Why in the News
Estimates of how many Indians are poor now range from about 5% to more than 26%, depending on which poverty line and method is used. For more than a decade India has had no official consumption-based poverty number, and the 2022-23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) now gives fresh data to set one.
What is a poverty line, and why do estimates differ so widely?
- Poverty line: A poverty line is the monthly spending per person below which a household counts as poor. It works like a pass mark: move it, and the share who fail changes.
- Higher lines, higher poverty: Most of the gap comes from the lines themselves, because a higher threshold counts far more people as poor.
- Method matters: One camp takes an old line and adjusts it for inflation. The other rebuilds the line from spending patterns in the latest survey.
- World Bank lines: These use purchasing power parity (PPP) dollars, which compare currencies by what they buy. They are not built on a basket of Indian basic needs.
- The takeaway: Where the line is drawn decides how much economic insecurity the country sees.
What do the latest estimates say for 2022-23?
- World Bank extreme poverty line: At $3 a day, 2.6% of Indians were poor.
- World Bank lower middle-income line: At $4.20 a day, the same year’s figure jumps to around 16.1%.
- SBI Research: Adjusting the Tendulkar line for inflation gives poverty of 7.2% in rural and 4.6% in urban India.
- Rangarajan and Dev (2014): An inflation-adjusted Rangarajan Committee line gives 10.8%.
- Sethu, Surya and Ruthu (2024): Rebuilding the Rangarajan method from the latest survey gives 26.4%.
How did India’s poverty line evolve, and why is there no official number now?
- Calorie norms: The Alagh Task Force (1979) set separate minimum calorie norms for rural and urban populations.
- Lakdawala Committee: It refined the approach with State-specific poverty lines and price indices.
- Tendulkar Committee (2009): It dropped the direct calorie method for a wider consumption basket that counted spending on health and education. Critics found its thresholds too low.
- Rangarajan Committee: It proposed higher lines for the same year, 2011-12, raising the poverty estimate.
- Missing data: The 2017-18 consumption survey was never published, leaving researchers to rely on reconstructed estimates.
What does multidimensional poverty add, and what does a low count hide?
- Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI): It measures deprivation in health, education and living standards, such as sanitation, drinking water and housing, which consumption alone misses.
- NITI Aayog decline: NITI Aayog puts multidimensional poverty at 14.96% in 2019-21, a sharp fall.
- Projected, not measured: NITI Aayog’s 11.28% figure for 2022-23 is a projection from earlier trends, not the result of a fresh survey.
- Other MPI estimates: For the same period the World Bank puts it at 15.5% and the Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI) at 16.4%.
- Upper middle-income line: Four in five Indians lived below the World Bank’s $8.3-a-day line, yet average daily income per person is over three times that. A low extreme-poverty count masks deep inequality.
Challenges
- No credible benchmark: Without an official line, India cannot say how much poverty has fallen or how much remains.
- Stale baskets: Inflation-adjusting an old line ignores what households now need to spend on.
- Basic services gap: 30% of Indians still lack access to basic sanitation.
Way Forward
- New official poverty line: The Union government should set a line built on the 2022-23 HCES and current spending patterns.
- Fixed survey calendar: The statistics ministry should release consumption surveys on a fixed schedule, whatever their results.
- Twin indicators: Report consumption poverty alongside a freshly surveyed MPI, so each checks the other.
- Vulnerability tracking: Track those living just above the line, not only those below it.
Conclusion
Poverty in India has fallen sharply, but without an agreed line the country cannot measure how far, or how many remain insecure. Whether the Union government adopts a new official poverty line from the latest consumption survey is the decision to watch.
Key numbers
- State Bank of India (SBI) Research lines (Tendulkar-based): about Rs 1,632 (rural) and Rs 1,944 (urban) per person a month.
- Sethu, Surya and Ruthu lines: Rs 2,515 and Rs 3,639 per person a month.
- Official estimates for 2011-12: Tendulkar Committee 21.9%; Rangarajan Committee 29.5%.
- NITI Aayog MPI, 2015-16: 24.85%.
- World Bank lines: 2021 PPP; the $8.3 figure is for 2023.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2020, GS2, 15 marks] “The incidence and intensity of poverty are more important in determining poverty based on income alone”. In this context analyse the latest United Nations Multidimensional Poverty Index Report.”