G20 : Economic Cooperation ahead

A template for Indian engagement with the West

Note4Students

From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :

Prelims level : G-7

Mains level : Paper 2- Opportunity for India to institutionalise its relations with the West

The article highlights the significance of the recent G-7 summit for India.

India’s engagement with the West

  • Two important messages emerge from India’s participation in G-7 with the members of the G-7 and three other invited guests — Australia, South Africa and South Korea.
  • First is that India is a “natural ally” of the G-7 and its partners.
  • The other is the emphasis on shared democratic values that bind India with the West.
  • The two ideas are certainly not new to India’s foreign policy, but they acquire special importance at the current juncture.
  • In the last few years, India embarked on an expansive engagement with Europe.
  • This G-7 summit can be seen as the beginning of an institutionalisation of India’s cooperation with the West.

What makes this G-7 Summit different from the past Summits?

  • China factor: After the 2008 financial crisis, the more representative G-20, which includes China, Russia, India and many others, seemed to supersede the G-7.
  • But amidst the growing sense that China has gamed the global economic order to America’s disadvantage, there has been renewed interest in like-minded coalitions like the G-7.
  • Widening the base of G-7: There is also the recognition of the case for widening the base of institutions like the G-7 beyond the geographic West to include large democracies like India.
  • Coalition of democracies: The case for a “coalition of democracies” was certainly gaining ground over the last two decades within American academia and the political class.
  • But economic globalisation and the absence of great power rivalry meant there was no compelling policy urgency to construct an “alliance of democracies”.
  • That condition has altered radically in the last few years amidst the growing US tensions with China and Russia. 

Dealing with the challenges presented by China

  • U.S. President Biden declared his main objective as rallying democracies to meet the great challenges of our time, especially those presented by China.
  • G-7 summit has responded to Biden’s call in the following forms:
  • 1) By offering the outline of a potential alternative to China’s ambitious Belt and Road Initiative.
  • 2)By calling for a reorientation of global supply chains away from China.
  • 3) By demanding a fresh inquiry into the origins of the Covid-19 pandemic in China.
  • 4) By reprimanding Beijing policies in Xinjiang and Hong Kong.
  • 5) By raising concerns about the conflict across the Taiwan Strait.
  • However, there is a strong view that the door must be kept open for engagement with China on issues like climate change while calling out its unacceptable policies.

India’s relations with China: New context for engagement with West

  • The rupture in the US engagement with China coincides with the rapid deterioration in India’s relations with China.
  • This also sets up a new context for India’s partnership with the West.
  • If the Indo-Pacific provides a regional basis for India’s engagement with the US and Europe, mitigating climate change and the management of the Covid-19 pandemic provides a global template for India’s engagement with the West.

Way forward

  • The case for renewal and reform of democratic institutions is urgent in both the US and India.
  • So is the need for sustained consultations between India and its Western partners on a range of new challenges presented by digital technologies, including radicalisation, disinformation, electoral interference, cyber-attacks and the role of large social media companies. 
  • The statement on open societies provides a sound basis for such an engagement.

Conclusion

India must begin institutionalisation of its relationship with the West and increase its engagement on various common issues including the China challenge.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments