💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

GS Paper: GS2

  • China-Vietnam red diplomacy 

    Why in the News?

    Vietnamese President’s recent trip to China seeks to rekindle the historical ties and camaraderie between Mao Zedong and Ho Chi Minh, to strengthen political trust in their bilateral relationship strategically.

    Current Diplomatic Relationship between China and Vietnam:

    • Revived Political Trust: Vietnamese President to Lam’s visit to China sought to revive the historical comradeship between Mao Zedong and Ho Chi Minh.
      • This visit aimed to strategically strengthen political trust and enhance the comprehensive strategic cooperative partnership between the two communist nations.
    • Joint Statement on Cooperation: Both countries reaffirmed their commitment to advancing socialism and expressed their desire to build a “Vietnam-China community with a shared future.”
    • Economic and Strategic Agreements: The visit resulted in 14 agreements covering areas such as connectivity, infrastructure, healthcare, and media.
      • Trade between the two nations remains robust, with China being Vietnam’s largest import market and a significant investor. Bilateral trade in 2023 reached $171.9 billion.

    How do recent events reflect the complexities of Vietnam’s foreign policy towards China?

    • Bamboo Diplomacy: Vietnam’s foreign policy, known as “Bamboo Diplomacy,” is based on flexibility and resilience.
      • It aims to maintain strong ties with multiple global powers, including China, while also hedging its bets with the U.S., India, Russia, and Japan to counterbalance Chinese dominance.
    • Economic Dependence vs. Strategic Hedging: Vietnam’s growing economic interdependence with China, reflected in trade and investment, contrasts with its efforts to hedge against over-reliance by fostering ties with other global players. This balancing act illustrates Vietnam’s pragmatic approach to foreign policy.

    Challenges Vietnam Faces in Maintaining Sovereignty Amid Growing Chinese Influence:

    • Territorial Disputes: The ongoing territorial contestation over the Paracel Islands in the South China Sea poses a significant challenge for Vietnam.
    • Economic Dependence: While Vietnam benefits from economic ties with China, the growing trade deficit and increased Chinese investments create a dependency that could challenge Vietnam’s autonomy in decision-making, especially in strategic areas like infrastructure and connectivity.
    • Strategic Hedging and Sovereignty: Vietnam’s efforts to hedge against Chinese influence through partnerships with the U.S., Japan, and India.

    Note: Hedging refers to a strategic approach taken by a country to safeguard its interests and security in a complex and uncertain environment.

    Way forward:

    • Enhance Bilateral Engagement: India should deepen its strategic partnership with Vietnam through increased economic cooperation, cultural exchanges, and joint defense initiatives.
    • Support Regional Multilateralism: India should actively participate in regional forums and initiatives that promote multilateral cooperation, such as the Quad and ASEAN-led dialogues.

  • Why Chagos Islands matter?

    Why in the News?

    • British Foreign Minister announced that the deal with Mauritius has settled the long-standing dispute over the sovereignty of the Chagos Islands, the UK’s last overseas territory in Africa.
      • The agreement also ensures the long-term future of the Diego Garcia military base, which is jointly operated by the UK and US.

    About Chagos Islands (Archipelago)

    • The Chagos Archipelago is a group of 58 islands located in the Indian Ocean, approximately 500 km south of the Maldives.
    • It is a strategically significant area, with one of its islands, Diego Garcia, serving as a key military base jointly operated by the UK and US.
    • The archipelago has been at the centre of a decades-long sovereignty dispute between the UK and Mauritius.

    Key Deals and Agreements Related to the Chagos Archipelago

    1. British Indian Ocean Territory (BIOT) Formation (1965)

    • The UK established the BIOT, incorporating the Chagos Archipelago.
    • The islands were detached from Mauritius before its independence.
    • Mauritius received a grant of 3 million pounds from the UK as compensation for the detachment.

    2. UK-US Agreement on Diego Garcia (1966)

    • Britain and the US signed a defense agreement, making the BIOT available for joint military purposes.
    • Diego Garcia became a key military outpost due to its strategic location in the Indian Ocean.
    • The land for the military base was acquired in 1967, and in 1971, the plantation on Diego Garcia was shut down.
    • The BIOT administration passed an Immigration Ordinance, which prohibited residents from remaining on the island without a permit. This led to the forced expulsion of around 2,000 Chagossians, many of whom were resettled in Mauritius and the UK.

    3. United Nations and International Court of Justice (ICJ) Involvement

    • 2017: The UN General Assembly requested the ICJ to issue an advisory opinion on the legal status of the Chagos Islands.
    • 2019: The ICJ ruled that the UK’s continued administration of the islands was illegal, and the detachment of the islands from Mauritius in 1965 was not done with the free consent of the Chagossians. The UNGA adopted a resolution calling on the UK to withdraw from the Chagos Archipelago within six months.

    4. UK-Mauritius Agreement (2023)

    • After years of dispute, Mauritius and the UK reached an agreement over the sovereignty of the Chagos Islands.
    • Under this agreement:
      • The UK has ceded its claims over the islands.
      • Mauritius is allowed to implement a resettlement program on the islands, excluding Diego Garcia.
      • The UK retains sovereignty over Diego Garcia, allowing the military base to remain operational for an initial period of 99 years.
      • A new trust fund is being created for the benefit of Chagossians.

    Why did the UK keep Diego Garcia Base?

    • US-UK Defense Agreement: The base is vital for joint military operations, allowing rapid deployment in critical areas.
    • Global Operations Hub: Key for US air and naval missions during conflicts like the Gulf War and War in Afghanistan.
    • Geopolitical Control: Ensures a strong US-UK presence in the Indian Ocean to counteract other powers, especially China.
    • Strategic Location: Diego Garcia monitors the Malacca Strait and other essential global trade routes, especially energy supplies.

    PYQ:

    [2013] Discuss the political developments in Maldives in the last two years. Should they be of any cause of concern to India?

  • What special status is Ladakh seeking?

    Why in the News?

    Climate activist Sonam Wangchuk was detained at the Delhi border on Monday night while leading a group of protesters seeking to petition the Central government for Ladakh’s inclusion in the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution, along with other demands for greater autonomy for the region.

    What is Asymmetrical federalism?

    • Asymmetrical federalism refers to a system where some regions or states within a country have more autonomy or special provisions than others. This contrasts with symmetrical federalism, where all states or regions have equal powers.
    • Example in India: The Indian Constitution follows asymmetrical federalism, where certain regions like those under the Fifth and Sixth Schedules or specific northeastern states have special provisions and greater autonomy compared to other states.

    Which are the other States seeking constitutional safeguards?

    • Ladakh: The Union Territory of Ladakh has seen increasing demands for inclusion in the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution to safeguard its indigenous culture and provide greater autonomy.
    • Arunachal Pradesh: The state has passed a resolution seeking inclusion in the Sixth Schedule to grant more autonomy to its tribal populations.
    • Manipur: The Hill Area Committee in Manipur has also demanded inclusion in the Sixth Schedule for its tribal areas, particularly the ‘Hill areas’.

    Do the Fifth and Sixth schedules grant areas under them more autonomy?

    • Fifth Schedule: Grants special protections to ‘scheduled areas’ in 10 states. These areas are governed by Tribes Advisory Councils (TACs) and Governors, who have the power to regulate land transfers, businesses, and the applicability of laws.
    • Sixth Schedule: Provides greater autonomy to ‘tribal areas’ in four northeastern states (Assam, Meghalaya, Mizoram, and Tripura) through Autonomous District Councils (ADCs).
      • ADCs have more legislative, executive, and financial powers, including the ability to regulate land use, social customs, and taxation.

    Why did the British create provisions for ‘excluded’ and ‘partially excluded’ areas?

    • British Policy of Isolation: To avoid unrest and rebellion among the tribal populations, the British adopted a policy of ‘isolation’ by creating ‘excluded’ and ‘partially excluded’ areas in tribal regions under the Government of India Act, 1935.
    • Excluded Areas: These were mostly in the northeastern hilly regions, where the Governor had the authority to legislate.
    • Partially Excluded Areas: These included tribal regions in Central and Eastern India, where laws from central and provincial legislatures were applicable but with modifications, ensuring minimal interference with tribal customs and governance.

    Conclusion:  The government should initiate meaningful consultations with local stakeholders in regions like Ladakh, Arunachal Pradesh, and Manipur to address concerns about cultural preservation and autonomy, ensuring that any constitutional reforms reflect the aspirations of the indigenous populations.

  • Food safety laws in states

    Why in the News?

    The Uttar Pradesh government has mandated that all food establishments display the names and addresses of their owners and employees. In July, the Supreme Court put a hold on similar orders issued by the governments of Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand.

    What are the regulations for selling food in India? 

    • Licensing and Registration: All food businesses must register with the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) or obtain a license, depending on their scale of operation. Small-scale vendors are classified as “Petty Food Manufacturers” and must register under specific rules.
    • Display Requirements: Food business operators are required to prominently display their FSSAI registration certificate or license, including a photo ID, at their premises or vehicles to inform customers about the legitimacy of the food business.
    • Compliance and Penalties: Non-compliance with the Food Safety and Standards Act (FSSA) can lead to penalties, including fines up to Rs 5 lakh and imprisonment for up to six months. Violators may also receive an Improvement Notice, which could result in license suspension or cancellation if not addressed.

    What powers do states have to make laws in this regard?

    • Authority to Make Rules:
      • Under Section 94(1) of the FSSA, state governments can make rules for food safety after obtaining prior approval from the FSSAI.
      • Section 94(2) specifies areas where states can legislate, such as additional functions of the Commissioner of Food Safety and other matters requiring state-level rules.
    • Implementation: The Commissioner of Food Safety, appointed by the state government, is responsible for ensuring the efficient implementation of food safety regulations.
    • Legislative Approval: Any rules made by the state government must be presented before the state legislature for approval (Section 94(3)).

    Can a state government’s directives under FSSA be challenged in court?

    • Grounds for Challenge: Previous orders from UP and Uttarakhand were contested on grounds that they discriminated against individuals based on religion or caste, violating constitutional rights under Articles 15(1) and 19(1)(g).
    • Judicial Precedent: In July 2023, the Supreme Court ruled that only competent authorities under the FSSA could issue such directives, limiting police powers in this context

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthening Regulatory Framework: There is a need to enhance the regulatory framework by clarifying the roles and responsibilities of state governments and the FSSAI.
    • Engaging Stakeholders and Public Awareness: The government should engage with food business operators, consumers, and public health experts to foster better understanding and compliance with food safety regulations.

  • Preparing for the next pandemic: what NITI Aayog report says

    Why in the News?

    Four years after the onset of Covid, an expert group formed by NITI Aayog has proposed the establishment of a comprehensive framework to handle future public health emergencies or pandemics effectively.

    Lessons Learned from COVID-19:

    • Gaps in Legal Frameworks: Existing laws like the Epidemic Diseases Act (1897) and National Disaster Management Act (2005) were insufficient for handling large-scale health emergencies. These laws lack clarity on definitions of epidemics and provisions for managing public health crises, drug distribution, and quarantine measures.
    • Delayed Response and Coordination: The COVID-19 pandemic exposed weaknesses in coordination between central and state governments, highlighting the need for a more organized response mechanism.
    • Inadequate Surveillance: Insufficient disease surveillance and early warning systems delayed the identification of threats. The role of zoonotic diseases, especially viruses linked to bat species, underscored the need for better monitoring of human-animal interactions.

    What specific recommendations does the NITI Aayog report make?

    • Enactment of PHEMA: Introduce the Public Health Emergency Management Act for a more robust legal framework to manage pandemics and other health emergencies.
    • Empowered Group of Secretaries (EGoS): Establish a central committee to oversee pandemic preparedness, governance, R&D, surveillance, and response efforts.
    • Strengthened Disease Surveillance: Create a national biosecurity and biosafety network and monitor human-animal interfaces, especially for zoonotic diseases.
    • Emergency Vaccine Bank: Develop a stockpile of vaccines for rapid access during health crises, sourced domestically or internationally.
    • Early Warning and Research Network: Build a forecasting and modelling network, along with Centres of Excellence (CoEs) to advance research on priority pathogens and preparedness.

    How can India enhance its pandemic preparedness framework? (Way forward)

    • Strengthening Legal and Institutional Frameworks: Enact a Public Health Emergency Management Act (PHEMA) and establish an Empowered Group of Secretaries for coordinated pandemic response.
    • Enhancing Surveillance and Early Warning Systems: Build a robust disease surveillance network, biosecurity system, and epidemiology forecasting for early detection and response to outbreaks.
    • Investing in Health Infrastructure and Vaccine Stockpiles: Develop public health cadres, boost healthcare infrastructure, and create an emergency vaccine bank for rapid deployment during health crises.

  • In France, a summit for diplomacy, tech and diversity

    Why in the News?

    France is set to host more than 100 heads of state, government leaders, and senior officials for the 19th Francophonie Summit on October 4-5, 2024.

    How can Technology Enhance Diplomatic Efforts Between India and France?

    • Digital Collaboration: The summit emphasizes cooperation in digital technology, which can strengthen ties through joint projects, knowledge sharing, and innovation in areas like AI and cybersecurity.
    • Facilitating Communication: Technology, particularly AI, can enhance communication between diplomats and stakeholders, enabling more efficient exchanges and negotiations in multiple languages.
    • Showcasing Innovations: Events like the FrancoTech Fair will provide platforms for Indian and French innovators to collaborate on addressing common challenges, fostering deeper bilateral relations through shared technological advancements.

    What Role Does Diversity Play in Shaping Diplomatic Strategies?

    • Cultural Exchange: Emphasizing multilingualism and cultural diversity fosters mutual understanding and strengthens relationships, allowing for more nuanced diplomatic interactions.
    • Inclusive Decision-Making: Acknowledging diverse perspectives helps create more representative and effective diplomatic strategies, ensuring that various stakeholders are considered in negotiations.
    • Promotion of Values: Embracing diversity aligns with the core values of democracy and human rights, which can enhance the credibility and appeal of diplomatic efforts.

    What are the Implications of Global Cooperation in Addressing Contemporary Issues?

    • Shared Responsibility: Global cooperation is essential for addressing challenges like climate change, health crises, and digital governance, promoting collective action and resource sharing among nations.
    • Strengthening Multilateral Institutions: Enhancing cooperation leads to reforms in institutions like the UN, World Bank, and IMF, making them more effective and responsive to global needs.
    • Fostering Innovation: Collaborative efforts among nations can drive innovation in technology and policy, enabling quicker and more effective responses to pressing global issues and facilitating knowledge exchange.

    Way forward: 

    • Establish Joint Innovation Initiatives: India and France should create collaborative platforms for research and development in emerging technologies, focusing on areas like AI, cybersecurity, and digital infrastructure to enhance diplomatic relations and tackle common global challenges.
    • Promote Multicultural Diplomatic Engagement: Both nations should prioritize cultural exchanges and inclusive dialogue that reflect diverse perspectives, thereby strengthening mutual understanding and fostering more effective and representative diplomatic strategies.

  • [2nd October 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The Waqf Bill 2024 is one that needs review

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q). “The diverse nature of India as a multi-religious and multi-ethnic society is not immune to the impact of radicalism which is seen in her neighborhood? Discuss along with strategies to be adopted to counter this environment. (UPSC CSE 2014)

    Q). What are the challenges to our cultural practices in the name of Secularism? (UPSC CSE 2019)

    Q). Customs and traditions suppress reason leading to obscurantism. Do you agree? (UPSC CSE 2020)

    Q). Are tolerance, assimilation, and pluralism the key elements in the making of an Indian form of secularism? Justify your answer. (UPSC CSE 2022)

    Mentor’s Comment:  Sometimes, the religious sentiments among the public infringes the very particulates of the secular governance. The Waqf (Amendment) Bill 2024 has also sparked same controversy in India, particularly among the Muslim community and various political leaders. Critics argue that the bill threatens the autonomy of Waqf properties, which are religious endowments, by increasing government control and including non-Muslim members in Waqf boards.

    However, the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) reviewing the bill received an overwhelming response from the public, with conflicting reports on the number of suggestions submitted that ranged from 1.25 crore to 5 crore, which prompted some government officials to question the legitimacy of this feedback. In today’s editorial, we will have a look at more extra edges that we need to consider while drafting this new law for the Waqf Boards all over India.

    _

    Let’s learn!

    Why in the News?

    The Waqf (Amendment) Bill 2024 has sparked significant controversy in India, particularly among the Muslim community and various political leaders.

    • The Fundamental Rights enshrined in Part III of the Constitution, prohibits the state from enacting laws that infringe religious rights, declaring any such laws void.
    • However, this freedom is subject to considerations of public order, morality, and health, allowing for state intervention only when necessary to maintain societal harmony.
    What does the Indian Constitution say about Religious freedom?

    • Article 26 guarantees every religious denomination the right to manage its affairs, including the establishment of religious institutions and the ownership of property.
    •  Also, as in Article 13(2), the state is forbidden to make any law that takes away or abridges the rights conferred by this Part, declaring that any law made in contravention of this clause shall be void.

    What are the criticisms faced by the Waqf Bill 2024?

    • Potential Misuse of the Power: The bill proposes 44 amendments to the existing Waqf Act of 1995, including the replacement of Waqf tribunals with District Collectors for property disputes. The opponents labeled this as a politically motivated move to weaken the Muslim community.
    • Threatens the Religious Autonomy: The Religious Endowments Act, of 1863 says that the ‘members of the said committee shall be appointed from among persons professing the religion for religious establishments”. Secondly, the UP’s Sri Kashi Vishwanath Temple Act, 1983 provides that no non-Hindu is eligible to be a member of its management at any level.
      • However, the Minority Affairs Ministry has proposed through the Waqf Bill 2024 that two member seats each in the Central Waqf Council and all the State Waqf Boards be reserved for ‘non-Muslims’.
      • The All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) and other organizations have mobilized against the bill, claiming it undermines constitutional rights and could exacerbate communal tensions
    • Lack of Consultation: The Justice Rajinder Sachar Committee spent 18 months gathering data to draft the Waqf (Amendment) Act 2013, which strengthened the Waqf law in India. Unlike previous committees, the current Ministry did not engage with key stakeholders such as the Central Waqf Council or Muslim organizations before drafting the bill.

    Why the reconstitution of CWC is necessary?

    The Ministry is urged to quickly reconstitute the Central Waqf Council (CWC) according to existing waqf laws to oversee data collection from states. For two years, it needs to monitor state Waqf Boards and manage waqf properties closely that have been hindered so far. The reasons are as follows:

    • Membership Changes: The 2024 Bill proposes reducing Muslim membership in the CWC and State Waqf Boards from 100% to less than 50%, raising concerns about community representation.
    • Legal Concerns: The Bill aims to remove the requirement for CWC officials to be Muslim, contradicting constitutional rights related to religious management.
    • Women’s Representation: Confusion exists over the proposal for female representation in the CWC, which was already established in a previous amendment.
    • Re-registration Requirement: Existing waqfs must re-register under a new government-controlled portal, risking legal rights for those who fail to comply.
    • Removal of Donor’s Will: The Bill proposes discontinuing the mandatory implementation of the donor’s will, compromising existing waqf governance.

    Way Forward: The Waqf (Amendment) Bill 2024 represents a significant shift in the governance and management of Waqf properties in India. As the Bill undergoes review, stakeholders must ensure that it balances the need for reform with the preservation of community rights and interests, fostering a system that genuinely serves its intended religious and charitable purposes.

    https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/the-waqf-bill-2024-is-one-that-needs-review/article68706813.ece

  • Special Gram Sabhas on Gandhi Jayanti

    Why in the News?

    The Ministry of Panchayati Raj is organizing special Gram Sabhas across 750 Gram Panchayats on 2nd October 2024, marking Gandhi Jayanti.

    Vision to Achieve Gram Swaraj Through People’s Participation

    • These special Gram Sabhas will embody Mahatma Gandhi’s vision of Gram Swaraj—a vision of self-reliant villages driven by people’s participation in decision-making.
    • It emphasizes community-led governance, where elders, women, and youth collaborate to develop Gram Panchayat Development Plans (GPDP).

    Lal Bahadur Shastri’s Legacy

    • The event also coincides with the birth anniversary of Lal Bahadur Shastri, India’s second Prime Minister.
    • Shastri championed the values of simplicity, self-reliance, and community development.
    • Shastri’s slogan, “Jai Jawan, Jai Kisan,” emphasized the strength of India’s rural economy and its farmers, making his vision a key component of this grassroots initiative.

    About Gram Sabha

    Details
    Role and Significance • Centerpiece of the Panchayati Raj system
    • Responsible for village development and local governance
    Constitutional Provision • Defined under Article 243(b) of the Indian Constitution
    • Primary body in the Panchayati Raj system
    • A permanent body
    Members • Individuals above 18 years of age
    • Must be residing in the village
    • Listed in the electoral rolls
    Meetings • Must meet 2 to 4 times annually as per State Panchayat Raj Acts
    • Common meeting dates:
    1. Republic Day (26th Jan)
    2. Labour Day (1st May)
    3. Independence Day (15th Aug)
    4. Gandhi Jayanti (2nd Oct)
    • Panchayats may choose other dates for meetings
    Organizing Body • Organized by the Panchayat Secretary (Gram Sevak)
    • Done with approval of the Sarpanch
    Conditions for Convening • 10% of members or 50 people (whichever is greater) can request a meeting
    • A written request must be submitted 5 days prior to the meeting
    Decision-Making Process • All decisions of the Panchayat require the approval and validation of the Gram Sabha
    Purpose • Discuss local governance and development issues
    • Make need-based plans for the village

     

    PYQ:

    [2012] In the areas covered under the Panchayat (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996, what is the role/power of Gram Sabha?

    1. Gram Sabha has the power to prevent alienation of land in the Scheduled Areas.
    2. Gram Sabha has the ownership of minor forest produce.
    3. Recommendation of Gram Sabha is required for granting prospecting licence or mining lease for any mineral in the Scheduled Areas.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    (a) 1 only

    (b) 1 and 2 only

    (c) 2 and 3 only

    (d) 1, 2 and 3

  • Who is an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI)?

    Why in the News?

    Following complaints from Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card holders about being reclassified as “foreigners,” the Ministry of External Affairs clarified, that no changes have been made to the rules governing OCI status.

    About Overseas Citizen of India (OCI)

    Details
    About
    • OCI scheme, introduced in August 2005, allows Persons of Indian Origin (PIOs) who were citizens of India after January 26, 1950 or were eligible for Indian citizenship on that date, to register for OCI status.
    • Serves as a form of dual citizenship for the Indian diaspora.
    • The Ministry of Home Affairs defines an OCI.
    OCI Card Benefits OCI cardholders receive a multiple-entry, life-long visa to visit India and are exempt from registering with local authorities for extended stays.
    Population (as of 2023) USA: 16.8 lakh > UK: 9.34 lakh > Australia: 4.94 lakh> Canada: 4.18 lakh
    Recent Rules (2021 Notification)
    • OCI card holders need permission to visit protected, restricted, or prohibited areas.
    • Special permits are also required for activities such as conducting research, undertaking missionary or journalistic work, and visiting areas like Jammu & Kashmir.
    OCI vs NRI Rights Under the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) 2003, OCI card holders are now on par with foreign nationals regarding economic, financial, and educational rights, reversing earlier parity with NRIs.
    Significant Changes to OCI Rules
    • 2005: Lifelong visas and exemption from FRRO registration
    • 2007: Parity with NRIs for inter-country adoption and domestic airfare
    • 2009: Parity with NRIs for entry fees to monuments and professions like doctors and architects
    Eligibility Restrictions
    • Individuals with parents or grandparents from Pakistan or Bangladesh cannot apply for an OCI card.
    • Foreign military personnel (retired or active) are also not eligible.
    Spouse Eligibility Spouses of Indian citizens or OCI card holders, whose marriage has been registered for at least two years, can apply for an OCI card.
    OCI Card Restrictions
    • OCI card holders cannot vote, hold constitutional positions, or be elected as a members of Parliament or Legislative Assembly.
    • They are also restricted from holding government employment in India.

     

    PYQ:

    [2021] With reference to India, consider the following statements: (2021)

    1. There is only one citizenship and one domicile.
    2. A citizen by birth only can become the Head of State.
    3. A foreigner once granted citizenship cannot be deprived of it under any circumstances.

    Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    (a) 1 only
    (b) 2 only
    (c) 1 and 3
    (d) 2 and 3

  • Was animal fat present in Tirupati laddus?

    Why in the News?

    The ghee samples used by ‘Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams’ for ritual offerings and ‘Laddu Prasadam’ were found to contain foreign fats, including fish oil, beef tallow, and lard, as per the NDDB’s analysis report.

    What did the ALF of the National Dairy Development Board find in the Tirupati laddus?

    • The Centre for Analysis and Learning in Livestock and Food (CALF) of the National Dairy Development Board found that ghee samples supplied to the Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD) for preparing laddus were adulterated with various fats.
    • Adulterants detected included:
      • Plant-based fats: soybean, sunflower oil, rapeseed oil, linseed, wheat germ, maize germ, cotton seed, coconut, and palm kernel fat.
      • Animal-based fats: fish oil, beef tallow, and lard (pig fat).

    Existing Laws:

    • The Indian Penal Code (1860) penalizes food adulteration under Section 272, but penalties are often minimal, leading to insufficient deterrence.
    • The Food Safety and Standards Act, of 2006 aims to consolidate food safety regulations, but implementation remains weak due to inadequate resources and oversight.

    Implementation Gaps:

    • Despite robust standards set by the FSSAI, the actual enforcement is lacking. For instance, many tests that could detect sophisticated forms of adulteration are only sometimes conducted due to a lack of testing facilities and trained personnel.
    • A study by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) highlighted that major brands of honey were found to be adulterated with undetectable syrups, raising concerns about the effectiveness of current testing protocols.

    Why maintaining a good baseline data (specific to Indian conditions) is necessary?

    • Biological Variation in Indian Cows: Baseline data specific to Indian cows is needed for accurate results. Indian cows may have different genetic and biochemical profiles compared to European cows, meaning the existing international standards for detecting adulteration (like the ‘s-values’) may not accurately reflect the composition of Indian cow ghee.
    • Adulterants Unique to Local Conditions: The types of adulterants commonly used in India, such as certain vegetable oils or animal fats, may differ from those in other regions. Establishing baseline data for Indian adulterants would improve the precision of detecting the specific types of foreign fats used in India.
    • Accurate Interpretation of Results: Without specific data on the composition of Indian cow ghee, it becomes difficult to interpret the results from methods like gas chromatography. Customized baseline data ensures that the detection methods yield accurate and meaningful conclusions in the Indian context.

    Way forward: 

    • Strengthen Enforcement Mechanisms: Increase resources for testing facilities and train personnel to implement FSSAI standards more effectively, ensuring regular checks for sophisticated adulteration.
    • Develop India-Specific Testing Protocols: Create testing standards based on baseline data specific to Indian cows and local adulterants to improve accuracy in detecting food adulteration.