforce India’s strategic partnerships with other nations and further enhance its readiness for joint operations in complex and dynamic air warfare environments.

  • [29th March 2025] The Hindu Op-ed: Advantage China in Africa’s nuclear energy market race 

    PYQ Relevance:

    Question: “If the last few decades were of Asia’s growth story, the next few are expected to be of Africa’s.” In the light of this statement, examine India’s influence in Africa in recent years. [UPSC 2021]

    Linkage: The broader context of competition for influence in the continent. 

    Mentor’s Comment:  The Russia-Ukraine war highlighted the need for energy security, affecting even Africa. As African leaders rethink their energy sources, nuclear power is becoming a key solution. Currently, South Africa has Africa’s only nuclear plant, but countries like Ghana, Nigeria, and Kenya plan to adopt nuclear energy. By 2035, Africa could generate 15,000 MW, attracting $105 billion in investments.

    Today’s editorial talks about how African countries are changing their energy sources and how China is becoming a major player in Africa. This content would help in GS Paper 2 International relation.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    With several African nations reshaping their energy sources. China is likely to become their top choice for partnership, offering financial support, technology, and infrastructure to expand their nuclear energy sector.

    What are the key factors driving Africa’s shift toward nuclear energy?

    • Energy Security & Reduced Dependence on Imports: The Russia-Ukraine war exposed energy vulnerabilities, forcing African nations to diversify energy sources. Example: South Africa relies on coal but is now exploring nuclear expansion to ensure stable energy supply.
    • Expanding Electricity Access: Many African countries face severe power shortages, affecting economic growth and quality of life. Example: Nigeria has frequent blackouts and signed an MoU with China to develop nuclear power plants.
    • Clean Energy Transition & Climate Goals: African nations aim to reduce carbon emissions and shift from fossil fuels to meet global climate commitments. Example: Uganda plans a 2 GW nuclear plant to support its clean energy goals by 2031.
    • Economic & Industrial Growth: Nuclear energy can power industries, create jobs, and attract foreign investments. Example: Ghana is developing Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) with U.S.-based NuScale Power to boost industrialization.
    • Foreign Investment & Technological Advancements: Countries like China, Russia, and the U.S. are investing in Africa’s nuclear sector, providing funding and expertise. Example: Burkina Faso, Mali, and Niger signed nuclear agreements with Russia’s Rosatom to develop their energy sector.

    Which countries are leading the race to invest in Africa’s nuclear market, and why?

    • China – The Dominant Player: Offers easy financing and infrastructure development under the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Example: Nigeria & Uganda signed MoUs with China to build nuclear power plants, with Uganda planning a 2 GW nuclear plant by 2031.
    • Russia – Strategic Engagement: Through Rosatom, Russia has signed agreements with multiple African nations, leveraging its nuclear expertise. Example: Egypt’s El Dabaa nuclear plant is being built by Rosatom, though progress is slow due to economic challenges.
    • United States – Seeking a Foothold: Organizing the US-Africa Nuclear Energy Summit (USANES) to strengthen ties and push for Small Modular Reactors (SMRs). Example: Ghana partnered with NuScale Power and Regnum Technology Group to develop SMRs.
    • France – Losing Influence: Historically dominated Africa’s nuclear sector but is now struggling to maintain relevance, especially in Francophone Africa. Example: South Africa’s Koeberg nuclear plant was built by a French consortium, but new projects are going to other players.
    • South Korea – Emerging Contender: Korea Hydro and Nuclear Power (KHNP) is actively exploring opportunities in Africa’s nuclear energy sector. Example: South Korea is negotiating to supply nuclear reactors to various African countries, competing with China and Russia.

    How is China strengthening its dominance in Africa’s nuclear energy sector?

    • Financial Support & Infrastructure Investment: China provides easy financing and builds transmission networks through the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Example: Uganda signed an MoU with China in 2024 for a 2 GW nuclear plant, with the first 1 GW unit expected by 2031.
    • Training & Scholarships for African Engineers: The China Atomic Energy Authority, in cooperation with the IAEA, offers nuclear training programs for African students. Example: Since 2012, African students have been trained in Chinese nuclear procedures and technology, making China a preferred partner.
    • State-Owned Companies Leading Expansion: China General Nuclear Power Group (CGN) and China National Nuclear Corporation (CNNC) spearhead projects across Africa. Example: Nigeria signed a deal with CNNC in 2024 to develop nuclear power plants, covering design, construction, and maintenance.
    • Comprehensive Agreements Beyond Just Nuclear Plants: China integrates nuclear power development with broader energy and infrastructure investments, making deals attractive. Example: Kenya is considering China for both a research reactor and potential future nuclear plants as part of wider infrastructure projects.
    • Exploiting Gaps Left by Other Players: With France losing influence and Russia struggling financially, China steps in with better financing and execution capacity. Example: Burkina Faso, Mali, and Niger, despite approaching Russia’s Rosatom, may turn to China for funding and technology due to Russia’s economic constraints.

    Where are African countries planning to build new nuclear plants, and what are their projected timelines?

    • Egypt – El Dabaa Nuclear Plant: Egypt is building a large nuclear plant with help from Russia’s Rosatom.The first reactor is expected to start working by 2028.
    • Uganda – 2 GW Nuclear Power Plant: Uganda signed an agreement with China in 2024 to build a big nuclear plant. The first part (1 GW) should be ready by 2031.
    • Nigeria – Future Nuclear Plants: Nigeria signed an agreement with China in 2024 to develop nuclear energy. The timeline is not confirmed yet.
    • Kenya – Research Reactor: Kenya plans to build a small research reactor by 2030 to learn more about nuclear energy. It has not yet chosen a partner for a full power plant.
    • Ghana – SMRs & Large Reactor: Ghana is working with U.S. company NuScale for small reactors and China for a big reactor. The exact timeline is still unclear.

    Why is India’s access to African uranium becoming more challenging?

    • Growing Chinese Influence: China is investing heavily in Africa’s nuclear sector, securing long-term uranium supply deals. Example: China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) funds energy projects, strengthening its ties with uranium-rich nations like Namibia and Niger.
    • Geopolitical Realignments: Many African nations are aligning with China and Russia, reducing India’s negotiating power. Example: Burkina Faso, Mali, and Niger have strengthened ties with Russia, which may affect India’s access to uranium deals.
    • Competition from Other Global Players: France, Russia, and the U.S. are also competing for uranium resources, making it harder for India to secure long-term agreements. Example: France has historical control over Niger’s uranium exports, limiting India’s access.
    • Economic & Infrastructure Constraints: India lacks direct investment in African uranium mining compared to China, which provides infrastructure and financial support. Example: China’s CNNC (China National Nuclear Corporation) has mining rights in Namibia, while India only has agreements without major investments.
    • Security & Political Instability: Many uranium-rich African countries face political instability and security risks, making long-term agreements uncertain. Example: Niger’s 2023 military coup created uncertainty in uranium exports, impacting India’s potential deals.

    What should India do to secure a uranium supply from Africa? (Way forward)

    • Increase Direct Investment in Mining & Infrastructure: India should partner with African nations to develop uranium mines, processing facilities, and infrastructure instead of just relying on purchase agreements. Example: India can invest in Namibia’s uranium mining sector, similar to how China’s CNNC has secured long-term rights.
    • Strengthen Bilateral & Multilateral Agreements: India must negotiate long-term uranium supply deals with African nations through trade pacts and diplomatic engagement. Example: India can expand its agreements under India-Africa Forum Summit (IAFS) to secure uranium from Niger, Malawi, and South Africa.
    • Leverage India’s Civil Nuclear Agreements & Technology: India should offer nuclear technology collaboration to African nations as an incentive to secure uranium supply. Example: Partnering with Ghana and Kenya on Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) could help India gain better access to uranium sources.
  • [UPSC Webinar] By Arvind Sir | Most IMP Mains PYQs & Microthemes For UPSC 2026 | Join on 31st March at 7:00 PM

    [UPSC Webinar] By Arvind Sir | Most IMP Mains PYQs & Microthemes For UPSC 2026 | Join on 31st March at 7:00 PM

    Register Now!

    Register for the session to get complete UPSC 2026 preparation plan and strategy

    Register Now!
    UPSC

    Read about Arvind Sir’s UPSC 2026 Prep Webinar

    Why Most Aspirants Fail—And How You Can Avoid Their Mistakes
    Every year, thousands of aspirants spend countless hours studying irrelevant topics, only to be blindsided by the actual demands of the UPSC Mains. They drown in bulky books, ignore question trends, and fail to recognize that UPSC has a pattern—one that favours the well-prepared.

    If you’re a beginner, you have a golden opportunity: start with clarity, not confusion. This webinar will give you a shortcut to smart preparation by revealing precisely what UPSC asks and how to prepare for it.

    The Most High-Value Questions—What UPSC Keeps Repeating
    The UPSC Mains exam is not unpredictable—it rewards those who study the proper set of questions. Our team has analyzed years of Previous Year Questions (PYQs) and identified the most frequently recurring themes.

    These are the questions that UPSC keeps returning to, in different forms, year after year. In this webinar, we will break them down for you, showing you why they are essential and how to answer them effectively. If you can master these, you will walk into the exam hall with a massive advantage over thousands of aspirants.

    Microthemes: The Hidden Goldmine of UPSC Preparation
    Beyond broad subjects, UPSC often asks questions on microthemes—specific subtopics that catch students off guard. For example, instead of a generic question on Indian Economy, you might get one on Gig Economy trends post-COVID. Instead of a broad history question, UPSC may ask about the impact of Raja Ram Mohan Roy on women’s rights in modern India.

    These laser-focused topics often carry high-scoring potential, but most aspirants miss them. This webinar will map out the most crucial microthemes for 2026—ensuring you prepare smarter, not harder.

    Why Beginners Must Attend This Webinar—And What You’ll Gain
    If you’re starting your UPSC journey, you might be feeling overwhelmed. Should you begin with NCERTs? Should you memorize the syllabus? What about newspapers? The truth is, none of this matters if you don’t know what UPSC asks.

    This session will help you cut through the noise and start with a crystal-clear roadmap. You’ll learn to prioritize your study, recognize question trends, and, most importantly, focus on what UPSC truly values.

    A Rare Opportunity— Register Now!
    This isn’t just another generic UPSC strategy session. This power-packed masterclass is designed to give you a clear advantage over other aspirants.

    By the end of this session, you will have a list of must-study PYQs, a breakdown of microthemes, and a step-by-step strategy to approach UPSC preparation like a topper. If you’re serious about UPSC 2026 – Register now!

    Register Now!

    Arvind Sir, has identified key blind spots in UPSC preparation. He will conduct a free Zoom masterclass on, 31st March at 7 PM. In this session, he will share a proven strategy, used by rankers, to structure Mains preparation with microthemes for scoring 800+ marks.

    Don’t miss out! Join him on, 31st March, at 7 PM!

    See you in masterclass”

    Register Now!

    It will be a 45 minute webinar, post which we will open up the floor for all kinds of queries which a beginner must have. No questions are taboo and Arvind Sir is known to be patiently solving all your doubts.

    Join us for a Zoom session on 31st March 2025 at 7:00 p.m. This session is a must-attend for you If you are attempting UPSC for the first time or have attempted earlier and now preparing for next year, then it is going to be a valuable session for you too.

    See you in the session”

    Register for the session for a focussed UPSC 2026 Prep

    Register Now!

    In this Civilsdaily masterclass, you will get:

    1. A 45-minute deep dive on how to plan your UPSC strategy from the start to the end.
    2. How do first-attempt IAS Rankers get the most out of their one year prep?
    3. Insider tips that only the top IAS and IPS rankers know and apply to get rank.

    By the end, you’ll have razor-sharp clarity and a clear path to crack UPSC with confidence and near-perfect certainty. 

    Join UPSC session on 31st March 2025, 7:00 pm

    Register Now!

    (Don’t wait—the next webinar won’t be until April 25)

    These masterclasses are packed with value. They are conducted in private with a closed community. We rarely open these webinars for everyone for free. This time we are keeping it for 300 seats only.

    Ready to attend the UPSC Webinar?

    Register Now!

    Not sure yet?

    We recommend you register here. It takes less than 10 seconds to register.

    • No spam! Once in a while, we’ll only send you high-quality exam-related content. 
    • We will inform you about the upcoming Masterclasses that might benefit you.
    • You can demand one free mentorship call from verified Civilsdaily mentors. 
    • You can always choose to unsubscribe. 

  • Supreme Court relief to Pratapgarhi: Can’t be so shaky on our basics over a poem or stand-up comedy

    Why in the News?

    The Supreme Court quashed the FIR against Congress MP Imran Pratapgarhi, stating that even if many people dislike someone’s views, their right to express them must be respected and protected.

    What was the Supreme Court’s rationale for quashing Imran Pratapgarhi’s FIR?

    • Poem Did Not Incite Violence or Enmity: The court ruled that the poem “Ae khoon ke pyase baat suno” did not promote violence or hatred but instead advocated facing injustice with love. Example: The court compared this to other forms of artistic expression, such as satire and stand-up comedy, which may provoke strong reactions but should still be protected under freedom of speech.
    • Freedom of Expression is Fundamental to Democracy: The judgment emphasized that even if many people dislike or oppose certain views, an individual’s right to express them must be protected. Example: The ruling cited how literature, poetry, and films enrich public discourse, and restricting them would lead to a stifled society.
    • Failure of Police to Conduct Preliminary Inquiry: The court noted that under Section 173(3) of the BNSS, the police must conduct a preliminary inquiry before registering an FIR for offenses punishable with 3 to 7 years of imprisonment. Example: If the police had followed this procedure, they would have found no prima facie case against Pratapgarhi, preventing an unjust criminal prosecution.

    Why did Justices Oka and Bhuyan stress the importance of protecting free speech in their ruling?

    • Essential for a Healthy Democracy: The court emphasized that freedom of expression is crucial for a vibrant democracy, where diverse opinions must be debated rather than suppressed. Example: The judges stated that even if many people dislike a view, it must still be protected, reinforcing that countering speech with speech, not suppression, is the right approach.
    • Integral to Human Dignity and Fundamental Rights: The ruling linked free speech to Article 21 (Right to Life with Dignity), arguing that without the ability to express ideas, individuals cannot live a dignified life. Example: The court cited the Preamble of the Constitution, which guarantees liberty of thought and expression as a core constitutional ideal.
    • Judiciary’s Duty to Protect Fundamental Rights: The judges stressed that if the police or executive fail to uphold free speech, the courts must step in to protect citizens’ rights under Article 19(1)(a). Example: The court stated that even judges may not always like certain spoken or written words, but they are bound by their duty to uphold the Constitution and free speech rights.

    Which Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) sections did Gujarat Police invoke against Pratapgarhi, and what do they address?

    • Section 196 – Promoting Enmity Between Groups: It Covers acts that promote enmity between different groups based on religion, race, place of birth, residence, or language and disturb harmony. Example: If a speech or post incites hostility between communities, it could fall under this section. However, the court found no such intent in Pratapgarhi’s poem.
    • Section 299 – Outraging Religious Feelings: It Covers deliberate and malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings by insulting a religion or religious beliefs. Example: If someone defames a religious text or practice with intent to offend, they may be booked under this section. The court ruled that Pratapgarhi’s poem had no such intent.
    • Section 173(3) of BNSS – Preliminary Inquiry Requirement: Mandates a preliminary inquiry before registering an FIR for offenses punishable by 3 to 7 years of imprisonment. Example: The court noted that the police should have conducted an inquiry first to see if a prima facie case existed, preventing unnecessary criminal charges.

    What role did the Supreme Court assign to police and judiciary in upholding Article 19(1)(a)?

    • Police Must Conduct a Preliminary Inquiry Before Filing an FIR: The court held that police must verify if a case genuinely falls under restrictions on free speech before registering an FIR. Unwarranted criminal proceedings can have a chilling effect on expression.
      • Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015): The Supreme Court struck down Section 66A of the IT Act, ruling that arbitrary arrests for online speech violate free expression.
    • Judiciary Must Act as the Guardian of Fundamental Rights: Courts must intervene when executive actions violate fundamental rights, ensuring that speech is not suppressed under vague or excessive laws.
      • S. Rangarajan v. P. Jagjivan Ram (1989): The Supreme Court ruled that mere disagreement or offense cannot be grounds for restricting free speech.
    • Both Institutions Must Uphold Constitutional Ideals: Police and courts must ensure that freedom of expression is safeguarded in a democracy, as it is crucial for a vibrant public discourse.
      • Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar (1962): The Supreme Court clarified that only speech inciting violence or public disorder can be restricted.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Safeguards Against Misuse of Laws: Implement clear guidelines for law enforcement to distinguish between genuine hate speech and protected expression to prevent arbitrary FIRs. Example: Mandatory legal training for police on free speech rights and BNSS provisions.
    • Judicial Oversight and Quick Disposal of Cases: Establish fast-track mechanisms for courts to quash frivolous cases that violate Article 19(1)(a). Example: Special benches to review cases involving free speech violations to ensure timely justice.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q  Question: What do you understand by the concept “freedom of speech and expression”? Does it cover hate speech also? Why do the films in India stand on a slightly different plane from other forms of expression? Discuss. [UPSC 2014]

    Linkage: The scope of freedom of speech and expression, a central issue in the Pratapgarhi case. 

  • India’s geopolitical vision should be larger

    Why in the News?

    Earlier this month, Russian President Vladimir Putin thanked leaders, including PM of India, for helping to end the Ukraine- Russia war. This was appreciated in India, but it raises a key question—why doesn’t India engage more in global conflict resolution?

    Why has India refrained from playing a more active political role in global conflicts despite its past interventions in regional crises?

    • Focus on Economic Growth: India has prioritized economic development over geopolitical interventions to strengthen its position as the world’s fifth-largest economy. Example: Since the early 2000s, India has focused on domestic growth and international trade rather than direct involvement in conflicts like the Syrian civil war.
    • Risk of Straining Bilateral Relations: Engaging in conflicts could upset key diplomatic partnerships and economic ties with different nations. Example: India has refrained from directly criticizing Russia over the Ukraine war to maintain strong trade relations, especially in energy and defense.
    • Multi-Alignment Strategy over Direct Intervention: India prefers to maintain balanced relations with global powers rather than taking sides in conflicts. Example: During the Israel-Gaza crisis, India condemned terrorism but avoided taking an active role in mediation.
    • Regional Conflicts Best Handled by Key Players: India often views conflicts as better managed by regional stakeholders or major global powers. Example: In West Asia, India has significant economic interests but does not intervene like Turkey or Saudi Arabia in conflicts such as the Yemen civil war.
    • Avoiding Overstretching Diplomatic and Military Resources: Actively engaging in multiple conflicts could strain India’s diplomatic bandwidth and military capacity. Example: While India plays a crucial role in Indo-Pacific security (e.g., QUAD), it has avoided direct involvement in conflicts like the South China Sea dispute.

    What are the key reasons behind India’s geopolitical reticence, and how do they impact its global ambitions?

    • Economic Prioritization Over Geopolitical Involvement: India has focused on economic growth, infrastructure development, and poverty reduction rather than engaging in global conflicts. This has strengthened India’s economy but has limited its influence in global strategic affairs. Example: India avoided a major role in the Ukraine-Russia war to protect trade and energy interests.
    • Balancing Strategic Partnerships: India follows a multi-alignment policy, maintaining good relations with diverse global powers. This ensures economic and diplomatic stability but restricts India from taking firm stances on contentious global issues. Example: India has strong ties with both the U.S. and Russia, leading to neutral stances in conflicts like Ukraine.
    • Reluctance to Meddle in Complex Regional Conflicts: India prefers not to intervene in regions where dominant players (e.g., U.S., China, EU) have vested interests. This often makes India appear as a passive actor rather than a decisive global leader. Example: India refrained from mediating in the Israel-Palestine conflict, unlike Qatar and Turkey.
    • Lack of Institutional Mechanisms for Conflict Mediation: India does not have a formal diplomatic framework for mediation in global conflicts. This limits India’s credibility as a conflict-resolution leader despite its historical role in peacekeeping. Example: Unlike Norway’s role in the Sri Lanka peace process, India avoided direct mediation post-2009.
    • Fear of Strategic Overstretch and Retaliation: Actively engaging in conflicts could lead to economic sanctions, diplomatic backlash, or military confrontations. This cautious approach preserves internal stability but weakens India’s claim for a UNSC permanent seat and a stronger global role. Example: India has not taken a proactive role in Afghanistan’s political transition to avoid provoking regional powers like China and Pakistan.

    Which countries or regions are currently filling the space left by India’s limited involvement in international conflict mediation?

    • China – Expanding Diplomatic and Strategic Mediation: China has positioned itself as a key mediator in conflicts, using economic influence and strategic partnerships. Example: In 2023, China brokered a historic diplomatic agreement between Saudi Arabia and Iran, reducing tensions in the Middle East.
    • Turkey and Qatar – Active Engagement in Regional Conflicts: These countries have taken up mediation roles, particularly in the Middle East and Afghanistan, leveraging their geopolitical positions and relationships with conflicting parties. Example: Qatar facilitated negotiations between the U.S. and the Taliban, leading to the 2020 U.S.-Taliban peace deal.
    • European Union – Diplomatic Initiatives and Soft Power: The EU engages in conflict resolution through diplomatic channels, economic incentives, and humanitarian aid. Example: The EU has played a mediatory role in the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, facilitating peace talks and ceasefire agreements.

    Way forward: 

    • Develop Institutional Frameworks for Mediation and Peacebuilding: Establish specialized diplomatic institutions focused on conflict resolution, leveraging India’s experience in UN peacekeeping and historical ties with developing nations. Example: Creating an “India Peace Mediation Initiative” under the Ministry of External Affairs to offer diplomatic and humanitarian support in global conflicts.
    • Strengthen Strategic and Economic Diplomacy for Conflict Prevention: Enhance regional cooperation through trade, infrastructure projects, and multilateral platforms like BRICS and the G20 to prevent conflicts at their roots. Example: Expanding India’s diplomatic role in West Asia and Africa through economic investments and diplomatic engagement to foster long-term stability.

    Mains question for practice:

    Question: The West is fostering India as an alternative to reduce dependence on China’s supply chain and as a strategic ally to counter China’s political and economic dominance.’ Explain this statement with examples. [UPSC 2024]

    Linkage: India’s potential role in the global balance of power and how external actors perceive India’s strategic significance in countering a major global power is an important theme. A larger geopolitical vision for India would involve strategically navigating such external expectations and leveraging its position to advance its own interests.

  • Massive Earthquake hits Myanmar and Thailand

    Why in the News?

    A powerful 7.7 magnitude earthquake struck Myanmar, with its epicentre near Mandalay, the country’s second-largest city.

    Massive Earthquake hits Myanmar and Thailand

    What caused the Earthquake in Myanmar?

    • Myanmar is situated between the Indian Plate and the Eurasian Plate, which makes the region seismically active.
      • The Sagaing Fault, running from north to south through Myanmar, marks the boundary of these plates.
      • It is an active fault line that has caused significant earthquakes in the past, including a 7.9 magnitude earthquake in 1912 and a 6.9 magnitude earthquake in 2016.
    • The Indian Plate was moving northward along the Sagaing Fault relative to the Eurasian Plate. The friction and stress built up along this fault led to a sudden release of energy, resulting in the earthquake.
    • The earthquake’s epicentres was located 17.2 km from Mandalay, Myanmar’s second-largest city, at a depth of just 10 km.

    Why are Shallow Earthquakes more destructive?

    • Proximity to the Surface: Shallow earthquakes (less than 70 km deep) cause intense shaking. For example, the Myanmar earthquake occurred at 10 km, leading to rapid, forceful seismic waves and extensive damage.
    • Energy Release: Shallow earthquakes retain more energy in seismic waves, causing stronger surface shaking and greater destruction.
    • Higher Intensity: Shallow quakes produce higher intensity shaking, resulting in more structural damage compared to deeper quakes, where seismic waves lose energy.
    • Aftershocks: Shallow earthquakes often lead to more intense aftershocks, further damaging already weakened structures. The Myanmar earthquake had aftershocks, including one with magnitude 6.4.

    Back2Basics: Earthquake and Related Terminologies

    • Earthquake is a sudden shaking of the ground caused by energy release from tectonic plate movements or volcanic activity, generating seismic waves.
    • Key Terminologies:
      • Focus (Hypocenter): The point inside the Earth where the earthquake originates, deep beneath the surface.
      • Epicenter: The point on the Earth’s surface directly above the focus, usually the most affected area.
      • Seismic Waves: Waves that carry the energy released during an earthquake and cause ground shaking.
      • Fault: A crack or fracture in the Earth’s crust where movement occurs, often causing earthquakes.
      • Magnitude: A measure of the earthquake’s size or energy, commonly measured on the Richter scale.
      • Intensity: The strength of shaking at specific locations, measured by the Modified Mercalli Intensity (MMI) scale.

    Types of Earthquake Waves:

    • Body Waves: Travel through the Earth’s interior, detected first by seismographs.
      • Primary Waves (P-Waves): Fastest, compression waves that move through solids and liquids.
      • Secondary Waves (S-Waves): Shear waves, slower than P-waves, that move through solids only.
    • Surface Waves: Travel along the Earth’s surface, slower but cause more damage.
      • Love Waves: Move side-to-side horizontally, causing significant damage.
      • Rayleigh Waves: Cause elliptical ground motion, similar to ocean waves, very destructive.

     

    [UPSC 2021] Consider the following statements:

    1. In a seismograph, P waves are recorded earlier than S waves.

    2. In P waves, the individual particles vibrate to and fro in the direction of waves propagation whereas in S waves, the particles vibrate up and down at right angles to the direction of wave propagation.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    (a) 1 only (b) 2 only (c) Both 1 and 2 (d) Neither 1 nor 2

     

More posts