💥Join UPSC 2027,2028 Mentorship (July Batch) + XFactor Notes & Microthemes PDF
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

GS Paper: GS2

  • Multilateral Development Banks: A Call for Reform

    What’s the news?

    • A G20 expert panel on strengthening multilateral development banks (MDBs) suggests a paradigm shift.

    Central idea

    • Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs) play a pivotal role in financing and fostering sustainable development globally. However, a G20 expert panel has proposed significant reforms aimed at making MDBs more effective and adaptive to the evolving challenges of our time.

    Key Takeaways

    • MDBs should align their financial and analytical operations to assist national governments in setting up platforms for prioritized sustainable development goals (SDGs).
    • The emphasis is on goals that demonstrate the commitment of country leadership and significant national investment.

    What are Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs)?

    • MDBs are international institutions consisting of multiple developed and developing countries.
    • Role:
    • Facilitate developmental objectives.
    • Offer financial and technical assistance across sectors like transport, energy, and urban infrastructure.
    • Major contributions to the lending pool from developed nations, while developing nations largely borrow for developmental projects.

    The need for reform within MDBs

    • Addressing the Climate Crisis: The expert group cites global challenges such as the climate crisis. There’s knowledge of mitigation measures but a lack of global mechanisms, particularly in emerging markets and developing economies (EMDEs).
    • In Sync with National Priorities: MDBs should resonate with individual nations’ developmental priorities.
    • Engaging the Private Sector: The call is to integrate the private sector more closely into MDB operations. Breaking past limited interactions between private and sovereign financing will be key.
    • Coordinated Effort: Greater synchrony among stakeholders is essential for MDB success. The expert group seeks more involvement from national governments to create a unified vision encompassing goals, policies, investments, and financing.
    • Changing MDB Perceptions: Currently, MDBs’ bureaucratic and risk-averse nature might deter private sector engagement. Given the MDBs’ goal to enhance financing to $390 billion by 2030, the private sector’s involvement is crucial.

    MDBs and Their Traditional Role in India

    • World Bank: Established in 1944, the World Bank’s commitment in India totals $97.6 billion. It has supported sectors including public administration (19%), agriculture (15%), and transport (11%).
    • Asian Development Bank (ADB): ADB, set up in 1969, has pledged assistance worth $59.7 billion in India. Notably, $20.2 billion (34%) has been for transport, $15 billion (25%) for energy, and $6.7 billion (10%) for urban infrastructure.
    • Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB): Founded in 2016, AIIB has approved $9.9 billion for India. Transport (42%), energy (14%), and economic resilience (12.6%) are key sectors.
    • European Investment Bank: Established in 1958, it has sanctioned 22 projects in India, totaling Euro 4.5 billion. The focus has been on transport (Euro 2.45 billion) and energy (Euro 1.5 billion).

    Conclusion

    • The expert group’s recommendations bring to the forefront the pressing need to recalibrate MDBs’ functions and enhance their impact. Aligning with national priorities, ensuring broader stakeholder coordination, and actively involving the private sector can transform the developmental landscape and address global challenges more effectively.

  • Places in news: Rafah Crossing

    rafah crossing

    Central Idea

    • Palestinians have been gathering at the Rafah border crossing with Egypt in the southern Gaza Strip.
    • Meanwhile, Egypt has opened the borders for UN humanitarian aid for Palestinians.

    What is Rafah Crossing?

    • The Rafah Crossing is a border crossing point between the Gaza Strip and Egypt, located in the southern Gaza Strip.
    • It serves as one of the few access points for people and goods to enter or exit the Gaza Strip, which is a Palestinian territory along the eastern coast of the Mediterranean Sea.
    • Egypt has maintained strict movement restrictions at the Rafah crossing for years, raising concerns that it indirectly supports Israel’s Gaza blockade, which began in 2007 after Hamas took control.

    Egypt’s Role and Restrictions

    • Security Concerns: Security concerns in North Sinai, where Egypt has battled jihadists linked to Al Qaeda, have largely justified these restrictions.
    • Avoiding Exodus: Egypt may be reluctant to open the crossing without clear conditions and guarantees to avoid a mass exodus of Palestinians from Gaza.
    • Responsibility Concerns: Egypt is concerned about being responsible for a large influx of Gazans if the crossing is opened indefinitely.
    • Permanent Resettlement: Egypt is reluctant to facilitate a permanent resettlement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from Gaza.

  • Caste Enumeration and OBC Sub-Categorization in India

    obc caste

    Central Idea

    • The recent publication of Bihar’s caste survey results has sparked discussions about the possibility of similar exercises in other states as India enters a new electoral cycle.
    • Enumerating castes and sub-categorizing Other Backward Classes (OBCs) for equitable reservation distribution have long been contentious issues.

    Who are Other Backward Classes (OBCs)?

    • Origins of OBCs: OBCs represent communities and castes considered socially and educationally backward, distinct from Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs).
    • Constitutional Mandate: The Indian Constitution mandates affirmative action for OBCs through Articles 15(4) and 16(4), enabling special provisions and reservations.

    Diverse Categories within OBCs

    • Occupational Classification: OBCs have historically been identified based on their occupations, including land ownership, farming, labor, and artisanal work.
    • Two Broad Categories: OBCs can be broadly categorized into landowners (e.g., Yadavs and Kurmis in Bihar and Uttar Pradesh) and non-landowners.
    • Inequality Concerns: A demand for reservation within OBCs has emerged, as a few “upper” OBCs have reportedly benefitted disproportionately from the existing 27% reservation, a result of the Mandal Commission’s recommendations over 30 years ago.

    EBCs in Bihar

    • EBC Identification: Bihar’s caste survey identified 27% of the population as “pichhda” (backward) and 36% as “atyant pichhda” (Extremely Backward Classes, or EBCs).
    • Historical Context: The state had previously categorized castes as “more backward,” and the Karpoori Thakur Formula, implemented in the 1970s, offered reservation benefits to various groups, including OBCs, economically backward OBCs, women, and the economically disadvantaged from “upper castes.”

    Historical OBC Commissions

    • Kaka Kalekar Commission (1953): Established in 1953, it recommended identifying socially and educationally backward classes and 25-40% reservation in government jobs.
    • Mandal Commission (1979): Appointed in 1979 but implemented in 1990, it identified 3,743 OBC castes, suggested 27% reservation in government jobs and educational institutions, and proposed no sub-categorization.

    State-specific Subcategorization

    • Diverse State Approaches: Various states have implemented subcategorization within their OBC quotas based on unique criteria.
    • Examples: Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, and Kerala have subgroups within their OBC reservations.

    Subcategorization at the National Level

    • Subcategorization Initiative: In 2015, the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment tasked the National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC) with examining the subcategorization of OBCs.
    • NCBC’s Recommendation: The NCBC proposed subcategorization into Extremely Backward Classes, More Backward Classes, and Backward Classes.

    Recent Developments: Rohini Commission

    • In October 2017, the Rohini Commission was formed to explore OBC subcategorization.
    • It submitted its report in July 2023, although its contents remain undisclosed.

    Conclusion

    • The issue of caste enumeration and subcategorization of OBCs in India reflects complex social and political dynamics.
    • While it aims to ensure equitable distribution of reservation benefits, it also highlights the need for nuanced, state-specific approaches to address the diverse composition of OBC communities.
    • The recent report by the Rohini Commission holds potential significance, but its implications and recommendations await public scrutiny and debate.

  • In India, reproductive autonomy remains a pipedream

    Central idea

    • A recent Supreme Court case in India has spotlighted reproductive autonomy. It centers on a 27-year-old mother of two, grappling with an unwanted pregnancy due to lactational amenorrhea, igniting a debate on India’s abortion rights, known for their relative liberalism.

    Background

    • India’s population policy promotes a two-child norm, making it seemingly unremarkable for a woman to seek an abortion to avoid becoming a mother for the third time.
    • However, this case is far from straightforward due to the pregnancy being at 26 weeks, exceeding the gestational limit prescribed in the 2021 Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act.
    • In such cases, medical practitioners’ opinions hold paramount importance.

    Reproductive Autonomy vs. Ethical Concerns

    • Interchangeable Terminology: The heart of the matter lies in the interchangeable use of terms like foetus, child, and baby, particularly given the advanced stage of pregnancy. This linguistic flexibility can significantly impact the ethical considerations of the case.
    • Concerns of Foeticide: As the pregnancy had reached 26 weeks, concerns emerged regarding the termination possibly constituting “foeticide.” The advanced stage of pregnancy blurs the line between a developing foetus and a potentially viable child, leading to ethical dilemmas.
    • Justice Nagarathna’s Emphasis: Justice Nagarathna emphasized the paramount importance of prioritizing the petitioner’s decision and upholding her reproductive autonomy. Her stance echoes Justice D Y Chandrachud’s earlier observation regarding the intrinsic right of pregnant women to choose abortion without the need for consent or authorization from a third party.
    • Balancing Reproductive Autonomy and Ethics: The case highlights the intricate balance required between recognizing and safeguarding the fundamental rights of pregnant women to make choices about their bodies and reproductive health, while simultaneously addressing the ethical dimensions of such decisions within the framework of societal values and laws.

    The legal framework and amendments pertaining to abortion in India

    • MTP Act of 1971: The Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act of 1971 was the foundational legislation that regulated abortion in India. It permitted abortions up to 20 weeks of gestation under specific conditions, such as the risk to the life or physical or mental health of the pregnant woman.
    • Amendment in 2021: In 2021, the MTP Act underwent significant amendments to modernize and liberalize India’s abortion laws. The key changes included:
      • Extending the permissible gestational limit from 20 to 24 weeks.
      • Expanding access to abortion services by allowing a broader range of healthcare providers to perform abortions, including mid-level providers.
    • Constitution of Medical Boards: The 2021 amendment introduced provisions for the constitution of Medical Boards. These boards consist of medical experts responsible for assessing cases where pregnancy termination is sought beyond 24 weeks.
    • Reducing Dependency on Courts: By allowing Medical Boards to make determinations, the amendment sought to reduce the burden on the judicial system and expedite the decision-making process for cases involving late-term pregnancies.

    Way forward

    • Citizen with Agency: The petitioner approached the court as an empowered citizen, asserting her right to make choices about her own body.
    • Socially Accepted Context: Her pregnancy occurred within societal norms, emphasizing that reproductive autonomy applies broadly.
    • Sound Mental Health: Her rational decision challenges stereotypes about individuals seeking abortions.
    • Absence of Foetal Anomalies: Her request is driven by personal choice, not medical necessity.
    • Reproductive Choice: She firmly expressed her desire not to have another child, highlighting the importance of individual reproductive decisions.
    • Seeking State Support: By seeking state support for safe abortion services, she aligns with international commitments on access to reproductive healthcare as a human right.

    Conclusion

    • This case underscores the battle between reproductive autonomy and ethical considerations surrounding abortion in India. As women navigate the complex journey to assert their reproductive rights, questions arise about whether they can truly claim ownership of their bodies on their own terms.

  • India’s Evolving Role in the Middle East Crisis

    What’s the news?

    • As tensions continue to escalate in the Middle East, diplomatic efforts have gained momentum. US President Joe Biden’s decision to visit Israel to assess Israeli plans is a significant development.

    Central idea

    • The world finds itself sharply divided on this issue, with emerging geopolitical faultlines becoming increasingly solidified. These divisions are not limited to international boundaries but are also being mirrored within nations. Given India’s growing interests in the Middle East, it cannot remain indifferent to the reverberations from its extended neighborhood.

    India’s Growing Stake in the Middle East

    • Remarkable Foreign Policy Achievement: India’s engagement in the Middle East, under Prime Minister Modi’s leadership, stands as a remarkable foreign policy achievement. This success transcends the often-debated.
    • Building Strong Ties: prime Minister’s efforts have resulted in India building strong ties with key stakeholders in the Middle East. These relationships have given India a distinct and influential role in the region.
    • Beyond Ideology: While the India-Israel relationship has been growing steadily since the 1990s. Prime minister Modi has emphasized the need for India’s Arab partners to build a relationship that addresses 21st-century challenges, shifting the focus away from religious heritage.

    India’s Balanced Approach

    • Pragmatism in Diplomacy: India’s approach to the Middle East is marked by pragmatism and balance. It seeks to navigate the complex dynamics of the region with a steady hand.
    • Solidarity with Israel: India’s expression of solidarity with Israel in the wake of a terror attack should not be viewed as a shift in policy, but as a natural response to support a friendly nation in a time of crisis.
    • Support for a Two-State Solution: India’s Ministry of External Affairs reaffirms its support for negotiations aimed at establishing a sovereign, independent, and viable Palestinian state living in peace alongside Israel. This stance reflects India’s long-standing position and commitment to a peaceful resolution.

    India’s Transformational Role

    • Recognizing Regional Shifts: India’s engagement with the Middle East is shaped by its keen recognition of the transformative changes taking place in the Arab world. It was among the first to acknowledge and adapt to these shifts.
    • Pragmatic Engagement: India’s foreign policy in the Middle East is no longer driven solely by religious considerations. Instead, it emphasizes pragmatic engagement with regional stakeholders.
    • Critical Player: This transformational role positions India as a critical player in the region. It allows India to respond effectively to emerging challenges and opportunities in a rapidly changing Middle East.

    Conclusion

    • As the Middle East sees soaring tensions, Indian diplomacy will inevitably be under scrutiny. While challenges in the region aren’t new for New Delhi, what has evolved is its ambition to play a significant role in alignment with changing strategic realities.

  • Judicial Perspectives on LGBTQI Marriage and Adoption Issues

    Central Idea

    • In a recent landmark decision, the Supreme Court, led by Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud, deliberated on granting legal status to same-sex marriages.
    • This case has sparked significant interest as it explores the intersection of individual rights and societal norms.

    Judicial Perspectives on Various Issues:

    [A] Fundamental Right to Marry

    Issue Minority View (CJI) Majority View
    Petitioner Argument
    • Marriage is not fundamentally important;
    • It gained significance through state regulation as Civil Union.
    • Marriage’s importance is personal preference and social status.
    • It is necessarily NOT a fundamental right.

     

    [B] Interpretation of Special Marriage Act

    Issue Minority View (CJI) Majority View
    Framing the Issue
    • Cautioned against expansive interpretations;
    • Suggested encroachment on the legislature’s domain.
    • Concurred with the minority view.
    • Emphasized the SMA’s purpose for facilitating civil marriages between heterosexual couples.

     

    [C] Queer Couples’ Right to Adopt a Child

    Issue Minority View (CJI) Majority View
    Discriminatory Regulations
    • Struck down certain CARA regulations, asserting that they do not serve the child’s best interests.
    • Highlighted the discriminatory impact on the queer community based on their sexuality.
    • Acknowledged the discriminatory aspect.
    • But believed legislative action, rather than judicial imposition, should bring about this change.

     

    [D] Civil Unions for Queer Couples

    Argument Minority View (CJI Chandrachud) Majority View
    Recognition of Civil Unions
    • Connected the right to form intimate associations with freedom of speech and expression.
    • Proposed that the state should acknowledge various entitlements for such relationships.
    • Disagreed with prescribing a “choice” of civil unions.
    • Suggested that the state should facilitate this choice for those who opt for it.

     Conclusion

    • The Supreme Court’s decision on same-sex marriage reflects a complex interplay of legal, social, and legislative factors.
    • While the minority view leans towards immediate recognition of civil unions and highlights the importance of individual rights, the majority opinion emphasizes the legislative role in bringing about changes in societal norms.
    • The verdict underscores the evolving landscape of LGBTQ+ rights in India and the ongoing dialogue surrounding equal rights and inclusivity.

  • Explained: India’s Bid for the 2036 Olympics

    Olympics

    Central Idea

    • Prime Minister Modi recently confirmed India’s formal bid to host the 2036 Olympic Games, raising questions about the financial implications and benefits of hosting this prestigious event.

    About Olympics

    Origins Began in ancient Greece in 776 BCE in Olympia.
    Revival Revived by Pierre de Coubertin in 1896 in Athens, Greece.
    Five Rings Olympic flag features five interlocking rings representing unity among 5 continents.
    Olympic Motto “Citius, Altius, Fortius” (Faster, Higher, Stronger) reflects the pursuit of excellence.
    Sports Included Features a diverse range of sports, from athletics and swimming to archery and gymnastics.
    Discontinued Sports Some sports, like tug of war and live pigeon shooting, have been removed.

    Selecting the Olympics Host City

    • International Olympic Committee (IOC) Decision: The host city is chosen by the International Olympic Committee members through a secret ballot, with the majority vote determining the winner.
    • Competition and Diplomacy: Securing the opportunity to host the Olympics involves significant financial resources and diplomatic efforts. Typically, winners are announced 7-8 years before the event.

    Olympics

    Cost of Hosting the Olympics

    • Expensive Endeavor: Bidding for the Olympics is a costly proposition, with countries spending $50-100 million, even for unsuccessful bids. In case of a successful bid, the expenses can soar into billions of dollars.
    • Examples of Expenditure: Tokyo spent $150 million for its failed 2016 bid and even more for the successful 2020 bid. Toronto refrained from bidding due to the $60 million cost for the 2024 bid.
    • Infrastructure Investment: Hosting the Olympics entails building stadiums and enhancing infrastructure to accommodate athletes and tourists.

    Funding the Olympics Expenses

    • Local Government Responsibility: The majority of expenses, especially on infrastructure, are shouldered by the local government and are spread across the country’s budget.
    • Borrowing for Cost Overruns: Countries often resort to borrowing to cover cost overruns. The IOC contributes some revenue to the host country, but it constitutes a relatively small amount, e.g., $1.5 billion for Rio De Janeiro in 2016.

    Assessing the Worth of Hosting the Olympics

    • Benefits of Hosting: Hosting the Olympics elevates a country’s global status, promotes it as an investment and tourist destination.
    • Cautions on Overspending: Excessive spending can have dire consequences, as seen with Canada’s 30-year debt from the 1976 Montreal Games, the impact on Greece’s financial crisis after the 2004 Athens Olympics, and Rio’s $900 million bailout request from the Brazilian government.
    • Positive Outcomes: In some cases, such as Beijing, hosting the Olympics led to significant GDP growth acceleration, by at least 0.8%.

    India’s Prospects

    • Favorable Timing: India’s bid aligns well with its status as the world’s most populous and fastest-growing major economy.
    • Past Experience: Having previously hosted the 1982 Asian Games and the 2010 Commonwealth Games, India possesses a favorable track record, which the IOC takes into consideration.
    • Gujarat’s Bid: Gujarat is contemplating bidding for the 2026 Commonwealth Games, which could further demonstrate India’s hosting capabilities.
    • Economic Power: India’s ascent as an economic powerhouse enhances its candidacy’s appeal to other nations.

    Conclusion

    • While India’s bid to host the 2036 Olympics presents an opportunity to boost its global profile and economic prospects, it is essential to strike a balance between ambition and fiscal prudence.
    • The economic implications, positive and negative, of hosting such a monumental event should be carefully evaluated to ensure that the effort and investment yield substantial long-term benefits for the nation.

  • India-Sri Lanka ferry service restarted

    What’s the news?

    • The passenger ferry service, named ‘Cheriyapani,’ was officially launched on a recent Saturday.

    Central idea

    • The Nagapattinam-Jaffna ferry service revives an ancient India-Sri Lanka sea route, fostering bilateral ties, tourism, and people-to-people relations. Additionally, it promises economic benefits for local traders on both coasts.

    The New Ferry Service

    • The passenger ferry service, Cheriyapani, was officially launched.
    • Travelers can avail a one-way ticket for approximately Rs 7,670, which includes a generous baggage allowance of up to 40 kg per passenger.
    • The journey departs from Nagapattinam at 7 am, reaching Kankesanthurai by 11 am, and the return trip commences at 1.30 pm, arriving in Nagapattinam by 5.30 pm.

    Historical Context

    • Maritime linkage between India and Sri Lanka has a rich history, with the Indo-Ceylon Express or Boat Mail operating from Chennai to Colombo via Thoothukudi port until 1982. The civil war in Sri Lanka disrupted these services.
    • Before the conflict, Dhanushkodi to Talaimannar was a popular route, connecting Chennai via train and coal-powered steam ferry.

    Past Attempts at Ferry Services

    • Post-Independence Services: Following India’s independence and the formation of Sri Lanka as a separate nation in 1948, ferry services continued to operate between the two countries, connecting ports like Chennai and Colombo.
    • Indo-Ceylon Express: The Indo-Ceylon Express, also known as the Boat Mail, ran between Chennai and Colombo via the Thoothukudi port from the early 1900s until 1982. This service was a significant mode of transportation and trade between the two countries.
    • Disruption Due to Civil War: The prolonged civil war in Sri Lanka, which began in 1983, led to the suspension of ferry services between India and Sri Lanka. This conflict disrupted not only transportation but also the overall relationship between the two countries.
    • Memorandum of Understanding (MoU): After the end of the civil war in 2009, there were renewed efforts to restore ferry services. In 2011, a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) concerning passenger transportation by sea was signed, leading to the launch of a ferry service.
    • Proposals for New Routes: Besides the Nagapattinam-Jaffna route, there were proposals to establish ferry services from Rameswaram to Talaimannar and Karaikal to Kankesanthurai. O

    Potential Impact of the Nagapattinam-Jaffna Ferry Service

    • Boost to Religious Tourism: Prominent Indian pilgrimage centers such as Nagapattinam, Nagore, Velankanni, Thirunallar, and temple towns like Thanjavur, Madurai, and Tiruchi are expected to witness an influx of Sri Lankan tourists.
    • Economic Benefits: The ferry service has the potential to stimulate regional commerce and trade. Local traders and businesses on both sides of the Palk Strait may benefit from increased cross-border trade and tourism.
    • Diplomatic and Bilateral Relations: High-level statements from leaders of both countries, such as Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Sri Lankan President Ranil Wickremesinghe, indicate the diplomatic significance attached to the service.
    • Infrastructure Development: The anticipation of increased travelers has prompted infrastructure development initiatives. Investments in port facilities, customs procedures, and immigration processes can enhance the overall travel experience.
    • Promotion of Regional Peace: Increased people-to-people interactions facilitated by the ferry service can contribute to regional peace and stability by fostering mutual understanding and goodwill between communities on both sides of the strait.

    Initial Challenges Faced by the Nagapattinam-Jaffna Ferry Service

    • Service Frequency Adjustment: The Shipping Corporation of India (SCI) had initially planned to run the ferry services every day for ten days. However, this schedule was adjusted to operate thrice a week.
    • Ticket Pricing: The cost of a one-way ticket, approximately Rs 7,670, has been considered relatively high by some passengers. High ticket prices can deter potential travelers, particularly those on a tight budget.
    • Ticketing Systems: Reports suggest that the ticketing systems for the ferry service may not be as efficient as desired. Passengers have experienced difficulties with booking tickets, which can lead to inconvenience and dissatisfaction.
    • Reduced Passenger Interest: Poor response and passenger turnout during the initial days of operation may be indicative of reduced interest in the service. Building awareness and creating incentives for passengers to choose the ferry over other modes of transportation is crucial.
    • Operational Efficiency: Operational efficiency is critical for the ferry service’s success. Ensuring timely departures, arrivals, and efficient boarding processes is essential to maintain passenger satisfaction and reliability.

    Leaders’ Perspectives

    • Prime Minister Narendra Modi, during the launch of the service on October 14, emphasized that connectivity is not just about bringing cities closer; it also fosters closer relationships between countries and their people.
    • Sri Lankan President Ranil Wickremesinghe, in a video message, regarded the revival of the ferry service as a significant step toward strengthening connectivity between India and Sri Lanka.

    Conclusion

    • The inauguration of the Nagapattinam-Jaffna ferry service signifies a promising chapter in the historical maritime linkage between India and Sri Lanka. By addressing operational challenges and leveraging its potential, this initiative can contribute to regional development, tourism, and strengthened bilateral ties.

  • Money Laundering Probe against a Political Party

    Central Idea

    • The Enforcement Directorate (ED) is contemplating adding a political party as an accused in a money laundering probe linked to the now-defunct Excise Policy of the Delhi government.

    Booking a Political Party for Money Laundering

    • Applicable Law: Section 70 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) addresses offences by companies, and it can be invoked in this case.
    • Definition of “Company”: While a political party isn’t a ‘company’ under the Companies Act, the PMLA includes an explanation that broadens the scope to include ‘associations of individuals,’ potentially encompassing political parties.

    Precedent for such Cases

    • If pursued, this action could set a significant precedent in India’s legal landscape.
    • Previously, political parties have been investigated under the Income Tax Act.
    • Trusts and NGOs are already within the purview of the PMLA, as per a notification by the Finance Ministry.

    Connection between Charges and Political Party

    • The central allegation by the ED is that the political party received the proceeds of crime in the excise scam.
    • An additional explanation in Section 70 of the PMLA specifies that a “company may be prosecuted, notwithstanding whether the prosecution or conviction of any legal juridical person shall be contingent on the prosecution or conviction of any individual.”
    • This implies that even if cases involving party members fail, the party can still be prosecuted for money laundering separately.

  • Supreme Court declines to Legalize Same-Sex Marriage

    Central Idea

    • The Supreme Court of India has declined to approve same-sex marriages in a blow to LGBTQ rights.
    • CJI said that it was outside the court’s remit to decide the issue and that parliament should write the laws governing marriage.

    Same-Sex Marriage Demand

    • Petitioners are urging for the reinterpretation of the Special Marriage Act (SMA), 1954, by replacing “man and woman” with “spouses” to accommodate LGBTQIA+ couples.
    • Such right to marry not only symbolizes equality but also grants access to numerous legal benefits, including insurance, adoption, and inheritance.

    Petitioners’ Demands

    Arguments Summary
    Constitutional Basis Asserted that the right to marry for non-heterosexual couples is implicit in various constitutional articles, including Articles 14, 15, 16, 19, and 21.
    Previous Landmark Judgments Referenced key Supreme Court judgments such as ‘Navtej Singh Johar vs. Union of India’ (2018) and ‘KS Puttaswamy vs. Union of India’ (2017) to support their case.
    Benefits and Rights Emphasized the importance of equal access to marriage-related benefits and rights, such as pensions and provident funds.
    Minimum Marriageable Age Suggested different minimum marriageable ages for lesbian, gay, and transgender couples based on gender identity.
    Recognition of Fundamental Rights Cited the Transgender Persons Protection Act, 2019, as a precedent recognizing the right to marry for all queer identities.

    Respondent’s Arguments

    Arguments Summary
    Maintainability and Jurisdiction Questioned the court’s jurisdiction to hear the case and raised concerns about the maintainability of the petitions.
    Impact on Existing Laws Argued that introducing marriage equality would impact 160 existing laws, making it the prerogative of Parliament to enact such changes.
    SMA Character and Intent Emphasized that the Special Marriage Act (SMA) was intentionally designed for heterosexual marriages, and changing its character and intent would require legislative action.
    Legitimate State Interest Contended that the State has a legitimate interest in regulating marriages, addressing aspects such as age of consent, bigamy, and prohibited degrees of marriage.
    Welfare of Children Advocated for prioritizing the welfare of children born to heterosexual parents, leading to differential treatment of heterosexual and homosexual couples.
    Public Perception Expressed concerns about societal acceptance and potential collateral damage to various legal provisions if same-sex marriage were declared a fundamental right.

    States Responses

    • Rajasthan, Assam, and Andhra Pradesh opposed the plea for legal recognition of same-sex marriages.
    • Sikkim, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Manipur sought more time to respond.
    • Also, many fundamentalist religious organizations are opposed to such marriages.

    Conclusion

    • It must be noted that only Taiwan and Nepal allow same-sex unions in Asia, where largely conservative values still dominate politics and society.
    • The Supreme Court’s verdict on marriage equality in India is poised to shape the country’s LGBTQIA+ rights landscape profoundly.

    Also read:

    [Sansad TV] Perspective: Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage