Why in the News
The past decade’s reforms are usually judged by what the state built. The argument here is that the most distinctive change is making Viksit Bharat (a developed India) a jan andolan, a movement owned by the people rather than delivered by the state. The Swachh Bharat Abhiyan and the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) are offered as evidence.
What is a jan andolan approach to development?
- What it is: A jan andolan approach tries to change what people believe and expect, not only what institutions deliver. It is like a public campaign that makes a new habit a social norm.
- Why it matters: Research shows culture and belief systems shape long-term growth. How those beliefs change is less understood.
- The reform record: Infrastructure investment, fiscal prudence, banking clean-up and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) strengthened the economy. The Goods and Services Tax (GST) created one national market under “One Nation, One Tax”.
- Civilisational diplomacy: Foreign policy also draws on cultural heritage. Eg. In 2016, the Prime Minister gifted the Saudi King a replica of Kerala’s Cheraman Juma Masjid, believed to be India’s first mosque.
- The takeaway: The claim is that changing norms outlasts building institutions, because institutions work only when people adopt them.
How did Swachh Bharat change sanitation norms?
- Norms, not money: Earlier programmes built toilets but did not change the habits that left them unused.
- Reframing: The mission presented sanitation as dignity and collective responsibility. It invoked Gandhi and enlisted swachhagrahis (sanitation volunteers), panchayats, schools, religious leaders and self-help groups (SHGs).
- Health dividend: Infant and child mortality fell faster after the mission, which covered over 10 crore rural households. One estimate puts infant deaths averted at 60,000 to 70,000 a year.
- Women’s dignity: Calling the toilet an “izzat ghar” (house of dignity) tied sanitation to women’s place in society. Research links more toilets to fewer sexual assaults, and school toilets keep adolescent girls in class.
How did PMAY use property titles to shift gender norms?
- Rule on paper: Earlier subsidised housing schemes required women to co-own the property, but the rule was rarely enforced.
- Conditional subsidy: Under PMAY, the subsidy is released only if the house is registered in a woman’s name, alone or jointly with her husband. Compliance is tracked house by house.
- Outcome: Nearly three-quarters of the 2.68 crore rural houses completed by the end of 2024 belong to women, solely or jointly.
- Voice at home: Research shows women who own assets have a stronger say in decisions on health, money and major purchases.
- Slow norm change: A title deed will not end patriarchy overnight. Making a woman’s name a condition of the subsidy shifts attitudes faster than persuasion alone.
Is it a people’s movement, or a state-steered one?
- Triggered from the top: Both schemes changed behaviour through state levers, a mass construction drive and a subsidy condition. The “bottom-up” movement was set in motion by the state.
- Contested attribution: The mortality, safety and ownership gains rest on research estimates. How much came from changed norms rather than new assets is not settled.
Challenges
- Sustained use: Toilets need water supply and maintenance, or households slip back to open defecation.
- Nominal ownership: A woman’s name on a title does not ensure control over selling, renting or mortgaging the house.
- Measuring norm change: Outcomes such as averted deaths rest on estimates, not routine administrative data.
Way Forward
- Phase II of Swachh Bharat: Fund water supply and waste management under Swachh Bharat Mission (Grameen) Phase II to keep villages open defecation free.
- Ownership with control: Link PMAY titles to women’s names in land records and to credit access.
- Independent evaluation: Commission regular third-party studies of behaviour outcomes under both schemes.
- Local ownership: Give panchayats and SHGs funds and duties to maintain community assets.
Conclusion
Tying benefits to behaviour can shift social norms faster than persuasion, but such change is hard to measure and easy to overstate. The test is whether toilets stay in use and women’s titles become real control over household decisions.
Government Initiatives for Women’s Economic Empowerment
- Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY): Women hold 56% of accounts under this financial inclusion scheme.
- MUDRA loans: Women receive about two-thirds of Micro Units Development and Refinance Agency (MUDRA) loans for small businesses.
- Lakhpati Didi: Aims to enable 3 crore SHG women to earn over Rs 1 lakh a year.
- Namo Drone Didi: Gives drones to SHGs to provide farm services.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2017] Which of the following statements is/are correct regarding Smart India Hackathon 2017? 1. It is a centrally sponsored scheme for developing every city of our country into Smart Cities in a Decade. 2. It is an initiative to identify new digital technology innovations for solving many problems faced by our country. 3. It is a programme aimed at making all the financial transactions in our country completely digital in a decade. Select the correct answer using the code given below: (a) 1 and 3 only (b) 2 only (c) 3 only (d) 2 and 3 only ANSWER: (b)”