Why in the News
India’s solar push over the past decade has centred on centralised solar megaparks, which draw nearly ten times the fiscal, policy and commercial interest of decentralised projects. Households, farmers and Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) have been left at the margins of a transition meant to be inclusive.
Why do big projects so often under-deliver?
- Appeal of scale: Governments favour big projects for the jobs, contracts, domestic procurement, political visibility, image of modernity and profits they bring.
- Iron Law of Megaprojects: Scholar Bent Flyvbjerg finds large projects end up “over budget, over time, under benefits, over and over again”. The pattern holds for metros, high-speed rail, tunnels and even the Olympic Games.
- Growth is not automatic: Infrastructure creates long-term growth only when it is well planned, controls costs, plans its surroundings and responds to social needs.
- The takeaway: Big projects routinely overrun, so an energy transition built on megaprojects can miss the people it is meant to serve.
How has India’s energy transition been run?
- Top-down targets: For a decade and a half the transition has been driven by national targets and top-down management: more panels, inter-State transmission, hydrogen and batteries.
- Lost local potential: Renewable energy can free scattered populations from dependence on a centralised grid. In a high insolation (sunlight received) country like India, local generation could undo decades of poor rural energy provision.
- Big lends to big: Large banks lend to large power companies, which sell large amounts of power to large consumers such as industry and data centres.
- Late refocus: Only recently has policy turned to the local feeder level (the line that supplies a cluster of villages or farms), with priority to rooftop solar, solar irrigation and household electrification.
Why have small users struggled to go solar?
- Costly credit: Banks no longer lend to small businesses, so costlier Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) fill the gap. Solar then costs small firms more and often pays off only with large State subsidies.
- Poor panels: Small rural buyers often get the worst-quality panels, with little recourse and low supplier accountability. Many MSMEs lost money and gave up.
- Weak rural discoms: Urban distribution companies (discoms) are often private and better managed. Most rural discoms are State-owned, underinvested and focused on procurement, tendering and load balancing, not small consumers.
- Missed jobs: Policies such as the Udyam portal (the MSME registration system) are meant to target MSMEs, yet a sector that could employ up to 200 million people has struggled to join the transition.
What would a people-centred transition look like?
- Appropriate technology: Economist E F Schumacher called technology appropriate when it is people-centred, decentralised, resource-efficient, labour (not capital) intensive and moderately priced. The idea matters more as policy stresses job creation.
- Headline bias: Public attention goes to record investment numbers, tender designs, national targets and pilot plants, not to small local users.
- SELCO model: The SELCO Foundation has spent decades building renewable energy business models for farmers and agrarian entrepreneurs.
Challenges
- Uncertain climate finance: India will seek more international climate finance at the coming Conference of the Parties (COP), but its arrival is uncertain.
- Upfront cost for farmers: Component A of the Pradhan Mantri Kisan Urja Suraksha evam Utthaan Mahabhiyan (PM-KUSUM), the farm solar scheme, gives no capital subsidy, so a farmer must raise the full cost of a solar plant.
- No storage support: PM Surya Ghar, the rooftop solar scheme, does not subsidise batteries, so solar homes still lean on the grid after sunset.
Way Forward
- Modular projects: Build smaller, modular and replicable projects with tightly calibrated cost estimates, as Flyvbjerg suggests.
- Domestic finance first: Convince Indian financial institutions that the small-consumer transition matters as much as national targets.
- Rural discom reform: Invest in rural discoms and make small consumers a service priority.
Conclusion
India’s transition has scaled fast at the national level but has not reached the small consumers who gain most from local power. Whether lenders, rural discoms and schemes shift support towards these users will decide if the transition is inclusive.
Government initiatives for decentralised solar
- PM Surya Ghar Muft Bijli Yojana: Launched in 2024 by the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE), it targets rooftop solar in one crore households by March 2027.
- PM-KUSUM: Run by MNRE since 2019, the scheme funds small solar plants on fallow land, off-grid solar pumps and solarised grid pumps.
- Feeder level solarisation: Under PM-KUSUM, a whole agricultural feeder can be solarised at once, and the planned PM-KUSUM 2.0 is built around this route.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2024] Consider the following: 1. Battery storage 2. Biomass generators 3. Fuel cells 4. Rooftop solar photovoltaic units How many of the above are considered “Distributed Energy Resources”? (a) Only one (b) Only two (c) Only three (d) All four* ANSWER: (d)”