💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Subject: Governance

Important aspects of Society

  • Women’s political empowerment — more talk, less action

     

    Women's Reservation Bill: A Long Road Ahead - Civilsdaily

    Central Idea

    Political empowerment of women in India faces challenges despite the 2023 women reservation Act, with recent Assembly elections showing inadequate efforts by political parties to field more women candidates.

    Key Highlights:

    • Two routes for women’s political empowerment: legislative reservation and quotas within political parties.
    • Examples from Nepal, Bangladesh, and Pakistan using legislative reservation.
    • Countries like Australia, Canada, South Africa, and Sweden achieve women’s representation without legislatively-backed quotas.
    • In India, the 2023 Act reserves 33% seats for women in State Assemblies and Parliament.
    • Despite the Act, recent Assembly elections show insufficient commitment from political parties.

    Key Challenges:

    • In Madhya Pradesh, BJP and Congress fielded 28 and 30 women candidates, respectively, out of 230 seats after the Act.
    • Telangana sees minimal increase, with BJP and Congress fielding 12 women candidates each out of 119 seats.
    • No party in any state reaches the mandated 33% mark for women candidates.
    • Despite innovative moves like Congress reserving 40% seats in UP in 2022, overall progress is lacking.
    • TMC’s success in Odisha and West Bengal suggests regional parties are more proactive in women’s political representation.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • Act passed in Lok Sabha with significant majority, only two opposing members.
    • In Uttar Pradesh 2022 elections, Congress reserved 40% seats for women, a bold move.
    • BJD and TMC’s success in Odisha and West Bengal elections with more women candidates.

    Critical Analysis:

    • The Act, though commendable, looks good on paper due to its linkage with delimitation after 2026.
    • Regional parties like TMC have shown commitment and won with more women candidates, questioning the reluctance of national parties.

    Way Forward:

    • National and regional parties need to demonstrate genuine commitment to women’s political empowerment by increasing the number of women candidates.
    • Learning from the success of regional parties like TMC, other political entities should actively promote and support women in politics.
    • Continuous monitoring and public discourse can encourage political parties to fulfill their commitment to women’s representation.

    While the enactment of the 2023 women reservation Act is a positive step, recent Assembly elections reveal a gap between legislation and action, with political parties showing reluctance to genuinely empower women in politics. Continuous efforts and monitoring are crucial for bridging this gap and ensuring meaningful representation.

  • Rythu Bandhu Scheme suspended ahead of Elections

    Central Idea

    Rythu Bandhu Scheme: Key Facts

    • The Rythu Bandhu scheme is also known as Farmer’s Investment Support Scheme (FISS).
    • It is a welfare programme for farmers started in 2018 by the Telangana government.
    • Under the scheme, the state government provided the 58 lakh farmers in Telangana with ₹5,000 per acre of their land as a farm investment for two crops.
    • There is no ceiling on the number of acres held by a farmer.
    • So, a farmer who owns two acres of land would receive Rs 20,000 a year, whereas a farmer who owns 10 acres would receive Rs 1 lakh a year from the government.
    • This investment is made twice a year, once for kharif harvest and once for Rabi harvest.
    • It is the country’s first direct farmer investment support scheme where cash is paid directly to the beneficiary.

    Reasons for suspension

    • The election commission had allowed the disbursement of funds for the rabi harvest this season, provided they are not publicised, in accordance with the model code of conduct.
    • However, the model code was violated after the state finance minister made a public announcement of the same.

  • [pib] AAINA Dashboard for Cities

    Central Idea

    • The Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) has introduced the ‘AAINA Dashboard for Cities’ portal (aaina.gov.in).

    About AAINA Dashboard

    • The AAINA Dashboard is envisioned as a permanent platform for ULB-related data, with regular updates.
    • It invites Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) across India to voluntarily share their key data regularly through a user-friendly data entry form on the portal.
    • The primary objectives of the AAINA Dashboard are:
    1. City Benchmarking: Enable cities to assess their performance relative to other cities.
    2. Inspiration: Inspire cities by identifying areas for improvement and showcasing possibilities.
    3. Peer Learning: Promote peer learning and engagement among cities.

    Dashboard Structure

    The AAINA Dashboard will categorize data submitted by ULBs into five key pillars:

    1. Political & Administrative Structure
    2. Finance
    3. Planning
    4. Citizen-Centric Governance
    5. Delivery of Basic Services

    Data Submission Process

    • ULBs will contribute their data, including audited accounts and self-reported performance metrics, by logging into the dashboard’s portal.
    • ULBs will have the flexibility to update their information as needed, ensuring that the dashboard remains a dynamic and up-to-date resource.https://pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=1976720

  • Amplifi 2.0 Portal for Data-Driven Urban Policymaking  

    Central Idea

    • The Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs in India has taken a significant step towards fostering data-driven policymaking by launching the Amplifi 2.0 portal.

    Amplifi 2.0 Portal

    • Amplifi 2.0 stands for Assessment and Monitoring Platform for Liveable, Inclusive, and Future-Ready Urban India portal.
    • It was introduced by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs.
    • This platform aims to provide easy access to raw data from Indian cities, facilitating researchers, academics, and stakeholders in their efforts to formulate informed urban policies.
    • Currently, 258 urban local bodies have been onboarded, and data for 150 cities is accessible on the platform.
    • Objectives:
    1. To make data from all 3,739 municipal corporations accessible through the portal.
    2. Offer a wide range of data, including total consumption, water quality testing, healthcare expenditure, slum population statistics, and road accident fatalities.

    Significance

    • Previously, the Ministry used data provided by civic bodies to rank cities based on four indices.
    • These indices encompassed ease-of-living, municipal performance, climate smart cities assessment, and data maturity assessment.
    • The government plans to release various reports based on subsets of these four indices, shifting towards a more data-centric approach.

  • Why is Bihar demanding the Special Category Status?

    Special Category Status

    Central Idea

    • Recently, Bihar govt passed a resolution seeking Special Category Status (SCS) for the state.
    • This demand comes in light of the revelations from the “Bihar Caste-based Survey, 2022,” which unveiled that nearly one-third of Bihar’s population continues to grapple with poverty.

    Special Category Status (SCS): An Overview

    • Definition: SCS is a classification conferred by the Central government to support the development of states facing geographical or socio-economic disadvantages.
    • Origins: SCS was instituted in 1969, based on the recommendations of the 5th Finance Commission (FC).
    • Criteria: Five criteria are assessed before granting SCS, including factors like hilly terrain, low population density, and economic backwardness.
    • Historical Allocation: Initially, three states—Jammu & Kashmir, Assam, and Nagaland—were granted SCS. Subsequently, eight more states, including Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand, received this status.

    Benefits of having SCS

    • Financial Assistance: SCS states used to receive grants based on the Gadgil-Mukherjee formula, accounting for approximately 30% of total central assistance.
    • Devolution of Funds: Post the abolition of the Planning Commission and the recommendations of the 14th and 15th FCs, SCS assistance has been subsumed into increased devolution of funds for all states (now 41% in the 15th FC).
    • Funding Ratio: SCS states enjoy a favourable 90:10 Centre-State funding split for centrally sponsored schemes, compared to 60:40 or 80:20 for general category states.
    • Additional Incentives: SCS states receive concessions in customs and excise duties, income tax rates, and corporate tax rates to attract investments.

    Why Bihar’s Demand for SCS?

    • Resource Challenges: Bihar attributes its poverty and underdevelopment to limited natural resources, irregular water supply for irrigation, recurring floods in the north, and severe droughts in the south.
    • Industrial Shift: The state’s bifurcation led to the relocation of industries to Jharkhand, creating unemployment and investment voids.
    • Per-Capita GDP: Bihar’s per-capita GDP, at around ₹54,000, consistently ranks among the lowest in India.
    • Welfare Funding: Chief Minister Nitish Kumar asserts that Bihar houses approximately 94 lakh poor families and that SCS recognition would generate about ₹2.5 lakh crore, crucial for funding welfare initiatives over the next five years.

    SCS Demands from Other States

    • Andhra Pradesh: Since its bifurcation in 2014, Andhra Pradesh has sought SCS due to revenue loss post-Hyderabad’s transfer to Telangana.
    • Odisha: Odisha’s appeal for SCS underscores its vulnerability to natural disasters, such as cyclones, and a significant tribal population (around 22%).
    • Central Government’s Response: Despite these demands, the Central government, citing the 14th Finance Commission’s report, which recommended against granting SCS to any state, has consistently rejected them.

    Is Bihar’s Demand Justified?

    • Criteria Fulfillment: Bihar meets most SCS criteria but lacks hilly terrain and geographically difficult areas, crucial for infrastructural development.
    • Alternative Solutions: In 2013, the Raghuram Rajan Committee proposed a ‘multi-dimensional index’ methodology instead of SCS, which could be revisited to address Bihar’s socio-economic challenges effectively.

  • [pib] Ayurveda Gyan Naipunya Initiative (AGNI)

    Central Idea

    • The Central Council for Research in Ayurveda Sciences (CCRAS), under the Ministry of Ayush, has introduced the “Ayurveda Gyan Naipunya Initiative” (AGNI) to promote research and innovation among Ayurveda practitioners.

    Ayurveda Gyan Naipunya Initiative

    • AGNI aims to document and validate Ayurvedic medical practices, enhance evidence-based practice culture, and facilitate scientific research in the field.
    • It provides a platform for Ayurveda practitioners to share their innovative practices, fostering an evidence-based culture.
    • It also supports research to validate pragmatic Ayurvedic practices through scientific methods.

    Key functions

    • CCRAS will document and publish reported medical practices and therapeutic regimens for educational and academic purposes in consultation with the National Commission for Indian System of Medicine (NCISM).
    • AGNI provides a platform for Ayurveda practitioners to report their innovative practices and experiences across various disease conditions.
    • The initiative encourages the culture of evidence-based practice among Ayurveda practitioners, ensuring that their methods are grounded in scientific research.
    • AGNI seeks to identify interested Ayurveda practitioners willing to collaborate in creating a comprehensive database through applications.
    • Capacity building through research methods and good clinical practice training will also be offered.
    • AGNI will undertake research to mainstream pragmatic Ayurvedic practices through scientific validation and evidence-based appraisal.

  • Mosquitofish: India’s Battle against Invasive Species

    Mosquitofish

    Central Idea

    • In recent months, Indian states such as Andhra Pradesh, Odisha, and Punjab have introduced mosquitofish to combat mosquito infestations.
    • However, the unintended ecological consequences of introducing this invasive species have raised concerns.

    Backgrounder: Vector Borne Diseases

    • Global Mosquito-Borne Disease Prevalence: Mosquito-borne diseases affect over 150 countries and 500 million people worldwide.
    • India’s Burden: India alone reports approximately 40 million cases of mosquito-borne diseases annually.

    What is Mosquitofish?

    • Introduction in the 1960s: In the 1960s, biological control methods were adopted to combat mosquitoes, including the introduction of mosquitofish (Gambusia species).
    • Environmental Alternatives: These methods were considered environmentally friendly alternatives to chemical pesticides, which posed health and environmental risks.
    • Global Proliferation: Mosquitofish, originally from the U.S., have now become widespread globally, adapting to various environments with adverse ecological impacts.

    Mosquitofish in India

    • Historical Introduction: In 1928, Gambusia was introduced in India during British rule, mainly for malaria control.
    • Multiple Authorities Involved: Various governmental and private organizations, including the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), National Institute of Malaria Research (NIMR), municipal corporations, and health departments, introduced mosquitofish across India.

    Ecological Impact

    • Invasive Alien Species: Mosquitofish are considered among the hundred most detrimental invasive alien species.
    • Negative Effects: They prey on native fauna, leading to the extinction of native fish, amphibians, and freshwater communities.
    • Examples from Other Countries: Australia and New Zealand have reported similar ecological harm due to introduced mosquitofish.
    • WHO’s Stand: The World Health Organization stopped recommending Gambusia for mosquito control since 1982.

    Current Situation and Recommendations

    • Enforcement Measures: Stringent enforcement measures are essential to prevent further introduction of mosquitofish and mitigate past introductions’ consequences.
    • Alternative Solutions: Collaboration between mosquito biologists, entomologists, invasion ecologists, and fish taxonomists is suggested to identify native fish species capable of controlling mosquito larvae.
    • Local Solutions: Local alternatives should be favored over invasive species to preserve indigenous aquatic biodiversity and native species’ well-being.
    • National Centre for Vector Borne Diseases Control (NCVBDC): The NCVBDC should remove its recommendation for the use of Gambusia and Poecilia (guppy) fishes for mosquito control.

    Conclusion

    • India faces a pressing ecological challenge with the unintended consequences of mosquitofish introduction.
    • To safeguard the environment and native species, stringent enforcement and local solutions should replace invasive species in mosquito control efforts.

  • What elite critics of freebies don’t understand

    SC calls for a panel to inquire Freebies Issue

    Central idea

    Criticism surrounds politicians making empty promises for votes. The debate involves what’s genuinely good for the public versus just offering freebies. The solution suggests caution in promises, financial responsibility, and sticking to clear ideas for long-term success.

    Key Highlights:

    • The editorial criticizes political parties for making “reckless election promises” and engaging in competitive populism.
    • Elite condemnation of “fiscally irresponsible freebies” is a recurring theme in national discourse.
    • The Supreme Court has addressed the issue, expressing concern that freebies may hinder the state government’s ability to provide basic amenities.
    • The RBI also identified the distribution of freebies as a new risk to state finances.

    Key Challenges:

    • The challenge of mass communication in electoral politics is highlighted, emphasizing the need for simple and easily communicable messages.
    • Governance for development is complex, with political and economic contingencies affecting the ability to showcase tangible progress.
    • Excessive reliance on direct benefits erodes the party platform and may lead to a transactional relationship with voters.

    Key Terms and Phrases for adding value to answer:

    • Reckless election promises
    • Competitive populism
    • Fiscally irresponsible freebies
    • Basic amenities
    • Mass communication in electoral politics
    • Governance for development
    • Political economy
    • Direct benefits
    • Transactional arrangement

    Key Facts and Data:

    • The Supreme Court held hearings on a petition to bar parties from promising “irrational freebies from public funds.”
    • The RBI highlighted the “growing preference for distribution of ‘freebies’” as a new risk to state finances.

    Critical Analysis:

    • The editorial raises questions about the definition of public good versus freebies, emphasizing the need for a democratic contestation of these concepts.
    • The challenge of mass communication is explored, pointing out the reliance on simple messages like slogans during political campaigns.
    • Governance for development is considered complex, with obstacles such as time constraints and political economy dynamics.
    • Excessive reliance on direct benefits is criticized for eroding the party platform and creating a transactional relationship with voters.

    Way Forward:

    • The editorial suggests that while direct benefits are a legitimate aspect of building political mandates, party leaders should be cautious not to let these benefits supplant the broader party platform.
    • Emphasizes the importance of maintaining a coherent ideological framework to avoid the depletion of the party platform.
    • Calls for a comprehensive review of relevant trade-offs in state finances to ensure responsible fiscal policies.

  • How the armed forces can be prepared for transgender personnel

    US seeks to learn from allies' experience about transgender troops | LGBTQ+ rights | The Guardian

    Central idea

    The central idea revolves around advocating for the gradual and thoughtful inclusion of transgender individuals in the armed forces. By drawing parallels with successful women integration, proposing protected roles initially, and emphasizing social awareness, the approach aims for a balanced, transparent, and inclusive transformation within the military, recognizing and addressing historical discrimination.

    Key Highlights:

    • Growing Acceptance: People are becoming more accepting of transgender folks, which is a positive change. Society is starting to understand the importance of including everyone, regardless of their gender identity.
    • Recognizing Challenges: We’re acknowledging that transgender individuals have faced a tough time with discrimination, stigma, and fewer opportunities. This recognition is crucial in addressing historical disadvantages.
    • Legal Steps in India: India has taken legal steps, like the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act in 2019, to protect transgender rights. This shows a commitment to making things better since a significant judgment in 2014.
    • Armed Forces Proposal: There’s a suggestion to include transgender individuals in the armed forces. This proposal comes from the realization that they’ve been at a disadvantage and need proactive help to be part of every aspect of life.
    • Stepwise Integration Approach: The idea is to include transgender individuals gradually, just like how women’s roles in the armed forces expanded step by step. This way, we can be sure that we’re ready and set up for their inclusion.
    • Learning from Women’s Inclusion: We’re learning from how women were included in the armed forces. By doing this, we hope to avoid problems and make the integration process smooth and successful.
    • Roles for Transgender Personnel: Transgender individuals might start with roles in medical services and staff positions. Initially, these roles will be more protected to ensure they feel comfortable and respected.
    • Social Awareness Emphasis: There’s a suggestion to make the armed forces more aware of societal justice and the discrimination faced by transgender individuals. This change in mindset is vital for a successful integration.

    Key Challenges:

    • Societal Prejudices: A challenge is dealing with society’s biases within the armed forces. Overcoming these biases is crucial for creating an inclusive environment.
    • Balancing Inclusion with Discipline: We need to be careful about how inclusion might affect the strong discipline and camaraderie in the armed forces. Balancing inclusion with maintaining teamwork is a tricky but necessary challenge.
    • Infrastructure Support: Developing the needed support for transgender individuals is important. This includes making sure the armed forces are ready and equipped for their inclusion.
    • Dignity Concerns: We’re aware of concerns about respecting the dignity and self-respect of transgender individuals. To address this, there’s a proposal for more protected roles initially.

    Key Terms and Phrases:

    • Camaraderie and Discipline: The armed forces have strong bonds based on trust and teamwork. Keeping these bonds intact while embracing diversity is a challenge.
    • Sensitization Road Map: We’re planning a roadmap to sensitize the armed forces at all levels. This means we want everyone to understand and accept the realities of discrimination.
    • Competence and Capabilities: Transgender individuals should be accepted based on their skills and abilities. Competency and capability are what matter most.
    • Sheltered Appointments: Initially, there’s a proposal for more protected roles to make sure transgender individuals feel secure and respected.
    • Aide-de-Camp: Imagining a capable transgender officer in a prestigious role shows the positive impact they can have on perceptions and acceptance.
    • Gradual Integration: Just like how women were gradually included, we’re looking at a step-by-step approach for transgender integration.

    Key Facts and Data:

    • NALSA Judgment as a Legal Milestone: In 2014, there was a significant decision recognizing and protecting transgender rights. This decision set the stage for later legal measures.
    • Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act (2019): In 2019, India took legislative steps to protect transgender rights. These measures show a commitment to making things better.
    • Success of Women in Armed Forces: We’re looking at the achievements of women in the armed forces as a guide for including transgender individuals. Learning from past successes helps us avoid problems.

    Critical Analysis:

    • Acknowledging Historical Discrimination: We’re recognizing that a big change is needed in the armed forces’ way of thinking. This acknowledgment sets the stage for real change.
    • Calibrated Approach to Integration: We’re emphasizing the importance of careful planning and a step-by-step approach. This ensures that inclusion happens smoothly.
    • Learning from Women’s Inclusion: We’re learning from how women were included in the armed forces. This shows a readiness to apply lessons from one integration process to another.
    • Impact on Discipline and Camaraderie: We’re considering how inclusion might affect the unique bonds within the armed forces. This balance is crucial for a successful integration.
    • Recognizing Importance of Social Awareness: We’re identifying the need for the armed forces to understand societal justice. This change in mindset is vital for true and lasting change.

    Way Forward:

    • Advocating Wider Discussions: We’re suggesting more discussions and debates within the armed forces. This ensures that everyone’s perspective is considered.
    • Gradual Expansion of Roles: We’re advocating for more roles based on abilities and merit. This ensures that everyone gets opportunities based on their skills.
    • Involvement of Transgender Community: We’re suggesting that the transgender community should be part of decision-making. This makes sure their views are central to the integration process.
    • Establishing Social Awareness Strategy: We’re emphasizing the need for a strategy to make the armed forces more aware. This ensures that everyone understands and accepts the need for change.
    • Transparent and Just Process: We’re highlighting the importance of openness and fairness in the integration process. This ensures that the process is respectful and just for everyone involved.

  • A fact check unit that is unconstitutional

    Centre's fact-check unit: What is it and how does the Union govt defend it?

    Central idea

    The article critically examines the Government of Tamil Nadu’s establishment of a Fact Check Unit, highlighting constitutional concerns, the potential impact on freedom of speech, and the challenges posed by ambiguity and absence of due process.

    What is fact check unit?

    A Fact Check Unit is an entity or organization tasked with verifying the authenticity and accuracy of information, particularly in the context of news, announcements, policies, schemes, guidelines, and initiatives of a government or other institutions.

    Key Highlights:

    • Establishment of Tamil Nadu Fact Check Unit: The Government of Tamil Nadu issues an order to create a Fact Check Unit for verifying information related to the state government across diverse media platforms.
    • Constitutional Concerns Raised: Assertions about the order violating fundamental rights and being constitutionally vague and arbitrary, particularly emphasizing the potential infringement on freedom of speech.
    • Impact on Freedom of Speech: Examining the implications of the Fact Check Unit on freedom of speech and expression, highlighting the need for reasonable restrictions and challenging the authority of a Government Order in imposing such restrictions.
    • Chilling Effect Analysis: A deeper analysis of the perceived chilling effect on freedom of speech, exploring the implications of the Government acting as the arbiter of information authenticity.

    Press Information Bureau

    Challenges:

    • Scope Ambiguity and Potential Misuse: Critiques the lack of specificity in defining “information related to the Government of Tamil Nadu,” raising concerns about ambiguity and the possibility of misuse.
    • Due Process Absence: Points out the absence of due process, where the Fact Check Unit lacks a mechanism for the author’s hearing, positioning the government as the sole determinant of information authenticity.
    • Legal Limitations on Government Orders: Discusses the legal limitations of Government Orders in imposing restrictions on freedom of speech, underscoring the need for a more nuanced and legislative approach.
    • Global Challenges of Misinformation: Draws parallels with global challenges of misinformation, citing events like the U.S. presidential election, and underscores the necessity for effective measures in addressing this widespread issue.

    Key Phrases for enhancing answer quality:

    • “Chilling effect on freedom of speech”
    • “Unconstitutionally vague and arbitrary”
    • “Opportunity of hearing”
    • “Mis/disinformation and fake news challenge”
    • “Government as judge, jury, and executioner”

    Analysis:

    • Constitutional Implications Explored: In-depth analysis of the constitutional concerns, with a focus on how the Fact Check Unit might impact freedom of speech and questioning the legal standing of a Government Order.
    • Interrogation of Scope Ambiguity: Scrutiny of the ambiguity surrounding the definition of “information related to the Government of Tamil Nadu,” delving into potential implications for various forms of expression.

    Key Facts:

    • US Election and Misinformation Parallel: Drawing parallels with global challenges of misinformation during events like the U.S. presidential election, emphasizing the need for effective measures.

    Way Forward:

    • Stakeholder Consultation Advocacy: Advocacy for comprehensive consultations with stakeholders, including the public and intermediaries, to develop effective measures against misinformation.
    • Global Best Practices Exploration: Encouraging exploration of global best practices, such as the European Commission’s Code of Practice on Disinformation, for a more inclusive and well-informed approach.
    • Media Literacy Promotion Recommendation: Recommending the promotion of media literacy and support for an independent network of fact-checkers as constructive measures to combat misinformation.