Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Why in the News

The leaders of the U.S., China and Russia met in an unprecedented trilateral at Shenzhen on 19 November, and a Chinese proposal suggested calling the new order the “Shenzhen International System”. The three now treat each other as the only powers that matter, which undercuts India’s long assumption that it would be a pole in any multipolar order.

Why can India not assume it will be a pole?

  1. Old assumption: Indians calling for a multipolar order, a world with several centres of power, assumed India would be one.
  2. Status is earned: India holds one-sixth of humanity, but great power status is achieved, not granted. Heritage does not entitle it to be Vishwaguru (teacher to the world).
  3. Economic and military limits: Low per capita income and deepening inequality delay any claim to economic power. Without self-reliance in arms manufacturing, military might stays incomplete.
  4. The takeaway: India cannot yet be a pole on its own weight. It can still lead as the friend others choose to follow, as it did through non-alignment.

What would a “fourth pole” look like?

  1. Collective, not country: A truly multipolar order is not tri-polar. Its “fourth pole” would be “not one country, but a collective of nations”.
  2. Membership test: Members would not compromise on sovereignty, would not give in to expansionism, and would refuse to follow decisions they were not consulted on.
  3. Shared quest for autonomy: Many states seek strategic autonomy, meaning freedom to act without joining any power’s camp. Eg. Tokyo, Riyadh, Berlin, Brasilia and Manila.
  4. Nuclear rules: India cannot accept the three “foremost nuclear-armed powers” as sole arbiters of security. Like-minded nuclear powers could set common rules on arsenal growth, even a joint nuclear umbrella (shared nuclear protection).

How should India’s diplomacy change?

  1. Diplomacy of conscience: Conflicts have killed nearly half a million people in five years, so India should openly oppose mass civilian killing, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity. Eg. Nagorno-Karabakh, Sudan, Yemen.
  2. Mediation with a purpose: India’s recent moves to mediate on Ukraine are welcome, but civilian protection must sit at their heart.
  3. International law: The fourth pole should reject purely transactional deal-making. India should sign and ratify the Convention Against Torture and the Refugee Convention, the core treaties on torture and on people fleeing persecution.

Should India trade a Council seat for Global South goodwill?

  1. Limits of clubs: G20 and BRICS build networks of trust but cannot replace the legitimacy of universal multilateral forums such as the United Nations (UN).
  2. Hosting agencies: India can rebuild its multilateral presence by hosting significant UN and allied agencies.
  3. Security Council race: India is contesting a non-permanent UN Security Council seat for 2028-29 against Tajikistan, which seeks its first term. Withdrawing would earn goodwill across the Global South.
  4. Secretary-General choice: India could rally the Council’s elected members behind a Latin American candidate for UN Secretary-General, whose turn it rightfully is.

Challenges

  1. Assembling a collective: States from Kyiv to Yaounde share fears of great power rule, but turning them into one bloc is an untested act of statesmanship.
  2. Nuclear outsider: India is outside the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), so common rules among like-minded nuclear powers lack an agreed treaty base.
  3. Treaty costs: The Refugee Convention carries a duty of non-refoulement (not returning refugees to danger), which constrains India’s border and deportation choices.

Way Forward

  1. Standing dialogue: Convene a regular forum of like-minded middle powers on sovereignty and consultation.
  2. Anti-torture law: Enact a domestic anti-torture law so that ratifying the Convention Against Torture becomes possible.
  3. Multilateral hosting: Offer host country agreements to attract UN and allied agencies to India.

Conclusion

A great power directorate is forming, and India is no longer a pole by default. Whether India can turn its quest for autonomy into a collective that other states choose to join is the question to watch.

What is a multipolar world order?

  1. About: An international system in which power is spread among several major states, none able to dominate the others alone.
  2. Typology: Unipolar means one dominant power, as after the Soviet collapse. Bipolar means two rival blocs, as in the Cold War.
  3. India’s shift: Non-alignment was a strategy for a weak state in a bipolar world. India’s stated ambition now is to be a pole in a multipolar one.
  4. Frozen UN structure: The Security Council’s permanent membership is unchanged since 1945. The G4 bids of India, Brazil, Germany and Japan face the Uniting for Consensus group and the veto.

Matching Previous Year Question

“[2015, GS2, 12 marks] Discuss the impediments India is facing in its pursuit of a permanent seat in UN Security Council.”

Click here to Download X-Factor Notes for FREE. Cover the entire Microthemes with PYQs.

Download free X-Factor Notes
Revised and updated X-Factor Notes for UPSC Mains 2026: nine subject booklets