Five soldiers lost their lives when a tank was drowned away by powerful water currents in the Shyok River during a military training exercise in Ladakh.
About Shyok River
The Shyok River is a significant river flowing through the Ladakh region of India and the Gilgit-Baltistan region of Pakistan.
It is a tributary of the Indus River and is known for its length and the rugged terrain it traverses.
The Shyok River spans approximately 550 kilometres in length.
It has a drainage basin covering parts of both India and Pakistan, making it an essential water source for the regions it traverses.
Source and Course:
The river originates from the Rimo Glacier, located to the southeast of the Karakoram Pass.
It flows northwest to enter the Nubra Valley in Ladakh, a region known for its picturesque landscapes and sand dunes.
The river then turns southwest and flows through the disputed region of Gilgit-Baltistan, eventually joins the Indus River near Skardu.
Tributaries:
The Shyok River has several tributaries, the most notable being the Nubra River, which flows through the Nubra Valley.
Other significant tributaries include the Saltoro River, originating from the Siachen Glacier region.
Cultural and Historical Significance:
The river flows through that have been part of ancient trade routes between Central Asia and South Asia.
The Nubra Valley, through which the Shyok flows, is also known for its ancient monasteries and the Bactrian camels, which were used for trade along the Silk Route.
Geographical significance of Shyok River
Strategic Location: The Shyok River flows through the Ladakh region of India and serves as a vital geographical feature due to its proximity to the Line of Actual Control (LAC) between India and China. Its strategic location influences military deployments and infrastructure development in the region, particularly in the context of border disputes and security concerns.
Glacial Melt and Water Resources: Originating from the Rimo Glacier and fed by numerous tributaries, the Shyok River contributes significantly to the water resources of the region. Its flow is crucial for agriculture, hydroelectric power generation, and sustenance of local ecosystems, impacting the livelihoods and socio-economic activities of communities along its banks.
Q) “The most significant achievement of modern law in India is the constitutionalization of environmental problems by the Supreme Court.” Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws. (UPSC IAS/2022) Q) Examine the scope of Fundamental Rights in the light of the latest judgement of the Supreme Court on Right to Privacy. (UPSC IAS/2017)
Prelims: Q) The power of the Supreme Court of India to decide disputes between the Centre and the States falls under its (UPSC IAS/2014) (a) Advisory jurisdiction (b) Appellate jurisdiction (c) Original jurisdiction (d) Writ jurisdiction
Note4Students:
Prelims: Supreme Court on Endangered species;
Mains: Landmark Judgements by SC; Judicial Interventions;
Mentor comments: The Supreme Court in M K Ranjitsinh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. ruled that people have a right to be free from the adverse effects of climate change which should be recognised by Article 14 and Article 21 of the Constitution. The ruling of the Supreme Court was rendered in response to a writ brought by a government official. The court acknowledged the complex interplay between environmental conservation, social equity, economic prosperity, and climate change. It stressed the need to balance the conservation of endangered species like the Great Indian Bustard (GIB) with the imperative of protecting against climate change.
It appointed an Expert Committee to determine the best way to protect the species. This decision aimed to support India’s renewable energy goals and climate commitments while ensuring environmental protection. However, the effectiveness of court rulings on climate change remains a question, as climate change is a complex, multi-dimensional problem that requires a holistic approach. The court’s decision to defer to the executive on certain matters related to climate change policy has also been criticized by some experts.
Let’s learn
—
Why in the News?
The Apex court’s recent decision on M K Ranjitsinh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. to defer to the executive on certain matters related to climate change policy has been questioned by experts.
What was the Supreme Court’s recent Landmark Judgment?
• The Supreme Court in M K Ranjitsinh & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. ruled that that people have a right to be free from the adverse effects of climate change which should be recognised by Article 14 and Article 21 of the Constitution. • The ruling of the Supreme Court was rendered in response to a writ brought by conservationist and retired government official M K Rnajitsinh, who sought protection for two endangered species namely the Lessor Florican and the Great Indian Bustard. • The court acknowledged the complex interplay between environmental conservation, social equity, economic prosperity, and climate change. • While modifying its earlier order to underground power cables in the Great Indian Bustard’s habitat, the court prioritized transmission infrastructure to enable renewable energy development to address climate change.
Present challenges along the verdict of Supreme Court:
Unresolved questions: The judgment leaves unresolved questions regarding the court’s emphasis on large-scale clean energy as the main pathway to avoiding climate harm and its potential understatement of climate adaptation and local environmental resilience.
Non-clarity: The court did not clarify how the newly recognized right against the adverse effects of climate change will be protected in practice.
Two potential approaches to realizing this right emerge:
The proliferation of court-based climate litigation, which may lead to an incomplete patchwork of protections.
The enactment of climate legislation, which can provide an overarching framework to guide future policy.
The Need for Climate Legislation in India
Absence of an “umbrella legislation” in India : India needs climate legislation that is tailored to its unique context, rather than blindly copying other countries.
Framework climate legislation can set the vision for engaging with climate change across sectors and regions, create necessary institutions, and put in place processes for structured and deliberative governance in anticipation of and reaction to climate change.
Tailoring Climate Legislation to the Indian Context should also:
create a supportive regulatory environment for sustainable cities, buildings, and transport
enable adaptation measures like heat action plans and climate-resilient agriculture
protect key ecosystems like mangroves
consider social equity in achieving these goals
A single, omnibus law covering all these areas may not be feasible given India’s existing legal framework.
Lessons from International Experience:
• Climate laws in many countries, like the UK’s, focus narrowly on regulating carbon emissions, which is ill-suited for India. • Instead, India needs an “enabling law” that stimulates development-focused decisions across sectors towards low-carbon and climate-resilient growth. • An enabling law should be more procedurally-oriented, creating institutions, processes, and standards for mainstreaming climate change across ministries and society (emphasizing both adaptation and mitigation).
Federal Factor:
On Decentralized approach: Many areas relevant to climate action, such as urban policy, agriculture, water, and electricity, fall under the authority of state and local level governments. An Indian climate law must set a framework for coherent national action and decentralize sufficiently to empower states and local governments.
On Fiscal and Governing Policies: The regional states and local governments need to be provided with information and finance to take effective actions. This would enable diverse segments of society to bring their knowledge and expertise to the table in addressing climate change.
The Way Forward:
India should learn from international experience, both in terms of what not to do and what directions to follow.
The country’s climate legislation should be tailored to its unique context of being a developing, highly vulnerable nation still building its infrastructure.
In early June, approximately 300 families were relocated from the island of Gardi Sugdub in Panama’s Guna Yala province due to concerns about rising sea levels.
What is happening in Gardi Sugdub?
Location and Community: Gardi Sugdub, home to about 1,300 members of the Guna community, is an island in Panama’s Guna Yala province.
Sea Level Rise: The Caribbean region, where Panama is situated, is experiencing sea level rise at an average rate of 3 to 4 millimetres per year. This rate is expected to accelerate to 1 centimetre per year or more by 2100.
Flooding: Annually, particularly in November and December, seawater floods houses and streets on Gardi Sugdub, despite efforts to fortify the island.
Relocation: The Panamanian government constructed 300 new houses on the mainland in a development called Nuevo Cartí to relocate affected families.
How are other island nations affected by sea level rise?
Small island developing states (SIDS) are particularly vulnerable due to their low elevation and reliance on marine resources. SIDS in the Caribbean, Pacific, Atlantic, Indian Ocean, and South China Sea face existential threats from rising sea levels.
Examples of Impact: Islands such as Tuvalu, the Marshall Islands, and Kiribati are experiencing significant land loss and threats to their culture and economies.
Consequences: Coastal erosion, salinization of freshwater resources, and increased vulnerability to extreme weather events due to rising sea levels, storm surges, and ‘king tides.’
How fast is the global sea level rising?
Since 1880, global sea levels have risen by approximately 21–24 centimeters. The rate of increase has accelerated in recent decades.
Causes: The primary drivers are global warming, thermal expansion of seawater, and the melting of land-based ice such as glaciers and ice sheets.
Due to the Global Temperature Increase: The global average temperature has increased by at least 1.1 degrees Celsius since 1880, contributing to rising sea levels.
Way forward:
Strengthen Coastal and Environmental Defenses: Construct seawalls, breakwaters, and other barriers to protect against storm surges and coastal erosion. Restore and preserve natural coastal barriers such as mangroves, coral reefs, and wetlands to enhance natural protection.
Develop and Implement Climate Adaptation Strategies: Create comprehensive climate adaptation plans that include relocation strategies for vulnerable communities.
Mains PYQ:
Q Explain the causes and effects of coastal erosion in India. What are the available coastal management techniques for combating the hazard? (UPSC IAS/2022)
Denmark will impose a tax on its livestock farmers for the greenhouse gases (GHGs) emitted by their cows, sheep, and pigs from 2030.
What is it?
Denmark plans to impose a tax on livestock farmers for greenhouse gases (GHGs) emitted by their cows, sheep, and pigs starting in 2030.
Tax Rates: Farmers would initially pay about $43 per metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent produced by their livestock, increasing to around $108 by 2035.
Actual Cost: Due to a 60% income tax deduction, the actual cost per ton will start at 120 kroner ($17.3) and rise to 300 kroner ($43) by 2035.
Use of Tax Collection: The funds collected from the tax between 2030 and 2031 will be returned to the industry to support its green transition. The handling of proceeds will be revisited in 2032. The proposal includes the development of over 600,000 acres of new forest areas.
How Do Cows and Sheep Produce Methane?
Ruminants like cows, sheep, goats, and buffaloes have a specialized digestive system with four stomach compartments, including the rumen. In the rumen, partially digested food ferments, producing methane.
Methane is released primarily through burping and farting as the animals regurgitate and chew cud to complete the digestive process. Ruminant digestive systems are responsible for 27% of all methane emissions from human activity.
Why Are Methane Emissions a Problem?
Climate Impact: Methane is a potent greenhouse gas, responsible for 30% of warming since preindustrial times, second only to carbon dioxide. Over a 20-year period, methane is 80 times more potent at warming than carbon dioxide.
Ground-Level Ozone: Methane is the primary contributor to ground-level ozone formation, a highly irritating gas just above the Earth’s surface, contributing to 1 million premature deaths annually.
Rising Levels: Atmospheric methane levels have dramatically increased in recent years, with the NOAA reporting a record 17 parts per billion increase in 2021, surpassing the previous record set in 2020.
Way forward:
Dietary Adjustments: Introduce feed additives, such as seaweed or other natural supplements, that can reduce methane emissions during digestion in ruminants. This approach can significantly lower methane production without negatively impacting livestock health or productivity.
Improved Manure Management: Utilize advanced manure management practices, such as anaerobic digestion, to capture and convert methane emissions from decomposing animal waste into biogas. This not only reduces methane emissions but also provides a renewable energy source.
Mains PYQ:
Q Describe the major outcomes of the 26th session of the Conference of the Parties (COP) to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). What are the commitments made by India in this conference? (UPSC IAS/2021)
A mainland serow aka. Himalayan Serow (Capricornis sumatraensis thar) was recorded at 96 metres above mean sea level in Raimona National Park, Assam.
This is the lowest elevation recorded for the species beyond Bhutan, its natural habitat.
About Himalayan Serow
Details
About
Herbivore species.
Also known as Thar.
Resembles a cross between a goat, a donkey, a cow, and a pig.
Recognition
Official state animal of Mizoram.
Distribution
Found at altitudes between 2,000 metres and 4,000 metres (6,500 to 13,000 feet).
Found across the India-Bhutan border in Phibsoo Wildlife Sanctuary and Royal Manas National Park.
Present in eastern, central, and western Himalayas, but not in the Trans Himalayan region.
Conservation Status
IUCN Red List: Vulnerable
CITES: Appendix I
The Wildlife Protection Act, 1972: Schedule I
Back2Basics:Raimona National Park
Raimona National Park is a newly established protected area located in the Bodoland Territorial Region (BTR) of Assam.
It was officially declared a national park in June 2021, becoming the sixth national park in the state of Assam.
It shares its northern boundary with Bhutan, forming part of the transboundary conservation landscape.
It is characterised by dense forests, rivers, and grasslands. The park is part of the greater Manas Biosphere Reserve and serves as an extension of the Manas National Park.
The area is interspersed by the Sankosh River which flows through the park.
Flora and Fauna:
Flora: The park boasts a rich biodiversity with various types of vegetation, including semi-evergreen forests, mixed deciduous forests, and patches of grassland.
Fauna: Hosts a variety of wildlife, including:
Mammals: Asian elephants, tigers, clouded leopards, golden langurs, Indian gaur, and several species of deer.
Birds: Home to numerous bird species, including hornbills, great pied hornbills, and various migratory birds.
Reptiles and Amphibians: The park also supports a diverse range of reptiles and amphibians, adding to its ecological richness.
PYQ:
[2011] The Himalayan Range is very rich in species diversity. Which one among the following is the most appropriate reason for this Phenomenon?
(a) It has a high rainfall that supports luxuriant vegetative growth
(b) It is a confluence of different bio-geographical zones.
(c) Exotic and invasive species have not been introduced in this region.
Rajasthan’s barren Thar Desert may turn green, says a recent study in the journal Earth’s Future.
About Thar Desert
The Thar Desert is the 18th largest subtropical desert globally and is one of the most densely populated deserts.
Approximately 40% of the human population in Rajasthan resides in the Thar Desert.
It extends from the Sutlej River and is bounded by the Rann of Kutch, the Aravalli Mountains, and the Indus River.
About 85% of the Thar Desert is located in India, with the remainder in Pakistan.
In India, it spans across Rajasthan, Gujarat, Haryana, and Punjab as well.
Civilizations are believed to have thrived in the Thar region around 50,000 years ago across the extinct Saraswati River.
The Desert National Park (home to the endangered Great Indian Bustard, desert fox, desert cat, blackbuck, and Indian gazelle) is situated in the Thar Desert in the northwest Indian state of Rajasthan.
Why the thar desert getting greener?
Climate Change Effects:
Alteration of Weather Patterns: Climate change is causing shifts in rainfall distribution in the thar desert area.
Potential for Vegetation Growth: The increased precipitation could provide favorable conditions for vegetation growth, contributing to the greening of the desert.
Indian Monsoon Dynamics:
Westward Extension of Indian Monsoon: The Indian monsoon, known for bringing heavy rainfall to eastern India, is now extending further westward into regions like the Thar Desert.
Impact on Moisture and Rainfall: This change in monsoon dynamics could lead to increased moisture and rainfall in the desert region, facilitating the growth of vegetation.
Expansion of Indian Ocean Warm Pool (IOWP):
Influence on Monsoon Patterns: The Indian Ocean Warm Pool (IOWP) influences monsoon patterns and rainfall distribution over the Indian subcontinent.
Westward Expansion due to Climate Change: Climate change is causing the IOWP to expand westward, potentially resulting in increased rainfall over semi-arid regions like the Thar Desert and promoting greening.
Water Management Practices:
Contribution to Greening: Effective water management practices, such as rainwater harvesting and irrigation techniques like johad, kuis, and kunds, may be playing a role in the greening of the Thar Desert.
Utilization of Water Resources: By harnessing and efficiently utilizing available water resources, local communities and authorities can support vegetation growth and ecosystem restoration efforts in the desert.
Introduction of Irrigation
Commercial Cropping: Irrigation was introduced during British colonial rule in the 19th and 20th centuries to convert arid and semi-arid ecosystems into cropland.
Restrictions on Grazing: The right to graze animals was restricted to landowners who cultivated crops, leading to the transformation of nomadic pastoralists into sedentary agropastoralists.
Sustainability of this transformation
Recent greening activities, largely on arid scrub savannahs, have threatened species adapted to such climates and have been linked to locust outbreaks.
The Indira Gandhi Canal project in the 1980s led to extensive crop cover in the Thar Desert, resulting in areas becoming infertile due to waterlogging and salinity.
Planting invasive species, such as prosopis juliflora and acacia tortilis, has led to habitat degradation and biodiversity loss.
PYQ:
[2018] Which of the following leaf modifications occur(s) in the desert areas to inhibit water loss?
Hard and waxy leaves
Tiny leaves
Thorns instead of leaves
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
(a) 2 and 3 only
(b) 2 only
(c) 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3
[2020] The process of desertification does not have climate boundaries. Justify with examples.
[2013] Major hot deserts in northern hemisphere are located between 20-30 degree north and on the western side of the continents. Why?
South India’s first and the country’s largest leopard safari was inaugurated at the Bannerghatta Biological Park (BBP).
About Bannerghatta Biological Park
BBP is located near Bangalore and was established in 2002.
It spans an area of approximately 731.88 hectares, situated within the larger Bannerghatta National Park, which covers around 25,000 acres.
The park was created to facilitate the conservation of wildlife, promote tourism, and educate the public about wildlife and conservation efforts.
River Suvarnamukhi stream, the main source of water for the animals of the park, runs through the centre of the park.
Leopards in India
The Indian Leopard (Panthera pardus fusca) is a leopard subspecies widely distributed on the Indian subcontinent.
These are the smallest of the big cats.
They are known for their ability to adapt to a variety of habitats.
They are strong and agile predators that can climb trees and drag their prey up for safety.
Conservation Status:
IUCN Red List: Vulnerable
CITES: Appendix I
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972: Schedule I
Do you know?
As per, Status of Leopards in India Report, 2022:
India’s leopard population is estimated at 13,874 individuals.
Madhya Pradesh houses the largest population of leopards in the country – 3907 (2018: 3421), followed by Maharashtra (2022: 1985; 2018: 1,690), Karnataka (2022: 1,879 ; 2018: 1,783) and Tamil Nadu (2022: 1,070; 2018: 868).
PYQ:
[2012] Consider the following:
Black-necked crane
Cheetah
Flying squirrel
Snow leopard
Which of the above are naturally found in India?
(a) 1, 2 and 3 only
(b) 1, 3 and 4 only
(c) 2 and 4 only
(d) 1, 2, 3 and 4
Lakshadweep has been severely affected by the fourth global coral bleaching event (GCBE4), the most severe on record according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
Global Coral Bleaching Events (GCBE)
A GCBE means significant coral bleaching has been confirmed in all the ocean regions wherewarm-water corals live: the Pacific, Atlantic, and Indian Oceans in both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres.
Previous Events: Mass coral bleaching recorded in 1998, 2010, and 2014-2017.
Current Event (GCBE4): Began early 2023, with over 70.7% of the world’s coral reefs impacted by bleaching-level heat stress as of May 23, 2024.
Lakshadweep Specifics
Kavaratti atoll survey indicated an 84.6% bleaching extent, with mass bleaching observed. Previous bleaching events in Lakshadweep were 81% (1998), 65% (2010), and 41.9% (2020).
Resilient species also showing signs: Acropora digitifera, Pocillopora grandis, Isopora palifera, Pavona venosa, Hydnophora microconos.
Contributing Factors: Increased temperatures attributed to global warming; from April 1 to May 2, 2024, temperatures ranged between 29.6°C to 32.8°C.
Importance of Coral Reefs
Marine Biodiversity: Support diverse marine life including fish, invertebrates, and algae.
Coastal Protection: Act as natural barriers against erosion and storm surges.
Local Economy: Provide sustenance and livelihood for local communities and attract tourists.
GCBE-4 and Indian Context
Gujarat Coast: Monitoring coral bleaching mid-summer, with 30-40% bleaching observed annually; most corals recover.
Tamil Nadu: Lesser impact in the Gulf of Mannar due to late bleaching onset and early monsoon reducing seawater temperatures.
Temperature Reduction: The onset of monsoon has slightly reduced water temperatures in Lakshadweep.
Recovery Uncertain: The long-term health of corals depends on sustained cooler conditions and the absence of further stressors.
Back2Basics: Corals
Corals are made up of genetically identical organisms called polyps.
These polyps have microscopic algae called zooxanthellae living within their tissues in a mutualistic relationship.
The coral provides the zooxanthellae with the compounds necessary for photosynthesis.
In return, the zooxanthellae supply the coral with organic products of photosynthesis, like carbohydrates, which are utilized by the coral polyps for the synthesis of their calcium carbonate skeletons.
Corals are marine invertebrates or animals which do not possess a spine.
They are the largest living structures on the planet.
Each coral is called a polyp and thousands of such polyps live together to form a colony, which grows when polyps multiply to make copies of themselves.
Coral reefs are also called the “rainforests of the seas”.
Types of Coral
Corals are of two types — hard corals and soft corals:
Hard corals extract calcium carbonate from seawater to build hard, white coral exoskeletons. Hard corals are in a way the engineers of reef ecosystems and measuring the extent of hard coral is a widely-accepted metric for measuring the condition of coral reefs.
Soft corals attach themselves to such skeletons and older skeletons built by their ancestors. Soft corals also add their own skeletons to the hard structure over the years. These growing multiplying structures gradually form coral reefs.
Conditions Needed for Corals to Flourish
Extensive submarine platforms for the formation of colonies by the coral polyps (not more than 90m below sea level).
High mean annual temperature ranging 20-21 degrees Celsius.
Clean sediment-free water because muddy water or turbid water clogs the mouths of coral polyps resulting into their death.
Oceanic salinity ranging between 27-30 ppt.
Ocean currents and waves, as they bring food supply for the polyps.
PYQ:
2014: Which of the following have coral reefs?
Andaman and Nicobar Islands
Gulf of Kachchh
Gulf of Mannar
Sunderbans
Select the correct answer using the code given below:
The Tamil Nadu government has approved the controlled hunting of wild boars causing distress to farmers near forest areas.
Presently, Wild boars are NOT listed as Vermin under the Schedule V of the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972.
About the Farmers’ Conflict Resolution Committee
The Committee includes representatives from the Departments of Forest, Revenue, Agriculture, and Horticulture, along with scientific experts and wildlife enthusiasts.
Objective: The committee was formed to study the impact of raids by elephants and wild pigs on agricultural crops.
Implementation Protocol:
Approval Process: The culling will require approval from a local three-member checking body.
Composition of the Checking Body: The body will include a forester or forest guard, the Village Administrative Officer, and the ward member.
Supervision: Culling operations must be conducted in the presence of these three members.
Zoning for Culling Operations
Areas adjacent to reserve forests will be divided into three zones:
Zone A: Within one kilometre from forest limits.
Zone B: One to five kilometres from forest limits.
Zone C: Beyond five kilometres from forest limits.
Restrictions: Shooting of wild pigs is prohibited within five kilometres of the reserve forest (Zones A and B).
Scientific Approach to Culling:
Scientific Methodology: The shooting of wild boars must adhere to a scientific approach, considering the intensity and frequency of conflict incidents.
Expert Concerns: Experts highlight the ecological role of wild boars and caution against indiscriminate killing.
About Indian Wild Boar
Details
Scientific Name
Sus scrofa cristatus
Habitat and Distribution
High grass, bushes, forests, high crops, dense forests, grasslands, scrublands, agricultural areas; Indian subcontinent, various altitudes from sea level to mountains
Gestation: around four months; Litter size: multiple piglets
Ecological Role
Seed dispersal aiding plant propagation;
Important prey species maintaining predator-prey balance in the ecosystem
Conservation Status
IUCN Red List: Least Concern
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972: Schedule III
Proposed reclassification to Schedule V (vermin) due to agricultural damage.
Present Culling
Section 11-B (1) of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 allows the Chief Wildlife Warden to issue special orders to kill dangerous wild animals.
Back2Basics: Schedule III of WPA, 1972
Protection Level: Lesser degree of protection compared to Schedule I and II.
Prohibition: Hunting of these species is prohibited except under special circumstances defined by the Act.
Penalties: Violations related to these species attract penalties, though they are less stringent than those for higher schedules.
Species Listed in Schedule III: As per the latest available data, the following are examples of species listed under Schedule III of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972:
Chinkara (Gazella bennettii): Also known as the Indian Gazelle, found in various parts of India.
Blackbuck (Antilope cervicapra): A species of antelope native to India.
Blue Bull (Boselaphus tragocamelus): Also known as the Nilgai, the largest Asian antelope.
Indian Wild Boar (Sus scrofa cristatus): A subspecies of the wild boar native to the Indian subcontinent.
Sambar (Rusa unicolor): A large deer native to the Indian subcontinent.
Legal Provisions:
Hunting Prohibition: Hunting any animal listed under Schedule III is prohibited except for purposes like scientific research, education, and when permitted by the authorities under specific conditions.
Penalties: The penalties for offenses involving Schedule III animals include imprisonment up to three years, or a fine up to Rs. 25,000, or both.
PYQ:
[2017] In India, if a species of tortoise is declared protected under Schedule I of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, what does it imply?
(a) It enjoys the same level of protection as the tiger.
(b) It no longer exists in the wild, a few individuals are under captive protection; and now it is impossible to prevent its extinction.
(c) It is endemic to a particular region of India.
(d) Both B and C stated above are correct in this context.
Q Climate change is a global problem. How India will be affected by climate change? How Himalayan and coastal states of India will be affected by climate change? (UPSC IAS/2017)
Q Should the pursuit of carbon credits and clean development mechanisms set up under UNFCCC be maintained even though there has been a massive slide in the value of a carbon credit? Discuss with respect to India’s energy needs for economic growth.(UPSC IAS/2014)
Mentor comment: The Indian Himalayan Region is crucial for its rich biodiversity, serving as a habitat for diverse flora and fauna, including endangered species. It plays a vital role in regulating regional and global climate patterns, hosting the source of major rivers essential for water supply and agriculture. Culturally and spiritually significant, it supports the livelihoods of indigenous communities, offering opportunities for tourism, research, and sustainable development.
Let’s learn!
Why in the News?
The dissonance between the special development needs and the development model being pursued in the Indian Himalayan Region.
Supreme Court’s Stance on Sustainable Development
Rights-Based Regime: Recent Supreme Court judgments indicate a move towards recognising sustainable development as a fundamental right.
Case Highlight: In the State of Telangana and Others vs. Mohd. Abdul Qasim (2024), the Court emphasised the need for an ecocentric view of the environment.
Trusteeship of Earth: The Court stated that humanity must act as trustees of the Earth, respecting the rights of natural entities like rivers, lakes, and mountains.
A model of destruction
Hydroelectric Power Stations: Rampant construction of hydroelectric power stations without consideration for the rights of rivers and streams.
Road Widening: Reckless widening of hill roads to four lanes, leading to frequent damage during river floods.
Construction Violations: Rampant construction violates norms and regulations, including building on river beds, flood plains, steep slopes, seismic zones, and landslide-prone areas.
Environmental Disasters: Instances like the Teesta dam breach in Sikkim and monsoon floods and landslides in Himachal Pradesh in 2023 highlight the destructive impact of the development model on the environment, ecology, and local communities.
Need for a Balanced Development Approach
Ecocentric and Anthropocentric Views: Both approaches require aligning growth aspirations with environmental science and the rights of people and nature.
Supreme Court’s Guidance: The Court’s judgments stress the intersectionality of environmental protection and human rights.
Carrying Capacity and Developmental Rights: Judicial Precedence
Carrying Capacity Studies: In Ashok Kumar Raghav vs Union of India (2023), the Supreme Court sought a way forward to manage the carrying capacity of Himalayan states.
Right to a Clean Environment: In the Great Indian Bustard case, the Court linked the right to life and equality with the right to be free from adverse climate impacts.
Significance of Infrastructure and Climate Resilience
Sustainable Infrastructure: Development must be resilient to climate change impacts to ensure equality and access to opportunities.
Impact on Social Inequality: Disasters amplify social inequality, disproportionately affecting the poor.
Judicial Mandate: The Supreme Court’s judgments call for integrating disaster management in development planning.
Fundamental Right to Sustainable Development
New Fundamental Right: The right to be free from adverse climate impacts is now recognized as a fundamental right.
Implications for IHR: People in the IHR have a fundamental right to a development model that is sustainable and respects the region’s carrying capacity.
Need for Legal Framework: The Supreme Court’s judgments should guide the creation of a legal framework to ensure sustainable development in the IHR.
Way Forward
Integrated Approach Needed: Development planning must incorporate disaster prevention and resilience measures.
Convergence of Authorities: The planning stage convergence of different authorities is essential to ensure that all disaster and climate resilience concerns are addressed before project implementation.
Role of Science and Policy: Science, policy, and action must align in an integrated approach involving policymakers, planners, scientists, and communities.
Call for Action: The Supreme Court’s judgments provide a basis for necessary course corrections in development practices, especially in the IHR.
Balancing Development and Resilience: Achieving a balance between development and disaster resilience is crucial for sustainable progress.
![[1st July 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: Court on climate right and how India can enforce it](https://www.civilsdaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/1-July-1568x882.jpg)
![[25th June 2024] The Hindu Op-ed: The Court spells the way in Himalaya’s development](https://www.civilsdaily.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/25-June-1568x882.jpg)