Foreign Policy Watch: India-Nepal

Controversy around the $500 million MCC grant to Nepal

Note4Students

From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :

Prelims level : MCC

Mains level : Chinese influence in Nepal

Nepal’s House of Representatives has ratified 500 million US Dollar grant assistance-Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) pact along with the “interpretative declaration”.

What is Millenium Challenge Corporation?

  • The MCC was founded in 2004 as a US foreign aid agency that acts in accordance with governments that have demonstrated a commitment to good governance, economic freedom, and citizen investment.
  • It was envisioned as an organisation that would follow the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness’ key principles.
  • MCC works with countries that have been identified as being eligible for assistance to develop programmes that are based on MCC’s purpose of decreasing poverty via economic growth.
  • MCC’s results framework, which is based on the fourth and fifth principles of the Paris Declaration, Results and Mutual Accountability.
  • It provides a framework for applying the agency’s rigorous methods for projecting, tracking, and evaluating the effects of its programmes.
  • MCC uses this framework to address basic questions about aid effectiveness.

Investments made by MCC

  • Compact and threshold programmes are the two types of programmes in which MCC invests.
  • Compacts are large, five-year grants implemented by an accountable entity established by each partner nation.
  • Thresholds are smaller funds focusing on policy and institutional transformation in selected countries implemented by MCC.

The background of the project

  • MCC’s partnership with Nepal began in 2011, when the country requested assistance.
  • MCC first chose Nepal for a smaller threshold grant, and subsequently in December 2014, for a larger compact.
  • Three years later, in September 2017, the MCC-Nepal compact was signed, with the US committing $500 million and Nepal committing $130 million.
  • Nepal is expected to generate an electricity infrastructure with 400kVA transmission lines through the MCC project, which will be used to distribute power both domestically and to India.
  • Furthermore, the MCC’s implementation could boost the Nepalese economy by increasing employment possibilities and increasing per capita income.

Issues with the project

  • It is estimated that if the agreement is not passed by Parliament, the power producers in the country are likely to lose a staggering Rs. 142 billion every year.
  • As a result, PM Sher Bahadur Deuba is striving to get the MCC passed in Parliament as soon as possible, even if it means splitting the coalition government.
  • In addition, if he fails to get it through Parliament, there is a possible risk of losing his international credibility.

America vs China: Objections around MCC

  • The MCC agreement has created a political divide in Nepal.
  • The compact has been criticised in Nepal as endangering the country’s sovereignty, integrity, and constitutional autonomy.
  • The claim that the MCC agreement supersedes the national charter and shall prevail over Nepal’s domestic laws.
  • Many have interpreted this to suggest that the compact replaces the constitution, compromising Nepal’s sovereignty.
  • The MCC’s inclusion in the Indo-Pacific Strategy (IPS) is considered problematic for Nepal, as the majority of the country’s political class views the US strategy as anti-China.

India’s role in the ongoing political crisis in Nepal

  • Few claim that the electricity generated by MCC will be only for export to India and will not be for the local public.
  • As a result, it will not benefit the local economy directly.
  • Nepal’s hydroelectric generation potential is huge, with over 6,000 large and small rivers.
  • However, through a series of barrages and dams, India has control over the majority of Nepal’s major rivers.
  • Nationalists in the Himalayan country have strongly objected to this.
  • In Nepal, where India is still perceived as a meddling big brother, its goal of strengthening India’s military capabilities through this agreement to counter China’s was questioned.

 

UPSC 2022 countdown has begun! Get your personal guidance plan now! (Click here)

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments