Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Why in the News

A resolution plan backed by 95.09% of lenders’ votes and approved by a tribunal is not final if it fails to pay dissenting financial creditors as the law requires. The Supreme Court has upheld the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal’s (NCLAT) order sending Twinstar Technologies’ Rs 2,962-crore plan for 13 Videocon group firms back to the lenders. It also held that tribunals cannot rewrite a defective plan themselves.

How does insolvency resolution under the IBC work?

  1. What it is: The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016 lets the lenders of a defaulting company pick a resolution plan, a bid to repay them and run the firm. It works like a supervised auction.
  2. Committee of Creditors (CoC): The company’s financial creditors form a CoC, which votes on the competing plans. Its commercial judgement decides which bid wins.
  3. Tribunal approval: The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) approves the plan the CoC selects, and the NCLAT hears appeals against that approval.
  4. Dissenting financial creditors: Lenders who vote against a plan must still get at least their liquidation value, what a closure sale of the company would pay them. A majority vote cannot lower this.
  5. The takeaway: A majority vote decides the plan, but it cannot override the protection the Code gives to lenders who said no.

What happened in the Videocon case?

  1. Size of the default: Insolvency proceedings covered Videocon Industries Ltd. and 12 other group firms, whose admitted claims came to about Rs 64,839 crore.
  2. CoC and NCLT approval: The CoC approved Twinstar’s plan in 2020, and the NCLT, Mumbai approved it in June 2021.
  3. Deep haircut: The plan meant a haircut, the share of dues lenders write off, of 95.85%. The NCLT noted this and still approved the plan.
  4. NCLAT’s objection: In January 2022, the NCLAT set aside the approval and returned the plan to the CoC. Paying dissenting lenders in deferred debentures, debt repayable later, did not meet the Code’s requirement.

What has the Supreme Court settled?

  1. Appeals dismissed: The Court dismissed Twinstar’s appeals against the NCLAT order, so the plan returns to the CoC for reconsideration.
  2. Power to remit: It affirmed the NCLAT’s authority to send an approved plan back to the CoC. It also laid down the circumstances in which this power may be exercised.
  3. No rewriting by tribunals: Neither the NCLT nor the NCLAT may modify a plan to cure a legal defect. A plan that breaks the law must go back to the CoC.
  4. Law above commercial wisdom: Payment to dissenting creditors is a mandatory condition of the Code, so it lies outside the CoC’s commercial discretion.

Challenges

  1. Delay erodes value: Each remittal restarts negotiation among creditors, while the assets of the stressed firms continue to lose value.
  2. Deep haircuts: Plans that recover a small fraction of admitted claims weaken lender trust in IBC outcomes. Eg. The Videocon plan.
  3. Uncertainty for bidders: An approved plan can be reopened years later on appeal, which can deter serious resolution applicants.
  4. Tribunal capacity: Heavy caseloads at the NCLT and NCLAT stretch the Code’s time limits for resolution.

Way Forward

  1. Compliance check before approval: The NCLT should test every plan against the mandatory payment rules before approving it, not after an appeal.
  2. Model terms for dissenters: The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) should issue model clauses for paying dissenting creditors.
  3. More benches: The Centre should fill NCLT and NCLAT vacancies and add benches to meet the Code’s timelines.
  4. Deadline on remittal: Fix a time limit for the CoC to reconsider a remitted plan.

Conclusion

The ruling places the Code’s protection for dissenting lenders above a majority vote and leaves the repair of a defective plan to creditors, not tribunals. Whether the Videocon lenders can now agree a compliant plan quickly, or the process drags on, is what to watch.

Matching Previous Year Question

“[2017] Which of the following statements best describes the- term ‘Scheme for Sustainable Structuring of Stressed Assets (S4A)’, recently seen in the news? (a) It is a procedure for considering ecological costs of developmental schemes formulated by the Government. (b) It is a scheme of RBI for reworking the financial structure of big corporate entities facing genuine difficulties. (c) It is a disinvestment plan of the Government regarding Central Public Sector Undertakings. (d) It is an important provision in ‘The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code’ recently implemented by the Government. ANSWER: (b)”

Click here to Download X-Factor Notes for FREE. Cover the entire Microthemes with PYQs.

Download free X-Factor Notes
Revised and updated X-Factor Notes for UPSC Mains 2026: nine subject booklets