Why in the News
The Prime Minister has accused India Inc of not hiring, not raising salaries and not innovating after the government cut taxes. Official survey data contradict the charge on jobs and point to government policy as the main cause of stagnant salaries.
What is the dispute over India Inc’s record?
- Prime Minister’s charge: After the government cut taxes, firms did not hire more, pay more, innovate or use the trade agreements it signed.
- Market economy argument: In a market economy, government policies mostly shape hiring, pay and investment, so blaming firms misreads the cause.
- The evidence base: The rebuttal uses the government’s own National Sample Survey (NSS) and Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS), household surveys recording who works, in what job and for what pay.
- The takeaway: Firms respond to the incentives policy creates, so better jobs and pay must come from changing policy, not from speeches.
Has industry failed to create jobs?
- Salaried jobs: Regular-pay jobs, the kind industry provides, have more than doubled since 2004-05 to reach 147.6 million.
- Faster growth since 2011: Salaried jobs grew by 4.6 million a year after 2011, nearly twice the pace of 2004-11. They are now a quarter of all jobs, up from a sixth.
- Total employment: Total employment rose by a record 20 million a year in 2019-20 to 2024, mostly outside farming.
- Women’s jobs: Women held 38.9 million salaried jobs in 2025, more than double the 2011 number. Nearly one in five working women now draws a regular salary.
Why have salaries stagnated?
- Real salary trend: The average real salary (pay adjusted for inflation) rose 3.5% a year until 2011-12, then fell 0.4% a year.
- Graduate glut: Employed graduates more than doubled after 2011-12, from 42 million to 97 million, so graduate salaries fell. When supply more than doubles, price does not rise.
- Global slowdown: International Labour Organization (ILO) data show real wage growth in developing countries slowed from 2.5% a year in 2000-11 to 0.7% after 2019. India grows at that same rate, placing it mid-pack.
- Gains at the bottom: The real daily wage of casual labourers, hired by the day, has risen 3.4% a year since 2011. A salaried worker’s pay advantage over them has nearly halved, so inequality has narrowed.
Is the fault in India Inc or in government policy?
- Corporate tax cut: The September 2019 corporate tax cut from 30% to 22% corrected one of the developing world’s highest tax burdens, not a favour.
- Tax burden: Tax collected by the Centre and States together averaged 17.3% of gross domestic product (GDP) in 2019-24, above China, Vietnam and Indonesia. For its income level, India taxes 3.3 points of GDP more than expected.
- Tariffs and QCOs: Import tariffs have risen every budget since 2018. Quality Control Orders (QCOs), rules barring products without a mandated quality certificate, cover hundreds of items and keep out cheaper imported inputs to protect domestic suppliers.
- Investment climate: Import curbs other than tariffs and an “ultra-regressive” 2015 model investment treaty, India’s template for investor protection, deter foreign investors. Net Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) fell under half a billion dollars in 2024-25.
- Who sets incentives: A firm shielded by tariffs and QCOs gains more by lobbying than innovating. Government, not industry, writes those rules, and “exhortation is not policy”.
Challenges
- Graduate oversupply: Graduates have multiplied faster than skilled jobs, holding down educated workers’ pay.
- Protection lobbies: Firms that gain from tariffs and QCOs have every reason to resist their removal.
- Income data gap: India still lacks official household income data; the first official Household Income Survey is under preparation.
Way Forward
- Scrap QCOs: Withdraw the Quality Control Orders that block cheaper imported inputs.
- Cut tariffs: Lower import tariffs so firms compete rather than seek protection.
- Back reformers: Overrule officials who undermine reform and let competition prevail.
Conclusion
Stagnant salaries reflect a surge in educated workers and incentives set by policy, not a failure of corporate will. Whether the government trims tariffs and quality orders will decide if job growth starts to carry better pay.
Key numbers
- Salaried jobs: 67.9 million (2004-05), 85.2 million (2011-12), growing 2.5 million a year; women 13.1 million (2004-05), 16.7 million (2011-12).
- Monthly real salary (2024 prices): Rs 18,442 (2004-05), Rs 23,637 (2011-12), Rs 22,314 (2025); graduates Rs 41,782 to Rs 35,046.
- Salaried to casual pay ratio: 4.4 times (1999-2000) to 2.4 times (2024).
- Tax revenue, 2019-24: China 14.3%, Vietnam 13.2%, Indonesia 9.7% of GDP.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2015] A decrease in tax to GDP ratio of a country indicates which of the following? (1) Slowing economic growth rate (2) Less equitable distribution of national income Select the correct answer using the code given below. (a) 1 only (b) 2 only (c) Both 1 and 2 (d) Neither 1 nor 2 ANSWER: (a)”