Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Why in the News

India is hosting the first Civilisational Dialogue Forum of the 10 nation Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) in New Delhi, with ministers and partners from over 25 countries. The Prime Minister proposed it at Tianjin in 2025, and Pakistan is attending for the first time since the May 2025 conflict. The stake is who defines “civilisation” in Eurasian diplomacy.

Why has “civilisation” become contested ground?

  1. Western monopoly: After the Cold War, the West owned the language of universal principles such as democracy, markets and human rights. Emerging powers kept the language but treated it as one view among several.
  2. Global Civilization Initiative: The President of China unveiled the Global Civilization Initiative in 2023. A year later the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), on China’s initiative, designated 10 June the International Day for Dialogue among Civilizations.
  3. Chinese forums: China held a ministerial Global Civilizations Dialogue in July 2025 and the Nishan Forum in September 2026.
  4. The takeaway: China is turning “civilisation” into its own brand name, so it can argue modernity has many models, not only the Western one.

What does India want from the forum?

  1. Soft connectivity: The only stated aim is reviving cultural links: Buddhist circuits, Sufi lineages and the Taxila to Samarkand trade routes.
  2. Authorship in the SCO: India wants to shape the agenda of a body whose Secretariat sits in Beijing. It rejects the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and clashes with Pakistan at almost every meeting.
  3. A brand name: An Indian flagship project shows the SCO is not only China’s platform. Such authorship is worth more than a veto, which only blocks.
  4. Plural civilisation: China argues ancient continuity justifies centralised order. India counters that its continuity has been plural and layered. Eg. The Purana Qila‘s walls, the forum’s venue, built by Sher Shah Suri, stand over ancient Indraprastha.

How does the forum fit India’s multi-alignment?

  1. Agenda setting: The forum follows the Artificial Intelligence (AI) Impact Summit earlier this year and India’s BRICS chairmanship, including the September summit.
  2. Multi-alignment: India joins every relevant grouping but lets no single partner control its choices. Eg. The India-European Union (EU) Strategic Partnership Review on 9 November and the Manila Quad summit on 17 November.
  3. Horizon Europe: India has concluded talks on joining Horizon Europe, the EU’s flagship research programme.
  4. Parallel tracks: The West speaks through rulebooks on AI, chips and carbon borders. India answers with separate tracks: semiconductors with Brussels, supply chains with Washington and Tokyo, and Quad maritime security.

Will India’s forum legitimise Beijing’s narrative?

  1. Democratic cover: Each civilisation forum strengthens China’s claim that universal standards are a Western imposition. A democracy as host makes that claim look like an Asian consensus.
  2. Buddhism and succession: China also claims Buddhism as its heritage, which matters for the Dalai Lama’s succession.
  3. Contest over words: India can deny Beijing a monopoly over “civilisation” in Eurasian diplomacy, a small but realistic aim. “Agenda-setting, not attendance, is the real currency of soft power.”
  4. Antiquity trap: Rival claims to be oldest breed conflict, so trying to prove India is older plays into Beijing’s framing.

Challenges

  1. Spending gap: India can never out-spend China in Central Asia.
  2. Trust deficit with China: India has tried to normalise ties since 2024, but the memory of the Galwan clash persists.
  3. Authoritarian alibi: Civilisational talk is often an excuse used by authoritarian regimes, and India’s hosting could lend it democratic credibility.
  4. Consensus rule: SCO decisions need consensus, so any member can strike a line India wants.

Way Forward

  1. Inclusive message: Use the forum to show civilisations gain strength by absorbing others, not by claiming to be older.
  2. Shared Asian identity: Build an Asian identity where China takes part without dominating and India bridges the Global South, the West and Central Asia.
  3. Uncontested tracks: Expand SCO tracks no member blocks, such as traditional medicine and startups.

Conclusion

India is contesting a word, not territory, and the forum is a modest but winnable move. The test is whether it projects an inclusive idea of civilisation rather than an antiquity contest on Beijing’s terms.

About the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation

  1. Origin: Founded at Shanghai on 15 June 2001 out of the Shanghai Five, a border confidence building mechanism.
  2. Members: Belarus, China, India, Iran, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Pakistan, Russia, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. India and Pakistan joined together in 2017.
  3. Security core: The Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure (RATS) at Tashkent keeps a shared terror watchlist.
  4. Cultural pillar: Culture is the only SCO pillar where India faces neither a Chinese nor a Pakistani objection.

Matching Previous Year Question

“[2026, GS2, 15 marks] “China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has transformed South Asia from a regional space into a theatre of great power competition.” Analyse the strategic implications of the BRI for India’s security and regional influence in South Asia.”

Click here to Download X-Factor Notes for FREE. Cover the entire Microthemes with PYQs.

Download free X-Factor Notes
Revised and updated X-Factor Notes for UPSC Mains 2026: nine subject booklets