GS Paper: GS3-24. Various Security Forces and Agencies and their Mandate.

Context

All major powers undertake a periodic (every 4-5 years) review of their evolving national security objectives. The government of India, on the other hand, has neglected to undertake any such exercise, in the past 75 years.

India’s defence budget for FY 2022-23

• In 2022-23, the Ministry of Defence has been allocated Rs 5,25,166 crore.
• This includes expenditure on salaries of armed forces and
  civilians, pensions, modernisation of armed forces, production establishments, maintenance, and research and development organisations.
• According to the Stockholm International Peace
  Research Institute (SIPRI), India was the third largest defence spender in absolute terms in 2020
  after USA and China.
• In the last decade (2012-13 to 2022-23), the budget of the Ministry of Defence has grown at an annual average rate of 8.6%, while total government expenditure has grown at 10.8%.
• Defence expenditure as a percentage of GDP declined from 2.3% in 2012-13 to 2% in 2022-23.

Neglect of defence expenditure in India

• Defence expenditure as non-plan expenditure: Independent India saw defence expenditure being relegated to the “non-plan” category, within the ambit of a Soviet-inspired, central economy.
• Pension bill linked to defence budget: In another anomaly, the pension bill of veteran soldiers — a separate charge on the exchequer — was linked to the defence budget.
• Neglect of modernisation needs: And the growing pension bill was given as an excuse for the dwindling funds available for force-enhancement and hardware replacement/modernisation.
• As a result, the finance ministry, instead of finding ways and means of raising essential, additional funds for national defence demanded that they evolve measures for reducing the pension bill.

Two issues with our national security approach

1] Lack of periodic review

• Every nation faces the eternal “guns vs butter” dilemma.
• Periodic review: All major powers undertake a periodic (every 4-5 years) review of their evolving national security objectives, the options available, and the economic/military means available for achieving them.
• Apart from providing fiscal guidance, this process also facilitates the evolution of a national security strategy. 
• China, has, since 2002, been issuing, with unfailing regularity, a biennial “Defence White Paper”, which encapsulates all of the foregoing, and is available on the Internet; for the information of foes and friends, alike.
• The government of India, on the other hand, has neglected to undertake any such exercise, in the past 75 years.
• India is amongst the few major powers which has failed to issue a National Security Strategy or Doctrine.

2] Lack of organisation reforms

• A second fact that we need to face is that our armed forces have remained in a Second World War time-warp, as far as their organisation and doctrines are concerned.
• Lack of political will and internal resistance: Attempts at organisational reform have come to naught due to lack of political will as well as internal resistance from the services; with the constitution of a Chief of Defence Staff and creation of a Department of Military Affairs providing the latest examples.

Way forward

• Given the transformed nature of warfare, down-sizing of the Indian army, by substituting manpower with smart technology and innovative tactics, has become an imperative need.

Agnipath Scheme

• Recently announced Agnipath scheme provides for the recruitment of youths in the age bracket of 17-and-half to 21 years for only four years with a provision to retain 25 per cent of them for 15 more years.
• Later, the government extended the upper age limit to 23 years for recruitment in 2022.
• The personnel to be recruited under the new scheme will be known as Agniveers.

Suggestions for Agneepath Scheme

• 1] Not the best time to introduce reform: Given the parlous security situation, on the country’s northern and western borders as well as the ongoing domestic turbulence, this is not the best time to cast the armed forces — already short of manpower — into turmoil, with a radical and untried new recruitment system.
• 2] The scheme is suitable for the army only: Such a scheme, in its present form, is suitable only for the army, whose large infantry component is not excessively burdened with technology.
• In case of the navy and air force,  at least 5-6 years are required before a new entrant can acquire enough hands-on experience to be entrusted with the operation or maintenance of lethal weapon systems and complex machinery and electronics.
• 3] Trial before implementation: A radical change of this nature should have been subjected to a trial before service-wide implementation.
• Ideally, a few units of the regular or Territorial Army could have been earmarked as a testing ground, and feed-back obtained.
• 4] Legal backing to post-demobilisation employment: Experience of the past has shown that the home ministry has resisted induction of ex-servicemen into the armed-police and para-military forces, on the grounds that it would spoil the career path of their own cadres.
• Neglect by the state government: Similarly, state governments and other agencies have blatantly ignored the reservations mandated for ESM.
• Therefore, if the Agnipath scheme has to offer a meaningful promise of post-demobilisation employment or education, this must be mandated by an Act of Parliament, on the lines of the “GI Bill” enacted by the US Congress.

Conclusion

A scheme on the lines of Agnipath, appropriately constituted, and focused on enhancing “combat effectiveness” rather than “effecting savings” or “generating employment,” could have triggered a reformative process. But the above given caveats need to be borne in mind in this context.

UPSC 2023 countdown has begun! Get your personal guidance plan now! (Click here)

Context

Recently, the Agnipath scheme for recruitment of short-term contracted soldiers was announced.

About Agnipath Scheme

• This will be the only form of recruitment of soldiers into the three defence services from now.
• The scheme aims at strengthening national security and for providing an opportunity to the youth to serve in the armed forces.
• Recruits under the scheme will be known as ‘Agniveers’.
• After completing the four-year service, they can apply for regular employment in the armed forces.
• They may be given priority over others for various jobs in other government departments.
• The move is expected to decrease the average age profile of armed forces personnel from the current 32 to 24-26 years over a period of time.

Benefits of the Agnipath Scheme

• Lower the average age: The average age in the forces is 32 years today, which will go down to 26 in six to seven years, the scheme envisions.
• Youthful armed forces will allow them to be easily trained for new technologies.
• Employment opportunities: It will increase employment opportunities and because of the skills and experience acquired during the four-year service such soldiers will get employment in various fields.
• High-skilled workforce: The scheme will also lead to the availability of a higher-skilled workforce to the economy which will be helpful in productivity gain and overall GDP growth

Financial constraints and challenges

• Directing funds towards modernisation: It has been argued that the savings in the pensions bill — which will show up on the books only after a couple of decades — would be directed towards the modernisation of defence forces.
• The armed forces do not have that kind of time available to them to postpone their already long-delayed modernisation.
• Shortage: The Indian Air Force is already down to 30 squadrons of fighter jets against the 42 squadrons it needs, and the Indian Navy is at 130 ships when its vision was to be a 200-ship navy; the Indian Army is already short of 1,00,000 soldiers.
•  Instead of expanding the economy to support the military, the Government has resorted to shrinking the military.

Issues with the short-term recruitment

• No theoretical modelling: As the short-term recruitment policy has neither been theoretically modelled nor tried out as a pilot project, the exact consequences of the move will only be known as they play out.
• Adverse effect on professional capabilities: But its adverse effect on the professional capabilities of the armed forces is certain.
• It starts with the very high turnover of young soldiers, the increase in training capacities and infrastructure and the augmentation of the administrative setup for greater recruitment, release, and retention of soldiers.
• An armed forces boasting of a poor teeth-to-tail ratio is further increasing the tail.
• Impact on operational capabilities: The tooth-to-tail ratio (T3R), in military jargon, is the amount of military personnel it takes to supply and support (“tail”) each combat soldier (“tooth”).
• The Indian Air Force and the Indian Navy employ their airmen and sailors in very specialised roles, which require technical skills, and a high degree of training and experience.
• Because the short-term contractual soldier model (the Agniveer scheme) is going to take a few years to fully play out at an organisational level, the actual degradation of operational capability will only be known then.
• Class-based recruitment abolished: In the Agnipath proposal, the class-based recruitment has been replaced with an all-India all-class recruitment.
• It will strike at the core of the organisational management, leadership structures and operating philosophy of the Indian Army.
• Even though the soldiers in the Indian Army are professionally trained, they also draw their motivation from their social identity  — where each soldier cares for his reputation among the peers in his caste group or his village or his social setting.
• To replace that with a pure professional identity of a soldier will bring its own challenges in a tradition-bound army.
• Training challenges: There will be major problems in training, integrating and deploying soldiers with different levels of experience and motivations.
• An organisation which depends on trust, camaraderie and esprit de corps could end up grappling with rivalries and jealousies amongst winners and losers, especially in their final year of contract.
• Legal challenges: Even though the Government has kept the contract at four years to deny the Agniveer gratuity and is not counting the contractual period towards regular service, these provisions are bound to be challenged legally.
•  Over time, this will lead to the salary and pension budget creeping back up again.
• Political imbalance: The Agnipath scheme also does away with the idea of a State-wise quota for recruitment into the Army, based on the Recruitable Male Population of that State which was implemented from 1966.
• This prevented an imbalanced army.
• Academic research shows that the high level of ethnic imbalance has been associated with severe problems of democracy and an increased likelihood of civil war.
• Impact on motivation: A short-term contractual soldier, without earning pension, will be seen as doing jobs after his military service that are not seen to be commensurate in status and prestige with the profession of honour.
• Impact on motivation: It will reduce the motivation of those joining on short-term contracts while diminishing the “honour” of a profession which places extraordinary demands on young men.
• Social unrest: There are numerous examples of demobilised soldiers leading to increased violence against minorities.
• This could happen in India as the youth who are not given regular recruitment after four year’s service would turn to violence.

Conclusion

The Government’s yearning for financial savings runs the risk of reducing the honour of a profession, the stability of a society and the safety of a country.

UPSC 2023 countdown has begun! Get your personal guidance plan now! (Click here)