India had seen one of the worst food disaster in 1943, that was known as Bengal Famine. Things were not so great after Independence either and in 1961, we were again on the brink of mass famine. This is where we called upon a US agro-scientist Norman Borlaug, who is also called the father of green revolution to seek his help & secure India’s food output.
This is where Indira Gandhi and M.S. Swaminathan come into picture – a heavily government backed programme which delivered the much critical food security and sufficiency at a time of great peril.
In comes HVY (high-yielding varieties) of wheat and India transformes from “a begging bowl to a bread basket”. Punjab is frequently cited as the Green Revolution’s most celebrated success story. Yet, far from bringing prosperity, two decades of the Green Revolution have left the Punjab riddled with discontent and violence
Whoaah, what were the negative impacts of Green Revolution in India?
#1. The Myth of High Yields: The term “high-yielding varieties” was a misnomer, because it implies that the new seeds are high yielding of themselves. But these HYV seeds were more like “high responsive varieties” as they highly responsive to certain key inputs such as fertilizers and irrigation water.
In the absence of additional inputs of fertilizers and water, the new seeds perform worse than indigenous varieties
#2. Loss of Diversity: If and when you study Environment and Biodiversity, you will realise the importance of diversity. Green revolution hampered it in two ways –
- It replaced mixtures and rotations of crops like wheat, maize, millets, pulses and oil seeds with monocultures of wheat and rice
- The introduced wheat and rice varieties came from a very narrow genetic base
#3. Increasing Pesticide Use/ Fertilizer use: This follows naturally from the point #1. While this did give a boost to manufacturing sector (those who produced fertilisers), it killed the soil. This is the reason why Eco Survey talks about indiscriminate use of urea and the need for soil health cards. Read this amazing backgrounder on Soil Health Card and the backgrounder on Fertilisers and the Challenge of Reform. There are some amazing infographics inside!
Fair enough, so what did we do next? Did we call for a revised Green Revolution and how did it shifted the policy making in India?
Here’s where this National Food Security Mission steps in + Call for a Second Green Revolution in India. We will focus the rest of the write up on National Food Security Mission only.
All that you need to know on National Food Security Mission
- The National Food Security Mission is a Centrally sponsored scheme and was launched in the year 2007
- Main Focus Areas (at the time of launch): Increase the production of rice, wheat and pulses by 10, 8 and 2 million tonnes respectively by the end of 11th Plan
- How was it to be achieved? (you will see hints of undoing the cons of green revolution)
- Area expansion and productivity enhancement;
- Restoring soil fertility and productivity;
- Creating employment opportunities; and
- Enhancing farm level economy
- Fast Forward to 12th Plan (2012-2017), the mission and targets have changed:
- Additional production of 25 million tonnes of food grains comprising of 10 million tonnes rice, 8 million tonnes of wheat, 4 million tonnes of pulses and 3 million tonnes of coarse cereals (coarse cereals are new entrants!)
- Promotion of commercial crops like cotton, jute & sugarcane (note this too – could be a prelims question!)
Here are the 5 components of NFSM
- NFSM- Rice (implemented in 194 districts of 25 states)
- NFSM-Wheat (in 126 districts of 11 states)
- NFSM-Pulses: (in 622 districts of all 27 States) This mission is further supplemented by Accelerated Pulses Production Program (A3P). India is biggest producer of pulses at 25% of world’s production and still it has to import pulses. This is mainly because of low yields. A3P aims at Integrated Nutrient Management and Plant protection to enhance yields and productivity.
- NFSM-Coarse cereals
- NFSM-Commercial Crops
Note: All states were not covered during 11th plan for NFSM.
So, basically we keep on reviewing the performance of our active missions and include more districts, states into the plan. Seems logical right? Whenever such upgrades take place, we also deploy some best practices. And you will find that such best practices aim at correcting the errors of First Green Revolution. Hope this helps you tie up the basics else Agricultural economics largely lacks that glamour which let’s say Rajan Economics had 😉
Note: If you have some agricultural background, please feel motivated to share more insights. Most of the UPSC aspirants never had a first hand interaction with the fields of India hence we sometime lack the appreciation.
This sorts of finish the tidbits on NFSM. Now, here’s an interesting question which might trouble you from time to time as you study these schemes in greater details.
What is the difference between Centrally Sponsored Schemes and Central Sector Schemes?
Differences arise due to 2 things –
- Pattern of funding
- Implementation strategy
#1. Centrally Sponsored Scheme (sponsor = take it as some discount from sarkar)
- Certain % is borne by states like: 50:50, 60:40, 90:10
- Mainly formulated on subjects from the State List
- Funding Route: Transferred directly to State/ District Level Autonomous Bodies/Implementing Agencies
- Implemented by: State Govt.
#2. Central Sector Schemes (sab kuch sarkar par)
- 100% by Union government
- Implemented by: Central Government Machinery
- Mainly formulated on subjects from the Union List
- Schemes directly implemented in States/UTs but resources are not generally transferred to states
- Can you please give some examples of schemes under these 2 categories?
It is usually recommended that you read the preface of a novel before you dive headlong into the chapters. Helps you get the flavour of what’s to come. Likewise, spend next 1 minute in understanding the organisation structure of the Ministry of Agriculture & Farmer Welfare. These departments often come in news directly or by virtue of some attached office and a brief familiarity is good to have!
Departments under Min. Of Agriculture & Farmer Welfare
- Department of Agriculture, Co-operation and Farmers Welfare (DAC&FW):
- Major department – has five attached offices and twenty-one subordinate offices
- Further, one Public Sector Undertakings, nine autonomous bodies, ten national-level cooperative organizations and two authorities work under its administrative control!
- Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying & Fisheries (DAHD&F)
- Department of Agricultural Research and Education (DARE):
- This department manages the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) and you will keep on hearing about ICAR in news as it innovates on a lot of things.
Now that you know this, let’s spend next 4 minutes in understanding an important attached office of DAC&FW
[Tidbits] Why is Directorate of Economics & Statistics (DES) so important?
- The Directorate provides statistical inputs to DAC&FW, CACP
- Coordinates with international bodies such as the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) on global efforts to improve agricultural statistics
- The DES releases 4 advance estimates and final estimates of area, production and yield in respect of major food grains, oilseeds, sugarcane and fibres.
- Provides Agricultural Market Information System (AMIS) initiative of the G20 members of agriculture
UPSC is notorious for asking about such initiatives like AMIS & associated partners (G20).
Do we really have to go into such great details? Not really. Don’t overburden yourself. Infact just read it once and pray to god that you retain the name. UPSC asks such tidbits type questions in PRELIMS. It keeps an eye on some important department/ directorate and frames a very easy question (provided you know basic info!)
That’s all for the second lesson. We move onto next in a few days only if I know that this helped you in some practical way. And the best way to show that is by commenting and sharing this blog post 🙂
References: Apart from extensive research around news articles, the mainstay of this series is the annual report of the Ministry of Agriculture to the GOI –Click to download a copy
All articles in this series are listed here – First timers to IAS Prep? Prepare Indian Agriculture for GS Mains with me!