Why in the News
India has voted against a proposed global moratorium on the death penalty at the United Nations (UN), defending retention as a sovereign decision backed by judicial safeguards. Its own record tests that claim: executions have stopped, yet death row is at its fullest in a decade, and the Supreme Court keeps releasing prisoners after years on it.
What safeguards does India rely on, and what do they promise?
- What it is: The death penalty, or capital punishment, is execution by the state for the gravest crimes. India keeps it in law but says courts impose it only under strict judicial checks.
- “Rarest of rare”: Courts may award death only in the “rarest of rare” cases, where life imprisonment is clearly inadequate. It works like an emergency exit meant to stay shut except in extremes.
- High Court confirmation: A death sentence from a sessions court, the district trial court for serious crimes, cannot be carried out until a High Court confirms it. The Supreme Court has also narrowed its use.
- India’s stand at the UN: India separates court-ordered judicial executions from extrajudicial killings carried out without trial. That distinction holds in law, but the claim that due process fully protects the condemned is weaker.
- The takeaway: The safeguards are only as strong as the investigation, trial and appeal beneath them, and the record shows each of these can fail.
What does the record show about these safeguards?
- Executions halted, offences expanded: India last executed convicts in 2020, in the Delhi gang-rape and murder case. Parliament has since added capital offences in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), the new penal code.
- Swelling death row: 574 people were on death row at the end of last year, the highest since 2016. Trial court rulings drove the rise, which challenges claims that the safeguards work in practice.
- Releases from death row: Project 39A, a criminal justice research centre at National Law University Delhi, found that the Supreme Court released 38 persons from death row over the past decade.
- Years lost: Those released had spent eight years on death row on average, and some had spent more than two decades there.
- Gaps the safeguards miss: The checks do not stop convictions built on flawed evidence or false testimony. They also do not fix unequal access to competent lawyers among those facing the penalty.
Is the death penalty worth the risk of error?
- Infallibility required: An execution cannot be undone, so the punishment needs a near-flawless criminal justice system, which India cannot supply.
- No extra deterrence: Research finds the death penalty deters crime no more than life imprisonment. Globally the trend runs the other way: only a small group of countries are executing more people.
- “Penal populism”: This means adding harsh punishments to answer public outrage, especially after sexual violence. It leaves untouched the poor policing and low conviction rates that actually weaken deterrence.
- Escalation risk: Very harsh punishment for non-fatal crimes can push offenders to escalate violence, even to killing witnesses who could testify against them.
- Law Commission’s view: The Law Commission of India’s 2015 report, headed by Justice A.P. Shah, found the penalty “fails to achieve any constitutionally valid penological goals”, meaning the aims of punishment. It recommended abolition except for terrorism and waging war.
Challenges
- Error at trial: Flawed evidence and false testimony can still produce death sentences that take years to overturn on appeal.
- Unequal defence: Prisoners facing death often depend on overstretched legal aid, so outcomes track the quality of counsel.
- Delay as punishment: Long years on death row add suffering the sentence never ordered. Eg. Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014) commuted sentences for delay.
- Politics of outrage: New capital offences follow high-profile crimes without matching investment in investigation and prosecution.
Way Forward
- Formal moratorium: The Union government should formally suspend executions while a review is under way.
- Statute review: Commission a review of capital penal statutes and of the treatment of prisoners on death row.
- Narrower scope: Remove the death penalty for offences that do not involve intentional killing.
- Stronger process: Improve investigation, prosecution and access to legal aid, with abolition in law as the end goal.
Conclusion
India’s defence of the death penalty rests on safeguards that its own trial courts and appeals show to be fallible. Whether India turns its unofficial pause on executions into a formal moratorium, or keeps adding capital offences, is the choice to watch.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2019] With reference to the Constitution of India, prohibitions or limitations or provisions contained in ordinary laws cannot act as prohibitions or limitations on the constitutional powers under Article 142. It could mean which one of the following? (a) The decisions taken by the Election Commission of India while discharging its duties cannot be challenged in any court of law. (b) The Supreme Court of India is not constrained in the exercise of its powers by laws made by the Parliament. (c) In the event of grave financial crisis in the country, the President of India can declare Financial Emergency without the counsel from the Cabinet. (d) State Legislatures cannot make laws on certain matters without the concurrence of Union Legislature. ANSWER: (b)”