Why in the News
For the first time, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) has ruled that a state committed genocide, finding Myanmar guilty of genocide against the Rohingya minority. The court held that Myanmar’s 2017 military operation in northern Rakhine State violated the Genocide Convention. The ruling now tests whether a court with no enforcement arm can make a state comply.
What is the ICJ, and what did it hold?
- What the ICJ is: The ICJ is the United Nations’ top court, also called the World Court. It settles legal disputes between states, much like a civil court where the parties are countries.
- Its composition: It sits at The Hague and has 15 judges, elected for nine-year terms by the UN General Assembly and the Security Council.
- The verdict: By a 9-6 decision, the court found that Myanmar “has committed genocide against the Rohingya group”. The bench included Navi Pillay, this year’s Nobel Peace Prize winner.
- Defence rejected: The court rejected Myanmar’s claim that the operation was a legitimate counter-insurgency campaign, a military operation against armed rebels.
- The takeaway: A state, not only its individual officials, now carries a court finding of genocide, which strengthens the Rohingya claim to return and reparations.
What happened in Rakhine in 2017?
- The clearance campaign: In August 2017, Myanmar’s military launched what it called a clearance campaign in Rakhine State after an attack by a Rohingya insurgent group.
- Accusations at the time: Security forces were accused of mass rapes and killings and of burning thousands of homes.
- The court’s findings: Security forces:
- killed thousands of Rohingya civilians;
- committed widespread sexual violence and extreme violence against children;
- attacked Rohingya fleeing in large numbers.
- Scale of killing: Evidence before the court showed Myanmar forces killed about 10,000 Rohingya.
- Refugee exodus: About 1.2 million Rohingya refugees now live in Bangladesh, mainly in crowded camps in Cox’s Bazar district under harsh conditions.
What did the court order, and can it be enforced?
- Return of refugees: Myanmar must allow the Rohingya a “safe, voluntary and dignified return to their place of residence”.
- Punishing perpetrators: Myanmar must investigate, prosecute and punish those found to have committed genocidal acts.
- Compensation: Myanmar must pay compensation to the Rohingya, with the amount to be decided in later court proceedings.
- No enforcement arm: The court’s rulings are final and legally binding, but it can only report non-compliance to the UN Security Council.
- Call for enforcement: An umbrella body of Myanmar opposition groups said “this judgment must now be enforced”.
Why does the ruling matter beyond Myanmar?
- Pending genocide cases: The court is also handling genocide allegations linked to Gaza and the war in Ukraine, where this ruling will be the reference point.
- UN response: The UN Secretary-General called it “a demonstration of international justice” and a reaffirmation that impunity for such acts must not stand.
- Diplomatic follow-up: The United Kingdom expelled Myanmar’s defence attache shortly after the ruling was read.
- Myanmar’s silence: Myanmar’s delegation at The Hague and its government gave no immediate reaction.
Challenges
- Security Council veto: Non-compliance goes to the Security Council, where a single permanent member’s veto can block any action.
- Unsafe conditions for return: A voluntary return depends on security inside Rakhine State, which the order cannot itself guarantee.
- Open-ended refugee burden: Bangladesh carries the cost of hosting the refugees with no fixed timeline for their return.
Way Forward
- Compliance reporting: States party to the Genocide Convention should press Myanmar to report the steps it takes to implement the order.
- Verified return: Bangladesh, Myanmar and the UN refugee agency should verify safety in Rakhine before any return begins.
- Individual prosecution: National and international courts should pursue the individuals behind the 2017 operation, since the ICJ judges only states.
Conclusion
The ICJ has given the Rohingya a legal finding of genocide, but not the means to enforce it. Whether Myanmar implements the reparations, or the matter reaches a divided Security Council, is what to watch.
Back2Basics: Genocide Convention
- What it is: The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948.
- Definition: Genocide means acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.
- Route to the ICJ: Its Article IX lets a party take a dispute over the Convention to the ICJ. Eg. The Gambia filed this case against Myanmar in 2019.
- India’s status: India ratified the Convention in 1959.
Matching Previous Year Question
“[2022] With reference to the “United Nations Credentials Committee”, consider the following statements : 1. It is a committee set up by the UN Security Council and works under its supervision. 2. It traditionally meets in March, June and September every year. 3. It assesses the credentials of all UN members before submitting a report to the General Assembly for approval. Which of the statements given above is/are correct ? (a) 3 only (b) 1 and 3 (c) 2 and 3 (d) 1 and 2 ANSWER: (a)”