Why in the News
West Bengal’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls gave deleted voters a right to appeal, but voters left “under adjudication” are neither on the roll nor deleted, so they can neither appeal nor vote. Over 25,000 such voters remain in minority-dominated Murshidabad, Malda, Nadia and Howrah, and officials are unsure of the total.
How did the Bengal SIR move from re-verification to appeals?
- What the SIR is: An SIR is a time-bound, house-to-house re-check of the electoral roll, the list of people entitled to vote. It is like a fresh roll call, not an update of the old list.
- Logical discrepancies: After the first round of deletions, the Election Commission of India (ECI) flagged about 60 lakh voters on the roll for “logical discrepancies”, mismatches in their records.
- Judicial adjudication: The Supreme Court then ordered judicial officers to decide these voters’ eligibility. About 32 lakh names were added back and 27 lakh deleted.
- Appellate tribunals: On March 20, the Court ordered appellate tribunals so that deleted voters could appeal. 17 tribunals now hear these cases.
- The takeaway: The appeal route opens only after a decision, so a voter whose case was never decided has no remedy at all.
Who is stuck, and what has it cost them?
- Undecided cases: These voters attended hearings in December 2025 or January, but their cases were never disposed of. They sit outside both the roll and the tribunal process.
- Booth-level scale: In one Samserganj booth, 62% of voters remain under adjudication. In one Farakka polling part, the share is nearly 60%.
- Lost vote: Affected voters could not vote in this year’s Assembly elections. One schoolteacher on poll duty could not cast her own vote.
- Cost of going to court: Officials told booth-level officers (BLOs) to approach the courts, but many families cannot afford a lawyer.
Who is responsible for clearing the backlog?
- Login reactivation: On October 29, the Additional Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) asked District Election Officers (DEOs) to restore judicial officers’ login IDs to decide pending cases. A status report was due by November 3.
- Only judges can act: The CEO’s office says judicial officers did not properly dispose of these cases, and court orders bar it from acting. It has informed the Calcutta High Court and the ECI.
- Tribunal backlog: In September, the ECI told the Supreme Court that only 1.26 lakh of 38.31 lakh appeals had been disposed of.
- Political blame: The Trinamool Congress, the Congress and the Communist Party of India (Marxist) blame the Centre and the ECI. The Congress calls it “targeted exclusion”, and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) says the ECI must answer.
Challenges
- No deadline for decisions: Nothing fixes how long a voter may remain under adjudication, so a case can stay open indefinitely.
- Remedy gap: The appeal route covers only decided cases, leaving undecided voters with no forum short of a court petition.
- Diffused accountability: The CEO’s office points to judicial officers and the courts, so no single authority owns the backlog.
Way Forward
- Time-bound disposal: The Calcutta High Court should direct judicial officers to decide pending cases within a fixed period.
- Interim inclusion: Keep a voter on the roll while the case stays undecided beyond a set deadline.
- Direct tribunal access: Allow undecided voters to approach the appellate tribunals.
- Public tracking: The ECI should publish booth-wise counts of pending adjudication cases.
Conclusion
Bengal’s SIR built a remedy for voters wrongly deleted but none for voters the process never decided. Whether judicial officers clear these cases, and whether the courts set a deadline for doing so, will decide when these voters regain their franchise.
Key numbers
- Roll size: 7.66 crore when the SIR began (October 27, 2025); 7.04 crore after Absent, Shifted, Deceased or Duplicate deletions.
- Adjudication order: Supreme Court, February 2026.
- Samserganj, Booth No. 44, Ward No. 21: 590 of 949 voters under adjudication.
- Farakka, Part 192: 799 of 1,372 voters under adjudication.
- Appeals filed: 22.21 lakh by deleted voters; 16.10 lakh against inclusion of others.
Back2Basics: Legal basis of an electoral roll revision
- Article 324: Gives the ECI superintendence, direction and control over the preparation of electoral rolls.
- Section 21(3), Representation of the People Act, 1950: Lets the ECI order a special revision of the rolls at any time, for reasons recorded.
- Roll freeze: Under Section 23(3), the roll freezes on the last date of nominations, so a later decision cannot restore a vote for that election.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2026, GS2, 10 marks] Is the right to vote a fundamental right? Discuss the position of the Election Commission of India while undertaking the revision of electoral rolls. Can it also examine the question of citizenship of voters?”