💥UPSC 2026, 2027 UAP Mentorship September Batch

[2025 GS1 UPSC MAINS] Does tribal development in India centre around two axes, those of displacement and of rehabilitation? Give your opinion. (15 Marks)

Smash 2025 FLT 05
Q8. Empowerment of tribal communities requires shifting from top-down policies to bottom-up participation. Examine the extent to which current governance models enable this shift.
PYQ
Q. Given the diversities among tribal communities in India, in which specific contexts should they be considered as a single category? (2022)

Tribal communities (8.6% of India’s population, Census 2011) live in resource-rich but economically poor regions. Post-independence, much of India’s developmental trajectory has led to tribal displacement, making rehabilitation the dominant state response.

Tribal Development in India: Displacement and Rehabilitation

Displacement

  • Large Dams & Irrigation Projects – Submergence of tribal villages. Eg– Sardar Sarovar Dam displaced ~40,000 families in Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra.
  • Mining & Industrial Projects – Resource-rich tribal belts face land alienation. Eg– Niyamgiri Hills mining (Odisha) threatened Dongria Kondhs; coal mining in Chhattisgarh displaced Gond tribals.
  • Wildlife & Conservation Policies – Eviction from forests under protected areas. Eg– Tiger Reserves like Kanha, Simlipal, Nagarhole forced relocation of tribal hamlets.
  • Urban Expansion & Infrastructure – Highways, SEZs, power plants displace tribal settlements. Eg– POSCO steel project (Odisha) displaced betel farmers, many from tribal backgrounds.
  • Environmental Projects – Afforestation under CAMPA led to occupation of FRA land. Eg– Chhattisgarh protests (2021) against afforestation on tribal cultivable land.

Rehabilitation

  • Compensation Packages – Land-for-land or cash payments. Eg– Narmada Rehabilitation Policy promised land to displaced families (though implementation was uneven).
  • National Rehabilitation & Resettlement Policy (2007) – Guidelines for humane resettlement, skill training, housing, and livelihood restoration.
  • Forest Rights Act (2006) – Recognition of individual and community rights over forest land. Eg– Dongria Kondhs protected rights against Vedanta mining in Niyamgiri.
  • Livelihood Support – Skill-building, agricultural land allocation, and jobs in development projects. Eg– Coal India’s policy of providing employment to one family member of displaced.
  • Social Infrastructure – Resettlement colonies with housing, schools, healthcare. Eg– Resettlement under R&R for Tehri Dam included townships with basic amenities.

Beyond Displacement and Rehabilitation: Towards Empowerment

  1. Guiding Philosophy: Nehru’s Tribal Panchsheel Policy – Principles included: respect for tribal culture, development along tribal genius, training in self-governance, not over-administering, and building confidence in tribals.
  2. Constitutional Safeguards – Fifth & Sixth Schedules provide self-governance, autonomy in tribal regions.
  3. Legal Empowerment
    • PESA Act, 1996 empowers Gram Sabhas in Scheduled Areas to decide on resources and projects.
    • Forest Rights Act, 2006 secures land and community forest rights.
    • Eg– Dongria Kondhs’ Gram Sabha vetoed Vedanta’s mining project in Niyamgiri Hills (2013).
  4. Socio-Economic Development Schemes – Vanbandhu Kalyan Yojana, TRIFED for minor forest produce, Eklavya Model Residential Schools for education.
  5. Cultural Preservation- Eg– Warli painting (Maharashtra), Gond art (Madhya Pradesh) supported under TRIFED.
  6. Health & Nutrition Focus – Eg– Poshan Abhiyaan with special focus on tribal districts.
  7. Political Representation – Eg– ST reservation in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies; 50% seats in some Panchayats reserved for women, including tribal women.

Way Forward

  1. Livelihood Diversification – Promote eco-friendly livelihoods such as bamboo, lac, honey, eco-tourism, minor forest produce with MSP and market linkages through TRIFED.
  2. Inclusive Development Planning – Institutionalize Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) in all projects affecting tribal areas, ensuring genuine participation.
  3. Climate & Resilience Building – Make tribal communities partners in afforestation, watershed management, and renewable energy projects, linking them with green jobs.
  4. Cultural Tourism Corridors – Develop tribal heritage circuits (like Bastar, Nagaland, Meghalaya) to generate revenue while preserving identity.
  5. Xaxa Committee on Tribal Development (2014) – Recommended protection against alienation, better health and education delivery, and promotion of tribal languages in schooling.
  6. N.C. Saxena Committee on Forest Rights Act (2010) – Recommended simplified claim verification, community forest management, and avoiding forced evictions.

Tribal development in India must move from a “reactive approach of rehabilitation” to a “proactive model of empowerment”. As Verrier Elwin argued, true tribal development means protecting roots while expanding wings.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

JOIN THE COMMUNITY

Join us across Social Media platforms.