Q.2) Why was the 97th constitutional amendment struck down partially by the Supreme Court? What are the issues with the Union government playing a greater role in the cooperative sector? (10 Marks)

“Mentor’s Comments”

  • https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/a-judgment-that-must-be-taken-in-the-right-spirit/article35595284.ece
  • In the intro, mention the background of the 97th amendment.
  • In the body, mention the procedural reason given by the court under Article 368 for striking down the part of the amendment requiring ratification by states. In the next part, mention the issue of the Union government seeking to control the sector and issues with it such as it is in State List and the idea of states controlling the sector goes back to Government of India Act 1919 placing it in the provincial list, organising principles of the mechanism differ from area to area and depends on industry or crop, homogeneity is not suitable for the sector.
  • Conclude by stating that the government takes this judgement in the right spirit and avoid excessive control over the sector.

 

10 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Raghava IAS
Raghava IAS
1 month ago

Pls find the answer and provide suddestions.

Order I’d:#0000445827

Adobe Scan Jul 29, 2021_1.jpg
Adobe Scan Jul 29, 2021_2.jpg
Utkarsha Yadav
Utkarsha Yadav
1 month ago

Please review Sir
Payment Id pay_HHWzC2O9xhkaqA

0_CamScanner 07-29-2021 23.07_1.jpg
1_CamScanner 07-29-2021 23.07_2.jpg
Sehaj Singh
Sehaj Singh
1 month ago

Pay ID
#0000440503

5C232409-CB84-4078-AA50-1A69622852B6.jpeg
3D20A68D-246D-4CA4-A35C-CE387285DC9A.jpeg
Jaya Ratnasami
Jaya Ratnasami
1 month ago

Payment:0000382105

Cs1.jpeg
Cs2.jpeg
ankita thakur
ankita thakur
1 month ago

Payment id-HJHAZEWKSzM3CX

Adobe Scan 01-Aug-2021_1.jpg
Adobe Scan 01-Aug-2021_2.jpg