Q.3) What are the issues with the argument for special treatment of the states with higher contribution to the GST pool? (10 marks)

“Mentor’s Comments”

  • https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/gst-concessions-on-covid-relief-nirmala-sitharaman-7353390/
  • In the intro, mention the unanimous adoption of GST through 101st Constitution Amendment Act.
  • In the body mention the issues with the argument for special treatment such as governance issues and contradiction in the welfare state in which unequal treatment is given to citizens in different states, implications for federalism, the locational or geographic advantage enjoyed by the state GST collected by State does not represent the revenue of that state etc.
  • You can conclude by mentioning the need to continue the equal weightage to the states to preserve the idea of federalism.

 

23 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Harshaa Sharma
Harshaa Sharma
1 month ago

Idpay_HJ2s89guguFYwg

IMG_20210611_174753.jpg
ankita thakur
ankita thakur
1 month ago

Payment id-HJHAZEWKSzM3CX

Adobe Scan 11-Jun-2021 (4)_1.jpg
Adobe Scan 11-Jun-2021 (4)_2.jpg
SUMITA DOWERAH
SUMITA DOWERAH
1 month ago

Payment Id: pay HFrdyJMOEZ9967. Please review, Sir.

Adobe Scan 12-Jun-2021_1.jpg
Adobe Scan 12-Jun-2021_2.jpg
Adobe Scan 12-Jun-2021_3.jpg
Pulkit Saxena
Pulkit Saxena
1 month ago
Reply to  SUMITA DOWERAH

Nice one , can be better
Issues with argument are :
Special treatment can increase the interstate disparity
States which are contributing higher are also depends on other states
Against the idea of equity as it would defy the centre’s inclusive policy to reduce horizontal imbalances in growth.
Against the idea of cooperative federalism .

shubham yadav
shubham yadav
1 month ago

Please review it sir
Pay I’d -pay_HHhwlNw9vfR4HH

CamScanner 06-12-2021 19.07.07_1.jpg
CamScanner 06-12-2021 19.07.07_2.jpg
Murari Jha
Murari Jha
1 month ago

UPI Reference No.-114715258066

Adobe Scan 13-Jun-2021 (1)_1.jpg
Adobe Scan 13-Jun-2021 (1)_2.jpg
Adobe Scan 13-Jun-2021 (1)_3.jpg
Kartikey Singh
Kartikey Singh
1 month ago

pay_HHogiMPYpQ87sC

IMG_20210614_135910275_HDR.jpg
IMG_20210614_135927505_HDR.jpg
Mradul sharma
Mradul sharma
1 month ago

ref id- #0000422539

gst pool answer 1.jpg
gst pool answer 2.jpg
Mradul sharma
Mradul sharma
1 month ago
Reply to  Swatantra

the correct word here would be “mutual” (i wanted to explain how things aren’t going well with both center and state) but i wrote consensual in flow. wrong word wrong context. will be careful next time sir.

shivanshu pandey
shivanshu pandey
1 month ago

pay_HH4AoVE2qPd386

16236822823419111328194391577974.jpg
16236823014278927121112657719907.jpg
Vishnu Agrawal
Vishnu Agrawal
1 month ago

Order id: 0000422561
sir please review.

Vishnu Agrawal
Vishnu Agrawal
1 month ago
Reply to  Vishnu Agrawal

answers attached.

WhatsApp Image 2021-06-16 at 10.20.47 AM (1).jpeg
WhatsApp Image 2021-06-16 at 10.20.47 AM.jpeg
Arpit Singh
Arpit Singh
1 month ago

Payment id HHU8LODcXby9Db

image.jpg
image.jpg