Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/28/29 || 1:1 Mentorship Batch Admissions Open

Search results for: “”

  • To build domestic ecosystem, Centre bans lithium-ion battery waste export

    To build domestic ecosystem, Centre bans lithium-ion battery waste export

    Why in the News

    India’s export policy for lithium ion battery black mass has changed from “Free” to “Prohibited“, so this battery waste can no longer be shipped abroad. The Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT), the trade policy arm of the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, has notified the ban with immediate effect. The aim is to keep critical minerals for domestic recyclers, whose capacity to process black mass is still limited.

    What is black mass, and why is it valuable?

    1. What it is: Black mass is the powder left after waste lithium ion batteries and consumer electronics are broken down. It is like the scrap gold in old jewellery, waiting to be extracted.
    2. Minerals inside: The powder holds lithium, cobalt, manganese, nickel and graphite, along with silicon, tin and rhenium. Recycling recovers them for use in new batteries.
    3. Secondary source: India has limited reserves of these minerals and depends heavily on imports, so discarded batteries and electronic waste are treated as a second source of supply.
    4. Reason for exports: Domestic recycling and refining capability is limited, so some firms sold black mass abroad, the easier route, instead of recovering the minerals.
    5. The takeaway: Every tonne of black mass exported carried away minerals that India otherwise has to import.

    What has the government changed?

    1. Waste covered: The ban covers unsorted waste and scrap of primary cells and primary batteries (single use types) and electric accumulators (rechargeable batteries), where these contain no lead, cadmium or mercury.
    2. Meaning of the two categories: A “Free” item needs no licence to export. A “Prohibited” item cannot be exported at all.
    3. Transition rule: Para 1.05 of the Foreign Trade Policy, 2023 applies. It ordinarily lets a shipment go through where an irrevocable letter of credit (a bank’s firm payment promise) was opened before the change.
    4. Linked scheme: Days earlier, the Union Cabinet approved a Rs 2,814 crore scheme for critical mineral processing, focused on lithium and nickel. It offers capital expenditure support, meaning help with the cost of setting up plants.
    5. Sectors the scheme serves: The scheme is expected to support electric mobility, battery energy storage, electronics, defence and specialty steel.

    Why has the government acted now?

    1. Stated purpose: The government wants black mass generated in India to be recycled and refined within the country.
    2. Expected gains: The official statement expects assured feedstock (raw material) for recyclers, fuller use of their capacity, and more investment and employment.
    3. Import bill: Higher domestic recovery of lithium, cobalt and nickel reduces import dependence and foreign exchange outgo, in line with Aatmanirbhar Bharat (self reliant India).
    4. Restrictions abroad: Several countries have already restricted black mass exports to retain critical minerals for their own supply chains.
    5. China’s export controls: China now controls exports of high performance lithium ion batteries, cathode materials and graphite anodes. The Ministry of Heavy Industries told Parliament that this puts Indian electric vehicle (EV) makers’ supply at risk.

    Can domestic industry use the black mass that stays?

    1. Registered recyclers: 57 lithium ion battery recyclers are registered on the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) portal for Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR). EPR makes battery producers responsible for recycling used batteries.
    2. Capacity gap: Their combined capacity is 5.17 lakh tonnes a year. Capacity to process black mass itself is only about 75,500 tonnes a year.
    3. Destination of exports: Exported black mass largely reaches recyclers in China, notes a Centre for Social and Economic Progress (CSEP) fellow. China has the largest recycling capacity and a huge battery cell industry.

    Challenges

    1. Small refining base: Black mass processing capacity is a fraction of total battery recycling capacity, so retained material may stay unprocessed.
    2. Recovery quality: Recovering the most material at the grades battery makers require needs technical expertise and experience.
    3. Missing buyers: India lacks large battery cell manufacturing, so recycled minerals have few domestic buyers.

    Way Forward

    1. Refining capacity: Use the new capital support scheme to build plants that turn black mass into battery grade lithium, nickel and cobalt.
    2. Cell manufacturing: Develop domestic battery cell manufacturing so that recovered minerals are bought and reused within India.
    3. Technology partnerships: Fund research partnerships between recyclers and laboratories to raise recovery rates.
    4. Collection tracking: The CPCB should track on the EPR portal how much collected battery waste reaches registered refiners.

    Conclusion

    The export ban is notified and in force, and no further date has been announced. What to watch is whether refining and cell manufacturing capacity grows fast enough to use the black mass now kept at home.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2026] Which of the following statements about Rare Earth Elements (REEs) and Critical Minerals is/are correct? 1. Modern technological innovations including Artificial Intelligence, robotics and space exploration extensively utilise Rare Earth Elements (REEs). 2. China has the highest share in mining of REEs followed by India. 3. The Government of India launched the National Critical Mineral Mission (NCMM) in 2025 to establish a robust framework for self-reliance in the critical mineral sector. 4. Rare Earth Elements are a set of 13 metallic elements. Select the answer using the code given below: (a) 1 and 3 only (b) 3 only (c) 1, 3 and 4 (d) 1, 2 and 4 ANSWER: A”

  • Turning battery waste into strategic mineral wealth

    Turning battery waste into strategic mineral wealth

    Why in the News

    Recycling end of life lithium ion batteries can give India a domestic source of critical minerals such as lithium, nickel and cobalt, for which it depends heavily on imports. The case has sharpened after the Prime Minister warned at the 18th BRICS Summit in New Delhi against the “weaponisation of technology and critical minerals“. Recycling capacity has to be planned before spent electric vehicle batteries arrive in bulk.

    What is battery recycling, and why is it a strategic resource?

    1. What it is: Battery recycling recovers lithium, nickel and cobalt from end of life batteries. It is like mining discarded phones and vehicles instead of ore.
    2. Rising demand: Transport and other sectors are shifting to electricity, so demand for lithium ion batteries is growing.
    3. Supply risk: The ores are scarce or their supply chains are concentrated in a few places. This exposes supply to geopolitical tensions, trade restrictions and resource nationalism (countries restricting mineral exports).
    4. Processing capability: China dominates the processing of critical minerals, and India lacks this capability.
    5. The takeaway: Recycling will not end import dependence, but it creates a mineral supply that sits inside India.

    Where do used batteries go today?

    1. Landfills and informal channels: Batteries from mobile phones and other electronics often reach landfills or informal recycling run by kabadiwalas (scrap dealers).
    2. Informal recovery: Manual methods are inefficient and unsafe. They recover only 10% to 20% of the material.
    3. Formal recovery: Formal recycling facilities recover over 90%, so every battery in informal hands loses most of its mineral value.

    How much can recycling contribute as electric vehicles grow?

    1. Electric vehicle stock: More than 8.7 million electric vehicles (EVs) were on Indian roads by 2025-26, so the volume of spent batteries will rise.
    2. Share of lithium demand: Recycling can meet about 10% to 12% of India’s lithium demand for EV battery manufacturing.
    3. Secondary source: Recycled material is a strategic secondary source alongside mining and overseas sourcing.

    Why is building recycling capacity early a hard business decision?

    1. Legal foundation: The Battery Waste Management Rules, 2022 rest on extended producer responsibility, which makes producers responsible for collecting and recycling the batteries they sell.
    2. Planning ahead of the surge: Investing “just in time“, only when spent batteries arrive, is unrealistic for plants and logistics, so capacity has to be built earlier.
    3. Underused plants: Plants built early run below capacity at first, so their revenue may not cover financing costs.
    4. Long gestation: Recycling facilities take long to pay back, so the business is not an immediate windfall.

    Challenges

    1. Diverse battery chemistries: Batteries use different mixes of materials, which makes mineral recovery difficult and recycling economics unattractive.
    2. Black mass: Recyclers stop at black mass, the intermediate powder of mixed battery metals, and do not recover the minerals.
    3. Difficult collection: Returning a retired battery is not easy for EV users, and a circular economy cannot scale without public participation.
    4. Missing standards: India lacks standards for battery characterisation, recycled mineral quality and second life use (reuse of a retired battery).

    Way Forward

    1. Recycled share in the stockpile: The proposed national critical mineral stockpile should carry a mandated share of recycled minerals, which creates predictable demand.
    2. Recovery technology research: Industry and research laboratories should develop technologies with higher recovery and purity and no environmental impact.
    3. Standards and design: The government should set standards backed by testing infrastructure, and manufacturers should adopt “design for repurposing and recycling”.
    4. Take back by manufacturers: EV makers and their dealer and service networks should offer take back or buy back options that pay the user.
    5. Patient capital: Lenders and investors should provide long term capital to battery recyclers.

    Conclusion

    Battery recycling gives India a modest buffer against mineral supply shocks, provided the system is built before the batteries arrive. Whether the proposed national stockpile reserves a share for recycled minerals is the decision to watch.

    Government Initiatives for Critical Minerals

    1. List of critical minerals: The Ministry of Mines identified 30 critical minerals in its report Critical Minerals for India, July 2023. The list has no statutory force.
    2. National Critical Mineral Mission: The Cabinet approved it in January 2025. It covers exploration, overseas assets, recycling, stockpiling and research.
    3. Khanij Bidesh India Limited (KABIL): It acquires mineral assets abroad. Eg. A lithium brine agreement in Catamarca, Argentina, January 2024.
    4. Secondary recovery: A 2025 amendment to the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 allowed recovery of critical minerals from tailings (ore processing residue) and waste dumps.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2025] In the context of electric vehicle batteries, consider the following elements: I. Cobalt II. Graphite III. Lithium IV. Nickel How many of the above usually make up battery cathodes? (a) Only one (b) Only two (c) Only three (d) All the four ANSWER: (c)”

  • Tamil Nadu’s growing industrial water challenge

    Why in the News

    Tamil Nadu ranks third on NITI Aayog’s Investment Friendliness Index (IFI), but the index flags inadequate industrial water supply in its landlocked and rain shadow districts. The State holds only 3% of India’s water resources, so its industrial growth now depends on how it prices, governs and reuses water.

    What is Tamil Nadu’s industrial water challenge?

    1. What it is: The State’s economy has outgrown its water reserves, so new factories compete for water that is already scarce. It is like a household whose spending has outgrown its income.
    2. Rain shadow location: Much of the State lies in the rain shadow of the Western Ghats, the drier side of the range. Average annual rainfall is 960 mm.
    3. Rising demand: Industrial water demand is projected to grow by over a quarter between 2001 and 2050.
    4. Effect on factories: Water scarcity disrupts production, raises operating costs and makes wastewater management difficult for textile, automobile and power units.
    5. The takeaway: Water supply, not skills or policy, can now limit the State’s next round of investment.

    How strong is the State’s investment record, and what gaps does the index flag?

    1. The index: The IFI, released in July 2026, is a first of its kind report on States’ readiness to attract and sustain investment. Only Gujarat and Maharashtra rank above Tamil Nadu.
    2. Three gaps: The index flags limited international air connectivity, infrastructure constraints at Chennai Port and inadequate industrial water supply.
    3. Foreign investment: The State’s Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) inflows peaked at $3.681 billion in 2024-25, even as national FDI had declined.
    4. Industrial base: The State hosts 130 Global Fortune 500 companies across 110 industrial parks.

    How stressed are the State’s water sources?

    1. Surface water: Surface water potential is 853 TMC (thousand million cubic feet). It is spread unevenly across reservoirs, tanks and upstream flows.
    2. Groundwater overall: A 2025 assessment by the Central Ground Water Board (CGWB) and the State found extraction at about 73.5% of the extractable resource.
    3. Over exploited districts: The average hides local stress. Salem, Vellore and Chennai are classified as over exploited.
    4. Critical districts: Krishnagiri and Coimbatore are in the critical category, with extraction approaching 90% to 100%.

    How do pollution and water costs shape investment decisions?

    1. River pollution: Western Tamil Nadu is an industrial centre with polluted rivers. In June 2026, 28 industries received closure orders under the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974.
    2. Shared responsibility: Industries are accountable for the effluent (factory wastewater) they discharge, but polluted water bodies undermine the investments the State seeks.
    3. Zero liquid discharge (ZLD): A ZLD plant treats and reuses its wastewater, and recovers up to 90% of the water required. Eg. Textile clusters in Tiruppur.
    4. Limits of recycling: Tiruppur’s clusters still face freshwater shortages, and smaller units cannot bear the recycling costs.
    5. Investor behaviour: Royal Enfield’s first expansion outside Tamil Nadu since 1955 went to Rayalaseema in Andhra Pradesh, also a rain shadow region. Investors consider environmental risks.

    Challenges

    1. Budget cut: The Water Resources Department’s allocation has been cut by 8.06% to ₹9,264 crore.
    2. Repealed groundwater law: The Tamil Nadu Groundwater (Development and Management) Act was repealed in 2013, leaving no legal framework since.
    3. Pending Bill: The Tamil Nadu Water Resources (Regulation, Management and Augmentation) Bill, 2026 has been passed and awaits the Governor’s assent.
    4. Climate variability: Erratic water cycles and El Niño make water availability uncertain.

    Way Forward

    1. Availability based pricing: The State should price industrial water by local availability, as an investment in water security and not a penalty.
    2. Green energy for recycling: Linking green energy with ZLD, desalination and sewage treatment can make them affordable for industry.
    3. Water in investment planning: The State should treat water as infrastructure to be built and paid for with every industrial project.
    4. Prudent consumption: Industries should reduce the water they use for each unit of output.

    Conclusion

    Tamil Nadu’s investment appeal now rests on water that is unevenly available and weakly regulated. The Governor’s decision on the pending water Bill will show whether water governance keeps pace with industry.

    Key numbers

    1. Industrial water demand: 1,555 MCM (million cubic metres) in 2001, projected at 1,985 MCM by 2050.
    2. Groundwater, 2025: Annual recharge 22.61 BCM (billion cubic metres), extractable resource 20.46 BCM, extraction 15.04 BCM.
    3. Runoff to the sea: 177.12 TMC a year on average, from 17 major river basins.
    4. Water budget: ₹10,076 crore in the Interim Budget, before the cut.
    5. Special Economic Zones: Over 42 in the State.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2015, GS1, 12 marks] India is well endowed with fresh water resources. Critically examine why it still suffers from water scarcity.”

  • Vizag is cleanest city, Puri bags crown among coastal towns

    Why in the News

    For the first time, the Swachh Survekshan awards carry separate categories for the cleanest riverfront town, coastal town and Himalayan city. A new “Swachh Sheher Jodi” award pairs each State’s best city with its worst. At the 10th edition, organised under the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), Visakhapatnam was named the cleanest city with over 10 lakh people and Puri the cleanest coastal town.

    What is Swachh Survekshan, and how are cities grouped?

    1. What it is: Swachh Survekshan is the annual cleanliness survey of cities under Swachh Bharat Mission Urban. It works like a yearly report card on urban sanitation, hygiene and waste management.
    2. Population categories: Cities compete within population groups, so a small town is not ranked against a metropolis.
    3. Super Swachh League: Winners of previous years are judged in this separate category.
    4. Presentation: The President of India presented the awards in New Delhi.
    5. The takeaway: Judging past winners separately lets new cities top the population categories.

    Which cities won in the main categories?

    1. Super Swachh League: Navi Mumbai came first, followed by Surat and Vijayawada.
    2. Above 10 lakh population: Visakhapatnam was the cleanest city, followed by Jabalpur and Lucknow.
    3. 3 lakh to 10 lakh: Ujjain came first, followed by Chandigarh and Guntur.
    4. 50,000 to 3 lakh: Dewas came first, followed by the New Delhi Municipal Council and Sagar.
    5. Indore: The city was ranked the cleanest for eight consecutive years. It topped the league last year, ahead of Surat and Navi Mumbai.

    What new categories were added this year?

    1. Cleanest riverfront town: Rewa in Madhya Pradesh, followed by Bilaspur in Chhattisgarh and Varanasi in Uttar Pradesh.
    2. Cleanest coastal town: Puri in Odisha, followed by Alappuzha in Kerala and Ratnagiri in Maharashtra.
    3. Cleanest Himalayan city: Rudrapur in Uttarakhand, followed by Jammu and Shopian.
    4. Swachh Sheher Jodi: The best performing city of each State mentors its worst performing one. Ahmedabad and Sanand were the best mentor and mentee pair.
    5. Other Jodi winners: Indore and its partner town Depalpur came second. Tirupati and Kuppam came third.

    How has the survey grown?

    1. Coverage: The survey has expanded from 73 cities in its first year, 2016, to 4,751 cities in 2025-26.
    2. Citizen feedback: This edition gave citizen feedback greater emphasis and drew responses from 2.7 crore citizens.
    3. Movement in ranks: Around 1,700 cities improved their ranking, about one in five of them by over 500 positions.
    4. State level recognition: Jaipur was recognised as the cleanest city in Rajasthan and Gwalior in Madhya Pradesh.
    5. President’s message: The President stressed participation by all stakeholders and a sense of cleanliness among children from an early age.

    Challenges

    1. Rank is relative: A rank shows a city’s position within its category, not whether all its waste is processed.
    2. Laggard cities: The mentor and mentee category exists because the worst performing cities in each State trail far behind the best.
    3. Citizen behaviour: Cleanliness depends on the daily habits of residents, which a yearly survey cannot enforce.

    Way Forward

    1. School curricula: Schools should teach topics such as plastic waste management, as the President suggested.
    2. Targets for city pairs: States should set measurable sanitation targets for each mentor and mentee pair.
    3. Scores with ranks: MoHUA should publish each city’s scores with its rank, so that cities see what to fix.

    Conclusion

    The survey now ranks cities across many more categories, and past winners compete apart. How the mentored towns move in the next edition will show whether pairing lifts the weakest cities.

    Back2Basics: Swachh Survekshan

    1. Assessor: The Quality Council of India carries out the assessment for MoHUA.
    2. Scoring domains: The 2024 edition scored cities on three domains: service level progress, certification and citizen voice.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2026, GS3, 15 marks] What are the challenges to solid waste management in India? Discuss the governmental policy framework on solid waste management. Discuss the success/failure cases of Delhi and Indore cities highlighting the salient feature of their solid waste management initiatives.”

  • Deadline to remediate all legacy landfills now pushed to Dec 2027

    Why in the News

    The target for clearing all of India’s legacy landfills has moved from October 2026, the original end of Swachh Bharat Mission Urban 2.0, to December 2027. The Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA) had planned to remove every legacy dumpsite within the Mission’s five year period. Over 1,000 lakh tonnes of old waste is yet to be cleared, and the extended Mission itself runs only till March 2027.

    What is a legacy landfill, and what did the Mission promise?

    1. What it is: A legacy landfill is a dumpsite where a city’s mixed waste has piled up unprocessed for years. It is like a backlog of garbage the city never cleared.
    2. Remediation: Remediation means treating and removing the old waste, so that the land under it is reclaimed for use.
    3. Mission commitment: Swachh Bharat Mission Urban 2.0, launched in 2021, planned to remove all legacy dumpsites across cities within its five year period.
    4. The takeaway: The original Mission period has ended with over a third of the old waste still on the ground.

    What has changed in the timeline?

    1. Original end date: The Mission was to continue until 1 October 2026.
    2. Mission extension: The Mission has been extended till March 2027, but the remediation target now sits nine months beyond that.
    3. Staggered completion: Most remaining landfills are expected to be cleared by the end of the extended Mission. Some will take until the new target date.

    How much legacy waste has been cleared so far?

    1. Sites cleared: Of 2,607 dumpsites on the Mission dashboard, 1,402 have been completely remediated.
    2. Sites pending: Work is ongoing at 1,057 sites, and 148 sites show no progress.
    3. Waste and land recovered: 64% of the waste quantity has been remediated and 70% of the area reclaimed.
    4. Total legacy waste: The sites together held 3,135 lakh tonnes of waste spread over about 15,545 acres.
    5. Waste still to be cleared: 1,139 lakh tonnes of waste over 4,632 acres remains to be remediated.

    Which sites are holding up the target?

    1. Bhalswa, Delhi: The Union Housing and Urban Affairs Minister said work at Bhalswa would be “completed by December 31”. Fresh waste still reaches the site and will be processed separately.
    2. Okhla and Ghazipur, Delhi: The Okhla site is almost clear. Ghazipur will take one more year.
    3. Deonar, Mumbai: Authorities recently began trials to remove waste from Deonar, considered one of the oldest and largest legacy landfills in Asia.
    4. Concentrated backlog: MoHUA launched the Dumpsite Remediation Accelerator Programme last year to speed up work at 214 sites holding 80% of the waste yet to be remediated.

    Challenges

    1. Fresh waste inflow: New waste keeps arriving at sites under remediation, so cleared land fills up again. Eg. Bhalswa in Delhi.
    2. Large city sites: A small group of big dumpsites holds most of the remaining waste, and these are the slowest to clear.
    3. Stalled sites: Some dumpsites on the dashboard show no progress at all.
    4. Target beyond the Mission: The remediation target now runs past the Mission’s extended term, which leaves funding and monitoring for the final months unclear.

    Way Forward

    1. Processing of daily waste: Urban local bodies should segregate and process fresh waste, so that none reaches a dumpsite under remediation.
    2. Site wise deadlines: MoHUA should publish a completion date for each site under the accelerator programme.
    3. Funding for the final phase: The Centre should state how remediation after the Mission’s extended term will be financed.
    4. Use of reclaimed land: Cities should assign reclaimed land to waste processing plants or green cover, so that dumping does not restart.

    Conclusion

    Most dumpsites are cleared, but the largest ones have pushed the finish line beyond the Mission built to clear them. The dashboard count at the close of the extended Mission will show whether the new target holds.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2019] As per the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016 in India, which one of the following statements is correct? (a) Waste generator has to segregate waste into five categories. (b) The Rules are applicable to riotified urban local bodies, notified towns and all industrial townships only. (c) The Rules provide for exact and elaborate criteria for the identification of sites for landfills and waste processing facilities. (d) It is mandatory on the part of waste generator that the waste generated in one district cannot be moved to another district. ANSWER: (c)”

  • Two years after SC flag, no final protocol to measure burnt area of farm fires

    Why in the News

    India counts farm fires by satellite every season, but it still has no finalised measure of how much farmland is actually burnt. The Indian Agricultural Research Institute (IARI) has stated that burnt area estimates for Punjab and Haryana remain “unverified” and “unfinalised“, nearly two years after the Supreme Court called burnt area the most important measure of farm fires. Falling fire counts therefore cannot confirm that stubble burning has declined.

    What is “burnt area”, and how does it differ from a fire count?

    1. What it is: Burnt area is the extent of farmland actually burnt in a season. It is like measuring the damage instead of counting the accidents.
    2. Active fire count: It records a fire only if a satellite passes overhead when the fire is visible. IARI publishes daily bulletins from National Remote Sensing Centre (NRSC) data.
    3. Burnt area mapping: It identifies burnt land after the event, so it captures the cumulative extent, including small or short fires that satellites miss.
    4. The takeaway: A falling fire count can hide burning that continues outside the satellite’s view.

    What did the Supreme Court flag, and what has happened since?

    1. Supreme Court scrutiny: In November 2024, a two judge Bench questioned the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM), the Delhi region’s air quality regulator. Data had shown burnt area rising as fire counts fell.
    2. Court’s observation: The Bench said: “The extent of fire can be demonstrated only by a burnt area… That’s most important.”
    3. Two protocols: A standard protocol for counting active fires has existed since 2021. CAQM formed an expert committee under the NRSC in January 2024 to standardise burnt area mapping.
    4. IARI’s position: IARI says it is “only researching” satellite mapping and “there is yet no standardized methodology”. Its estimates for 2025 and the four preceding years are not authenticated.

    Why is the burnt area protocol still not final?

    1. Satellites used: The method uses Sentinel-2 satellites of the European Space Agency. They revisit an area every five days and detect burn scars through infrared imagery.
    2. Validation: The protocol is still being tested. Satellite maps are compared with independent reference data to find missed fires and wrongly marked areas.
    3. Ground truthing gap: In CAQM’s ground truthing, meaning field checks of satellite readings, teams could not detect more than 50% of satellite detected fires.
    4. Mixed fields: Standing crops, harvested straw and scorched earth lie close together at harvest, so satellite models confuse burnt fields with dry residue.

    What does the evidence show about fire counts and burnt area?

    1. Haryana: Recorded fire incidents more than halved in 2025, but burnt area rose by nearly a quarter, a report by the International Forum for Environment, Sustainability and Technology (iFOREST) found.
    2. Punjab: Fire incidents also more than halved, but burnt area fell by only about 15%.
    3. Evening fires: Over 90% of large fires occurred after 3 pm, outside the overpass times of polar orbiting satellites, which cross a place only at fixed hours.
    4. Shift in timing: A Space Applications Centre study, using geostationary satellites that watch one region continuously, found peak burning moving to late afternoon and evening.

    Challenges

    1. No official baseline: Without an authenticated burnt area figure, governments cannot tell whether stubble burning fell or only moved out of satellite view.
    2. Pollution share unclear: Without a finalised burnt area measure, agencies cannot reliably estimate how much stubble burning contributes to air pollution.
    3. Divided responsibility: NRSC supplies data, IARI publishes bulletins and CAQM validates maps, so no single body owns the final figure.

    Way Forward

    1. Deadline for the protocol: CAQM and NRSC should set a date to complete validation and adopt the burnt area protocol.
    2. Two metrics together: IARI’s bulletins should report validated burnt area alongside fire counts.
    3. Continuous monitoring: Agencies should add geostationary imagery to track fires lit after the counting satellites have passed.

    Conclusion

    Fire counts remain the only official yardstick of stubble burning, and the method to measure burnt area is still being validated. Whether CAQM adopts a final protocol before the next paddy harvest is the thing to watch.

    Key numbers

    1. Haryana, 2024 to 2025: Fire incidents 1,406 to 662; burnt area 7,117 sq km to 8,812 sq km (iFOREST).
    2. Punjab, 2024 to 2025: Fire incidents 10,909 to 5,114; burnt area 23,262 sq km to 19,757 sq km (iFOREST).
    3. Paddy area burnt each season: 49.1% in Punjab and 17.69% in Haryana (IARI study, 2018 to 2021).

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2021, GS3, 10 marks] Describe the key points of the revised Global Air Quality Guidelines (AQGs) recently released by the World Health Organisation (WHO). How are these different from its last update in 2005? What changes in India’s National Clean Air Programme are required to achieve these revised standards?”

  • Across India, 70% of stations reported ‘severe’ PM2.5 readings

    Why in the News

    ‘Severe’ PM2.5 peaks spread from 96 air quality monitoring stations before Deepavali to 375 during it, nearly 70% of the stations that reported. An analysis of all Continuous Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Stations (CAAQMS) of the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) also found that many stations stopped reporting during the festival. The Board’s explanation for the missing data does not fully account for those gaps.

    How is air quality monitored, and what counts as ‘severe’?

    1. What a CAAQMS is: A CAAQMS is an automatic station that measures air pollutants round the clock and reports readings every hour. It works like a weather station for pollution.
    2. PM2.5: PM2.5 is fine particulate matter small enough to reach deep into the lungs.
    3. ‘Severe’ category: A PM2.5 reading of 250 micrograms per cubic metre or above falls in the ‘severe’ category.
    4. Network size: The CPCB network has 634 stations, of which only 571 were live and reporting during Deepavali, as per its data portal.
    5. The takeaway: A peak is recorded only if the monitor keeps reporting when pollution is highest.

    How widespread was the Deepavali spike?

    1. Reporting stations: The share of ‘severe’ stations is counted out of the 551 stations that reported PM2.5 at least once in the hourly readings taken during Deepavali.
    2. Delhi: All 59 stations in Delhi recorded ‘severe’ peaks.
    3. Seven other States: Among States with at least 20 stations, more than two thirds of stations reported ‘severe’ peaks in Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and Andhra Pradesh.
    4. Tier 2 cities: The analysis also ranks tier 2 cities, excluding State capitals and cities in the National Capital Region (NCR), by their median (middle value) PM2.5 readings.

    Why is the missing data contested?

    1. CPCB’s explanation: CPCB analysers for particulate matter are calibrated to measure a range of 1,000 micrograms per cubic metre. Automated data checks ignore values outside that range, which “may appear as a data gap” during “extreme episodes“.
    2. Silence before the limit: Many stations partly or fully stopped reporting PM2.5 even though their reading in the preceding hour was not close to the analyser limit.
    3. Last readings before silence: The number of stations that failed to report PM2.5 for at least one hour rose during Deepavali. Most of them last reported 500 micrograms per cubic metre or less.
    4. Tamil Nadu: Of 37 stations in Tamil Nadu, only nine reported PM2.5 at least once in the Deepavali window. The State stood out for absent data, not for lower pollution.

    What do sulphur dioxide readings say about ‘green crackers’?

    1. Expected effect of green crackers: The push towards ‘green crackers‘, which are designed to pollute less, was expected to bring down emissions, especially of pollutants such as sulphur dioxide (SO2).
    2. No decline in three cities: Stations in Delhi, Mumbai and Kolkata show no drop in SO2 values during Deepavali over the last five years.
    3. Chennai: Chennai shows a sharp decline this year. It is unclear whether the fall is real or reflects the absence of accurate readings.

    Challenges

    1. Unmeasured peaks: Analysers with a fixed upper range cannot record the worst hours, so true peak exposure stays unknown.
    2. Late health response: Without live readings, authorities cannot issue timely health advisories or emergency curbs.
    3. Uneven network: Monitors are concentrated in large cities, so smaller towns and rural areas are thinly covered.
    4. Weak cracker enforcement: Conventional crackers are hard to tell apart from certified green crackers at the point of sale.

    Way Forward

    1. Higher range analysers: The CPCB should install analysers that measure beyond the present range at known hotspots.
    2. Flagged data: Automated validation should publish out of range values with a flag, not remove them.
    3. Uptime audits: State Pollution Control Boards should publish station wise uptime for every high pollution episode.
    4. Cracker testing: Regulators should test samples of crackers on sale against green cracker norms before the festival.

    Conclusion

    Severe festival pollution now extends well beyond Delhi, and the monitoring network loses data when readings are highest. Whether the CPCB accounts for stations that stopped reporting below its stated limit remains unresolved.

    Back2Basics: Green crackers

    1. Developer: Green crackers were developed by the National Environmental Engineering Research Institute (NEERI), a laboratory of the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR).
    2. Emission claim: They are designed to emit about 30% less particulate matter than conventional crackers.
    3. Legal position: The Supreme Court, in Arjun Gopal v. Union of India (2018), permitted only green and reduced emission crackers.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2021, GS3, 10 marks] Describe the key points of the revised Global Air Quality Guidelines (AQGs) recently released by the World Health Organisation (WHO). How are these different from its last update in 2005? What changes in India’s National Clean Air Programme are required to achieve these revised standards?”

  • We need to turn COP commitments into capital

    Why in the News

    The 31st Conference of the Parties (COP31) to the United Nations climate convention has been billed as the “implementation COP“, to be judged by the investment, trade and projects that follow it. The gap between climate pledges and what science requires persists because the conditions that turn commitments into capital are missing. Lack of will is rarely the reason.

    What does turning commitments into capital mean?

    1. What it means: A climate commitment becomes capital when money is actually invested in a project. A pledge is like a sanctioned building plan, and capital is the money that builds it.
    2. Conditions for investment: Investment follows stable policy, credible incentives, common standards, bankable projects (projects with returns reliable enough for lenders) and finance at reasonable cost.
    3. Business position: The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), the official focal point for business in the United Nations climate process, has put forward these five conditions.
    4. The takeaway: After a decade of negotiating targets and frameworks, the test is how quickly governments deliver action.

    Which three areas need focus?

    1. Clean energy: Installed capacity alone no longer measures the transition. The goal of 35% electrification depends on grids, connections, system design and regulation keeping pace with renewable deployment.
    2. Adaptation: Adaptation must become an economic priority:
      • public money stays essential where resilience earns no commercial return;
      • insurers, lenders and development banks can do more if they can measure the return on resilience.
    3. Finance: The New Collective Quantified Goal (NCQG), the climate finance target adopted at COP29, commits to at least $300 billion a year.

    What blocks private capital for climate action?

    1. Wider ambition: The NCQG runs to 2035 and sits within a wider ambition of $1.3 trillion, which cannot be met without private capital.
    2. Obstacles to private capital: Private capital is held back by:
      • rules that make lending to clean infrastructure unnecessarily expensive;
      • multilateral development banks (MDBs) that draw in too little private money for every dollar they deploy;
      • credit ratings that price perceived risk, not actual risk, in emerging markets.
    3. Evidence on actual risk: The ICC Trade Register pools performance data from leading banks. It shows consistently low default rates in trade and supply chain finance.
    4. Carbon markets: Buyers and sellers of carbon credits need neutral dispute resolution enforceable across borders, which ICC arbitration and mediation offer.

    How do trade and developing economies fit in?

    1. Trade emissions: International trade accounts for as much as 30% of global emissions, yet there is no common definition of sustainable trade.
    2. Sustainable trade principles: The ICC Principles for Sustainable Trade and Trade Finance grade how sustainable a transaction is. Exporters can show the grade as more countries adopt carbon border measures, charges on the carbon content of imports.
    3. Small businesses: Through the SME Climate Hub, many small and medium enterprises have committed to halve emissions by 2030 and reach net zero by 2050.
    4. Developing economies: For developing economies, the transition lasts only if it builds manufacturing capability and widens market access. Standards and border measures designed without their producers become new trade barriers.
    5. Nature based solutions: Healthy ecosystems and sustainable land use are integral to climate action, so nature based solutions, which work through ecosystems, deserve a far larger share of climate finance.

    Challenges

    1. Adaptation gap: Private capital goes to projects with returns, so adaptation in poorer countries stays dependent on scarce public money.
    2. Contested goal: Developing countries, India among them, criticised the new finance goal as too low for their needs.
    3. Debt burden: A large share of climate finance comes as loans, which adds to the debt of developing countries.

    Way Forward

    1. Risk data: Regulators and rating agencies should use actual default data to price risk, which would lower the cost of capital.
    2. Catalytic lending targets: MDBs should set clear targets for catalytic lending, meaning public money used to draw in private money.
    3. Adaptation indicators: The adaptation indicators agreed at COP30 need robust methodologies and usable data.

    Conclusion

    Climate targets are in place, and the binding constraint is the cost of capital in developing economies. The test is whether governments set rules on risk, lending and standards that move private money without creating new trade barriers.

    What is Climate Finance?

    1. About: Climate finance is money from public and private sources for cutting emissions (mitigation) and for preparing for climate impacts such as floods and heat (adaptation).
    2. Earlier goal: Developed countries pledged in 2009 to mobilise $100 billion a year, the goal that the NCQG replaces.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2014, GS3, 12 marks] Should the pursuit of carbon credit and clean development mechanism set up under UNFCCC be maintained even through there has been a massive slide in the value of carbon credit? Discuss with respect to India’s energy needs for economic growth.”

  • Needed: A sustained decline in emissions

    Why in the News

    The latest Global Carbon Budget study forecasts a slight fall in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from fossil fuel burning this year. The study was presented at the 31st Conference of the Parties (COP31) to the United Nations climate convention in Antalya, Turkey. The fall comes largely from an energy shock, not from a lasting shift, and India’s fossil fuel emissions are still rising.

    What is the Global Carbon Budget, and what does it forecast?

    1. What it is: The Global Carbon Budget is a yearly scientific count of the carbon dioxide the world releases, led by an office at the University of Exeter. It works like an annual carbon account.
    2. Fossil fuel forecast: The study forecasts a slight decline in emissions from fossil fuel burning this year compared to 2025.
    3. Causes of the fall: The drop results largely from two things: the energy shock, a sudden disruption in fuel supply triggered by the Iran war, and the wider use of wind and solar power.
    4. Large emitters: China, the world’s largest emitter, is expected to record a fall of nearly 1%. The United States, Europe and Japan are also projected to see declines.
    5. The takeaway: A fall caused mainly by a supply shock can reverse when the shock ends, so it does not show that emissions have peaked.

    Why is a one year fall not enough?

    1. Earlier dips: Shocks have reduced fossil fuel use before, and each fall lasted a single year:
      • geopolitical upheavals and economic disruptions in 1992 and 1998;
      • a similar disruption in 2009;
      • the Covid pandemic in 2020.
    2. Better economics for renewables: Energy economics favours renewables more today than in the pandemic years.
    3. Sustained decline: Much more is needed to make emissions fall year after year.

    Why is India an outlier?

    1. Rising emissions: India’s fossil fuel emissions are estimated to rise by more than 4% this year over last year.
    2. Capacity without full use: India has registered impressive growth in installed renewable energy capacity. Storage shortfalls and inadequate grid infrastructure stand in the way of optimal use of that energy.
    3. Surplus that is lost: Generation is abundant when the sun shines and winds blow. Much of that surplus cannot be used later because it cannot be stored.
    4. Weak utility finances: Power distribution companies (discoms) need to upgrade their infrastructure to absorb renewable power. Their poor financial health and long standing funding deficits are a hurdle.

    Why will renewable energy alone not contain warming?

    1. Deforestation and land use: The fall in fossil fuel emissions will be offset by rising emissions from deforestation and land use change, particularly in Southeast Asia.
    2. Peat fires: Dry conditions linked to the Super El Nino, an unusually strong warming of the Pacific Ocean, raise the risk of worse peat fires in the coming weeks. Peat fires burn carbon rich soil.
    3. Total emissions: Total carbon emissions are expected to rise from 42.8 billion tonnes last year to 43.3 billion tonnes this year.

    Challenges

    1. Rebound risk: Emissions rose again after earlier shocks once fuel supply and demand recovered.
    2. Coal based power: Coal still supplies most of India’s electricity, so rising power demand raises emissions.
    3. Costly storage: Battery and pumped storage projects need large upfront capital, which slows their addition.
    4. Forest and peatland loss: Demand for land drives the loss of forests and peatlands, which energy policy does not address.

    Way Forward

    1. Transition pathway: COP31 should chart a pathway for a just transition away from fossil fuels, one that protects workers and regions dependent on them.
    2. Carbon sinks: COP31 should push countries to halt the depletion of carbon sinks, the forests and soils that absorb carbon.
    3. Power company finances: The Centre and States should reopen the question of power company finances, so that discoms can fund grid upgrades.
    4. Storage and transmission: India should add storage and transmission capacity alongside new solar and wind plants.

    Conclusion

    A fall in fossil fuel emissions that depends on a crisis is not yet a sustained decline. The outcome to watch is whether COP31 agrees a transition pathway and whether India removes the storage, grid and utility finance constraints on its renewable capacity.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2022, GS3, 15 marks] Do you think India will meet 50 percent of its energy needs from renewable energy by 2030 ? Justify your answer. How will the shift of subsidies from fossil fuels to renewables help achieve the above objective? Explain.”

  • After Nvidia, a question for Indian boardrooms

    Why in the News

    The chief executive of Nvidia is alleged to have been cultivated, through a personal relationship, by a person assessed as a Chinese intelligence asset, meaning someone acting for an intelligence service. The episode shows that strategic competition between countries now runs through ordinary commercial networks. Indian corporate governance does not yet treat the targeting of people and knowledge inside firms as a routine risk.

    What risk does the Nvidia episode reveal?

    1. What it is: A foreign intelligence service cultivates a person, meaning it builds a relationship over time to reach what that person knows. It is like industrial spying done through friendships and business ties.
    2. Knowledge in private firms: The knowledge that matters most now sits inside private organisations, not state laboratories.
    3. Instruments of national power: Advanced process knowledge, design data and tacit expertise (unwritten know how held by key individuals) have become instruments of national power, so intelligence services seek out those individuals and their employers.
    4. Commercial channels: Cultivation proceeds through travel, partnerships, conferences, recruitment and personal association.
    5. The takeaway: Even in a company of exceptional scale and sophistication, one major customer relationship and one personal connection were enough to raise a national security concern.

    What do the GE Aviation and DuPont cases show?

    1. GE Aviation: Yanjun Xu approached employees of GE Aviation through academic and professional channels.
    2. DuPont: Walter Liew used former DuPont personnel to obtain titanium dioxide technology.
    3. Common method: Xu and Liew both succeeded by exploiting the ordinary openness of global business, where people move, meet and share freely.

    Why is India’s exposure distinctive?

    1. Strategic sectors: Indian firms are expanding in semiconductors, artificial intelligence (AI), aerospace components, telecommunications and advanced manufacturing. Larger powers treat these capabilities as strategic.
    2. Government warning: The government has publicly warned that India’s rising design and manufacturing capacity will be viewed as a threat. It has asked industry to prepare for cyber and other disruptions.
    3. Thinner buffers: Indian firms are still building their positions in global value chains (production spread across several countries), so they have fewer internal safeguards than a firm like Nvidia.
    4. Openness as exposure: The same openness that enables growth multiplies the opportunities for cultivation.

    Why do Indian boards miss this risk?

    1. Geopolitical risk as an external constraint: Boards register geopolitical risk as external constraints, such as tariff changes, export controls, supply chain concentration and sudden regulatory shifts in major markets.
    2. No settled practice: Most boards lack a settled practice for assessing:
      • which executives, engineers or researchers are points of leverage, the people through whom a firm’s knowledge can be reached;
      • how overseas partnerships or customer relationships create opportunities for observation;
      • how personal and professional networks can be turned to intelligence purposes.
    3. Functions in silos: Security, legal, human resources and business development teams work with limited shared visibility.
    4. People and relationships: The gap is not mainly in technical cybersecurity. What a firm must protect now includes its people and their relationships.
    5. Missing institutional response: Companies have not built internal arrangements in response to the government’s warnings.

    Challenges

    1. Commerce and security: Reporting requirements can turn ordinary commercial activity into a security regime and deter legitimate partnerships.
    2. Protection lags capability: Indian capabilities are expanding faster than the arrangements needed to protect them.
    3. Hard to detect: Approaches arrive through legitimate conferences, recruiters and customers, so they look like normal business contact.
    4. Employee privacy: Monitoring the personal ties of key staff can intrude on privacy and damage trust within a firm.

    Way Forward

    1. Standing board risk: Boards should treat the targeting of people and knowledge as a standing category of material risk (a risk serious enough for board attention), with regular assessment and accountability.
    2. No imitation of agencies: Boards need internal risk review, not intelligence functions of their own.
    3. Sector specific assessments: The government should give companies threat assessments for each sector in a form they can use.
    4. Reporting channels: The government should maintain channels through which firms can report suspicious approaches.
    5. Shared visibility: Security, legal, human resources and business development teams should review foreign partnerships and approaches together.

    Conclusion

    Strategic knowledge now sits with people in private firms, and Indian companies have not yet built safeguards around those people. Whether boards and the government make such protection routine before a serious compromise occurs remains unresolved.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2021, GS3, 15 marks] Analyse the multidimensıonal challenges posed by external state and non-state actors, to the internal security of India. Also, discuss measures required to be taken to combat these threats”