💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Subject: Environment

  • At COP 28, a chance to get past fear-mongering

    How Can Climate Action Be Inclusive? | Global Climate Change

    Central idea

    The article emphasizes that climate change action is essential for economic sustainability and counters the notion that it is unaffordable. It highlights the impact of fossil fuels on the cost-of-living crisis and advocates for redirecting funds from fossil fuel subsidies to renewable energy. The author calls for international cooperation at COP28 to triple renewable energy capacity, double energy efficiency, and address climate justice concerns.

    Key Highlights:

    • Global Cost-of-Living Crisis: Inflation’s widespread impact on billions globally, prompting a false narrative of green initiatives against the interests of the poor.
    • Fossil Fuels and Economic Strain: Fossil fuels, a major driver of the cost-of-living crisis, contribute to economic strain, affecting household budgets and impeding growth.
    • Worsening Climate Disasters: Amid rising costs, climate disasters intensify, causing economic damage and affecting millions globally.

    Key Challenges:

    • Fossil Fuel Dependency: Persistent reliance on fossil fuels remains a significant hurdle to addressing the cost-of-living crisis and mitigating climate change.
    • Government Spending on Subsidies: Trillions spent on fossil fuel subsidies divert funds from essential services and hinder investments in renewable energy.

    Key Terms:

    • Cost-of-Living Crisis: Global economic strain exacerbated by inflation.
    • Fossil Fuel Subsidies: Government financial support to the fossil fuel industry.
    • Renewable Energy: Sustainable alternatives to fossil fuels.
    • Climate Disasters: Increasingly severe climate-related events.
    • Energy Access: Ensuring access to reliable and affordable energy.

    Key Phrases for value addition:

    • “Green versus poor” Narrative: Misleading rhetoric obscuring the need for a sustainable future.
    • “Fossil fuel taps can’t be turned off overnight”: Recognizing the gradual nature of transitioning from fossil fuels.
    • “Global Stocktake on climate action”: Assessment of progress and tools to speed up climate action.
    • “Tripling the world’s renewable energy capacity”: Ambitious goals for renewable energy expansion.
    • “Fear Mongering”: Misleading tactics to discourage climate action.

    Key Examples and References:

    • Impact of Fossil Fuel Prices: Household bills rising up to $1,000 in 2022.
    • Government Spending: Trillions spent globally on fossil fuel subsidies in 2022.

    Key Facts:

    • Climate Predictions: This year projected to be the hottest in 125,000 years.
    • Inflation Impact: Disproportionately affecting the poorest households.
    • Fossil Fuel Subsidies: Diverting funds from essential services and renewable energy projects.

    Key Data:

    • Global Spending on Subsidies: Trillions allocated to fossil fuel subsidies.
    • Climate Impact: Economic damage and lives affected by escalating climate disasters.

    Critical Analysis:

    • The article underscores the interconnected challenges of inflation, fossil fuel dependency, and climate change.
    • Governments’ hesitation to phase out subsidies is identified as a critical obstacle.
    • Emphasis on the imperative shift to renewable energy for economic growth and effective climate action.

    Way Forward:

    • Advocacy: Push for responsible phasing out of fossil fuel subsidies.
    • Encouragement: Support governments in investing in renewable energy and energy-efficient solutions.
    • Climate Justice: Back initiatives addressing climate justice and adaptation to climate impacts.

  • Places in news: Nugu Wildlife Sanctuary

    Nugu Wildlife Sanctuary

    Central Idea

    • The National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA) has made a crucial recommendation to designate the Nugu Wildlife Sanctuary, adjacent to the Bandipur Tiger Reserve, as a core critical tiger habitat.

    Nugu Wildlife Sanctuary

    • Location: It is situated in H.D. Kote taluk of Mysuru district, Karnataka.
    • Geographic Area: Nugu Wildlife Sanctuary encompasses a 30.32 sq km expanse and was officially declared a Wildlife Sanctuary by the State.
    • Unique Geography: The sanctuary includes the backwaters of Nugu dam on its western side and shares borders with Alaganchi State Forest, a part of Bandipur TR, on the southwest side.
    • Flora and Fauna: Despite recovering from past degradation, the flora of Nugu shares similarities with Bandipur. The sanctuary supports a diverse range of flora and fauna, including elephant, tiger, leopard, wild dog, striped hyena, sloth bear, gaur, sambhar, chital, and four-horned antelope.
    • Riverine Wildlife: Nugu Wildlife Sanctuary is also home to two important riverine wildlife species: the smooth-coated otter and the marsh crocodile, emphasizing its rich biodiversity.

    Conservation Efforts

    • Buffer Area: Nugu Wildlife Sanctuary is an integral part of the Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve and serves as a buffer area for Bandipur Tiger Reserve.
    • Ecological Significance: This sanctuary offers an inviolate and ideal habitat for tigers and elephants, making it a prime candidate for Core/Critical Tiger Habitat status within Bandipur TR.

  • Southern Annular Mode (SAM) and Indian Ocean Weather Conditions

    Southern Annular Mode

    Central Idea

    • The Indian National Centre for Ocean Information Services (INCOIS), a division under the Ministry of Earth Sciences (MoES), has made a significant discovery regarding the Southern Annular Mode (SAM), a crucial climate pattern.
    • Their research has revealed that SAM plays a pivotal role in influencing sea conditions across the Indian Ocean.

    What is Southern Annular Mode (SAM)?

    Description
    Idea behind
    • Mode of atmospheric variability representing north-south movement of the westerly wind belt around Antarctica.
    • Also known as Antarctic Oscillation (AAO).
    Phases
    1. Positive Phase: Wind belt contracts towards Antarctica.
    2. Negative Phase: Wind belt expands towards the equator.
    Impact on Weather Patterns
    • Influences temperature, rainfall, and storm intensity in the Southern Hemisphere.
    • Causes difference in the zonal mean sea level pressure at 40°S (mid-latitudes) and 65°S (Antarctica).
    Influence on Indian Ocean Affects ocean currents and sea surface temperatures, impacting regional weather and marine life.
    Climate Change Connection Trend towards more positive phases in recent decades, influenced by human-induced climate change.
    Effect on Antarctic Ice Impacts Antarctic ice sheets and sea ice extent through changes in wind patterns.
    Global Climate Interaction Interacts with other climate phenomena like ENSO.
    Predictability and Variability Exhibits seasonal predictability and interannual variability, important for long-term forecasting.
    Marine Ecosystems Affects marine ecosystems in the Southern Ocean, influencing productivity and species distribution.

    Role of Ocean Surface Waves

    • Coastal Processes: Ocean surface waves are key players in shaping coastal processes, impacting shoreline erosion, sediment transport, coastal engineering, and recreational activities.
    • Scientific Approach: The scientific team leveraged 40 years of data (1979 to 2018) from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecast.

    Positive and Negative SAM Phases

    • Positive SAM Phase: During a positive SAM phase, a cyclic pattern of warm sea surface temperature anomalies emerges, accompanied by strong winds that increase wave activity in the Indian Ocean. A new swell generation region along the east African coast contributes to heightened wave heights in the Arabian Sea.
    • Negative SAM Phase: Conversely, during a negative SAM phase, the eastern tropical southern Indian Ocean becomes the primary region for generating swells, resulting in reduced wave heights in the Arabian Sea.

    Significance of SAM

    • Coastal Planning: Understanding SAM allows for better coastal planning, helping coastal communities prepare for the impact of changing sea conditions.
    • Resource Management: SAM insights can aid in more efficient resource management, optimizing the utilization of marine resources.
    • Disaster Preparedness: Knowledge of SAM patterns can enhance disaster preparedness efforts, enabling timely response to potential ocean-related disasters.
    • Wave Predictions: The research contributes to improving wave predictions, offering advanced forecasting capabilities.
    • Benefiting Stakeholders: Stakeholders in the blue economy, including shipping, maritime boards, and the oil industry, can optimize their multi-million-dollar operations at sea based on SAM insights.

    Implications for Various Sectors

    • Monsoon Season Impact: Typically, inland vessel operations and oil exploration activities face restrictions during the monsoon season.
    • Fair Sea State Windows: Predicting SAM phases through the Ocean Forecasting System can identify “Fair Sea state windows” during monsoons.
    • Impact on Blue Economy: These fair windows can be leveraged by oil and shipping industries, making a significant contribution to blue economy activities along the Indian coast

  • How we are rescuing workers trapped in Uttarkashi tunnel

    Uttarakhand tunnel collapse LIVE: Pipeline laid inside to rescue 41 trapped workers | Hindustan Times

    Central idea

    The central idea focuses on the Silkyara Tunnel rescue in Uttarakhand, highlighting diverse worker representation and challenges in Himalayan geology. The strategic use of auger and drift technology plays a crucial role in the efficient rescue operation. The primary goal is the safe return of 41 trapped workers through a unified and adaptive approach.

    Key Highlights:

    • Silkyara Tunnel incident in Uttarkashi, Uttarakhand, sparks a coordinated effort by government and private agencies.
    • 41 workers trapped in a partially collapsed tunnel, representing a diverse group from different states.
    • Technological advancements, communication, and transportation are leveraged for the rescue operation.
    • Involvement of multiple government bodies, including the Prime Minister’s Office and various ministries.

    Key Challenges:

    • Risks and challenges associated with the rescue operation, including the unpredictable nature of Himalayan geology.
    • The need to balance urgency with caution in the rescue efforts.
    • Varying degrees of difficulty in deploying machinery due to the risk factor and geological complexities.

    Key Terms and Phrases for value addition:

    • Silkyara Tunnel
    • “All of government” approach
    • Himalayan geology
    • Simultaneity principle
    • Auger technology
    • Drift technology
    • Convergence of capability

    Auger Technology:

    • Definition: Auger technology involves the use of a rotating metal shaft with a blade at the end.
    • Application in Rescue: In the Silkyara Tunnel rescue, auger technology is deployed to scrape or cut debris and earth, creating a path for rescuers.
    • Success: A portion of 22 meters has been successfully negotiated, demonstrating the effectiveness of auger technology.
    • Challenges: Geological impediments have posed challenges, requiring restarting the effort.

    Drift Technology:

    • Definition: Drift technology involves scraping the sides of the tunnel to increase its size and create access.
    • Application in Rescue: Used to widen the tunnel for easier access and maneuverability in the rescue operation.
    • Timing: Top and side boring attacks on the tunnel alignment will commence in due course.
    • Redundancy: Provides a redundant approach to ensure the success of the rescue operation.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • 41 workers trapped inside a partially collapsed tunnel.
    • Efforts initiated by the Prime Minister’s Office, Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Ministry of Home Affairs, NDMA, and Uttarakhand SDMA.
    • Five rescue approaches with time frames ranging from five-six days to eight weeks.

    Critical Analysis:

    • Emphasis on the coordinated efforts involving various government bodies and private sectors.
    • Recognition of the unpredictable nature of Himalayan geology and the associated challenges.
    • Utilization of advanced technologies such as auger and drift technology to address the complexities.
    • Highlighting the psychological and social impacts on workers and the provision of psycho-social specialists.
    • Acknowledgment of the importance of enabling convergence of capability among competent agencies.

    Way Forward:

    • Continued focus on simultaneous approaches to expedite the rescue operation.
    • Prioritizing the horizontal approach using auger technology and drift technology.
    • Recognition of leadership from New Delhi as a crucial factor in ensuring effective coordination.
    • Emphasizing the importance of the safe return of the trapped workers as the primary goal.

  • What the OECD Report says of Climate Finance ahead of COP 28?

    Central Idea

    • A recent report published by the OECD reveals that economically developed countries failed to fulfill their commitment to jointly mobilize $100 billion per year for climate mitigation and adaptation in developing countries in 2021, missing the 2020 deadline.
    • The report’s findings have significant implications for the upcoming COP 28 climate talks in the United Arab Emirates, where climate finance is expected to be a contentious issue.

    Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)

     

    • Establishment: Founded in 1961, succeeding the Organisation for European Economic Co-operation (OEEC) which was established in 1948 to help administer the Marshall Plan for the reconstruction of Europe after World War II.
    • Members: Initially European-focused, it now includes 38 member countries from across the globe, including many of the world’s most advanced economies and some emerging economies.
    • Purpose: To stimulate economic progress and world trade. It’s a forum where governments can work together to share experiences and seek solutions to common problems.
    • Key Functions: Provides a platform for comparing policy experiences, seeking answers to common problems, identifying good practices, and coordinating domestic and international policies of its members.
    • Major Publications: Includes the OECD Economic Outlook, the OECD Employment Outlook, and the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) report.

    Key Findings of the OECD Report

    • Shortfall in Climate Finance: Developed countries mobilized $89.6 billion in climate finance in 2021, falling short of the $100 billion target.
    • Decline in Adaptation Finance: The report highlights a 14% decrease in financing for climate adaptation in 2021 compared to the previous year.

    Significance of the OECD Report

    • Representation of Developed Nations: The OECD consists of affluent countries such as the U.S., the U.K., Germany, France, Switzerland, and Canada, providing insights into their climate finance priorities before the COP 28 talks.
    • COP 26 Pledge: The report follows a commitment by developed nations at COP 26 in 2020 to double adaptation finance and acknowledges their failure to meet the $100 billion goal on time.

    Issues related to Climate Finance Accountability

    • Composition of Climate Finance: The report reveals that a significant portion of public climate financing comes in the form of loans, raising concerns about debt stress in developing countries.
    • Loan Classification: The report’s treatment of loans without considering grant equivalents can exacerbate the burden on poorer nations, as loans may require repayment with interest.
    • ‘Additionality’: The UNFCCC mandates that developed countries provide “new and additional” financial resources for climate purposes, preventing the diversion of funds from other essential sectors like healthcare.
    • Lack of Defined Criteria: Developed countries have resisted efforts to establish a clear definition of climate finance, allowing ambiguity in classifying various types of funding.
    • Double-Counting: Some developed countries have been accused of double-counting development aid as climate finance, leading to the misallocation of resources.

    Climate Finance Needs and Future Projections

    • The OECD report suggests that $100 billion was likely met in 2022, but this data remains preliminary and unverified.
    • Developing countries are projected to require approximately $1 trillion annually for climate investments by 2025, escalating to $2.4 trillion per year from 2026 to 2030, highlighting the inadequacy of the $100 billion goal.

    Conclusion

    • The OECD report on climate finance underscores the gap between promises made by developed nations and their actual contributions.
    • Issues of loan classification, additionality, and a lack of clear criteria for climate finance need to be addressed for greater transparency and accountability.
    • As developing countries face growing climate-related challenges, public funding from governments and multilateral development banks remains crucial to meeting their needs.

  • Recognising the impact of climate change on health

    Framework on climate change and its impact on health (adapted from... | Download Scientific Diagram

    Central idea 

    As India gets ready for the 28th Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP28), it is important to examine how climate change affects the country’s health. India’s inadequate health systems make our population particularly vulnerable to the impact of climate risks on health. Climate change affects health directly, causing more sickness and death. In more indirect ways, it affects nutrition, reduces working hours, and increases climate-induced stress.

    Key Highlights:

    • Vulnerability of Health Systems: Inadequate health infrastructure in India heightens susceptibility to climate change impacts on health.
    • Concerns Over Temperature Rise: Failure to cap global temperature rise raises fears of uninhabitable regions with a 2°C increase.

    Challenges:

    • Double Morbidity Burden: Convergence of communicable and non-communicable diseases worsens health challenges.
    • Neglected Non-communicable Diseases: Climate change impact on mental health and non-communicable diseases often overlooked in India.

    Key Phrases and Analysis:

    • Urban Heat Island Effect: Unplanned urbanization intensifies the urban heat island effect, straining the urban health system.
    • Poorly Managed Health Risks: Inadequate recognition and management of health risks associated with climate change-induced factors.

    Key Data and Facts:

    • Temperature-Related Health Risks: 1% increase above 29°C correlates with an 8% rise in hospitalization rates, emphasizing direct temperature impact.
    • Urbanization Challenges: Unplanned urbanization exacerbates climate-related health risks, necessitating interventions in urban planning and public health.

    Way Forward:

    • Holistic Mitigation Strategies: Mitigation involves understanding climate change pathways, modifying health information systems, and upstream interventions.
    • Multi-level Action: Coordinated action at global, regional, and local levels, involving researchers, policymakers, and governments for meaningful change.

     

  • Places in news: Kadalundi Mudflats

    Central Idea

    • Kadalundi’s mudflats are shrinking drastically with sands cover.
    • These mudflats have been a vital source of sustenance for thousands of migrant shorebirds, offering abundant prey like polychaetes and crustaceans.

    About Kadalundi Mudflats

    • Kadalundi Mudflats are situated in the Kadalundi Bird Sanctuary, which is located in the Kozhikode district of Kerala, along the southwestern coast of India. The sanctuary encompasses estuarine wetlands, mudflats, and mangrove forests.
    • The mudflats are part of the estuarine ecosystem formed at the confluence of the Kadalundi River and the Arabian Sea.
    • This unique environment is influenced by both freshwater from the river and saline water from the sea, creating a diverse habitat.

    Ecological significance

    • Kadalundi Mudflats are renowned for their rich biodiversity, especially in terms of avian species.
    • The Kadalundi Bird Sanctuary and the mudflats are protected under the Wildlife Protection Act of 1972.
    • The mudflats serve as a critical habitat for various resident and migratory birds.
    • It is estimated that over 100 species of resident and migratory birds visit the area, making it a paradise for birdwatchers and ornithologists.
    • They are a crucial stopover point for migratory birds travelling along the East Asia-Australasia Flyway.

  • COP28 in Dubai: What to expect from Climate meeting

    COP28

    Central Idea

    • The upcoming COP28, scheduled to be held in Dubai from November 30 to December 12, faces the daunting challenge of addressing the urgent climate crisis.
    • Despite decades of negotiations, current global commitments to combat climate change are deemed insufficient.
    • With temperatures rising at an alarming rate, the need for substantial action has never been more critical.

    What is COP?

    • The word ‘COP’ is an acronym for ‘Conference of the Parties. The ‘parties’ are the governments around the world that have signed the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), a treaty agreed upon in 1994.
    • Every year, the COP is hosted by a different nation and the first such COP meeting – ‘COP1’ – took place in Germany in 1995.
    • The conferences are attended by world leaders, negotiators, and ministers, and also by representatives from civil society, business, international organisations, and the media.
    • The last COP-27 edition convened in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt with the theme “Together for Implementation” and to renew and extend the agreements reached in the historic Paris Agreement.

    Climate Action So Far: Crisis and Inadequate Responses

    • Rising Temperatures: 2023 is poised to become the warmest year ever recorded, with monthly warming records continually broken.
    • Response Lag: Global efforts to combat climate change have not kept pace with the rapid temperature increase.
    • Assessment: Recent reports indicate that current climate action plans, even in an optimistic scenario, would only achieve a 2% reduction in emissions by 2030, far from the 43% reduction recommended by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) to limit warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius.
    • Financial Gap: Despite increasing climate risks, financial resources allocated for adaptation measures in developing countries are insufficient, with a vast disparity between the required and actual funding.

    Expectations from COP28

    COP28 aims to address these pressing climate challenges and achieve significant outcomes:

    (1) Tripling of Renewable Energy:

    • Objective: Triple the global installed capacity of renewable energy by 2030, resulting in 70% of electricity generation from renewables.
    • Potential: This initiative could reduce 7 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions by 2030, making it a substantial step toward emission reduction.
    • Support: The proposal has garnered endorsement from G20 countries and explicit support from 60 others.

    (2) Delivery of $100 Billion:

    • Background: Developed countries pledged to mobilize $100 billion annually in climate finance from 2020, a commitment that remains unfulfilled.
    • Progress: Developed nations are expected to claim fulfillment of this promise at COP28, though it remains inadequate compared to the trillions required for climate action.
    • Challenge: The greater challenge lies in negotiating additional funding beyond the $100 billion annually, commencing from next year.

    (3) Funding for Loss and Damage:

    • Fund Creation: The establishment of a loss and damage fund, designed to assist countries affected by climate change impacts, was a notable outcome of the previous climate meeting in Egypt.
    • Funding Flow: COP28 is expected to witness financial contributions to the loss and damage fund, signaling progress in addressing concerns, especially for small island nations.

    (4) Global Stocktake:

    • Mandate: As per the Paris Agreement (2015), COP28 will present findings from the first global stocktake exercise. This assessment evaluates countries’ progress in combating climate change and outlines necessary actions for the next five years.
    • Informing Action: The stocktake findings will inform discussions and actions during the conference, providing a roadmap for more effective climate action.

    (5) Phase-down of Fossil Fuels:

    • Challenge: Controversial debates on the scheduled phase-down or phase-out of fossil fuels, particularly coal, persist among nations.
    • Contentious Issue: Resolving the disagreement over fossil fuel reduction is expected to be a complex and unresolved matter at COP28.

    Conclusion

    • COP28, set to be held in Dubai, represents a critical opportunity to address the climate crisis.
    • With expectations of tripling renewable energy, fulfillment of $100 billion climate finance commitments, funding for loss and damage, and global stocktake findings, the conference aims to push climate action forward.
    • However, the contentious issue of fossil fuel phase-down remains a challenge for the conference.
    • The world eagerly anticipates the outcomes and progress toward mitigating climate change.

  • Mount Etna in Italy erupts

    etna

    Central Idea

    • Volcanic eruptions often make headlines only when iconic volcanoes like Etna, Kilauea, or Eyjafjallajokull erupt.
    • However, throughout any given year, our planet witnessed numerous volcanic eruptions, with as many as 50 to 80 occurring worldwide.

    About Mount Etna

    • Mount Etna, located in Italy, holds the title of Europe’s most active volcano and ranks among the world’s largest.
    • Its recorded volcanic activity dates back to 1500 B.C., with over 200 eruptions documented since then.
    • Etna’s recent eruptions have disrupted air travel, leading to flight cancellations at the nearby Catania airport.
    • Additionally, the accumulation of volcanic ash on roads prompted authorities to temporarily ban the use of cars and motorbikes due to safety concerns.

    Volcanic Eruptions this Year

    Many of the world’s most active volcanoes are concentrated in the Pacific Ring of Fire, encompassing regions like New Zealand, Southeast Asia, Japan, and the western coast of the Americas. This volatile area also experiences about 90% of all earthquakes globally.

    • Kilauea, Hawaii: The Kilauea volcano in Hawaii captivated the world with a nearly nonstop eruption that began in 1983 and continued for an astonishing 35 years until 2018. Remarkably, it rekindled in 2021, with the eruption still ongoing.
    • Dukono, Indonesia: Erupting since August 1933, Dukono volcano in Indonesia stands as a testament to long-term volcanic activity, defying the passage of time.
    • Santa Maria, Guatemala: The eruption of Santa Maria in Guatemala commenced in June 1922 and persists to this day, underscoring the enduring nature of certain volcanic phenomena.
    • Yasur, Vanuatu: Yasur in Vanuatu first erupted around 1270 and has maintained its volcanic activity, continuing as of June 9, 2023.

    Understanding Volcanoes

    • Volcanoes are geological features characterized by openings or vents through which lava, tephra (small rocks), and steam erupt onto the Earth’s surface.
    • They result from both their own eruptions and the broader processes of tectonic plate movement.
    • Volcanic eruptions are essentially the result of magma, or molten rock, beneath the Earth’s surface rising, bubbling, and ultimately overflowing, much like boiling milk spilling out of a pot on a stove.
    • The magma seeks pathways to vents within the volcano, where it erupts and is expelled across the land and into the atmosphere, a phenomenon referred to as lava.

    Types of Volcanoes

    Appearance Formation Eruption Style Notable Examples
    Cinder Cones Small, steep, conical Formed from basaltic magma with high gas content Often explosive eruptions with cinders/scoria Paricutin (Mexico), Sunset Crater (USA)
    Composite/Stratovolcanoes Tall and symmetrical Result from alternating layers of lava, ash, etc. Both explosive and effusive eruptions Mount St. Helens (USA), Mount Fuji (Japan)
    Shield Volcanoes Broad and gently sloping Primarily formed from basaltic magma Primarily non-explosive with extensive lava flows Mauna Loa, Mauna Kea (Hawaii)
    Lava Domes Rounded dome-like shape Formed from slow extrusion of viscous magma Typically non-explosive but can be dangerous Novarupta Dome (Alaska), Mount St. Helens’ Lava Dome (USA)

  • Understanding the Forest Conservation Amendment Act of 2023

    Central Idea

    • The Forest Conservation Amendment Act of 2023 has emerged with limited public discourse, raising concerns about its ramifications for forests and indigenous communities.
    • While aimed at addressing climate change and deforestation, the law’s provisions have sparked debates over forest utilization, economic gain, and the rights of forest dwellers, particularly indigenous communities.

    Forest Conservation Amendment Act, 2023: Key Provisions

    • Focus Areas: The amendment emphasizes climate change mitigation and effective forest management, while also promoting afforestation.
    • Jurisdiction Changes: The law restricts its applicability to areas categorized under the 1927 Forest Act and those designated as such after October 25, 1980.
    • Exemptions: Forests converted for non-forest use after December 12, 1996, and those within 100 kilometers of the China-Pakistan border for potential linear projects are exempt.
    • Security Measures: The central government gains authority to construct security infrastructure in areas up to ten hectares, even extending to vulnerable zones of up to five hectares.
    • Economic Initiatives: Initiatives like ecotourism, safari, and environmental entertainment may be implemented to enhance forest-dependent livelihoods.

    Motivation behind the Amendment

    • Godavarman Thirumulkpad Case: A landmark legal case in 1996 influenced the interpretation of forest land and led to the inclusion of private forests under the 1980 law.
    • Industrial Progress: Opposition to the law stemmed from concerns about hindering industrial growth and private landowners’ interests.
    • Debate and Controversy: The Forest (Conservation) Amendment Bill prompted extensive discussions but was passed with limited opposition, raising concerns among indigenous communities and human rights activists.

    Prior Consent and Indigenous Rights

    • Amendments in 2016 and 2017: These stipulated mandatory prior consent from tribal grama sabha for non-forest alterations, a provision now removed.
    • State-Level Engagement: State governments may involve grama sabhas in decisions related to land acquisition but might be cautious due to perceived hindrance to economic initiatives.
    • Impact on Forest Rights Act (FRA): FRA implementation has faced challenges, with governments preferring to limit forest areas rather than amend the Act to address Adivasi claims.

    Compensatory Afforestation Concerns

    • Ambiguities: Past issues with the Compensatory Afforestation Act have arisen from ambiguities and land shortages.
    • Environmental Implications: The new amendment mandates afforestation elsewhere for every parcel of land lost, but lacks specifications, leaving room for discretion.

    Forest Governance and Federal Norms

    • Afforestation vs. Forest Governance: Financial incentives for afforestation projects clash with forest governance principles, and concurrent list governance practices contradict federal norms.
    • Security and Environmental Concerns: While internal environmental security is crucial, it often takes a backseat to external security threats, impacting States prone to natural disasters.

    Conclusion

    • The Forest Conservation Amendment Act of 2023 raises complex issues related to forest governance, indigenous rights, and environmental security.
    • While aimed at addressing critical challenges, its implementation and impact on forest communities warrant careful consideration and debate to ensure a balanced approach to conservation and development.