💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

GS Paper: GS2

  • [7th June 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Health regulations need a base-to-top approach

    [7th June 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Health regulations need a base-to-top approach

    PYQ Relevance

    Q The public health system has limitations in providing universal health coverage. Do you think that the private sector can help in bridging the gap? What other viable alternatives do you suggest? (UPSC IAS/2015)

    Q In order to enhance the prospects of social development, sound and adequate health care policies are needed particularly in the fields of geriatric and maternal health care. Discuss. (UPSC IAS/2020)

    Mentors comment: In the last week of May, a tragic fire at a private neonatal care nursing home in New Delhi shocked everyone. Political parties started blaming each other, and the media exaggerated by incorrectly claiming that many nursing homes in Delhi operate without a license. Despite the intense media coverage, the incident has been largely forgotten, leaving the grieving parents behind. Instead of focusing on who to blame, it’s important to recognize that such tragedies are usually the result of systemic failures—in this case, the failure of health-care regulations.

    Let’s learn–

    Why in the news?

    Health regulations are crucial, but their implementation in India needs to be thoughtful and carefully balanced.

    Regulation and standards in the Indian health care system

    • Excessive and Complex Regulations: Some states have over 50 approvals required under multiple regulations for each healthcare facility, creating a bureaucratic burden. Despite the complexity, there is a perception among officials that the private health sector is under-regulated.
    • Unrealistic Standards: Many healthcare quality standards set by the government, such as those in the Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010, and the Indian Public Health Standards (IPHS), are considered unrealistic and difficult to implement. Only a small percentage of government primary healthcare facilities meet these standards despite their aspirational goals.

    Mixed health-care system in India 

    • Diverse Healthcare Providers: India’s healthcare system includes both government and private sector providers, ranging from single-doctor clinics and small nursing homes to large corporate hospitals, each serving different population segments.
    • Dominance of Private Sector: The private sector delivers approximately 70% of outpatient services and 50% of inpatient services, indicating a significant reliance on private facilities for health care by the Indian population.
    • Regulatory and Quality Challenges: There are disparities in regulation enforcement and quality standards between the private and government sectors, with issues such as approval delays, cost of compliance, and ensuring consistent quality care across diverse facilities.

    Challenges related to mixed health-care system

    • Regulatory Disparities: Uneven enforcement of regulations between private and government health facilities. Overzealous regulation of private facilities while government facilities face fewer consequences for similar infractions.
    • Approval Delays: Sluggish approval processes for private facilities, causing operational delays and financial strain. Long waiting periods for renewal applications, even when submitted well in advance.
    • Cost and Accessibility: High cost of services in large corporate hospitals compared to smaller clinics and nursing homes. Limited accessibility of government facilities for certain populations, despite being free or low-cost.
    • Differential Standards: Impractical to hold small clinics and nursing homes to the same standards as large hospitals. Need for a tiered approach to regulation, with essential and desirable standards based on facility type.
    • Financial Burden: High cost of compliance with regulations for smaller facilities, potentially making health services unaffordable for patients. The a need for government subsidies or funding to help smaller providers meet regulatory standards without increasing costs for patients.
    • Stakeholder Involvement: Insufficient involvement of health-care providers, facility owners, and community members in the formulation of regulations. Lack of representation from various types of facilities in regulatory processes.
    • Public Perception and Trust: Political rhetoric and sensational media coverage undermining trust in health-care providers. Potential for increased violence against health-care providers due to public mistrust.
    • Infrastructure and Safety: Inconsistent emphasis on essential safety measures like fire safety across facilities. Need for equitable implementation of safety standards in all healthcare buildings.

    Affordable care is one need

    • Role of Small Providers: Single doctor clinics and small nursing homes are crucial for providing initial access and health services, particularly for middle-income and low-income populations. These smaller providers deliver a significant portion of health services at a lower cost compared to large corporate hospitals.
    • Supportive Regulations: There is a need for regulations that support small providers to keep healthcare costs low and affordable. Guidelines should be practical and implementable, harmonizing multiple regulations and simplifying the application process with timely approval.
    • Differential Approach: Regulations should recognize the different capabilities of various health facilities. Smaller clinics and nursing homes should not be held to the same standards as large hospitals to avoid escalating costs that could be transferred to patients. Essential and desirable regulatory points should be established, with regular self-assessments and inspections to ensure compliance.
    • Government subsidies and funding should be considered to help smaller facilities adhere to necessary regulations without increasing costs for patients.

    Why do we need to Focus on the primary caregivers?

    • Accessibility and Affordability: Single-doctor clinics and small nursing homes provide essential health services at a lower cost, making health care more accessible and affordable for middle-income and low-income populations.
    • Primary Care Foundation: Promoting primary care helps manage health issues early, reducing the burden on secondary and tertiary care facilities and supporting the goals of the National Health Policy, 2017, for people-centric, accessible, and affordable health services.
    • Sustainable Support: Simplified, fair, and collaborative regulatory processes, along with government subsidies, can help primary-care providers operate effectively, ensuring quality and safety without escalating costs for patients.

    Conclusion: Primary health care is crucial for achieving the SDG goal of universal health coverage by providing accessible, affordable, and quality health services, thus reducing the burden on higher-level care facilities and promoting overall health equity.

  • India second-biggest foreign threat to Canadian democracy: report

    Why in the news?

    A parliamentary committee report in Canada has claimed India as the second-biggest foreign threat to the country’s democracy.

    About the Khalistan Movement

    • Origins and Objectives: The Khalistan Movement is a separatist movement seeking to create an independent Sikh state called Khalistan in the Punjab region of India.
    • Activities in Canada: Canada has a significant Sikh population, and some members support the Khalistan Movement. This has led to tensions between Canadian Sikhs and the Indian government.
    • Notable Incident: The murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a pro-Khalistan ideologue, in Surrey, British Columbia, on June 18, 2023, intensified these tensions.

    Historical Background

    • Canada and India established diplomatic relations in 1947. The relationship was enhanced by personal ties between Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and Canadian Prime Ministers Louis St. Laurent and Lester B. Pearson in the 1940s and 1960s.
    • Canada provided significant aid to India under the “Colombo Plan”, including food aid, project financing, and technical assistance. India has been one of the largest recipients of Canadian bilateral aid, amounting to over $3.8 billion CAD.

    Recent Developments

    • India and Canada have seen significant growth in bilateral trade, reaching $8.16 billion in 2023.
    • Canada is home to over 1.2 million people of Indian origin, who are well-integrated into the mainstream and active in politics.
    • The two countries have a strategic partnership underpinned by shared values of democracy and pluralism, with regular high-level interactions and long-standing people-to-people ties.
    • India and Canada have signed several agreements, including the Air Services Agreement, Extradition Treaty, Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty, and Nuclear Cooperation Agreement.

    Challenges

    • Interference Allegations: Canada claims that India has expanded its interference efforts beyond countering pro-Khalistani activities to include targeting Canadian politicians, ethnic media, and Indo-Canadian communities.
    • Mutual Suspicion: The Canadian Security Intelligence Service has also accused India of being involved in the election process in Canada, a claim denied by India.
    • Ethnic and Political Dynamics: The presence of a significant pro-Khalistan population in Canada complicates bilateral relations, with domestic politics in both countries influencing diplomatic interactions.

    India’s Stand

    • Denial of Allegations: The Indian government has consistently denied allegations of interference in Canadian affairs and the murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar.
    • Counter-Terrorism: India views the Khalistan Movement as a terrorist threat and seeks to counter its activities both domestically and internationally.
    • Diplomatic Responses: In response to accusations from Canada, India has taken measures such as suspending visa services and issuing official statements to refute claims of interference.

    Way forward:

    • Regular Consultations: Establish a framework for regular high-level meetings between Indian and Canadian officials to address mutual concerns and prevent misunderstandings.
    • Bilateral Committees: Form joint committees to handle specific issues such as security concerns, immigration, and trade disputes.

    Mains question for practice:

    Q Discuss the origins and objectives of the Khalistan Movement and analyse the current challenges it poses to bilateral relations between India and Canada. 15M

  • The representation of women in the incoming Lok Sabha, how it compares to previous years

    Why in the news?

    Over time, there has been a general inclination towards enhancing women’s representation in the Lok Sabha. However, the advancement has been gradual and inconsistent.

    Women in Lok Sabha 2024 (PRS data):

    • Number of Women MPs: India has elected 74 women MPs to the Lok Sabha in 2024, which is four fewer than in 2019.
    • Percentage of Representation: Women MPs make up just 13.63% of the elected strength of the Lower House.
    • Party-wise Distribution: Women MPs come from 14 different parties, with the BJP leading with 31 women MPs, followed by the Congress with 13.

    Different Demographic Observations:

    • Trend in Representation: Over the years, there has been a slow and non-linear increase in women’s representation in the Lok Sabha.
    • Historical Trends: Women’s representation started at 4.41% in 1952 and peaked at 14.36% in 2019.
    • New Faces: Out of the 74 women MPs elected, 43 are first-time MPs, indicating a higher percentage of newcomers compared to the overall House.
    • Younger Representation: The average age of women MPs is 50 years, younger than the overall House age of 56 years.

    Comparison with Other Countries:

    • International Comparison: India lags behind several countries in terms of women’s representation, with countries like South Africa, the UK, and the US having higher percentages of women MPs.
    • Global Rankings: Women make up 46% of MPs in South Africa, 35% in the UK, and 29% in the US.

    What Needs to Be Done?

    • Increase in Representation: There is a need for greater efforts to increase women’s representation in the Lok Sabha to achieve gender parity.
    • Policy Measures: Implementation of policy measures such as reserving seats for women in the Lok Sabha could help improve representation.
    • Encouraging Participation: Encouraging more women to enter politics and providing support for their political careers can contribute to greater representation.
    • Education and Awareness: Promoting education and awareness about the importance of gender equality in politics is essential for fostering a more inclusive political environment.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q What are the continued challenges for Women in India against time and space?  (UPSC IAS/2019)

  • Second Phase of China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)

    Why in the News?

    Pakistani PM is on a formal visit to China to attend the formal announcement of the second phase of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC-II).

    About CPEC-II

    • CPEC’s next phase shifts focus from infrastructure and energy to sectors like agriculture, Pakistan Railways’ Main Line-I (ML-1) upgrade, and realignment of the Karakorum Highway.
    • CPEC was initiated in 2015 as part of President Xi Jinping’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).

    Why CPEC-II?

    • It will provide Pakistan with a strategic advantage in terms of trade and commerce
    • CPEC-II includes significant investments in the energy sector, which will help overcome Pakistan’s chronic power shortages and ensure a stable supply of electricity
    • Provides a shortcut for China’s access to the Persian Gulf to secure oil imports, and
    • Stimulate industrial and economic activity in Pakistan.

    Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)

    • The Belt and Road Initiative, formerly known as One Belt One Road, is a global infrastructure development strategy adopted by the Chinese government in 2013.
    • It will invest in nearly 70 countries and international organizations.
    • Infrastructure projects include ports, railways, highways, power stations, aviation and telecommunications.
    • “Belt” refers to the overland routes for road and rail transportation, called “the Silk Road Economic Belt”; whereas “road” refers to the sea routes or the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road.
    • The project has a target completion date of 2049 which coincides with the 100th anniversary of the People’s Republic of China.

    India’s Concerns

    • Sovereignty Concerns: India expresses reservations as CPEC traverses through Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK), challenging territorial sovereignty and potentially bolstering Pakistan’s claim over the region.
    • Geostrategic Implications: The expansion of Gwadar port under CPEC extends China’s “String of Pearls” around India, prompting concerns over regional power dynamics.

    CPEC’s Progress so Far

    • Mixed Outcomes: The initial phase of CPEC primarily addressed infrastructure, energy, and port development projects, with progress showing variations.
    • Project Status: While several power projects have been completed, significant delays and challenges persist in transport-related projects and Special Economic Zones (SEZs).

    Challenges and Roadblocks

    • Slow pace: Gwadar, despite being the epicentre of multibillion-dollar projects, lacks basic necessities like reliable access to water and electricity, let alone other facilities.
    • Baloch freedom movement: This is another impediment to the stalled project where Chinese officials are targeted and killed.
    • Consistent security threat: China is also seeking to deploy its Army in the CPEC projects, to which Pakistan has contested.

    PYQ:

    [2018] The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) is viewed as a cardinal subset of China’s larger ‘One Belt One Road’ initiative. Give a brief description of CPEC and enumerate the reasons why India has distanced itself from the same. (150 Words, 10 Marks)

    [2016] ‘Belt and Road Initiative’ is sometimes mentioned in the news in the context of the affairs of

    (a) African Union

    (b) Brazil

    (c) European Union

    (d) China
  • [6th June 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The roads to India’s re-democratisation, the challenge

    [6th June 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The roads to India’s re-democratisation, the challenge

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q To what extent, in your opinion, has the decentralisation of power in India changed the governance landscape at the grassroots? (UPSC IAS/2022)

    Q How far do you think cooperation, competition and confrontation have shaped the nature of federation in India? Cite some recent examples to validate your answer.(UPSC IAS/2020)

    Mentor’s comment: The 18th Indian general election signals a potential end to a cycle despite no change in power. The Bharatiya Janata Party’s loss of majority could catalyze a re-democratization process. Over a decade, India witnessed political and economic power concentrating, sidelining institutions and exacerbating inequalities. A shift in power dynamics and narratives may lead to significant changes, but their realization remains uncertain.

    Let’s learn

    Why in the news?

    The election’s conclusion may signal a transition, yet the revival of India’s democracy rests on the involvement of pivotal actors, such as civil society.

    10 Years of Modi Government: A Critical Analysis 

    • Concentration of Power: For 10 years, India has experienced de-democratisation, with political and economic power concentrated in a few hands.
    • Bypassing Institutions: Top state officials made decisions, bypassing Parliament and federalism.
    • Economic Dominance: A few business cronies accessed resources and dominated the economy.
    • Increasing Inequalities: Inequalities increased, but the poor supported a pro-rich government due to identity politics and communal polarisation, overshadowing social issues.

    Expected Changes

    • Power Dynamics: Significant changes are anticipated in power dynamics and narratives due to the new balance of power.
    • Partial Realization: However, these changes might not fully materialize.

    No Shift, But a Tilt

    • Dominant Party: The BJP remains the dominant party, though Narendra Modi must now engage in coalition politics.
    • Institutional Empowerment: The weakening of Modi’s authority may empower institutions, including the Election Commission of India, the judiciary, and the media, to resist the government’s use of restrictive laws.
    • Revitalised Federalism: Federalism might be revitalised due to the need for support from state parties like the Telugu Desam Party (TDP) and Janata Dal (United) (JD(U)).

    Narrative Shifts

    • Counter to National-Populism: Mr. Modi’s national-populist claim of embodying the nation might be countered by an agenda prioritising social equality.
    • Social Justice Focus: The Congress, Samajwadi Party, Rashtriya Janata Dal, and others are mobilising supporters on social issues, including the caste census, to promote social justice.
    • Opposition’s Rise to Popularity: Rahul Gandhi’s Bharat Jodo Yatra and Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra have made him a popular leader, defending the Constitution and building a coalition of parties under the INDIA bloc.

    Different Scenarios within the NDA Alliance

    • Bihar’s Caste Census: Nitish Kumar might push the National Democratic Alliance to emulate Bihar’s caste census initiative.
    • Coalition Politics: The TDP, JD(U), and others may promote their agendas, leading to different scenarios:
    • Modus Vivendi: A modus vivendi based on concessions from the Modi government to accommodate demands from TDP, JD(U), and others.
    • Worst-Case Scenario: A worst-case scenario where TDP and JD(U) make demands affecting BJP’s power-sharing or support base, possibly shifting alliances and causing the government to fall.

    Potential Crisis

    • Scenario Development: The second scenario might unfold over months or years, especially if the Modi government weakens due to electoral setbacks.
    • Opposition Unity: The Opposition might solidify its unity, mobilize in the streets, and recruit more partners. Mayawati might revive the Bahujan Samaj Party in the new political context.

    Future of the Ruling Alliance

    • Coalition Management: Modi may struggle to keep the NDA together if partners demand too much or if he fails to manage coalition tensions.
    • Leadership Change: The Sangh Parivar might replace Modi with someone like Nitin Gadkari, supported by the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).
    • Resistance to Power Loss: Modi and Amit Shah are unlikely to relinquish power easily, using various techniques to maintain their positions.

    Role of Civil Society

    • Crucial Role: Civil society will play a crucial role in rejuvenating India’s democracy.
    • Beyond State-Level Change: A mere change of guard at the state level won’t suffice for re-democratisation or countering the dense network of RSS-related vigilantes.

    Way Forward

    • Strengthening Institutions: It’s crucial to bolster democratic institutions like the judiciary, Election Commission, and media to ensure checks and balances.
    • Promoting Federalism: Federalism should be revitalized by empowering state governments and ensuring equitable distribution of resources.
    • Inclusive Politics: Political parties must prioritize inclusive policies addressing social and economic inequalities, fostering unity beyond identity politics.
    • Civil Society Engagement: Encourage active participation of civil society in monitoring government actions, advocating for transparency, and promoting accountability.
    • Legal Reforms: Implement legal reforms to safeguard democratic processes and protect civil liberties, ensuring fair and transparent elections.
    • Coalition Dynamics: Effective management of coalition dynamics is essential to maintain stability and address regional aspirations within a federal framework.

    Conclusion

    • India’s democratic resilience will be tested in the coming years as it navigates the challenges of coalition politics, institutional empowerment, and societal inclusiveness.  
    • The interplay between political centralisation and resistance will shape the future path of India’s democracy, emphasizing the need for continuous engagement, reform, and accountability.

  • Do North Korea’s trash balloons indicate an escalation?

    Why in the news?

    South Korea has suspended the 2018 peace agreement and announced the possibility of resuming propaganda broadcasts in North Korea following Pyongyang’s release of thousands of balloons filled with trash and human waste into the South.

    Inter-Korean Peace Agreement, 2018

    • The 2018 inter-Korean peace agreement refers to several agreements and declarations made between North and South Korea to reduce military tensions and improve diplomatic relations. Key elements of the agreement included:
      • Ceasefire Maintenance: Maintaining and reinforcing the Korean Armistice Agreement.
      • Demilitarization: Implementing measures to reduce military tensions, such as dismantling guard posts in the Demilitarized Zone (DMZ).
      • Family Reunions: Facilitating family reunions for those separated by the Korean War.
      • Economic Cooperation: Pursuing economic projects and infrastructure development.
      • Propaganda Halt: Both sides agreed to cease propaganda broadcasts and leaflet drops across the DMZ.

    Why did South Korea suspend the 2018 agreement?

    • Recent Provocations: North Korea’s recent aggressive actions, including GPS signal jamming, missile launches, and the release of balloons carrying trash and human waste, pose a threat to South Korean security and civilian safety.
    • Lack of Trust: The ruling People Power Party (PPP) in South Korea cited a significant erosion of trust between the two Koreas. Senior PPP official Choo Kyung-ho emphasized that mutual trust needs to be restored for any agreements to be honoured.
    • Calls for Apology: South Korea demands an immediate apology from North Korea for these provocations, highlighting the need for accountability and reparations for the damages caused.

    North Korea emboldened by Russian support 

    • Military Assistance: The US has warned that Russia is aiding North Korea in developing advanced weapons technologies, such as hypersonic missiles, in exchange for artillery shells amid Russia’s ongoing war in Ukraine.
    • Diplomatic Shield: As a permanent member of the UN Security Council, Russia provides a diplomatic shield for North Korea, stalling efforts to pass new resolutions condemning North Korean actions. This backing allows Pyongyang to act more aggressively without significant international repercussions.

    Escalated Danger of Conflict

    The situation on the Korean Peninsula poses an escalated danger of conflict due to several factors:

    • Aggressive Posturing: North Korea’s recent actions, including missile tests and aerial provocations, signal an aggressive stance that could lead to military confrontations.
    • Policy Shift: Analysts believe Kim Jong Un may be deviating from the defensive policies of his predecessors, adopting a more aggressive strategy aimed at altering the status quo on the peninsula.
    • International Alliances: North Korea’s alignment with Russia, and possibly other authoritarian states like China and Iran, suggests a willingness to use military force to achieve geopolitical goals, challenging the US-led liberal world order.
    • Military Preparedness: The South Korean military and its allies need to stay vigilant as North Korea tests the South’s air defences and military response times, indicating a higher readiness for potential conflict.

    Way forward:

    • Engage in Multilateral Talks: Revitalize dialogue with key stakeholders, including the United States, China, Japan, and Russia, to address North Korea’s actions and find diplomatic solutions.
    • Leverage International Organizations: Utilize platforms like the United Nations to garner international support and pressure North Korea to comply with international norms.

    Mains PYQ: 

    Q Evaluate the economic and strategic dimensions of India’s Look East Policy in the context of the post-Cold War international scenario. (UPSC IAS/2016)

  • Securing India’s energy transition 

    Why in the news?

    India has signed new agreements and updated existing ones with a dozen African countries to secure critical minerals. This initiative is crucial for achieving India’s energy transformation goals.

    India’s Critical Mineral Acquisition Plans in Africa

    • India has signed new agreements and updated existing ones with a dozen African countries to secure critical minerals.
    • This initiative is crucial for India’s energy transformation goals, aiming to diversify sources and reduce dependence on any single supplier.
    • The agreements are part of a broader strategy to secure access to minerals necessary for renewable energy technologies and electric vehicles.

    Demand for Energy in India and China’s Dominance

    • Energy Demand in India: India’s peak power demand increased to 250 GW in 2023-24, marking a 12.7% increase from the previous year. By 2030, India’s peak power demand is expected to reach 366 GW, up from the current level of 240 GW.
    • China’s Dominance: China leads in securing and processing critical minerals, having established long-term relationships with mineral-rich countries in Africa and Latin America. Chinese companies dominate mining rights in economically poor yet mineral-rich nations.
      • China has built significant capacities for processing and refining minerals, making it the primary global hub for critical mineral processing.

    India’s Other Overseas Critical Mineral Acquisition Plans

    • Earlier this year, India signed an agreement with Argentina to explore and develop five lithium brine blocks.
    • The Geological Survey of India (GSI) discovered inferred lithium reserves of 5.9 million tonnes in Jammu & Kashmir.
    • India aims to diversify its sources of critical minerals by securing mining leases abroad, ensuring a stable and sustainable supply chain.

    Government Initiatives to Secure Critical Minerals

    • Exploration and Geological Studies: The government is pushing for more extensive exploration and geological studies within India to identify potential reserves of critical minerals. The Geological Survey of India has been tasked with accelerating the exploration of India’s 3.2 lakh sq km land mass using new data and technologies.
    • Securing Mining Leases Abroad: India is focusing on securing mining leases in other countries to ensure a diversified supply of critical minerals. The agreements with African countries and Argentina are examples of this strategy.
    • Building Domestic Capacities: The government is providing incentives to build refining and processing capacities within India for critical minerals. There is an emphasis on attracting private miners, both domestic and global, to participate in critical mineral exploration within India.
    • Policy and Auction Reforms: The government is analyzing why auctions often fail to generate enough interest and is considering policy changes to attract big players. Coordinated efforts between the Centre and state governments on clearances and royalty payments are being emphasized to streamline the auction process.
    • White Hydrogen Exploration: There is a call for active exploration of potential White Hydrogen deposits within India’s geographical borders.

    Way forward:

    • Accelerate exploration efforts across India’s 3.2 lakh sq km land mass.
    • Utilize new data sources and advanced technologies to identify potential reserves of critical minerals.
    • Focus on unexplored areas for potential discoveries of critical minerals, including White Hydrogen deposits.

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Do you think India will meet 50 percent of its energy needs from renewable energy by 2030? Justify your answer. How will the shift of subsidies from fossil fuels to renewables help achieve the above objectives? Explain. (UPSC IAS/2022)

  • Two lakh plus NOTA votes in Indore: Why NOTA was introduced, its consequences

    Why in the news? 

    Over 200,000 votes were cast for NOTA in the Indore Lok Sabha constituency. Let’s explore the reasons behind the introduction of this option and what occurs if, in an improbable scenario, NOTA garners more votes than all other candidates.

    Back2Basics: NOTA in Indian Elections

    • NOTA, which stands for None of The Above, is an electoral choice where voters can express their disapproval of all the candidates in a voting system.
    • In the 2013 PUCL v. Union of India case, the Supreme Court mandated the use of NOTA in direct elections for the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies.
    • The ruling specified that in such elections, voters should have the option to select to indicate their dissatisfaction with all candidates or political parties listed on the ballot.
    • The NOTA option was first used in the 2013 legislative assembly elections held in four states—Chhattisgarh, Mizoram, Rajasthan, and Madhya Pradesh, and the union territory of Delhi.

    Impact of NOTA Receiving the Highest Number of Votes in a Particular Constituency

    1. Legal Consequence:

    • Current Status: NOTA has no legal consequence; the candidate with the highest votes after NOTA wins the election.
    • Indore Case: Shankar Lalwani won with a massive margin over NOTA, which received the highest number of votes ever recorded for NOTA in any constituency.
    • Possible Change: There are ongoing discussions and petitions urging that elections be declared null and void if NOTA receives the highest number of votes.

    2. Future Considerations:

    • Petition by Shiv Khera: Calls for the ECI to frame guidelines to declare elections null and void if NOTA receives the majority vote and to debar candidates who receive fewer votes than NOTA for five years.

    Judicial Stand

    • 2013 Judgment: The Supreme Court ruled that the right to secrecy in voting includes those who choose not to vote, mandating the introduction of the NOTA option.
    • Rationale: The Court emphasised that secrecy is an essential feature of free and fair elections, supported by the introduction of EVMs to maintain voter anonymity.

    Current Deliberations:

    • New Petition (2024): The Supreme Court is considering a petition to make elections null and void if NOTA gets the highest votes, with additional consequences for candidates.
    • State-Level Precedents: Some states and union territories (e.g., Maharashtra, Haryana, Delhi) have declared NOTA as a “Fictional Electoral Candidate” for local elections, mandating fresh elections if NOTA receives the majority vote.

    Way forward:

    • Null and Void Clause: Introduce a clause in the Representation of the People Act to declare elections null and void if NOTA receives the highest number of votes.
    • Debarment of Candidates: Amend the law to debar candidates who receive fewer votes than NOTA from contesting elections for a specified period (e.g., five years).

    Mains PYQ:

    Q Discuss the procedures to decide the disputes arising out of the election of a Member of the Parliament or State Legislature under The Representation of the People Act, 1951. What are the grounds on which the election of any returned candidate may be declared void? What remedy is available to the aggrieved party against the decision? Refer to the case laws. (UPSC IAS/2022)

  • Tele MANAS cell for Armed Forces

    Why in the News?

    • The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) and the Ministry of Defence (MoD) have entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) to foster collaboration in operating a special cell of Tele MANAS.
      • This collaboration, spanning two years, aims to establish a pilot project at the Armed Forces Medical College in Pune.

    Suicides and Fratricides in Armed Forces: A Global Issue

    • As per information given in Parliament in April 2022, there were two cases of fratricide each year from 2019 to 2021 and one case in 2021.
    • In an older reply in Rajya Sabha on suspected suicide cases in the Army, the Government informed that during the years 2016 to 2018 there were 104, 75 and 80 cases, respectively.
    • A 2018 study correlated extended deployment to a 15% increased suicide risk in the U.S. military, the U.S. Department of Defence recorded 503 suicides among active-duty personnel in 2019.
    • Common reasons that forces an individual to take extreme steps are:
      • Family issues,
      • Family separation,
      • Prolonged deployment in difficult areas,
      • Continuous exposure to hazardous situations,
      • Traumas originated in Counter Insurgency or Counter Terrorism operations and
      • Wide range of Human Resource management issues.
    • Preventive Measures: The Army in its latest advisory issued in August 2023 stated that officers and religious teachers – at least one Pandit, Maulvi, Granthi or Pastor – are posted in each unit and selected other ranks are being trained on the nuances of counselling.

    What is the Tele MANAS Initiative?

    • Tele MANAS, or Tele Mental Health Assistance and Networking across States, stands as India’s National Tele Mental Health Programme.
    • It is envisioned as the digital extension of the District Mental Health Programme (DMHP).
    • Its announcement came in the Union Budget of 2022.
    • The Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) serves as the nodal agency overseeing its implementation.
    • The primary aim is to ensure universal access to equitable, accessible, affordable, and high-quality mental health care through round-the-clock tele-mental health services.
    • The International Institute of Information Technology, Bengaluru, serves as the technology partner.
    • The nodal centre for Tele MANAS operations is located at NIMHANS, Bengaluru.
    • The National Health Systems Resource Centre operates within the health system domain.
    • Helpline numbers for assistance are 14416 and 18008914416.
    • The implementation structure comprises two tiers:
    1. Tier 1: Consists of State Tele MANAS cells comprising trained counsellors and mental health specialists,
    2. Tier 2: Comprises resources from the District Mental Health Program (DMHP) and medical colleges.

    Reach and Impact

    • Nationwide Presence: Currently, 51 operational Tele MANAS cells operate across all 36 States and UTs, delivering services in 20 diverse languages.
    • Remarkable Response: Since its inception in October 2022, Tele MANAS has received over 10 lakh calls and manages a daily average of more than 3,500 calls.

    National Mental Health Programme (NMHP):

    • The NMHP was launched by the Government of India in 1982.
    • It was initiated to address the significant burden of mental disorders in the population.
    • Mental disorders affect approximately 6-7% of the population in India.
      • Objectives of NMHP: Ensuring the availability and accessibility of minimum mental healthcare to all, particularly the vulnerable and underprivileged sections of the population.
    • As part of NMHP, the District Mental Health Program (DMHP) was introduced in 1996 during the IX Five Year Plan based on the ‘Bellary Model’:
      • The Bellary Model emphasizes the importance of early detection, short-term training for physicians, and health worker training in identifying individuals with mental health issues.

     

    PYQ:

    [2023] Why suicide among young women is increasing in Indian society?
  • [5th June 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Election results 2024: How India read the election, how the BJP reads the result

    [5th June 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Election results 2024: How India read the election, how the BJP reads the result

    PYQ Relevance:

    Q “While the national political parties in India favour centralisation, the regional parties are in favour of State autonomy.” Comment. (UPSC IAS/2022)

    Q “The Indian party system is passing through a phase of transition which looks to be full of contradictions and paradoxes.” Discuss. (UPSC IAS/2016)

    Mentor’s Comment: The 2024 Indian general elections have been marked by significant political dynamics and raised critical concerns about democratic erosion. The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which once propagated the slogan ‘aayega toh Modi hi’ (in the end, Modi will come), shifted its narrative to ‘Abki baar 400 paar’ (this time, more than 400 seats). This shift symbolized not just an ambition for electoral victory but an assertion of near-total control, which has prompted widespread anxieties about the health of India’s democracy.

    Let’s Learn–

    Why in the news?

    The concerns of the average voter shaped the 2024 election, and how the BJP responds to these concerns will be crucial.

    Crossing the Red Line: Democratic Erosion

    • Constructed Democratic Legitimacy: For years, the BJP has defended itself against accusations of democratic erosion by pointing to its electoral success. However, democratic legitimacy extends beyond merely winning elections, it hinges on conducting fair elections. 
    • Contentious Actions: In the run-up to the 2024 elections:
      • Two Opposition Chief Ministers were jailed.
      • Many Opposition leaders faced investigations or tax probes.
      • The Election Commission of India (ECI) appeared partisan, not censuring the Prime Minister for violations of the Model Code of Conduct.
      • Traditional media often ignored Opposition campaigns and concerns.
    • Perception of Elections: This created a perception that elections were a foregone conclusion and performative.
    Equal Opportunity: Democratic Theories invoked

    • Robert Dahl’s View: Political theorist Robert Dahl emphasized the necessity for citizens to choose among all political actors and parties on equal footing. Equality of opportunity for all viewpoints is essential but often hard to measure.

    • Adam Przeworski’s Minimal Condition: Adam Przeworski noted that a minimal condition of democracy is plausible political alternation, where the ruling party occasionally loses.

    Voter Anxieties and Democratic Legitimacy

    • Systemic Failures: Voters across India expressed concerns about systemic coercion and manipulation of institutions by the ruling party. In Uttar Pradesh, Dalit communities feared constitutional changes. In southern states, there were anxieties about the federal structure and linguistic identities. These issues reflect a broader sentiment of institutional overreach by the BJP.
    • Media Control and Alternative Narratives: Traditional media’s reluctance to cover opposition campaigns led many voters to seek alternative narratives on social media. The overarching fear of a ‘tanaasahi’ (dictatorship) underscored the public’s discomfort with the BJP’s unbridled use of power.

    Electoral Dynamics and Opposition Strategy

    • Harnessing Voter Discontent: Despite the BJP’s dominance, the opposition effectively harnessed voter discontent. The campaign against electronic voting machine (EVM) manipulation, regardless of its factual basis, gained traction in rural areas, highlighting a significant mistrust in the electoral process.
    • The Battle for the Constitution: The opposition framed the election as a battle for the Constitution, resonating with voters concerned about democratic erosion. This narrative forced the BJP to reassure the electorate about not changing the Constitution, indicating that bottom-up feedback mechanisms were still influential.

    Implications for Governance and Democratic Accountability

    • The Role of Protests: Protests like those against the Citizenship (Amendment) Act and the farmers’ movement indicated a shift in how citizens exert democratic pressure. These movements succeeded outside formal political processes, demonstrating the erosion of traditional democratic institutions’ legitimacy.
    • The Path Forward: The BJP remains the largest party and is likely to form the government again. The critical question is whether it will continue its path of political centralization or heed the limits set by the electorate. Ignoring these limits could lead to new forms of resistance outside traditional democratic institutions.

    Conclusion: The 2024 elections have underscored the complexities of democratic erosion in India. Addressing these challenges requires reinforcing fair electoral processes and ensuring equitable opportunities for all political actors. The interplay between political centralization and citizen resistance will shape the future of India’s democratic trajectory, demanding a nuanced approach to governance that respects democratic principles and public accountability.