Why in the News?

India is increasingly seen as a likely destination for global “data dumping” as large data centres expand due to AI growth, government incentives, and geopolitical changes. This is a serious issue because data centres place heavy pressure on electricity, water, land, and environmental regulation, especially in water-stressed cities. Unlike earlier views that treated digital infrastructure as low-impact, data centres are now emerging as resource-intensive industrial units, raising concerns about sustainability, weak regulation, and long-term environmental costs.

What are Data centers?

1. Physical Digital Infrastructure: Large facilities that store, process, and manage digital data using servers, storage systems, and networking equipment.
2. Backbone of the Digital Economy: Support cloud computing, e-governance, AI, fintech, e-commerce, and social media services.

Why is India vulnerable to becoming a “data dumping” destination?

1. Geopolitical Stability: Provides predictability compared to other global regions, increasing investor preference.
2. Fiscal Incentives: Offers subsidised land, power, and expedited clearances for data infrastructure.
3. Domestic Market Scale: Ensures long-term demand for data storage and processing.
4. AI-Driven Demand: Accelerates need for hyperscale facilities with high energy density.

Why are data centres no longer “clean” digital infrastructure?

1. Electricity Intensity: Requires massive grid capacity, substations, and uninterrupted power supply.
2. Water Dependence: Uses large volumes for cooling, especially where air cooling is not feasible.
3. Thermal Pollution: Releases waste heat, intensifying urban heat stress.
4. Industrial Footprint: Mirrors heavy industry in land use, emissions, and infrastructure strain.

What environmental risks?

1. Water Stress: Many Indian cities already face chronic water shortages.
2. Grid Overload: Clustered data centres require grid upgrades and load balancing.
3. Externalised Costs: Environmental and infrastructure costs often borne by the public sector.
4. Weak Enforcement: Post-clearance monitoring and compliance remain inadequate.

What are the governance and regulatory gaps?

1. Institutional Lacunae: Noted by the Comptroller and Auditor General, Supreme Court, and National Green Tribunal.
2. Zoning Weaknesses: Data centres not uniformly classified as heavy infrastructure.
3. Opacity: Non-disclosure agreements restrict public scrutiny.
4. Fragmented Oversight: Multiple agencies without integrated regulation.

What lessons emerge from international and domestic resistance?

1. United States Experience: Community resistance in Virginia, North Carolina, and Minnesota due to water and energy stress.
2. Transparency Failures: Projects stalled due to non-disclosure and lack of public consultation.
3. Course Correction: Developers increasingly engaging communities early to reduce backlash.
4. Indian Parallel: Similar conditions exist but with weaker civic engagement and regulatory checks.

Risks of unchecked expansion

1. Capital Intensity: Limits government bargaining power once investments are sunk.
2. Subsidy Distortions: Shifts public resources toward private digital infrastructure.
3. Environmental Injustice: Local communities bear costs without proportional benefits.
4. Governance Risk: Early-stage policy failures become irreversible later.

Conclusion

Data centres must be treated as heavy infrastructure, not neutral digital assets. Without enforceable zoning, water-use ceilings, transparent disclosures, and robust environmental oversight, India risks replicating extractive development models under the guise of digital growth. Sustainable digitalisation requires aligning data infrastructure with ecological limits and democratic accountability.

PYQ Relevance

[UPSC 2015] Discuss the advantages and security implications of cloud hosting of servers vis-a-vis in-house machine-based hosting for government businesses.

Linkage: This question examines the trade-offs between efficiency-driven digital governance and strategic data control. It also connects with current debates on data centres, cloud infrastructure, and data sovereignty, where reliance on cloud hosting raises concerns of security, resilience, and regulatory oversight for government systems.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now