India’s relations with Israel have, of late, acquired a depth and diversity, which cannot be rolled back.” Discuss. 15 Marks)

Mentors Comments:
1. Discuss the relationship from the past
2. Mention recent steps on the same
3. Highlight specific challenges faced by the countries.
4. Suggest way forward

 

Answer:
India-Israel relations most notably exemplify realism as cardinal International relations theory wherein the expediency of national interest turns out to be the guiding force behind a nation s foreign policy. Scholars have argued that in the post-cold war era India started following a robust realist foreign policy posture and India s approach towards Israel is a classic affirmation of this stand.
Background of Indo- Israel relations:

  1. Since India established full diplomatic ties with Israel in 1992, relations between the two countries have grown at an astonishing pace, covering a wide range of issues from defence and homeland security, to agriculture and water management, and now education and even outer space.
  2. The formal acknowledgement of the relationship at the highest levels leaving behind hesitations of history and India’s de-hyphenation of its Israel and Palestine policies for the first time (and taking the related course-correction measures such as rethinking India’s voting choices on anti-Israel resolutions at the UN and dropping the demand for East Jerusalem as capital of a future Palestinian state), is the turning point in the relations of both countries going forward.

 

Depth and diversity in India-Israel relations in recent past:

Hinged on defence, intelligence-sharing, counter-terrorism on one side and cooperation in water harvesting and agriculture on the other, there are a number of avenues in which India-Israel ties would be key to the emerging global order.

  1. Economic Engagement: Israel, led by strong growth of private consumption, low inflation, rising labour force participation, a positive investors’ climate because of low-interest rates, natural gas finds and responsible fiscal policies, has a lot to offer.  Policy initiatives on ease of doing business and the opening of defence, construction and pharma sectors have added to India’s attractiveness as an investment destination.
  2. Defence collaboration: The India-Israel equation in defence has acquired strategic dimensions but there is the need and opportunity to make it “more broad-based” through production and manufacturing partnerships. Israeli defence industries are well inclined towards joint ventures to give a boost to the ‘Make in India’ campaign.
  3. Innovation and Entrepreneurship Culture: Israel embodies a culture of entrepreneurship highlighted by the power of innovation, global leadership in R&D spending and venture capital investment. A joint innovation and research and development fund can work wonders.
  4. A country that has no automotive industry for example, and yet they are the R&D centre for autonomous cars (self-driving) in the world.
  5. Agricultural Partnership and Water Conservation: Arid land technology, biotechnology and a joint action plan to research India specific and export-oriented seeds deserve attention. Israel has tackled its rain deficiency by developing technology solutions for waste and water management, purification, desalination techniques and water reuse in agriculture and industry. The Israeli dairy industry with its proven know-how and design, technology and genetic material can revolutionize the dairy industry in India.
  6. Medical and Pharma sector cooperation: Medical technologies and devices could be the next growth areas for collaboration.
  7. Diaspora potential: Another important factor in bilateral ties will be the Indian diaspora. Most Jewish Indians, about 80,000, have all moved here, and there are just about 4,000-5,000 left in India.
  8. Academia-Industry- government Connect: We have to learn from their universities, how they have technology transfer companies based right on their campuses, who help convert theory into useful products in a very short period of time.
  9. Counter-Terrorism and Intelligence Sharing: India and Israel are boosting up the counter-terrorism cooperation and sharing real-time intelligence on issues crucial to national security.
  10. Military and Strategic Ties: Israel is the second-largest source of defence equipment for India, after Russia. Arms trade between the two nations reached almost $600 million in 2016. India has purchased Barak I missiles, 3 Phalcon AWACS, and Israeli spike anti-tank missiles from Israel. Israel is developing Barak 8 missile for Indian Navy and IAF and plans to purchase 2 more Phalcon AWACS is in progress.
  11. Space Collaboration: In 2002, India and Israel signed a cooperative agreement promoting space collaboration. India has successfully launched TecSAR and RISAT-2 radar imaging satellites of Israel from PSLV of ISRO.

Sticky Points in the Relations:

  1. Bilateral Trade and investment still below potential: From just $200 million in 1992, bilateral trade (excluding defence) peaked at about $5 billion in 2012 but since then it has dropped to about $4 billion. Also, bilateral trade has not diversified much—diamonds and chemicals still make up for the large chunk of the pie.
  2. Private Sector still finding feet: Indian companies like Sun Pharma and ATG, a speciality tyre-maker, have big interests in Israel. But perhaps unsurprisingly, the Chinese are streets ahead of us in bilateral trade and their companies are investing heavily in Israel’s cutting-edge start-ups.
  3. Connectivity between the two countries still poor with just one direct flight from Mumbai 3 times a week and no direct flights from Delhi.
  4. Historical retrenchment: India’s consistent support for a sovereign, independent, viable and united Palestinian state with East Jerusalem as its capital, living within secure and recognized borders, side by side and at peace with Israel and Pro-Arab stance has been a sticky point.
  5. Limited People to People ties and cultural differences: Israelis and Indian approach business differently and often find it difficult to get on the same page. Though formal ties were established in 1992, but the ideological divide resurfaces time and again.

Way forward:

  • Investments to boost tourism, education and cultural ties and building bridges with the Indian diaspora in Israel can help significantly in this context.
  • Indeed, these are the low-hanging fruits in the bilateral relationship that can be plucked right away.
  • Taking cues of Israel’s industry-academia ecosystem, its innovation and start-up culture and the state of art cutting edge technology across sectors; India can build mutual collaborations for present and future development.
  • India s closer ties with Israel are very much in its national interest. Critics allege that India is now abandoning the Palestinian cause. However, India is just balancing and recalibrating its West Asia policy on the premise of its own national interest.

Tapping each other’s potential should be the imperative in the new “Strategic Partnership” to truly make “India-Israel is a match made in heaven”!

5
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
2 Comment threads
3 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
Parth VermaDeepanshu GulyaniDipanshu Sharma Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Dipanshu Sharma
Member

please review…
payment id:MOJO9a29300A6177473

Deepanshu Gulyani
Member

Greetings
Team CD please do reply to us asap. This question should be in GS paper 2 and last time also you have put India Mauritius in GS 3 portion. for Both papers there are different way to tackle the question.
Please acknowledge this
Thank you