Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Why in the News

India marks the first anniversary of the implementation of its four Labour Codes on 21 November, as layoffs grow with companies adopting artificial intelligence (AI). The stake is whether a worker who loses a job has any cushion beyond a one-time severance pay, since India has no unemployment relief system.

What happens to a worker who is laid off in India?

  1. Retrenchment: India uses the term retrenchment for what the U.S. calls a layoff, an employer ending a worker’s service. It hits workers in coal mines, tech firms and government services alike.
  2. Human cost: A retrenched worker loses regular income and benefits such as family health insurance, and is barred from a workplace of many years.
  3. Skills and contracts: Low-skilled workers can move to other jobs as long as the pay stays above their reservation wage, the lowest wage they will accept. Protection depends on the contract: trainee, contract worker or tenured.
  4. The takeaway: Job loss in India is a social as well as a financial shock, and formal rules cushion only part of it.

What have the Labour Codes changed, and whom do they leave out?

  1. Tribunals replace labour courts: The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 replaced labour courts with Industrial Tribunals, folding several dispute-settling bodies into one. The government calls this more efficient; critics dismiss much of the reform as “hogwash”.
  2. Narrow coverage: Mandatory layoff procedures apply only to coal mining, plantations and manufacturing, leaving out service, IT and informal workers.
  3. IT layoffs: The IT sector has seen some of its worst layoffs in five years, often without proper legal procedure.
  4. Gig workers: The Codes name gig, platform and informal workers, and States are framing laws to protect them. e-Shram, the national database of unorganised workers, is collecting their data.

Is severance pay fair, and should it be taxed?

  1. Legal status: Severance pay is mandated by law only in certain sectors; elsewhere it is customary.
  2. Government’s view: The government taxes severance as “profit in lieu of salary”, meaning salary received in advance. A specific provision now also taxes its once tax-free part as “income from other sources”.
  3. Fairness objection: The government takes about one-third of a payment meant to compensate for lost income and benefits.
  4. Generosity debate: Critics call Indian severance high, but Sri Lanka and many European countries have stricter rules. Most Indian employers pay once and close the file, skipping counselling and retraining.

What can India learn from other countries’ unemployment insurance?

  1. Germany: Runs an earnings-linked unemployment insurance, paying a percentage of the worker’s prior earnings rather than a flat rate.
  2. United States: Funds payouts through a payroll tax. Its rate follows experience rating, meaning it depends on the employer’s own history of unemployment claims and payroll changes.
  3. U.K. and Singapore: Both run their own schemes, tailored to their cultures. An Indian scheme would need different parameters for urban and rural workers.

Challenges

  1. No unemployment relief: No state system supports a jobless worker, so the joint family, the traditional cushion, is the only fallback.
  2. Thin ESI network: Employees’ State Insurance (ESI), the workers’ health insurance scheme, has too few hospitals for its beneficiaries.
  3. Untested tribunals: Whether tribunal vacancies are filled on time and presiding officers are efficient has not been assessed.

Way Forward

  1. Tax-funded assistance: Pay unemployment assistance to vulnerable workers from tax revenue.
  2. Social security net: Bring more workers inside the existing social security net, with citizens and government agencies working together.
  3. Gig worker premium: Let gig workers opt in to a small premium against lost revenue, matched by the aggregator and the customer.

Conclusion

India protects a laid-off worker mainly through a one-time payment and sector-bound rules, with nothing that replaces income during the search for the next job. The test for the Codes’ second year is whether an unemployment insurance design covering formal and gig workers follows.

What are the Labour Codes?

  1. Consolidation: Four Codes replaced 29 central labour laws: the Code on Wages, 2019 and three Codes of 2020 on Industrial Relations, Social Security, and Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions.
  2. Concurrent subject: Labour is in the Concurrent List, so the Centre and the States both frame rules under the Codes.
  3. Permission threshold: Prior government permission for layoff, retrenchment or closure is needed only in establishments with 300 or more workers, up from 100.
  4. Social security fund: The Code on Social Security, 2020 defines gig and platform workers for the first time and provides for a fund with aggregator contributions.

Matching Previous Year Question

“[2022] In India, which one of the following compiles information on industrial disputes, closures, retrenchments and lay-offs in factories employing workers? (a) Central Statistics Office (b) Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (c) Labour Bureau (d) National Technical Manpower Information System ANSWER: (c)”

Click here to Download X-Factor Notes for FREE. Cover the entire Microthemes with PYQs.

Download free X-Factor Notes
Revised and updated X-Factor Notes for UPSC Mains 2026: nine subject booklets